News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by eurleif on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:43AM (#37700094)
Asking out of curiosity, not to be cruel: I wonder if he's willing to use medical equipment that uses non-Free software? To my knowledge, his stated position against using non-Free software is pretty much absolute; but given that medical equipment's software is almost universally non-Free, taking that stance here would seriously endanger his ability to receive necessary medical care.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by randunel on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:51AM (#37700148)
I remember Stallman claiming he would use non-free software if there was no alternative, providing an example of software use without alternative at some conference. His position isn't "absolute" to reject everything non-free, in his example he'd use Windows as long as there were no alternatives and usage had to be performed.

Unfortunately, I can't find a link with this claim to share.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by NhanH on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:55AM (#37700179)
I will answer this assuming good faith, but this line of reasoning is very irritating since the answer (to me) is obvious.

If RMS made a choice to use proprietary software, with the only alternative being his dead, there is absolutely no moral conflict, or even anything against his principle. The only issue could only ever arises if he claimed "Free Software is more important than human lives", which I am pretty sure not a claim he, or anyone, has ever made.

It's basically the same principle as if you point a gun to my head and tell me to kill a puppy or get shot (and I'm certain you would shoot me). It's obvious which choice I would make, and I hardly see that as an evidence of my hatred for puppy.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by aragonite on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:24AM (#37700367)
> The only issue could only ever arises if he claimed "Free Software is more important than human lives", which I am pretty sure not a claim he, or anyone, has ever made.

Valuing freedom (even in limited spheres) more than human lives is a pretty familiar American idea. For example, recall Patrick Henry's "give me liberty or give me death" and consider that he was talking about the prospect of being taxed without his consent, not enslavement. Also, recall Private Eightball from Full Metal Jacket:

"Personally, I think, uh... they don't really want to be involved in this war. You know, I mean... they sort of took away our freedom and gave it to the, to the gookers, you know. But they don't want it. They'd rather be alive than free, I guess. Poor dumb bastards."

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by erik_seaberg on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:39AM (#37700465)
Can modified firmware be used with human patients, or would somebody go to prison or lose his license to practice? Would you have to collaborate with a manufacturer before a device goes into certification?
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by mbakke on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:57AM (#37701048)
Arguably there should be laws mandating that medical equipment MUST be open for everyone to inspect, contribute, and share.

That does not answer your question though. It goes both ways: if the doctor recognises that a firmware tweak may save your life, then she should be able to do so.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by eurleif on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:31AM (#37700410)
>the answer (to me) is obvious

The answer is obvious based on your own personal principles, or based on RMS's stated principles?

>The only issue could only ever arises if he claimed "Free Software is more important than human lives"

He claimed that it is categorically not good to use non-Free software, with one exception for using non-Free software to develop a replacement for that software; and that "we must resist stretching [that exception] any further": https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/is-ever-good-use-nonfree-prog...

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by noirscape on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:49AM (#37700551)
It's not a bad question to ask; the FSF has proven in the past to be rather uninterested and unhelpful in helping developers of medical software get their stuff licensed in a way that's either compliant or as close to as[0] being compliant as possible[1]. Instead they opted to chide those wanting help for not being true believers of the cause and told them they'll never compromise. Basically the usual "FSF is only ever willing to do FOSS in it's own Ivory Tower even though its mission is to spread it beyond an Ivory Tower."

That said - RMS has iirc said in the past that for medical emergencies he's willing to make a personal exception on this stance.

[0]: Medical devices can't be GPL compliant due to the anti-Tivo clause combined with regulations of the FDA that demand that a medical device will always behave the exact same way in the exact same situation. This is also extended to the software, meaning that not being allowed to reflash the software if you're not the manufacturer is a requirement.

[1]: https://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/gplv3-fda

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by hutzlibu on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:10AM (#37700713)
"Medical devices can't be GPL compliant due to the anti-Tivo clause combined with regulations of the FDA that demand that a medical device will always behave the exact same way in the exact same situation."

What is the anti-tivo clause?

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by noirscape on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:30AM (#37700849)
Ok so that requires a bit of history. There's this company that makes video recorders (for your TV) called TiVo; it's not an abbreviation for anything, that's just the name.

--

Anyway, TiVo wanted to get onto the GPLv2 train like a lot of companies, but they also wanted people owning their devices to be unable to partially modify their firmware even as they distributed their copies of the firmware onto TiVo boxes. They enforced this by having a digital signature check that only allowed TiVos own software to run if the software stack was either entirely TiVo or entirely FOSS (Bradley Kuhn of the SFC iirc investigated the TiVo boxes post-hoc, the signature checks only were an issue if you partially replaced TiVos software, not if you went the whole hog on replacing it).

The FSF took personal offense to this practice and dubbed it "Tivoization", which is a shorthand for "attempting to restrict the ability to install or link with Free Software via hardware DRM".

As a result, the GPLv3 includes an explicit clause that if your software is distributed in a non-code form, that you also must distribute all the information required to be able to modify that distributed software, if there's parts on the device that prevent you from doing so. (Or in plain terms: on restricted hardware, you must give up the signing keys if you preload the hardware with FOSS software.)

--

This clause is usually just called the anti-Tivo(ization) clause and it's... pretty damn controversial. It's the main reason why the Kernel is still GPLv2 and not GPLv3; Linus Torvalds personally considers this clause to be a significant enough alteration of the "deal" that FOSS provides for the kernel, so he didn't upgrade (which to be clear would've also been very difficult since the kernel is 2.0-only, not or-later, so he'd require approval from all significant contributors at that point). It's also often cited as the main reason why the GPLv2 has/had strong corporate backing but software licensed under the GPLv3 has always kinda had issues with that; the v2 was seen as more "fair" in that companies were willing to work with its terms, while the v3 was seen as basically forcing them to give up important parts of their trade secrets and made them antsy of working with the FSF in general.

And as mentioned before, in some fields (medical is the one I know of, but I'm pretty sure there's a few others), regulatory compliance is impossible with v3 while very much possible with v2 because of this clause.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by hutzlibu on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:50AM (#37701003)
Thanks for the detailed explanation and ugh, it is so frustrating. I get and share the goal of being able to fully control your devices - but you have to work with what you have. And I think this fanatism and uncompromising attitude is really not helpful in getting there.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by debugnik on Friday September 29, 2023 @05:24AM (#37701235)
This is wrong, the GPLv3 only requires installation information for "User Products" (as defined in the license) which the manufacturer can update even if the user can't. Most medical equipment isn't User Products and can't simply be updated by the manufacturer for regulatory reasons.

That article was written before the finished GPLv3 was published, they had only published a stricter draft.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by noirscape on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:24AM (#37702108)
User Products would I'm pretty sure still target things like pacemakers and other daily technological appliances some people need to get around and I'm fairly sure those require the same FDA approval process.

Therefore; I'm not wrong.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by riffraff on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:49AM (#37700131)
GNU existed without a kernel for a while, RMS did not stop using computers. If there is no free alternative you use what you can.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by usr1106 on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:40AM (#37700476)
For a while? Wasn't GNU Hurd supposed to be the kernel? Just vague memories, didn't read up on it right now. Still not even close to ready.

Linux is not a GNU project. But it's free software, so I suppose RMS could use it without major pain. Although he'd probably prefer Linux to use GPLv3.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by erik_seaberg on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:00AM (#37700639)
GNU started with rewriting the Unix userland (especially GCC) years before announcing the Hurd effort. I think they developed and tested on BSD and SunOS, and later Linux (because they had nearly written the first distro, only without a kernel).
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by INTPenis on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:29AM (#37700401)
Younger folk might not remember that RMS actually once said that Word 5.0 was the best word processor he ever used.

He's not unreasonable, he's just very adamant about software freedom.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by chaps on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:51AM (#37700147)
The question is least on his mind: https://www.gnuhealth.org/
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by thih9 on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:49AM (#37700129)
Note that it wouldn’t be him using (operating) the machines.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by elromulous on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:47AM (#37700118)
Does that mean he doesn't drive/fly/ride in/on any cars/buses/trains/aircraft? Because the same applies to those.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by Gigachad on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:54AM (#37700175)
Stallman and the FSF has fairly arbitrary views on this stuff. Non free firmware running on microcontrollers is fine because it's part of the hardware. But if there is a firmware blob that gets copied over by the OS on boot, then it's not ok for unclear reasons.

Results in a lot of stuff getting rejected for FSF certification despite being just as open practically as the certified stuff.

A car probably just isn't seen as software to him if it's just the internal control systems. Maybe the entertainment system these days would be.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by Xelynega on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:18AM (#37700324)
I think you have this a bit backwards.

To my knowledge the FSF doesn't consider firmware blobs with no way to flash "part of certification" because it would be inoractical to do so. By definition "software you can't change" isn't "free"(as in speech, not beer), so I don't think it's an ideological line.

So they either have to consider any device with unmodifiable software to be non-free(basically removing entire device classes), or be realistic and draw the line somewhere. "Can you modify the software on the device from the rest of the gnu software" is a line that matches up with their ideals fairly well IMO.

Basically, Richard Stallman is well aware that cars are bundles of non-free software(see: https://jalopnik.com/richard-stallman-weighs-in-on-the-check...). He has voiced opinions that software controlling the brakes in your car should be FSF and not binary blobs that come pre-installed with no visibility.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by debok on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:05AM (#37700248)
RMS is notorious for his willingness to go through quite a lot of inconvenience to stick to his free software principles.

You can search his site for the word "ticket" to get an idea of how he feels about software systems in public transport.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by skrebbel on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:53AM (#37700168)
I think what it means is that if there were open source airplanes he’d take those, even at the cost of an enormous detour.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by ladyanita22 on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:43AM (#37700098)
i'd bet many machines run on old Linux kernels with some shitty blobs and software on top.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by thallosaurus on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:45AM (#37700105)
I got a slight feeling that most equipment runs on windows. Could also be wrong.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by skywal_l on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:51AM (#37700144)
From what I know in the industry, Windows for the UI and some real time OS for control like VxWorks.

But things are changing and linux is getting some traction.

The healthcare industry is very slow moving (as it should be).

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by ladyanita22 on Friday October 06, 2023 @05:06AM (#37788543)
All this stuff is constantly moving, but I bet things in the future will be RT Linux plus some RTOS-drive microcontrollers for specific hardware and safety stuff. That's where everyone is heading to.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by andrewia on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:46AM (#37700116)
Windows is common from what I've seen. When I did a brief interview with Abbott Medical Devices in the 2010s, Windows experience was mentioned.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by milianw on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:47AM (#37700120)
sadly there's also a lot of QNX :(
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by elromulous on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:50AM (#37700139)
Ah QNX, one of the few remaining vestiges of the microkernel.

I know it's not foss, and I'm aware of mach, but QNX still holds a place in my heart.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by londons_explore on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:50AM (#37700142)
Just installed a gas boiler that only has a 7 segment LCD to display the water temperature. Yet it runs Linux. And it takes 30 seconds to boot up.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by ladyanita22 on Friday October 06, 2023 @05:05AM (#37788521)
WTF I can't believe they put linux in there. Must be much fancier than a MCU-driven display.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by globular-toast on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:04AM (#37700236)
Do people really think RMS is like a Jehovah's Witness or something? The man is about practically bringing the change he wants to see. He started his own damn Unix clone that we still rely on to this day and you liken him to religious nutters?
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by l33t7332273 on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:51AM (#37700567)
I think TempleOS shows that designing an operating system does not mean you can’t be a religious nutter.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by code_duck on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:53AM (#37700160)
I don't believe that Stallman would give up his principles. I suppose one could investigate whether has ever been to an ER. My guess is that he would rather stand firm and die.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by code_duck on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:06PM (#37706246)
Not sure how people interpreted this, but it wasn't criticism or celebration of his misfortune. I intended to note that he is extraordinarily firm in standing by his beliefs and principles.
Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by rekado on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:50AM (#37701001)
There are two common misunderstandings about free software:

+ the opposition against proprietary software does not mean that using proprietary software is immoral on its own. (Although you'll find plenty of people who will make this some sort of purity contest, rms is not one of them.) The moral evil that the free software movement address is to be forced or coerced to use proprietary software. The mere use of proprietary software only becomes a moral issue when it results in drowning out free software. Much like the widespread acceptance of proprietary mobile phone apps leads to cultural shifts that essentially force everyone to use said apps to participate in life. (See wechat in China.)

+ The second is addressed here: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy//po/who-does-that-server-real...

As others have pointed out, there is no moral dilemma here. The demand for computational autonomy is not a dogmatic, religious belief that conflicts with medical treatment of a disease.

Re:Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hack... by belorn on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:09AM (#37701516)
This topic was discussed a while back on HN since its a topic that comes up a few times. Karen Sandler, executive director of the Software Freedom Conservancy, has a pacemaker with wireless communication that runs non-free software with undisclosed source code. When it was discussed on HN a developer for such company also gave his views, including the tight regulations that covers medical devices.

FSF gave Karen Sandler an reward for her work on this: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2018/mar/26/sandler-fsf-free-...

"Richard Stallman, President of the FSF, presented Sandler with the award during a ceremony. Stallman highlighted Sandler's dedication to software freedom. Stallman told the crowd that Sandler's “vivid warning about backdoored nonfree software in implanted medical devices has brought the issue home to people who never wrote a line of code. Her efforts, usually not in the public eye, to provide pro bono legal advice to free software organizations and [with Software Freedom Conservancy] to organize infrastructure for free software projects and copyleft defense, have been equally helpful.”."