News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by legitster on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:37PM (#38029898)
Is 50 FPS a huge issue?

I play a lot of city builders and so long as the UI is still smooth I really don't notice any gameplay difference between 30fps and 60fps.

I put 8 hours into Frostpunk before realizing I was limited to 30FPS.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by wackget on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:41PM (#38029961)
My personal opinion: yes. As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace, it's becoming less defensible for games to run anywhere below 60fps.

But it's the fact that these figures are being seen with the most powerful consumer graphics card (on a brand new unpopulated game map) that's the problem.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by legitster on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#38030235)
City Skylines 1 has been played and supported non-stop for over 8 years. Why should they limit the highest possible graphics settings only to existing technology?

Again, this is a simulation game. If I ask the game to spit out more detail and graphics than can be physically supported by today's technology, I guess I don't necessarily see this as a design fault.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by kaibee on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:09PM (#38030349)
If it were doing a ton of compute-shader simulation on GPU to actually increase the fidelity of the simulation that would be one thing, but having a badly implemented graphics pipeline isn't that.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by iforgotpassword on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:11PM (#38030387)
Somewhat yes, I didn't try it yet, but a few things don't add up then:

Why enable those heavy, performance crippling post processing filters by default?

From what I can find in this comment section, and I guess this has to be taken with a grain of salt, performance doesn't scale. It seems we max out at 50fps on a beefy 13th gen Intel with the fastest GPU available, but then there's a couple comments with mid-range hardware where performance is nearly identical.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by HappyDaoDude on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:59PM (#38033181)
To shoot from the hip on this one. It sounds like it could be limited by a single thread. Clock rates between mid and high end CPU's are significantly different but core count is. Thus if a single thread is holding up the works, that would explain the stagnant performance profile despite potential overall performance.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by danudey on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:00PM (#38030978)
> If I ask the game to spit out more detail and graphics than can be physically supported by today's technology, I guess I don't necessarily see this as a design fault.

To be clear: I had to turn the quality down to much worse than I recall Cities Skylines 1 looking in order to get worse performance than Cities Skylines 1.

The major complaint here is not "I cannot max the settings on my mediocre hardware", but rather "I cannot mediocre the settings on my max hardware"; the performance is bad at any level, but my hardware, while not top-of-the-line, should be able to run a game like this at 4K playable, or at 1080p while looking awesome and running great. Instead, I get 1080p with a mix of medium/low settings in order to get it looking pretty okay in most aspects.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by cmovq on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:05PM (#38032312)
> Why should they limit the highest possible graphics settings only to existing technology?

This assumes Cities Skylines 2 is using some next gen graphics technology when in practice it is a Unity game without any cutting edge graphics. Another comment mentioned they are doing 10k+ draw calls per frame - it's just poorly optimized.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by chemmail on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:02PM (#38032754)
Sticking with Unity probably killed them. They might as well have deved another engine.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Vetch on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:21PM (#38032907)
How does developing another engine help at all? It is very likely its graphics are so under-optimized because they spent most of their time on the simulation aspect, which is more than challenging enough. Dyson Sphere Program is a game with lots of stuff going on at a time, the engine isn't the issue. Cities Skylines 2 is just a very complex game.

As a city builder it has not just dynamic geometry (which makes graphics optimization more challenging) and lots going on on screen like DSP, but also a complex agent based simulation of a city, its transportation, its economy, and individual agent AIs. It is far more complex than most games despite not being graphically intensive. And do note that as far as cities builders go, it's also one of the most ambitious graphically. My personal opinion is they deserve some slack as long as the game continues to improve.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by serf on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:23PM (#38032458)
this is a trope that is spit out by the developers of every poorly optimized sim in recorded history.

Yes, scalability towards the future is good -- but not at the detriment of player performance now.

If the player base doesn't stick around during our current dark-times medieval technology stack, there won't be a player base when we have whatever future tech makes it playable -- see the problem?

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by FirmwareBurner on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:24PM (#38030544)
>As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace, it's becoming less defensible for games to run anywhere below 60fps.

You're forgetting the increasing popularity of the Steam Deck where even 60 FPS is a luxury.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by BlueTemplar on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:07PM (#38032326)
CS2 devs reportedly had 30 FPS as a target. Which is actually fine for that kind of game, but it sounds like that is NOT for low-end hardware ?
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by adgjlsfhk1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:26PM (#38032500)
For CPU heavy games it totally makes sense to target 30fps, but that better be 30fps at 1080p with integrated graphics, (or 30fps 1440p with 1060 class gpu). Add eye candy if you want, but it really should run well on any remotely modern system.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by giobox on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:43PM (#38032605)
> As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace

The Steam hardware survey suggests otherwise to my eyes; it's often easy to forget working in tech that a lot of Steam customers have relatively shit hardware:

https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/Steam-Hardware-Softw...

While they don't track monitor peak supported refresh, just looking at the rest of the results suggests to me high-refresh gaming (over 60FPS) is going to be relatively niche at best. Lots of PC gaming specs I take for-granted on my own builds or consider "average" are actually not that common.

I absolutely agree 60fps should be considered the floor for most modern PC games running on "reasonable" hardware though, 30fps belongs to the past.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by aeyes on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:55PM (#38032705)
Most Steam customers play games like Counter Strike, Dota, Team Fortress, PUBG, GTA, Call of Duty which have modest hardware requirements.

I wouldn't read too much into these stats.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by karaterobot on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:01PM (#38032744)
I don't think that's true. Most people who play PC games are Steam users, and they're playing a huge variety of games: pretty much any game that's not exclusive to some other store.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by giobox on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:02PM (#38032756)
> I wouldn't read too much into these stats.

This is probably one of the best public sources of data we have on the topic of what hardware actual PC gamers are using.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Iulioh on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:53PM (#38032686)
Off topic but 42% of VR headsets are Quest 2

Woahhh

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xnyan on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:47PM (#38033100)
It’s the cheapest headset that also offers a reasonable experience. For around $250 you get a well designed device that includes controllers and does not require a separate computer to use. It’s a very good value, and if you’re unsure about VR probably the best place to dip your toe in the water.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by wlesieutre on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:39PM (#38029935)
20 fps is playable for a city builder, but that's on a $2000 GPU

A bit unfair since most people aren't gaming at 4K (Steam hardware survey puts it at 3.29%), but still

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by washadjeffmad on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:17PM (#38030449)
Ok, so around 4 million users. I wonder what the overlap of 4K owners and people who play city builders is?
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by dimgl on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:52PM (#38030880)
I feel like this is grasping at straws? Plenty of unorthodox games go mainstream. Can’t expect consumer hardware to the stay the same forever. This game is just poorly optimized.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by washadjeffmad on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:05PM (#38032306)
I think I'm giving people the opposite impression that I intended.

Well-compensated people (like engineers) are more likely to own a 4K monitor and high-end GPU, so I meant to convey that there's probably a large overlap with the type of people who play city builders (like engineers), so they really should have accounted for that.

It was only after I bought my 4K 120Hz OLED that I found out how popular they are for sims, including pinball. It's been awesome.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by janosdebugs on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:29PM (#38031929)
Anecdotal evidence: I play at 4k if I can manage, and I sport a 2060S.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by ajaimk on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:38PM (#38029908)
4090 is the fastest available graphics card. That’s the problem.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by stodor89 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:48PM (#38030052)
50fps is okay. 50fps on a $1600 GPU is definitely not okay.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by bee_rider on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:51PM (#38030101)
It is just a matter of preference, I don’t see why people get bent out of shape about it.

30fps is fine for lots of games. Especially for stuff that doesn’t require super twitchy gameplay.

If somebody really cares about 60fps or 120fps, fine. But the developers have some effects they want to implement, and if some of them don’t fit into 8.3ms, let those of us who don’t mind 30fps enjoy them, right?

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by ryandrake on Thursday October 26, 2023 @08:41PM (#38033422)
30FPS on the world's #1 fastest GPU is totally not OK. Heck, I'd be unhappy with 30FPS on my ancient Radeon Pro 580.

I remember easily getting frame rates far in excess of my monitor's top refresh rate back in 1999.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by bee_rider on Thursday October 26, 2023 @10:52PM (#38034165)
Why isn’t it ok?
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by wander_homer on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:48PM (#38054150)
Because this means the game runs even worse on pretty much every PC out there, since the majority of gamers don't use the most powerful GPU on the market. And it's not like this game has some outstanding visuals which would somehow justify such performance.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by tomatotomato37 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:51PM (#38030108)
It's not the average that's the problem, is that it has hard stutters from when you do something like swing or rotate the camera around and force a lot of new things to load. Also there's no fps limiter so I can't stop the game from attempting to match my monitor's 165 FPS with a overheating laptop 3060, causing the stuttering to be even more visible.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by KennyBlanken on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:41PM (#38030754)
You can set a frame limit per-program in the NVIDIA control panel.

Undervolting also reportedly works really well in laptop nvidia chipsets, FYI.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by michaelt on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:54PM (#38030141)
50 FPS certainly doesn't make the game unplayable, it's true.

But if that's with an empty map, it's an ominous sign for people who plan to build a city in this city building game, as rendering usually slows as polygon count increases.

And if it's with an $1800 GPU, its an ominous sign for the 99.3% of gamers who don't have an $1800 GPU.

And if that's at 1440p - well, I'd wager a lot of the folks with a $1800 GPU also have a 4k screen.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by antisthenes on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:56PM (#38030178)
It's a huge issue, considering the game doesn't look like a revolution in graphics AND you're essentially playing it on a super-computer by 5-6 year old standards.

> I put 8 hours into Frostpunk before realizing I was limited to 30FPS.

Yes, and I have beaten games that rendered improperly at sub-30FPS as a kid, because the requirement was 16MB of VRAM, while my card only had 8. But that's just as irrelevant to the point being made.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by pdpi on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:23PM (#38030532)
If they said "The game is locked to 30fps" I'd probably have been ok with that. It's not a fast paced game, and capping the framerate at a low value is probably a decent enough design choice for that particular game. As you say, it's enough that you won't really notice it in gameplay.

The problem is that we're talking about the absolute highest end consumer card sold by nVidia rendering a blank map, without such a framerate lock in place. If it's not locked, then that framerate is the product of a performance bottleneck somewhere. With a modern gaming PC, "performance bottleneck" also means you're sitting next to a moderately powerful space heater.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by KennyBlanken on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:38PM (#38032028)
Locking a game to 30hz would not have been a "decent design choice" given that's half the refresh rate of nearly every computer monitor out there, especially for a game that involves a lot of scrolling.

Games get mocked for locking to 60hz, 30hz would get them laughed at outright.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by BlueTemplar on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:12PM (#38032363)
The devs supposedly aimed for 30 FPS (but missed it, because that would be for low end hardware?)

In my experience 30 FPS is perfectly fine for a game like this, I'm not sure what do you mean about "scrolling" ?

It's the much more fast paced, mostly first person games that really need those 60+ FPS...

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by serf on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:33PM (#38032535)
>In my experience 30 FPS is perfectly fine for a game like this, I'm not sure what do you mean about "scrolling" ?

A top down city sim 'scrolls' up/down/left/right around a map, which is a movement that is strongly associated to screen tearing -- which i'm not really sure is a relevant thing to bring up given the variety of v-sync options available.

Even a game locked at 30fps that 'scrolls' often shouldn't experience significant tearing with the options out there.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by mcpackieh on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:36PM (#38032563)
Even without tearing, a high framerate is very desirable for scrolling around a map or web page. For instance, iphones are widely praised for excelling in this regard. It's just easier on the eyes if things on screen move smoothly when you scroll/pan around, it's less fatiguing.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Aeolun on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:38PM (#38032580)
I notice when my mouse updates at 30fps. The movement feels noticably choppier.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by HappyDaoDude on Thursday October 26, 2023 @08:44PM (#38033439)
That is a fair call. The game visual updating slow is not a huge issue but if the input cursor is slow, it is very apparent.

Considering something like Simcity 2000/3000. Visual update is probably in single digits FPS most of the time, but the input cursor is very smooth.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by BlueTemplar on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:36AM (#38057290)
Yes, but this is an unrelated issue. Last game I have seen to not have an "hardware cursor" option/default was a badly made DirectX 8 one that has trouble running on Windows 7.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by kriops on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:24PM (#38030541)
It's like playing in black and white, kind of. But yes 50 FPS is completely fine if you have not gotten used to better. Also helps if the game doesn't rely on high levels of detail (which Skylines, unfortunately, does), so that moving the camera around doesn't just make everything blurry.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by BlueTemplar on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:15PM (#38032389)
If moving the camera around makes things blurry, then they must be using some kind of weird post-processing on top, can't blame that on the FPS alone !
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by kriops on Friday October 27, 2023 @03:25AM (#38035677)
Try moving file explorer windows with your display set to different refresh rates. “Blur” might be an incorrect description, but it’s how I would describe it at least.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by mrob on Friday October 27, 2023 @04:02AM (#38035889)
It's unrelated to post-processing. Moving the camera around makes things blurry at low frame rate (and 50fps is low) because of sample-and-hold blur. This can be mitigated by strobing the screen at the same speed as the frame rate, but few monitors support strobing at 50Hz (it would look annoyingly flickery) and if the game ever dropped below 50fps it would break the effect.

Blur Busters explains:

https://blurbusters.com/faq/oled-motion-blur

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xcv123 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:50PM (#38030855)
The issue is that if it runs at 50 FPS on an RTX 4090, it's going to run at 5 FPS on an average GPU.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Kuxe on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:14PM (#38031125)
Problem with these kinds of statements is that.. well, they're not true. I have RTX 2070 running in 3440x1440. I'm at 35fps on low settings with some special stuff turned off, e.g GI and fogs. In an small town with 4k inhabitants still, so things can get worse for me.

Regardless, the problem is blown out of proportion. I think we can give it some weeks and 4090 performance issues will be in the past.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xcv123 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:36PM (#38031379)
> I have RTX 2070 running in 3440x1440. I'm at 35fps on low setting

LOL. You just proved my point.

[dead]
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xcv123 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:43PM (#38031438)
Autism is a hell of a drug.
[dead]
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xcv123 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:22PM (#38031863)
LOL sorry. Yep 2070 is getting quite old now. Didn't realize it has been 5 years already
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by dimgl on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:50PM (#38030856)
Yes, yes it is. I have a 4k TV with 120hz. I want to be able to use it. If Anno 1800 can run at 100+ framerates, surely this game can too.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by sidewndr46 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:57PM (#38030953)
As someone who can safely say that watching a video game in 30 FPS is equivalent to watching a slideshow, yes. It gives me intense motion sickness immediately. So I can't play something below 60 FPS
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xboxnolifes on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:33PM (#38031346)
It's not just 50 fps. It's 50 fps with the best possible hardware and lowest possible settings.

But also, yes, even in a city builder low for is very annoying when you're used to the smoothness of 100+.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by epolanski on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:03PM (#38032295)
It's a 3000$ computer playing at low resolution, of course it is.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by nzgrover on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:20PM (#38032441)
Heh, in New Zealand, the card alone is $3500NZD
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by babypuncher on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:04PM (#38032772)
The problem is the UI won't be smooth on VRR displays unless they implemented some clever workarounds. Your mouse cursor will only update at the same framerate as the rest fo the game. Even budget gaming monitors these days support g-sync, freesync, or both, so it's no longer a problem that only affects a small % of users with deep pockets.

The only workaround I can think of that wouldn't also defeat the point of having VRR would be to add some in-engine low framerate compensation artifically boost the reported framerate to a multiple of the real framerate, but I have yet to see any games that actually do this.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by NBJack on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:30PM (#38032988)
Yes, particularly if you become accustomed to higher refresh rates. This is even worse if the game doesn't support VRR in any form natively.