News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by walthamstow on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:00AM (#37984459)
Yet another reason I'm glad I've been refusing my energy suppliers' repeated offers to install a smart meter over the past 10 years.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by sschueller on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:26AM (#37984682)
Why would you refuse if you can get detailed information out of a smart meter about your usage? You can save a lot of power by knowing what is going on and if you have solar you definitely want a smart meter. You also don't need people coming by every so often to check how much electricity, water and gas you have used.

Here in Switzerland 80% of homes are supposed to have smart meters by 2027 but it looks like it will take longer, we are at 20%[1]. Once you have one the energy company has to give you access to (by law[2]) it (rs232, Ethernet what every the device offers) so you can read the data from it.

[1] https://www.srf.ch/sendungen/kassensturz-espresso/kassenstur...

[2] https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2008/226/de#art_8_a

Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by jjgreen on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:50AM (#37984921)
Do you want people to know when you're at home? Fairly easy to do from electricity or water usage patterns. Supposedly only the utility supplier would have that information, but they are so incompetent at security, who knows who else? Certainly the police have access to that. Looks like a sensible security measure to avoid that exposure.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by rcxdude on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:56AM (#37984967)
Fairly easy to do with internet traffic as well. It's non-zero but more most people not likely a meaningful decrease in their privacy.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by sschueller on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:59AM (#37984997)
That is what laws and regulations are for.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by andylynch on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:45AM (#37985534)
You can also drive/walk past in the evening and see if the lights are on inside. Snooping a smart meter signal wouldn’t give away much more, and would be much for effort for a typical burglar
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by chrisandchris on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:09AM (#37985876)
> [...] You can save a lot of power by knowing what is going on [...]

I'm really curious how you go from "smart meter" to "save a lot of power". Just because I have a smeter, I won't save money. My regular meter already shows power consumption (not that convenient, that's true) and my smart meter won't tell me what actually uses my power. So, regarding saving power, it's the same as with a regular meter?

How do you save energy by having a smart meter?

Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by daveoc64 on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:23PM (#37987919)
I can easily see from the in-home display or an app on my phone how much electricity is being used in real time.

This acts as a great reminder to switch off anything that's using a lot of power.

Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by soco on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:34AM (#37986196)
I miss the point of those "advantages" - so what if I know how much water my guests used? Should I run over them in the bathroom and stop them from flushing? Should I let people only come in summer, and tell them to bring their own batteries? Should I stop having guests at all? All because the smart meter told me they pee at noon? And same for my usual electricity usage. I know what I have running and I know what I should shut down, I'm living in this house right. Not like some device sneaks on me and plugs itself in when I doze off. Ok, when I become a solar producer I will probably be helped by smarted devices, but until then I'm totally missing the point.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by forward1 on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:51AM (#37986456)
> Why would you refuse if you can get detailed information out of a smart meter about your usage?

Why would you block ads when you can get "relevant" information on what to buy and consume?

The same asymmetric relationship exists here: the power company gets a lot more benefits from this system than you do, in fact it may even be at your detriment and no one cares.

Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by crooksey on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:38AM (#37984799)
The newer generation smart meters operate on their own network, so that its critical and separate infrastructure so this won't happen again in the future. Also you have to be pretty set on not getting a smart meter as it removes you from a lot of competitive energy deals, especially ones with a cheaper night rate.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by andylynch on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:48AM (#37985575)
In Scotland yes but most most of England and Wales no; the latter used O2’s 2/3g even for new SMETS2 meters.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by Waterluvian on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:23AM (#37984651)
It’s nice of them to ask. Typically it’s theirs for running their side of the contract with you, and oftentimes they’ve got a right to come service it.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by hk1337 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:13AM (#37984558)
Depending on where you are they’ll likely just come and replace it or they’ll start charging you for having to send someone out to read your meter.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by francisofascii on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:22AM (#37984645)
Or they will estimate the monthly bill, and send meter readers less often than once a month.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by rcxdude on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:54AM (#37984953)
Or basically never. I don't think I've ever not self-reported the meter readings.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by hk1337 on Friday October 27, 2023 @09:59PM (#38046376)
Yeah, if you’re not costing them money they’ll probably leave it alone.
Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by sanderjd on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:52AM (#37985639)
Why? What does this matter to you? It's not like these people are going to lose their electrical service due to this.

It's a problem for the utilities, and a cost that will be borne by all their rate payers, but I don't see any individualized cost or benefit here that is dependent on having or not having one of these meters.

Re:Millions of smart meters will brick it when 2G and 3G tur... by mikelward on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:19AM (#37986015)
I don't understand how their problem affects you? Does installing a newer radio module require turning off your supply?