News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by wackget on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:41PM (#38029961)
My personal opinion: yes. As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace, it's becoming less defensible for games to run anywhere below 60fps.

But it's the fact that these figures are being seen with the most powerful consumer graphics card (on a brand new unpopulated game map) that's the problem.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by legitster on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#38030235)
City Skylines 1 has been played and supported non-stop for over 8 years. Why should they limit the highest possible graphics settings only to existing technology?

Again, this is a simulation game. If I ask the game to spit out more detail and graphics than can be physically supported by today's technology, I guess I don't necessarily see this as a design fault.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by kaibee on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:09PM (#38030349)
If it were doing a ton of compute-shader simulation on GPU to actually increase the fidelity of the simulation that would be one thing, but having a badly implemented graphics pipeline isn't that.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by iforgotpassword on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:11PM (#38030387)
Somewhat yes, I didn't try it yet, but a few things don't add up then:

Why enable those heavy, performance crippling post processing filters by default?

From what I can find in this comment section, and I guess this has to be taken with a grain of salt, performance doesn't scale. It seems we max out at 50fps on a beefy 13th gen Intel with the fastest GPU available, but then there's a couple comments with mid-range hardware where performance is nearly identical.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by HappyDaoDude on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:59PM (#38033181)
To shoot from the hip on this one. It sounds like it could be limited by a single thread. Clock rates between mid and high end CPU's are significantly different but core count is. Thus if a single thread is holding up the works, that would explain the stagnant performance profile despite potential overall performance.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by danudey on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:00PM (#38030978)
> If I ask the game to spit out more detail and graphics than can be physically supported by today's technology, I guess I don't necessarily see this as a design fault.

To be clear: I had to turn the quality down to much worse than I recall Cities Skylines 1 looking in order to get worse performance than Cities Skylines 1.

The major complaint here is not "I cannot max the settings on my mediocre hardware", but rather "I cannot mediocre the settings on my max hardware"; the performance is bad at any level, but my hardware, while not top-of-the-line, should be able to run a game like this at 4K playable, or at 1080p while looking awesome and running great. Instead, I get 1080p with a mix of medium/low settings in order to get it looking pretty okay in most aspects.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by cmovq on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:05PM (#38032312)
> Why should they limit the highest possible graphics settings only to existing technology?

This assumes Cities Skylines 2 is using some next gen graphics technology when in practice it is a Unity game without any cutting edge graphics. Another comment mentioned they are doing 10k+ draw calls per frame - it's just poorly optimized.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by chemmail on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:02PM (#38032754)
Sticking with Unity probably killed them. They might as well have deved another engine.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Vetch on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:21PM (#38032907)
How does developing another engine help at all? It is very likely its graphics are so under-optimized because they spent most of their time on the simulation aspect, which is more than challenging enough. Dyson Sphere Program is a game with lots of stuff going on at a time, the engine isn't the issue. Cities Skylines 2 is just a very complex game.

As a city builder it has not just dynamic geometry (which makes graphics optimization more challenging) and lots going on on screen like DSP, but also a complex agent based simulation of a city, its transportation, its economy, and individual agent AIs. It is far more complex than most games despite not being graphically intensive. And do note that as far as cities builders go, it's also one of the most ambitious graphically. My personal opinion is they deserve some slack as long as the game continues to improve.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by serf on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:23PM (#38032458)
this is a trope that is spit out by the developers of every poorly optimized sim in recorded history.

Yes, scalability towards the future is good -- but not at the detriment of player performance now.

If the player base doesn't stick around during our current dark-times medieval technology stack, there won't be a player base when we have whatever future tech makes it playable -- see the problem?

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by FirmwareBurner on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:24PM (#38030544)
>As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace, it's becoming less defensible for games to run anywhere below 60fps.

You're forgetting the increasing popularity of the Steam Deck where even 60 FPS is a luxury.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by BlueTemplar on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:07PM (#38032326)
CS2 devs reportedly had 30 FPS as a target. Which is actually fine for that kind of game, but it sounds like that is NOT for low-end hardware ?
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by adgjlsfhk1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:26PM (#38032500)
For CPU heavy games it totally makes sense to target 30fps, but that better be 30fps at 1080p with integrated graphics, (or 30fps 1440p with 1060 class gpu). Add eye candy if you want, but it really should run well on any remotely modern system.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by giobox on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:43PM (#38032605)
> As 160+Hz monitors are finally becoming commonplace

The Steam hardware survey suggests otherwise to my eyes; it's often easy to forget working in tech that a lot of Steam customers have relatively shit hardware:

https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/Steam-Hardware-Softw...

While they don't track monitor peak supported refresh, just looking at the rest of the results suggests to me high-refresh gaming (over 60FPS) is going to be relatively niche at best. Lots of PC gaming specs I take for-granted on my own builds or consider "average" are actually not that common.

I absolutely agree 60fps should be considered the floor for most modern PC games running on "reasonable" hardware though, 30fps belongs to the past.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by aeyes on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:55PM (#38032705)
Most Steam customers play games like Counter Strike, Dota, Team Fortress, PUBG, GTA, Call of Duty which have modest hardware requirements.

I wouldn't read too much into these stats.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by karaterobot on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:01PM (#38032744)
I don't think that's true. Most people who play PC games are Steam users, and they're playing a huge variety of games: pretty much any game that's not exclusive to some other store.
Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by giobox on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:02PM (#38032756)
> I wouldn't read too much into these stats.

This is probably one of the best public sources of data we have on the topic of what hardware actual PC gamers are using.

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by Iulioh on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:53PM (#38032686)
Off topic but 42% of VR headsets are Quest 2

Woahhh

Re:Cities Skylines 2 runs with 20fps on an Nvidia RTX4090 by xnyan on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:47PM (#38033100)
It’s the cheapest headset that also offers a reasonable experience. For around $250 you get a well designed device that includes controllers and does not require a separate computer to use. It’s a very good value, and if you’re unsure about VR probably the best place to dip your toe in the water.