Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by simonw on Thursday October 05, 2023 @03:30PM
(#37783150)
This affects the Twitter social media card of type summary_large_image - a short-term fix if this affects your site is to switch that for the summary card, which still shows a visible link title with a smaller, square cropped image. https://twitter.com/matteason/status/1709986442124951931
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by isodev on Thursday October 05, 2023 @03:25PM
(#37783089)
I think the “the masses” implies there are actually a lot of people still reading Twitter… perhaps it's just my bubble, but I feel not many actual humans are impacted by this change.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by avgcorrection on Thursday October 05, 2023 @03:29PM
(#37783141)
Use of that phrase tends to either signal that the author thinks that their little bubble is larger than it really is or that they have some sort of paternalistic need to inform this not-me-but-most-everyone-else group of people (or be concerned on their behalf). Or both.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by plorkyeran on Thursday October 05, 2023 @09:11PM
(#37786165)
Alternatively non-Brits may need to recognize that they aren't the primary target audience of British media and it's not a problem if they misunderstand something.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by ethanbond on Thursday October 05, 2023 @03:24PM
(#37783072)
"Who wouldn't want Elon Musk by their side, leading product?" - Linda
Thankfully no one will possibly consider just putting the titles inside the images in 48pt font with eye-bursting colors and no way to respond to user/device-specific configuration, right?
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by autoexec on Thursday October 05, 2023 @03:47PM
(#37783382)
If twitter really wants to "boost engagement" I'd suggest maybe not forcing people to log in or have JS enabled, but maybe that's just me. I haven't viewed anything on the platform itself since they made those changes.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by willio58 on Thursday October 05, 2023 @04:22PM
(#37783823)
> or have JS enabled
For 99% of users, they don't even know what Javascript is, let alone that you can disable it, let alone that they _should_ disable it on any site.
Not saying if that's a good thing or not, but I doubt allowing JS to be disabled would have any real effect on their engagement. In fact, I'm sure the frontend team at X would argue all the visual stuff enabled by JS increases engagement.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by xg15 on Thursday October 05, 2023 @04:29PM
(#37783895)
> "Our algorithm tries to optimize time spent on X, so links don't get as much attention, because there is less time spent if people click away," the billionaire said.
... at that point he might as well say "maximize" instead of "optimize"
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by snailmailman on Thursday October 05, 2023 @06:46PM
(#37785209)
I don’t understand this move at all. “There is less time spent if people click away”
So now people are forced to click every link if they want to see what it’s about? Can’t stay on Twitter and get the headline and lead-in?
I would think these link previews let people stay on twitter but what do I know. I’ve stopped using it a long time ago. The mastodon app I use has link previews so this won’t affect me much.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by slowmovintarget on Thursday October 05, 2023 @09:49PM
(#37786369)
Have they de-discovered a/b testing? Presumably it would have told them whether users stay or go because they have to click the link to find out what it is.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by anonymousab on Friday October 06, 2023 @12:20PM
(#37792773)
Musk's argument is that not showing any of the content other than the image will force people to instead put the article text content in the Twitter post itself, next to the image. By showing almost no context for a link, it will force posters to manually include more context, and thus people will stay on Twitter longer than when they were generating a bit of context for the embeds (e.g. article title).
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by optionalsquid on Thursday October 05, 2023 @05:21PM
(#37784445)
What are the consequences for people using screen readers?
Are the article details still accessible to those users or do they have go entirely by the tweet text?
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by Dig1t on Thursday October 05, 2023 @05:49PM
(#37784709)
This is an unpopular opinion, but I think Hacker News would be a worse experience with link previews.
One of the best things about this site, ui-wise, is that it feels "focused".
The focus is not on the links posted but on the text surrounding them, if you want to give a preview for what your link is talking about, you just explain it.
It also encourages less lazy discussion, because the title and pictures don't jump through the link into the current context.
It might not be a bad thing for X in the same way it works well here.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by genmud on Thursday October 05, 2023 @07:01PM
(#37785314)
And yet, we are talking about X. Which currently shows a cover photo and nothing else about a link, so you have no idea what the link / article / page is about.
Many people share links with commentary and without clicking on an article you would have no idea other than a photo, about what the commentary is referring to.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by chownie on Thursday October 05, 2023 @09:20PM
(#37786227)
But they've done the opposite, dropped the headline and just kept the picture. When you can only advertise your content through the picture, you get YouTube thumbnails, not HN.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by LorenPechtel on Thursday October 05, 2023 @08:33PM
(#37785957)
While my exposure to Xitter is limited to Xits that others post and very occasionally reading an associated thread I think there's *some* merit here.
URLs can be bulky and making them short has it's merits. However, it also reduces the information--what they are seeing as "engagement" is often going to be people clicking it, seeing it's garbage and closing it. Thus I would favor a middle ground: Short visible URLs but the whole thing is displayed if you hover over it. I have no good answer for mobile.
Re:X confuses the masses by removing all details from links
by defrost on Monday October 09, 2023 @01:14AM
(#37817096)
Think of it as just another retweet(?) (re-X (?)) by Musk as he scans through his feed looking for things to boost - it's not a professional graphic, just a bit of fanboy material.
If you want to be really disturbed .. follow the source and see if you can spot any tell tale signs of just how rabid a fan that particular fan might be.
Less a Musk fan work, more a devoted offering from a Musk Acolyte willing to die at the altar of Elon.
I have a pattern for producing screenshots of my pages for use in social media cards which is suddenly a lot more relevant: https://til.simonwillison.net/shot-scraper/social-media-card...
I've known 1 or 2 people in real life who use it
Looks like the perfect time to shave a few bytes off our pages and go OG-only. Ironically, X is perfectly fine with just og:images.
Thankfully no one will possibly consider just putting the titles inside the images in 48pt font with eye-bursting colors and no way to respond to user/device-specific configuration, right?
On behalf of global media conglomerates and petro addicts everywhere - can we jail Musk already
For 99% of users, they don't even know what Javascript is, let alone that you can disable it, let alone that they _should_ disable it on any site.
Not saying if that's a good thing or not, but I doubt allowing JS to be disabled would have any real effect on their engagement. In fact, I'm sure the frontend team at X would argue all the visual stuff enabled by JS increases engagement.
To be fair there are probably a least a couple dozen people who do this.
A RSS reader like UI would suffice. Make it fancy if you have to.
I wouldn't even mind inline contextual ads. Or subscriptions. Or paid apps.
And, hot damn, dedupe the noise. All those @#$%^ retweets. Once is enough. FFS.
And I only to see the "pinned" post once. Not every single time I visit.
--
PS, FWIW, nitter hasn't musked up the links. https://nitter.net/drvolts
... at that point he might as well say "maximize" instead of "optimize"
So now people are forced to click every link if they want to see what it’s about? Can’t stay on Twitter and get the headline and lead-in?
I would think these link previews let people stay on twitter but what do I know. I’ve stopped using it a long time ago. The mastodon app I use has link previews so this won’t affect me much.
... will feel compelled to pay for Twitter, since to post significant text in a tweet you need to pay.
That's the real goal, to push people to paud accounts, not to make Twitter stickier.
People have already started protesting by making fake headlines for articles about Elon, so I have a feeling this "feature" won't last very long.
One of the best things about this site, ui-wise, is that it feels "focused". The focus is not on the links posted but on the text surrounding them, if you want to give a preview for what your link is talking about, you just explain it.
It also encourages less lazy discussion, because the title and pictures don't jump through the link into the current context.
It might not be a bad thing for X in the same way it works well here.
Many people share links with commentary and without clicking on an article you would have no idea other than a photo, about what the commentary is referring to.
[1] https://github.com/insin/control-panel-for-twitter/releases/...
^1 while Twitter continues to put the headline in the aria-label on the link, given there's no accessibility team left to protect it
^2 unless you're using Firefox, as Firefox Add-ons now takes ~4 days to review new versions
URLs can be bulky and making them short has it's merits. However, it also reduces the information--what they are seeing as "engagement" is often going to be people clicking it, seeing it's garbage and closing it. Thus I would favor a middle ground: Short visible URLs but the whole thing is displayed if you hover over it. I have no good answer for mobile.
not sure it will work, but in an age where car heated seats and printer ink cartridges are behind subscriptions, why not this?
It's the age of nickel-and-diming, so I expect more of such weird antics to continue and spread to other websites.
Check out this animation posted by Elon Musk in the last few days https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1710561314278379959 where the X jerks slightly before it rotates, and then rotates off-center...
If you want to be really disturbed .. follow the source and see if you can spot any tell tale signs of just how rabid a fan that particular fan might be.
Less a Musk fan work, more a devoted offering from a Musk Acolyte willing to die at the altar of Elon.
It all starts making more sense in that context. And if it's not, say it out loud a few times.