News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by ipnon on Monday September 25, 2023 @04:28PM (#37650147)
This has a significant deterrence effect because it means you can’t just massively attack all airbases and expect the Air Force to be disabled. Even if you destroy all runways there will still be air units with all manner of destructive weapons in action, at least for a long enough time to massively retaliate in kind.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rewmie on Monday September 25, 2023 @05:09PM (#37650676)
> This has a significant deterrence effect because it means you can’t just massively attack all airbases and expect the Air Force to be disabled.

I'd be very surprised if being able to land/takeoff from highways wasn't one of the most basic design requirements for a project as massive as the F-35. If highways are already designed to be usable as ad-hoc airfields, it would make no sense at all to design new airplanes to keep them compatible.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by ipnon on Monday September 25, 2023 @05:31PM (#37650965)
Absolutely, that's why STOVL is the defining feature of the F-35B. It's common knowledge where American and allied air bases are, by making them able to base anywhere with modern infrastructure it makes "zerg rushes" untenable. The astute reader will note recent examples of countries with outdated airframes being vulnerable to massive surprise attacks.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by dragontamer on Monday September 25, 2023 @06:40PM (#37651714)
Both F-35B and F-35C are the variants that can liftoff from a Carrier (aka: Navy) or WASP-class Assault Ship (aka: Marines) respectively.

F-35A is the one that needs the full runway. This is a big deal, as the F35A has the best performance overall but needs the nicest conditions to launch. If the "hardest to launch" variant can be flown from a highway, then the other two models will do even better.

This is a "steelman argument". We're demonstrating the worst F35 at this job. All other variants will do even better.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by dragonwriter on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:45PM (#37652341)
> Both F-35B and F-35C are the variants that can liftoff from a Carrier (aka: Navy) or WASP-class Assault Ship (aka: Marines) respectively.

Other way around: F-35B is the Marine Corps STOVL variant, F-35C is the Navy CATOBAR variant.

(No reason an F-35B couldn’t take off from and land on a regular carrier, too, but its the C that is made to launch with a catapult and catch an arrestor hook to land.)

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by CydeWeys on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:27PM (#37653951)
And the simple mnemonic to remember it is that the F-35A is for the [A]ir Force and the F-35C is for [C]arriers.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by fragmede on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:48PM (#37654078)
And the F-35B is the one that does [B]rief Take Off and Landing
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by psd1 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:23AM (#37656610)
Or [B]oo! Made You Jump.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by 3seashells on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:59AM (#37655951)
Could a F-35A be launched from a near vertical catapult rail?
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by t0mas88 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:18AM (#37656560)
No. The acceleration would be far above the design limits of the airframe.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by coryrc on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:02PM (#37651954)
So all airbase runways are destroyed but the planes are untouched?

This is a dumb waste of money.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by fooker on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:18PM (#37652095)
It is a lot easier to hide planes than to hide runways.

It could be a dumb waste of money either way, but your conclusion doesn’t follow from your premise.

Consider the current Russia/Ukraine war, Russia destroyed the vast majority of the runways Ukraine could have used but Ukraine still has an air force.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by coryrc on Monday September 25, 2023 @09:28PM (#37653173)
> but Ukraine still has an air force.

That's a generous statement.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by anikan_vader on Monday September 25, 2023 @09:50PM (#37653304)
It is not, as the Ukrainian air force continues to conduct regular sorties and has successfully prevented the Russian air force from every gaining air supremacy.

The Russian air force has taken massive losses, both in terms of planes and pilots, but it also continues to exist, from a non-generous and factual perspective.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by vGPU on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:26PM (#37653946)
The Air Force with an estimated strength somewhere stern that of algeria and chile?

Last I checked, they literally had more trainer aircraft than actual combat jets left.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by CydeWeys on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:28PM (#37653955)
You got a source for that? They've had MiGs donated by other Eastern European countries as well.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:36PM (#37654009)
> The Air Force with an estimated strength somewhere stern that of algeria and chile?

It’s amazing that such a small airforce manages to prevent russia from gaining air superiority and even manages to effectively conduct sorties isn’t it.

Just shows you how different it is when your the invading force. russias airforce losses largely outsize Ukraines even though Ukraine has a smaller airforce and they older planes.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by anikan_vader on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:09AM (#37654697)
>> with an estimated strength somewhere stern that of algeria and chile?

You have named two countries with credible and substantial air forces. Critically, both the Algerian air force and Chilean air force exist (the claim that I initially defended). Indeed, both Chile and Algeria have similarly-sized economies to Ukraine, and both countries operate sizeable air forces relative to other countries in South America and North Africa.

It is worth noting that the Ukrainian air force has 50+ F-16s scheduled for delivery in the near future.

>> Last I checked, they literally had more trainer aircraft than actual combat jets left.

They did have a relatively impressive number of L-39 jet trainers at the beginning of the war, as you alluded to. It is difficult to assess how many have survived the war. I would presume that you are correct to estimate that trainer aircraft have a lower attrition rate than combat jets during war.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rewmie on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:17AM (#37655613)
> The Air Force with an estimated strength somewhere stern that of algeria and chile?

Some rankings list Algeria right below Russia, and above Spain and Canada in terms of air power, and Chile is ranked above Korea and Norway.

https://www.wdmma.org/ranking.php

Also, apparently that's all it takes to ground the self-described second army of the world.

I'm not sure you thought your argument through.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by notfromhere on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:52PM (#37654101)
The reason Russia doesn’t fly much over Ukraine because of its AA network, not because the Ukrainian Air Force is a particularly good opponent.

Can’t exactly fly combat sorties when the whole country is littered in NASAM and Patriot systems

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by anikan_vader on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:49AM (#37654531)
I agree that ground anti-air has played a larger role in denying either side air supremacy than fighter jets. But it is important to note that Russia failed to establish air supremacy over Ukraine during the almost year before western anti-air arrived. Meanwhile, the Ukrainian air force effectively carried out anti-air missions (including against drones) and even some ground attack sorties.

So, tellingly, the Russian air force failed to establish supremacy over Ukraine when Ukraine fielded only Soviet-era aircraft and anti-air (and in comparatively small numbers). Which strongly suggests that the Russian Air Force is not a particularly good opponent either.

But critically, the Ukrainian Air Force continues to exist as a fleet-in-being. So while it may not currently be capable of much force projection (I would argue that the Russian air force is also not capable of much force projection against a serious adversary), it does force its adversary to strategically deploy anti-air.

As Russian anti-air systems become depleted (which may be sooner or may be later, but due to the rapid destruction of S-400 systems of late, my money is on sooner), it is quite possible that the Ukrainian air force will play a larger role, especially given that training on F-16s commence in a handful of weeks.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by haldujai on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:18AM (#37656557)
Pretty sure Ukraine had one of the better GBADs in Europe going into the war, especially as that’s not an area the West invests a great deal in.

The CNA and RUSI have both released excellent reports on the VKS challenges and performance.

SEAD/DEAD missions seem to be much harder than the US has made them look in the past (granted against much weaker GBADs than Ukraine or Russia have).

https://www.cna.org/reports/2023/04/Russian-Combat-Air-Stren...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by anikan_vader on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:54PM (#37664092)
Thank you for the source, it has been good reading so far. Your comment about US SEAD operations in the past made me recheck my priors about the Gulf War. I was surprised to learn that Iraq had no strategic SAM systems [1].

[1] https://balloonstodrones.com/2022/10/19/looking-back-at-iraq...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by pvaldes on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:20AM (#37656577)
drones definitely should count as air force.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rewmie on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:38PM (#37652275)
> So all airbase runways are destroyed but the planes are untouched?

You should read the news regarding the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Ukraine has been operating their air force out it's highways and is making a fool out of Russia's armed forces with opsec tricks like fixing airways and hangars bombed by Russia but printing tarps with images of the bombed out runways to fool it to believe they are still decommissioned. Ukraine has been playing Russia so masterfully that they led Russian intelligence into believing Ukraine's air force was operating out of a secret network of tunnels.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by coryrc on Monday September 25, 2023 @09:33PM (#37653205)
If the USA's airbases are all bombed there's nothing going to be left on the planet. It's not a credible scenario. There may be other reasons, but this is a dumb one.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by SonicScrub on Monday September 25, 2023 @09:53PM (#37653319)
The F-35 is owned and operated by many nations besides the US. For example, those in the article itself (Norway).
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by WrongAssumption on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:04PM (#37653817)
The US operates 750 bases in 80 countries. I don't know why you are fixated on US operations, when military operations primarily take place outside of the US.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by CydeWeys on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:29PM (#37653959)
And we don't necessarily want to start the nuclear war that ends the world just because a small outlying base was hit ..
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by psd1 on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:20AM (#37656575)
Space-based weapons should make you uneasy about America's home-soil impunity.

This increases when rival powers gain heavy-lift capability. If you can lift a few tons into orbit, you can drop rocks on targets. Not sure if there's much a target can do about that, other than not be there when it falls.

It's not quite as apocalyptic as nuclear holocaust, which is nice.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by heavenlyblue on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:19AM (#37655631)
You do realise that the fact that this is one the news completely makes this tactic unworkable anymore?
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by nradov on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:18PM (#37652096)
This is more about enabling expeditionary operations in areas where there are no airbases at all.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by dragonwriter on Monday September 25, 2023 @07:47PM (#37652361)
> So all airbase runways are destroyed but the planes are untouched?

Yeah, you can move and hide planes and put them in hardened bunkers, its kind of hard to do any of that with airbase runways, so that is one scenario for it.

But mostly its “we want to operate in an area and haven’t built/don’t control purpose-built airbases there yet”

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by ImJamal on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:23AM (#37654322)
Any jet in the air or on ships (I don't think F35As are on ships, only B and Cs) would presumably be untouched if runways were destroyed.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by doikor on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:25AM (#37656142)
Planes in Finnish airbases are stored in hardened bunkers deep in the bedrock. There really isn't much outside of a direct nuclear hit that would take out the planes. Though without a runway getting them back into air is going to be really hard.

Though ideally you want the planes in air before the bombs lands. With that scenario these hundreds of temporary runways all over the country make much more sense.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by nicholasbraker on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:55AM (#37655927)
It's not only a matter of having a runway available. The F-35 is very data-centric and is very dependable on IT-systems which need connectivity also on remote sites. This can be easily solved by using modern 4G/5G networks (either dedicated MoD ones or public ones) with the "right" encryption running over it cleared for military use, but it is a constraint which needs to be taken into consideration. In the Gripen/Viggen days, you probably only needed a few trucks with equipment/fuel and conscripts. Now you need additional "datacenters in a box" to make this work.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by actionfromafar on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:35AM (#37673189)
Gripen days are not over.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rhuru on Monday September 25, 2023 @06:57PM (#37651905)
Isn't this a very common requirement though ? India mostly has Russian planes but most new major Indian highways have several stretched that can be used as runways and Air Force also does test landings from time to time.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by sacnoradhq on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:19AM (#37654288)
It's primary for forward tactical, war-time refueling because you can't just drive a jet from a hardened bunker on an air base to a random road far away. Wingspan and trees and such get in the way. Finland, Poland, etc. roads fit the criteria where it makes sense to have emergency alternate landing sites than first-to-be-destroyed fixed bases.

An adversary such as Russia undoubtedly already designates straight, manicured roads in Eastern Europe for anti-runway demolition as secondary targets.

Also, given Russia's hypersonic capabilities, they undoubtedly possess something between JP233 and DRDO SAAW: stand-off anti-runway and hardened target attack with area denial.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rnk on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:50AM (#37654966)
It would make sense that russia has ability to destroy roads, and airbases, but why aren't they using these effectively when attacking Ukraine? It's a lot smaller than all of Europe, should be easier to figure it out.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by konart on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:22AM (#37655663)
Initially Russian expectations missed the reality. The was no "one week of bombing " fase. Then Russia had to spend enourmous ammouts of rockets\artillery (mostly due to lack of planning and lack of military education\experience in the army) to have at least some results.

Right now Russia's abilities are very limited.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by risyachka on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:42AM (#37655823)
The main reason is that Russian military is rotten to the core, corrupt and has zero discipline (this has been the case for hundreds of years, probably due to mentality).
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by sacnoradhq on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:18AM (#37656556)
An associate of mine was a USAF Major who came into possession of a Soviet Belarussian MiG-21. He stashed it in a hangar in Germany and told absolutely no one outside his inner circle of war buddies about. The only person he ever showed if off to was a fairly high-up Russian who he mistakenly thought was "cool". Guess how long it was before the cockpit avionics were stolen, rendering it un-refurbishable? Sigh Never trust a Russian officer farther than you can throw them unless their name was Stanislav Petrov.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by JuanPosadas on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:27AM (#37673625)
> Never trust a Russian officer

Doesn't seem like a good story to backup this "lesson". What would happen if you showed a US Officer a (possibly missing) US Fighter jet in a hanger? Never trust a US Officer?

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by konart on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @04:04AM (#37671573)
I'd say it reason number two.

Reason number one would be that serving in military is viewed as good old "conscript obligation"[1]. Or as a way to get money (in some regions serving was the only way to get decent money. some people would actually give bribes to get a contract).

At the same time you learn nothing while in service (unless you are part of some elite force wich is a different story and they are few in number anyway).

A classic thing about russian military: out of a platoon only 2-3 guys are often throw grenades during their time. Only to show them off before some general. While others just mind their own business.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_the_Russian_Em...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by 3seashells on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:42AM (#37656271)
RussiA was downgraded to RussiC during this conflict.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:20AM (#37656110)
The answer for what Russia is up to, militarily, is not savoury to our mindset, conditioned as we are to perceive them as an ineffective enemy that can be "easily wiped out if we wanted to" ..

The simple fact is: Russia hasn't given itself permission to wage all-out war.

Yet.

Remember, its a "special military operation", the same way that the invasion of Iraq wasn't actually a war, but a "special military operation", also. Russia has not declared full, all-out war, which would involve activating the other 80% of its military resources against Ukraine.

In those circumstances, Russian military doctrine calls for a concealment strategy whereby they don't deploy their best units first - but rather, their more expendable units.

The Russians simply aren't revealing their hand in this, what they consider, the opening round of a larger war to come. If they played their hand in Ukraine too soon - when the time comes to engage in all-out open conflict with the West, we'd know what they had in store for us. They're reserving their most effective military tactics for when the gloves come off..

The USA also does this, incidentally - although it is more willing to shock and awe their enemy into submission in the opening moves of the battle, there are definitely weapons systems held in reserve for when things get desparate. The Russians are doing this, too.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:46AM (#37656311)
We have literally seen some of Russias most advanced equipment and most elite units, sent to and decimated in Ukraine.

They are fighting an all-out war, and if they aren't they are idiots considering how much of Russian territory and occupied Ukrainian territory has a tendency to explode suddenly.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:23AM (#37656611)
You don't want your enemy to believe you are strong, when you are strong. You want them to think you are weak, when you are strong.

It is highly specious to mis-underestimate ones enemies. Western military planners are not mis-underestimating Russias' capabilities - that task is left to their media wing, to sell the public on yet more war debt.

The belief that Russia is weak serves to sell more weapons - it does not necessarily reflect the fact that Russia has held a majority of its elite units, in reserve, and is not - yet - fighting an all-out war.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:35AM (#37656735)
I never said Russia is weak I just said that they aren't holding anything back and that they are clearly using their most modern weapons and defences and are still getting wiped out in droves.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:37AM (#37656760)
Maybe your understanding would benefit from referring to their actual doctrine:

https://www.cna.org/archive/CNA_Files/pdf/russian-military-s...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:48AM (#37656848)
What part of there doctrine says to reactivate T55/T54/T62's and to weld a random assortment of rocket systems to MTLBs in some sort of slightly more advanced technical?.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:51AM (#37656868)
"The important part is that there is no scientific basis for Russia fielding old T-62/T-55s and in fact Russia is verifiably fielding three times more T-90Ms than before."

https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/analysis-of-ukraines-esc...

The doctrine you are looking for is propaganda...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:09AM (#37657026)
But they have literally fielded BMPT's, T90's and S400's.

They are literally fielding there latest stuff

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:12AM (#37657050)
So .. what is it .. they're fielding junk because they have no new stuff, or they're fielding new stuff, and its effective?

Keep in mind, the Russians are quite capable of replacing every tank lost ..

https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/analysis-of-ukraines-esc...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:27AM (#37657172)
> So .. what is it .. they're fielding junk because they have no new stuff, or they're fielding new stuff, and its effective?

They have limited new stuff and they are fielding literally mad max'esuqe technicals.

> Keep in mind, the Russians are quite capable of replacing every tank lost ..

And yet russia is fielding T55's/T54's and T62's.

> https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/analysis-of-ukraines-esc...

I cannot take this source seriously when it just repeats what TASS says.

They are claiming that this Subarmine.

https://news.yahoo.com/pictures-emerge-damaged-russian-subma...

Is not going to have any increased repair time compared to when it didn't have two gaping holes in it?.

Thats obviously not true.

On second look this source is literally just Russian propaganda.

> I had forgotten to post this a while back. Ukrainian journalist Roman Revedzhuk who had previously run for office and was involved in Ukrainian politics for a long time revealed that he had received an insider report from the SBU that Ukraine had more than 310,000 KIA as of July:

Who would believe such obvious nonsense?.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by pohl on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:37AM (#37657783)
helpfulContrib, an account that was green just last week, sure seems to post a lot of things that Vlad would like “get out there”.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:20PM (#37664507)
Hey, that's rather discriminating.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by _kbh_ on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:32AM (#37658344)
> "The important part is that there is no scientific basis for Russia fielding old T-62/T-55s and in fact Russia is verifiably fielding three times more T-90Ms than before."

This is verifiably false, theres plenty of images of T-62's in Ukraine with Russian markings and with Russian style anti drone / RPG cages ontop of them.

You can find images of ~80 captured / destroyed Russian T-62's here.

https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by tome on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:22AM (#37657140)
> The belief that Russia is weak serves to sell more weapons

and if there were a belief that Russia was strong it would serve to sell ... fewer ... weapons?

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by woeirua on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:51AM (#37656349)
Insert Gru meme:

Panel 1: we invade Ukraine.

Panel 2: we hold back our best forces to bait the west into an ultimate conflict from which we will emerge victorious!

Panel 3: we lose the war in Ukraine.

Panel 4: we lose the war in Ukraine?

Bro, the Russians are losing T-90s. Plus tons of helicopters and aircraft. Those platforms cost $$$. They’re not holding something back.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:18AM (#37656555)
Whether its effective or not is a different story.

https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2000-05/russias-military-doc...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by jeltz on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:02AM (#37656962)
None of this matches what seems to be the reality on the battle field. Russia has fielded a lot of modern equipment and many of their elite units. There is plenty of footage of destroyed modern Russian equipment.

Yes, Russia is holding back but only to the level that they do not call for total mobilization and war economy. They are not holding back 80% or anything close to that.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by sacnoradhq on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:13AM (#37656511)
The Russian military is stuck executing a random terror campaign against the populace and defending being pushed out of Crimea, Kharkiv, and Donetsk. The reason is cost. They cannot afford an all-out offensive in bodies, bullets, mortars, or SRBMs.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by littlestymaar on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:55AM (#37656380)
> An adversary such as Russia undoubtedly already designates straight, manicured roads in Eastern Europe for anti-runway demolition as secondary targets.

Given the inability of Russian PGM to even destroy the runways of Ukrainian airbase[1], and the limited amount of these PGM in the inventory, I really doubt Russia has this capability, even at the scale of one of the small Baltic state.

> Also, given Russia's hypersonic capabilities, they undoubtedly possess something between JP233 and DRDO SAAW: stand-off anti-runway and hardened target attack with area denial.

And why hasn't still managed to shut down UAF after one year and a half of conflict? “Gesture of goodwill” maybe?

[1] See the infamous failed strike on the Ozerne airbase at the onset of the invasion: https://cdn.futura-sciences.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=1024,qua...

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by actionfromafar on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:29AM (#37673135)
The assumed capability to strike airbases is/was nuclear. The whole old Soviet doctrine was a nuclear doctrine.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by littlestymaar on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @06:17PM (#37682164)
True, in part because it was mostly a defensive doctrine.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by chakintosh on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:30AM (#37656675)
This is where the F35's VTOL becomes handy. If you had a few jets stashed away or survived the attack on an airbase, they just take off vertically.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by adwww on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:09AM (#37657034)
That's only the B variant, which only UK and Italy will operate in Europe.

I've never seen that use case discussed for the F35, but that was indeed the primary purpose of the Harrier - before it was eventually deployed onto small carriers.

Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by ajuc on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:14AM (#37657068)
F35A (the one from the article, and the one almost everybody is buing) isn't VTOL. F35B will likely melt the asphalt if it tried to take-off vertically from a regular highway.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by rambambram on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:38AM (#37657282)
I believe they had to cover the tarmac with some kind of protective mats in order to do this.
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by LtWorf on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:31AM (#37657223)
What's the fatality rate for failed vertical take offs?
Re:F-35A Has Flown from a Highway for the First Time by ajuc on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:13AM (#37657055)
Yes, but it's also possible with most older planes, including Mig-29 and F-16.

https://bnn.network/world/poland/natos-resilient-runway-init...

The highways have to be built with that in mind though (and many are). In Poland it's called DOL and there have been 21 of them built, but only 1 is used regularly.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highway_strip#Poland