News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:35AM (#37856315)
It's terrible, plastic recycling is a myth told by the petrol industry, that purposefully messed up the recycling labels and greenwashed the entire industry.

It's physically not possible to recycle plastic and get the same propriety back. About 10% of the plastic is "recycled" worlwide, meaning it's been reused to do something else but can't be used for the same thing (bottle -> insulation)

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by tokai on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:41AM (#37856374)
>but can't be used for the same thing

Eh no, why would that be? Where I live 87% of all recycled plastic bottles are reused for new bottles.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:54AM (#37856507)
I'm genuinely curious and would love to be wrong. Do you have some source?

Most of the time they say they do it, but it's much more expensive and recycled plastic quality degrades quickly, can't be mixed with other PET, so you still need to add a majority of regular plastic to the mix.

Quoting wikipedia "approximately 15% of collected PET bottles were actually recycled into new bottles" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PET_bottle_recycling

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by tokai on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:00AM (#37856574)
https://danskretursystem.dk/klima-og-miljoe/genanvendelsen-a...

From the text: "A full 87% of all collected plastic bottles were therefore recycled into new beverage bottles in 2022."

The used plastic is recycled multiple times: "PET plastic bottles are also good materials for many other products, but it is best when they become new beverage bottles. This preserves the high quality of the plastic so that it can be reused again and again"

Why did you write that they "can't be used for the same thing" when even wikipedia says its happens?

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:12AM (#37856703)
Good for danemark but I would still take this information with precaution. PET which is the most common type of plastic for bottles but loose it's propriety after 2-3 cycle. It's not recyclable forever like glasses.

That means your bottle of water will be a bottle of water max 2-3 times until it's not possible to use this plastic again for making bottle.

Wikipedia is not contradicting this, PET is reused in a mix of brand new plastic and old one.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by OfSanguineFire on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:07AM (#37856656)
Soft-drink bottles in the Nordic countries are returned to the supermarket, then washed and refilled. They are not recycled but reused. They are made from a noticeably higher standard of bottle than in other countries, and IIRC there is a code etched onto the bottle to mark how many times it has been refilled. Of course, eventually the bottle will have to be replaced, so new plastic is still consumed, but the system still ensures vast reuse and has for decades now.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by varjag on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:03AM (#37856603)
In Scandinavia plastic bottles are usually returned to recycling machines at the point of sale.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by goda90 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:12AM (#37856713)
In Chile there are thick 3 liter bottles that actually get reused. They have a deposit charge that you get back when you return the empty bottle to the store. New bottles will often be all scuffed up from being reused so many times.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by eimrine on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:49AM (#37856450)
Does it mean that a half (87% minus some losses of plastic material after melting it and forming again) of the brand new plastic bottles in your country are from reused material?
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by tokai on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:49AM (#37856455)
Yes. Or more likely over half of every new bottle is reused plastic. Multiple European countries where this is the case.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by eimrine on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:23AM (#37857592)
Last thing remaining is to make clear of what "bottle" word means in the calculations. I mean that a bottle can be containing either some food (pure water, soda, milk products) or some chemistry. Former (Coca-cola in my mind) is kind of never reused in my country, but latter (some P&G products for example) is almost always from reused material.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by Kuinox on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:39AM (#37856355)
It's not feasibly impossible, it's very hard, but for some type of plastic, you can recycle it infinitely (like PLA).
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:48AM (#37856443)
There is some nuance here, PLA is not a petrol based "plastic". It has the similar proprieties than regular plastic but is made from organic material. I was only referring to petrol based plastic, but not all bio-plastiscs are recyclable either.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by p0w3n3d on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:43AM (#37856388)
One fascinating thing is that on the one hand, the petrol industry messed up the recycling labels, but meanwhile, I am being made responsible by my government for the amount of plastic "I create".
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by ZeroGravitas on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:32AM (#37856880)
You should vote for someone that supports "Extended Producer Responsibility" laws that make the people who make the decisions deal with the costs. This has the magical effect of them suddenly being able to do things that they would falsely describe as "impossible", "impractical" or "too costly" when it's posssible to past the costs of not doing it onto someone else.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_producer_responsibili...

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by matsemann on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:00AM (#37856580)
Why is that bad to be responsible for it? I don't like the take that I often see, that "these big companies are responsible for Y% of total pollution, yet I have to use a paper straw" or similar. Like, why are those companies so big offenders? Because they're providing the products we as consumers consume.

If the external costs of our consumption got priced into what we have to pay, it could actually shift behavior. Companies not polluting as much would win, as their products would be cheaper and gain market share etc.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by ceejayoz on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:07AM (#37856661)
The parent poster's complaint is that industry "messed up the recycling labels", which is true; the recyling logo is basically meaningless.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/chasing-arrows-plastic-recyclin...

> The EPA agrees. In April, the agency recommended the Federal Trade Commission get rid of the chasing arrows recycling symbol for plastics, calling it "deceptive or misleading."

> But not every plastic with the symbol on it can be easily recycled. Inside the chasing arrows symbol sits a small number, called a resin identification code, or RIC. "The numbers were to communicate to people sorting the plastics, how recyclable they are on a scale from 1 to 7," said O'Neill. "It wasn't ever a signal to consumers to say, hey, all of this is recyclable." O'Neill said the numbers 1 and 2 are for the hard plastics found in things like containers and bottles. But items with the other numbers, 3 through 7, are more difficult to recycle.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by Aunche on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:33AM (#37856888)
The government isn't holding a gun to your head demanding that you accept responsibility for your plastic consumption. If it's something you care about, you're necessarily responsible. You can't just pass all the responsibility to corporations. Glass Coke bottles are still used in Mexico because consumers bother to deposit them enough for bottle reuse to be economical.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by kmeisthax on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:59AM (#37856568)
I absolutely hate the ongoing effort to shift the costs of pollution and environmental damage onto end consumers who have no say in the actual production of the products they purchase. "Carbon footprint" was literally coined by oil industries to blame people who buy their shit for buying their shit.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by robertlagrant on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:12AM (#37856710)
> "Carbon footprint" was literally coined by oil industries to blame people who buy their shit for buying their shit.

Where did you learn this?

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by kmeisthax on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:42AM (#37856979)
https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sh...

I misremembered the story. It wasn't literally coined by the oil industry, but it was heavily pushed by them. BP had an ad campaign talking about "personal carbon footprint" in 2005 which put the phrase into the public consciousness.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by amanaplanacanal on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:00AM (#37858158)
Carbon should be taxed when it comes out of the ground. It’s the only way that price signals can actually change people’s behavior.

Is also the most market friendly way to do it. But at least in the US it seems politically impossible.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by robertlagrant on Thursday October 12, 2023 @12:35PM (#37859503)
Well, consumption is what drives it. Education-based messages that convince people to consume less/differently are the non-authoritarian way to effect change.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by varjag on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:00AM (#37856575)
It is highly region specific.

In EU 42.1% plastics are recycled, 39.3% are burned as fuel and 18.5% go to landfill. So it's absolutely possible to do better than 10%.

https://circulareconomy.europa.eu/platform/sites/default/fil...

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:05AM (#37856634)
As I said recycling is most of the time actually downcycling. Don't get me wrong it's better than burning, but the fact we think bottle to bottle is the norm while it's absolutely not is a sign that we have failed somewhere.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by phero_cnstrcts on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:18AM (#37856758)
As the system currently is it’s actually more environmentally friendly to burn plastics instead of shipping it to China where it will either be burnt or dumped in the ocean.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by anticensor on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:10AM (#37858306)
What if we threw those thermoplastics in the oil refinery and let them pyrolyse under the heat of the distillation&cracking column?
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by baal80spam on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:08AM (#37856670)
> the fact we think bottle to bottle is the norm

Do people actually think so? I know nothing about recycling and I'd think that AT BEST 25% of materials are actually "got back" from a product.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by soco on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:45AM (#37857024)
That's a question I always had: is burning plastics bad? I mean, if we had a clean burning, no toxins and toxic ashes...? If this is true, then at least we are not damaging the environment with it (the overconsumption issue aside)
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by varjag on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:48AM (#37857963)
Most plastics are pure carbon and hydrogen so burn cleanly at high enough temperature in the furnace. Naturally CO2 emissions still an issue.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by RetroTechie on Thursday October 12, 2023 @12:12PM (#37859193)
This is why I have developed an aversion towards any plastics containing halogens: chlorinated like PVC, materials with brominated flame retardants, or worse: fluorinated compounds like PFAS.

Burn those, and a whole slew of nasties is produced.

Common plastics like PE, PP & such at least in theory can burn cleanly. If so: make 'm bio-based, maybe a few downcycling steps, followed by burning, maybe isn't too bad overall.

I have a bigger problem with discarded plastic (and related: microplastics) getting everywhere in our environment. That's an overlapping but different problem.

Plastics have their uses & advantages, but we really should be more critical about where they're needed & where not.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by lolinder on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:09AM (#37856682)
When you quote a number like 10% you need to be more specific what you mean, and preferably provide a source.

Most of the percentages I see quoted are percent of plastic in the entire use stream that ends up recycled, but then people interpret it as "there's no point in putting plastic in the recycling because it has a 1 in 10 chance of being recycled". But that's not what the number means, the number means that most plastic doesn't even get to a recycling center.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by h1fra on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:14AM (#37856726)
Well I'm quoting the OP: "Only 9% of the plastic ever produced has been recycled" And it's true not all plastic ends up in the recycling system.
Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by ZeroGravitas on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:21AM (#37856786)
That 9% is of all plastic produced between 1950 and 2015.

> it’s estimated that in 2015, around 55 percent of global plastic waste was discarded, 25 percent was incinerated, and 20 percent was recycled. Of the plastic waste produced between 1950 and 2015, only 9 percent was recycled.

https://ourworldindata.org/faq-on-plastics#how-much-of-globa...

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by lolinder on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:16AM (#37856751)
Yes, that number is dangerous when it's used to imply that recycling programs throw most of the stuff away. That's not what it means.

There are several people here who have actually said that they would rather send plastic to the landfill than to the recycling center because they read numbers like that and interpret them wrong.

Re:Think that your plastic is being recycled? Think again by amanaplanacanal on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:04AM (#37858219)
Well, plastic in the landfill is a form of carbon capture. Eventually something will evolve to eat all that stuff, though it might take a really long time.