> Microsoft owes the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) $28.9 billion in back taxes, not including penalties and interest
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/interest-rates-increase-for-the...
The IRS says Microsoft owes an additional $28.9 billion - in tax for 2004 to 2013 plus penalties and interest
For an SEC filing they really should be declaring the actual value of their liability - the interest on the bill is going to be $10bn+
Big investors will have eyes and ears inside the IRS, so will have known for years about this already.
Also, sharing "insider information" isn't illegal. In some narrow cases profiting off of "insider information" is illegal, but in most cases it's not.
If you're an institutional investor you can just call the CEO or investor relations and ask them tough questions about their business. Sometimes you can figure out within minutes that the CEO is a bozo.
You can visit their offices and talk to the employees. Are they smart and passionate and hard-working, or demoralized and looking to jump ship?
You can also derive material information for instance through freedom of information requests. Is a business being investigated by the SEC? If you write the right letter you can find out based on the kind of form letter you get in response. This information is clearly material (would move the stock if made public) and non-public (the SEC hasn't disclosed its investigation yet) and yet you're free to trade on this information because you derived it and because any investor would have gotten the same response if they had known exactly which magic words to use in their letter to the SEC.
If the CFO leaks the numbers of the quarter and you trade based on that you risk jail time. If you watch the company parking lot and notice that the finance department and CFO stay at work until 11pm in the week leading up to their earnings report you are free to short the stock based on this info.
Material does not mean "would move the market." It means there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important" in making an investment decision". https://www.sec.gov/rules/2000/08/selective-disclosure-and-i...
You can visit their offices and talk to the employees.
If an employee tells you something that is nonpublic information, and you act on it, that would likely be considering insider trading by the SEC. There is a fair amount of case law supporting this point. Indeed, the fact that you acted on the employee's information is generally sufficient proof that the information was material; and this is in fact the most common insider trading scenario.
You can also derive material information for instance through freedom of information requests. Is a business being investigated by the SEC?
If the target of the SEC is not aware of the investigation, the SEC will not disclose that information in response to a FOIA request. On the flipside, if a company is being investigated by the SEC, and knows it, that is material information that must be disclosed to the market.
If you watch the company parking lot and notice that the finance department and CFO stay at work until 11pm in the week leading up to their earnings report you are free to short the stock based on this info.
Such behavior would provide no useful information about the state of a company's financials. In the week leading up to earnings reports, the CFO and finance departments generally stay late making sure the financials are in proper shape, whether or not those financials are good or bad. This is standard practice at all publicly traded companies with proper controls, because there is a very short window of time between the end of the financial period and the time it must be reported for regulatory purposes.
In 2016 the SDNY ruled that issuers do not have a general duty to disclose the existence of an SEC investigation or a Wells Notice. Because "the securities laws do not impose an obligation on a company to predict the outcome of investigations".
https://www2.law.temple.edu/10q/sec-investigations-disclose-...
> the SEC will not disclose that information in response to a FOIA request
Not /intentionally/, of course.
> Such behavior would provide no useful information about the state of a company's financials
Some hedge funds have done very very well for themselves by making inferences from parking lot data. You don't need to be right 100% or 75% of the time for the strategy to work, you know.
It all depends how you come to know the thing, no? If you can infer something from public information others haven't, then bully for you.
I'm pretty sure that if that information is not public, then you're liable. IANAL though so I may be wrong.
If you make inferences from non-public information (e.g. talking to the CEO) you can freely trade on that, provided the CEO hasn't shared MNPI with you directly.
Every public company has an Investor Relations department that talks to institutional investors every day. Investors wouldn't bother talking to IR if they could get the same information somewhere else. And these communications are not made public and shared with other investors.
Abbreviating that is so misleading, it's incredibly hard to not see it as bad faith! MNPI means "material non-public information". You're saying "non-public information is fine but material non-public information is not", without making it as obvious.
Yes, it has to be material. "Owes $30b in taxes" is ABSOLUTELY material. If on top of that you learn about it from IRS insider contacts, enjoy your time in prison.
Please do read the Wikipedia article; it has a section on the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading
> SEC regulation FD ("Fair Disclosure") requires that if a company intentionally discloses material non-public information to one person, it must simultaneously disclose that information to the public at large.
You're making the exact mistake that I've repeatedly tried to correct. There is no bad faith on my part.
It's a "legal concept" in the same way that every word used in a lawbook is a legal concept; the US is based on case law, and there is a large amount of precedent for this definition in particular. Again, refer to the Wikipedia for some examples.
I see this mistake a lot among programmers (also myself at some point). They (we) naturally think law is like a rulebook where you go through a decision tree and then arrive at a perfect conclusion, but the truth is that it's up to the courts to decide on the specifics. And they might disagree on those things with you, and with each other, but in the egregious cases disagreements are rare.
Remember that agencies like the IRS, FDA, SEC must not leak a single bit of information (investigation/no investigation). Because that single bit is sufficient to profitably trade on. A hedge fund doesn't need to know the specifics or the exact date of an enforcement announcement in order to make out like a bandit. A tiny amount of signal is sufficient. In fact, a tiny amount of signal is preferred. If a firm knows for a fact that MSFT is in trouble with the IRS they can't trade on it. But if a little bit of information leaks from an agency, that's gold.
It's because insider trading is a generally stupid crime. If you're on Wall Street, there are better ways to make money. The people who insider trade are largely those who think Wall Street is constantly doing it--it's an old joke in finance.
This is pretty much the literal definition of insider trading, but feel free to follow this advice if you plan on having a long discussion with the SEC while they audit all of your trades for the past decade.
And these communications are not made public and shared with other investors.
This is false. IR departments will only discuss information that is already made available to investors, through press releases or public compliance filings (such as SEC filings). They absolutely will not provide nonpublic material information just because someone asks, and in the event they do so, it's literally their job to provide an investor communication so that the information is publicly available.
For example, when Hindenburg Research did a ton of research and discovered that Nikola was basically totally fraudulent, they traded extremely relevant information that wasn’t publicly available. Not insider trading.
Similarly, if Warren Buffet invests in a company, he knows that its stock is very likely to go up (just as a result of the halo effect around him). He doesn’t have to disclose that he plans to buy, though.
The public record is quite public.
Big market actors are just institutionalized corrupt people working for private companies. Change my mind.
I'm writing a long form article about this idea, how in America we do stuff like private prisons, allow pollution, the "family" court system and social media for kids even though some countries can easily fix these problems we refuse to address them because just TOO much money is being made (at least that's how the divorce industry was explained to me).
- Syriana
This is incorrect. https://www.natlawreview.com/article/sec-secures-largest-eve...
> they can break the SEC rules to artificially reduce the share price
No, stock manipulation with falsification of bad information is also heavily prosecuted.
Can you give specific examples where you think this happened? You might not be using the correct definition of “inside information” or “artificially reduce”.
Pfizer top-people bought a huge amount of shares before their vaccine was publicly approved and they sold it the moment the public was made aware that there was a vaccine for COVID-19 approved by the FDA
Microsoft bought a lot of Activision Blizzard shares a few days before they announced they would buy the company.
Having this thin line separating what's allowed and what isn't is not ideal. If you have privileged information, for example, that your product will be approved, something that isn't public knowledge, it should be considered insider trading.
It had to be an already scheduled sale or he will get busted. That doesn’t fly with the SEC.
> Pfizer top-people bought a huge amount of shares before their vaccine was publicly approved and they sold it the moment the public was made aware that there was a vaccine for COVID-19 approved by the FDA
By shares with expectation of approval is fine. They didn’t know it was approved.
> Microsoft bought a lot of Activision Blizzard shares a few days before they announced they would buy the company.
Do you realize how stupid this statement is? You buy a company by buying shares. Building up a stake before tendering an offer is the normal process.
> If you have privileged information, for example, that your product will be approved, something that isn't public knowledge, it should be considered insider trading.
That is insider trading and would be prosecuted if that’s what happened.
This might not be the most authoritative website but it lines up with what is in wikipedia: https://www.yourdictionary.com/articles/martha-stewart-jail-...
Unfortunately, they got the verb wrong: software is eating _not_ drinking the world.
Have you ever seen one of those machines in restaurants that from a hopper full of oranges, automatically slices, squeezes the juice into a glass and puts the rind etc into a composting bag? They do that to deliver a fresh glass of juice that people believe has a material difference from a can of frozen concentrate. Juicero was that but simplified and expanded to more than just oranges.
Consider the factory process of making different juices. Might use heat, introduce other molecules, etc. By performing part of the task in the factory and the final extraction onprem, there may be some meaningful differences in the consumable.
But sure, let’s all poke fun at something without considering the operational context.
https://www.ticomachine.com/faq/how-is-orange-juice-made.htm...
Apparently the founders and investors had not.
Accordingly the price might not move because of similar assumptions.
To be clear that’s just how I read that comment. I know nothing about this situation with Microsoft.
https://www.seattletimes.com/business/microsoft/microsoft-ir...
Sorry, just so I'm clear, you are claiming that major hedge funds have "moles" in the IRS that illegally funnel them the private tax information of major public companies?
What possible source do you have for this?
Better yet, the IRS and Microsoft are working together on a secret AI tax scheme and this is a cover-up for transferring large amounts of funds to the IRS or to Microsoft for the program to work.
There are tons of "Expert networks" companies where they tap key personnel for market info. I have received these sort of inquiries many times in the past. Hedge Funds are major users of these.
I can easily see the line of inquiry not breaking the law but getting close enough to extrapolate information on the companies being targeted (IRS personnel, for example), without outright naming them.
This is kind of digital fingerprinting, but for companies. You don't may never get the name of the company, but at some point the questions become so specific that shoe will only fit 1-2 companies.
I'm also a part of a few expert netowrks and I probably get to take phone calls a dozen times a year to help people who need information on my area of expertice.
What specific person would someone contact to findout that Microsoft has unannounced tax liabilities that wouldn't' in anyway break insider trading rules?
Who possibly could attest to this type of information and would freely offer it up? No serious expert network member would ever do this as it would be the end of their career and expose them to serious jail time.
Perhpas you could fleshout your explanation some more here.
What are confidential, ongoing tax cases at the IRS is not something expert networks provide.
This has been going on since 2007. The IRS sued Microsoft in 2015 [1] and been publicly targeting them since 2020 [2].
[1] https://www.seattletimes.com/business/microsoft/microsoft-ir...
[2] https://www.propublica.org/article/the-irs-decided-to-get-to...
Given the Stock Markets inability to predict the Twitter buyout despite public documents stating Elon Musk's contract to buy at $54.20/share throughout 2022, I'm pretty sure that stock market investors are literally illiterate, unable to read public documents.
Anyone who bought Twitter at $35/share after the contracts public disclosure knows what I'm talking about.
---------
AMC / APE for another example. Anyone who short sold AMC and bought long APE made bank this past year (before the AMC/APE stock ticker merge there were public documents in December 2022 stating AMCs intention to merge the two one-for-one)
I believe I saw an opportunity as wide as $8 for AMC and $1.50 for a legally equivalent APE a few months ago.
Literally public documents with public court signatures and everything, but so many people remaining ignorant for months, providing anyone 'who can read' an opportunity to make tons of nearly risk free money.
It doesn't make them "literally illiterate" though.
That clause was clearly for things outside of Elon (or former Twitter)'s control. Like if a government stepped in to stop the purchase.
Elon never had a good counter argument. So it was simply a case of those who were able to read the public court documents vs the ones who believed Elons out-of-court media blitz.
Alas, the only arguments that matter in court are the arguments that are filled in court. None of the discussion points you talked about even made it to the case, they were laughed out long before Elon gave up and bought Twitter.
------
Reading. It's a superpower. That's what the past year has taught me. A surpring number of people cannot read and will believe falsehoods even if they contradict written and agreed upon documents.
The biggest winners were those who short sold Tesla, knowing that Elon would be forced to sell Tesla stock to afford a $44 Billion purchase (even if $13 Billion was covered in loans and maybe $9 Billion in handshake agreements with other investors like Saudis or Larry Ellison etc. Etc.)
If you short sold Tesla and bought TWTR in preparation for the buyout event, you'd have made even more money. Etc. Etc. And some people did do that.
--------
Anyway. AMC/APE was the more recent event a few weeks ago proving the illiterate stock market traders. It's happening again and again. Tons of opportunities exist if you have the ability to read, and comprehend, the public legal text. This is absolutely not a thing typical traders can do, the price fluctuations are proof of that.
I dunno what the next event will be, but I'm keeping my eyes open for easy money.
Which in the context of modern anti-intellectualism makes a lot of sense it’s not unlike calling Y equals MX plus B machine learning. Soon arrogance will mean being able to form a complete sentence.
“My man” itself is also obnoxious and condescending.
He couldn't have. That clause protected Twitter, not him. It ensured Twitter would still get something in case outside forces, like government regulators or financing falling through, prevented the deal. It did not give Musk the right to pay a penalty and back out.
Twitter explicitly reserved the right to sue for specific performance, i.e. to force the deal through rather than merely getting damages. Musk explicitly signed away any rights to investigate or back out. Twitter was honest and forthright so any fraud claims were nonsense. Musk didn't have a leg to stand on, legally or factually.
The most he could have done was tie things up in court.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/11/business/dealbook/elon-mu...
The other guy you're talking to is being a dick. There was a concerted disinformation campaign from Musk and friends, and the papers were not willing enough to call "bullshit" on the front page. The truth was out there but hardly staring you in the face.
But hedge funds have teams of lawyers reading this stuff all day long. They have no excuse for not seeing through Musk's chicanery.
It kinda was, though. A bunch of lawyer-reacts at the time basically were "this isn't financial advice, but lol Musk is fucked and the Delaware court doesn't screw around or delay"
This would be "staring you in the face", and it's what the papers should have written:
MUSK ANNOUNCES LONG-SHOT PLAN TO BACK OUT OF TWITTER DEAL
He will likely be compelled to complete acquisition at $54.20 per share, legal experts say
Start putting your money in the market and you won't be talking about easy money for "anyone who can read" for very long.
Their point was something along the lines of "it doesn't take a genius to buy low and sell high".
My counter point, to which I don't believe I ever got a response, was "oh? try it then"
Markets are easy to read in hindsight. Most folks are predicting a housing market correction over the next 12 months. But, they've been doing that for the past 12 months too, and it hasn't really happened yet (very mild).
So, when to buy? The answer is that it's quite complicated, and the work is in the individual deal - it requires a lot of research, understanding neighborhoods, WFH trends, how to spot "lipstick on a pig" house flips, regulatory issues, flood zones, insurance rates, mortgage rates, warrantable vs non-warrantable loans and what properties qualify, hurricane standards, wiring, electrical service, plumbing, STR income, occupancy rates, management fees, cleaning fees and quality, long term rental income, renter risk profiles and a million other things that go into understanding whether a deal will make money.
No, it doesn't take a genius, but it does take a lot of hard work.
This is called "pairs trading", right? Is there any way it can blow up? Remember that this is AMC, which could be out of business in six months or could go up 3000% in another idiotic bubble.
I made a fair bit of money off Twitter because it was as simple as buying stock at the market rate. Anyone who reads the papers knew the price of Twitter to the penny and could have bought in with a phone call. The sort of trade you're talking about sounds harder to pull off safely. That's no excuse for the hedge funds, of course.
This was my first search on Google, but there were many, many, many documents of this nature.
Is this doc sufficient? Or are you looking for something else? I'm aware of earlier docs but it gets more legalize and arcane the further back you go.
By the time the trials started, the argument from Twitter was incredibly strong and well documented. But the stock price of Twitter was still like $40 so you'd have lots of opportunity to make money on the trade (Musk promised to buy at $54.20 after all)
All of that contributes to a completely different picture for me, compared to your statements. Sure, I can read documents like that (if I can find them, if I think of searching for them, ...), but I am not at all confident that my literal interpretation is sound. Thus my perceived risk of an investment would be much higher than yours.
So, maybe literacy is not the point here, but rather confidence in interpreting legal texts correctly, a good grasp of contract law and optimism/experience regarding external factors.
You DO NOT need to be a lawyer to get the arguments. By the time the discussion reaches this stage, the arcane bits are stripped out and referenced explicitly.
In fact, the jury are laypeople, just average Joe's and Jane's. All arguments must be simplified to a point that average people can understand. So it's a good point to pickup info.
---------
Here's a few key events to note on this particular trial:
1. Strong opening argument from Twitter over the contract. My opinion of course, but just read the document and get a gist of the argument yourself.
2. Weak opening arguments from Musk's lawyers.
3. Repeated reprimands from the trial judge for various mistakes the Musk lawyer team were committing
4. Inconsistency between what Elon Musk was saying in public / in the media and what his lawyers were saying in the trial.
-------
Note that in this special case, a judge decided the case instead of a jury. But the argument style at this late stage is simplified to the point where ordinary people / a jury can understand in any case.
> Plaintiff Twitter, Inc. (“Twitter”), by and through its undersigned counsel, as and for its complaint against defendants Elon R. Musk, X Holdings I, Inc. (“Parent”), and X Holdings II, Inc. (“Acquisition Sub”), alleges as follows:
If you are trying to say this is 'difficult to read', maybe don't pick things that are answered in the first paragraph.
But let us stop here. It is obvious that you are very confident in interpreting documents like that. So I hope you are enjoying great gains from your investments based on your interpretations in similar cases.
You see Elons side and evaluate their followup. You follow the back and forth and evaluate who has the stronger argument.
When it gets to the point that the judge is literally reprimanding Elon Musk's council for breaking rules and shenanigans, you start buying TWTR and short selling TSLA.
You're grossly overcomplicating this. You don't come up with arguments in a trial, that's the lawyers jobs. Your job as a reader is simply to pick out the side with the better argument.
-------
If you are worried about form, that's not your job. That's the judges job. And if you are worried about not understanding the complete argument, that's not even your job. That's the opposing lawyers job to make a cohesive and full argument.
At this stage of the trial, it's simply reading.
This is almost CERTAINLY true. MSFT will be able to tie this up in court, and has tremendous motivation to do so.
They could hire the best lawyers, accountants, lobbyists, etc in the world. Unless someone at microsoft did something criminal, it's likely they could knock a significant portion off the tax bill.
> The stock price doesn’t seem to be hurting pre-market at all.
Microsoft's market cap is $2.5 Trillion. The one-time tax bill amounts to about 1% of its 'total value'. It's like a one time $1000 special property tax on your $100K rental property. It sucks but it's not the end of the world. Besides, even if they had to pay $30 billion in back taxes, MSFT's customers are utlimately going to pay for it, not microsoft. It doesn't affect microsoft's market share in OS, Office, Servers, etc.
Microsoft’s operating income in fiscal year 2005 was about $15B and in 2013 almost $27B. So you can kind see where the IRS is getting this number: if they believe that Microsoft evaded tax worth about 10-15% of its earnings before taxes, that’s how it would add up to this whopping sum.
It seems like Microsoft believes they can settle for something much lower. The stock price doesn’t seem to be hurting pre-market at all.