News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by superkuh on Sunday September 24, 2023 @09:38AM (#37633010)
Nothing on mobile is okay. I know everyone loves their smart phones but they really are terrible computers in every way except for portability. Use a computer when you actually want to do things. Smartphones are just for when you're literally unable to use a real computer.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by graemep on Sunday September 24, 2023 @09:48AM (#37633078)
I recently bought a PineTab2. Its a pretty rough around the edges experience (hardware is fine, but Plasma Mobile is still lacking compared to Android) BUT with the case with a keyboard it is far better for writing anything. Not as good as my desktop, but a lot better than most mobile devices.

I usually use Whatsapp web and the Signal desktop app at my desktop when I want to write more than sentence or two. A physical keyboard makes it so much easier. For example, I left making my comments here today until I sat down at my desktop.

If you must use a phone for typing more than a tiny bit, buy a keyboard for it. Even a little bluetooth keyboard is a lot better.

I am tempted by phones with keyboards. I used to have a Blackberry a long time ago and there are Android phones in similar formats.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by tetris11 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @09:51AM (#37633106)
Yearly reminder that Nokia perfected the slideout keyboard on their N900 model over 10 years ago
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by asimovfan on Sunday September 24, 2023 @09:59AM (#37633187)
Also there was an actual linux distribution in it, Maemo. You could do things with it.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by tetris11 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:21AM (#37633385)
Maemo is still actively developed thanks to the fanatical/fantastic community around it.

https://maemo-leste.github.io/

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by tomjen3 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @09:53AM (#37633139)
They are much, much better for photos. I will even say they are better for most videos chats.

They are better music players. They are better GPS nav systems.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by brookst on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:09AM (#37633273)
Indeed. They are also better (virtual) tape measures, contactless payment devices, crash/fall detectors, emergency rescue summoners, and, yeah, phones.

Turns out different form factors are better at different things.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mrob on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:23AM (#37633402)
They are better for taking photographs simply because they're smaller, but for every other aspect of photo viewing, management, and editing, they are worse. They have a tiny screen, insufficient local storage and compute, and no keyboard or mouse.

They're not better music players. Sound quality can be identical because phones support USB DACs, but again, everything else is worse. On a real computer I can easily search my library just by typing. There's no way to find specific tracks that fast on mobile.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by Pxtl on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:44AM (#37633586)
> insufficient local storage

My phone has 128gb. How is that not enough for photo editing?

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mrob on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:49AM (#37633656)
Raw photographs are tens of megabytes each, and it's not unusual to take hundreds per session.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dredmorbius on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:15PM (#37634402)
Agreeing and amplifying: Taking a random search result, the Canon EOS R5 has a 45 MP sensor: <https://www.usa.canon.com/shop/p/eos-r5?color=Black&type=New>

Assuming 24 bits per pixel, that's 1 GB per image, or 128 images on a 128 GB storage.

Dedicated cameras have removable storage and professional photographers will carry multiple 500 GB -- 1 TB+ storage cards, swapping them out through a shoot.

I'll note that the iPhone 15 Pro specs list a 48 MP sensor, which is similar, though storage tends to be as jpeg rather than raw. Compression varies but sizes of 1/2 to 1/15 RAW at high quality are common.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mrob on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:13PM (#37635006)
>Assuming 24 bits per pixel, that's 1 GB per image

1Gb, not GB. And in practice it's not that high. Most digital cameras use a Bayer filter, with the pixel count specified as the number of grayscale pixels behind the individual filter elements. Raws are most often 12 or 14 bits per pixel, so about 68MB or 79MB for a 45MP sensor. This can be further reduced with lossless compression. Still a lot for a 128GiB phone, though.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dredmorbius on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:29PM (#37635186)
Gah! Thanks, corrected above.

Thanks for the additional detail, I'd wondered about the bpp and individual colour-sensing elements.

Point remains that RAW images are large.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by alanbernstein on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:52AM (#37633684)
I generally agree with you and the parent post. But touch screen is the best UI for photo cropping. This is awkward because it makes me want to split editing tasks between devices.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dredmorbius on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:52AM (#37634188)
Better than a Wacom tablet?
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by alanbernstein on Monday September 25, 2023 @03:11PM (#37649012)
I've never used one. I know they're popular with artists but I have very little concept of how they're used. I would not have guessed that anyone uses them to crop images.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dredmorbius on Monday September 25, 2023 @05:07PM (#37650633)
Given that what many touchscreen tablets (particularly e-ink) offer is a Wacom layer, the advantage is that you're getting far more precise indication of location. The difference between Wacom-in-display and Wacom-as-peripheral is much as with a mouse, in that you have to get accustomed to indicating actions off-screen which translate to on-screen movements, though in practice that seems to be a fast learn for most people. This can actually be better as depending on screen registration and depth of the display elements themselves, "direct registration" often isn't with offsets and parallax.

The precision of using a stylus and pen/pencil grip rather than a mouse, trackball, or trackpad is the primary win.

And yes, cropping is in fact a major function for graphic artists, though painting directly with the stylus + tablet is another option.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by tomjen3 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:56PM (#37635483)
I think they are also great for photo viewing, because they are easy to show to others. As the saying goes the best camera you have is the one you have with you.

Same reason I listed them as the best music players - I don't want to carry around a laptop to hear tunes. And while some audiphiles claim that they can hear a difference, I have never seen evidence that this is the case.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mrob on Sunday September 24, 2023 @05:03PM (#37637178)
If you EQ your headphones, e.g. to match the Harman curve[0] to better replicate the sound of loudspeakers in a moderately treated room, you'll probably find they need a lot of bass boost. This means you have to turn everything down to avoid clipping, which hurts the signal to noise ratio. If you only listen to low dynamic range music you still might not notice it, but for high dynamic range music, like orchestral music with natural sounding mastering, you will probably be able to hear noise from low quality DACs in the quiet parts.

Fortunately, good DACs are cheap now, e.g. the Apple USB to 3.5mm adapter [1].

[0] https://headphonesaddict.com/harman-curve/

[1] https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/r...

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by midoridensha on Monday September 25, 2023 @05:20AM (#37641253)
>Same reason I listed them as the best music players - I don't want to carry around a laptop to hear tunes. And while some audiphiles claim that they can hear a difference, I have never seen evidence that this is the case.

For playing music when I'm at work, etc., my phone sounds MUCH better than my laptop that's sitting at home.

Also, even if we really did compare apples to apples, I'm not sure how the sound hardware on a laptop is going to be any better than that on a phone.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by bluGill on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:09AM (#37633271)
They are better readers as well. Often reading is followed by some form of writing though and then they are terrible.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by bee_rider on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:50AM (#37633664)
The smartphone is the second best device for pretty much every task. For the vast majority of things, in which we’re not specialists, they are pretty good.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by superkuh on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:47AM (#37634143)
They're better for some types of photos. For example, you'd never want to take a photo of something you'd want to measure quantitatively with a smart phone. They hallucinate all the detail.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by matheusmoreira on Sunday September 24, 2023 @05:39PM (#37637453)
> They are better GPS nav systems.

Android even supports access to raw pseudorange data from the GNSS chipset now. Today's phones support all the constellations and new technology like GPS L5. There's even a way to turn off things like duty cycling to maximize accuracy at the expense of battery consumption. Should be possible to set up centimeter precision relative positioning with these things.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by ChrisMarshallNY on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:25AM (#37633428)
One of the most important watersheds in my career, was reading Jenson's The Simplicity Shift[0], many moons ago.

It was written pre-iPhone, and talked about the brutal necessity of reducing mobile UX to the very barest essentials.

I find that I am revisiting a lot of this stuff, when writing Apple Watch apps.

[0] https://jenson.org/The-Simplicity-Shift.pdf (Downloads the entire booklet as a PDF)

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by scottjenson on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:48AM (#37633641)
This is a lovely thing to read on a Sunday morning, thank you!
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by ChrisMarshallNY on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:01AM (#37633765)
No, thank YOU!

[EDIT] And, since I have you on the horn, There seems to be a PDF error, where the first page (The Challenge) is repeated twice.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by scottjenson on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:37AM (#37634063)
oooh, interesting! I'll check it out, thanks!
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by nameless_me on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:00AM (#37633760)
Thank you for sharing this work. I look forward to reading it.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by thih9 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:33AM (#37633495)
Sliders are okay.

Editing photos in lightroom mobile works fine. Interfaces that are about swiping and sliding - from match 3 games, through tinder, to scrolling feeds - are very responsive.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by crazygringo on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:02AM (#37633769)
> Smartphones are just for when you're literally unable to use a real computer.

Which is literally extremely frequent, since we often need to do stuff on the go. Which is why an article like this is so important -- we should improve, not give up. There's no reason to think text editing on a phone has reached its final form.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dTal on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:16AM (#37633877)
You can buy quad core x86 "laptops" - real computers - the size of a phone. How much more "on the go" do you need?
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by pawelmurias on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:41AM (#37659162)
I have big hand so tiny keyboard on a teeny-weeny keyboard won't be usable at all. Desktop Linux is super shit
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by superkuh on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:43AM (#37634109)
The reason I think it won't get much better is that the size of smart phones will not change. It is size that's really the issue for text editing. No space for a real keyboard, no space for a real display.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by myk9001 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:14PM (#37634397)
Maybe we can look at it as an opportunity for inventing a fundamentally different approach to text editing on mobile?

In another topic on HN people are discussing how software gets more bloated over time, because throwing more powerful hardware at a problem is easier than optimizing the software.

As mobile devices aren't likely to get much bigger or get equipped with a mouse and keyboard anytime soon -- in other words, we don't seem to have a hw solution -- isn't it the perfect moment to try something novel and different?

Sure, it isn't a given someone will come up with a great, new approach soon enough. Still seems worth it looking at this as an opportunity.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by Aerbil313 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:40PM (#37635928)
There are novel approach ideas. I have many of them, and even saw a few implemented. The problem is, any sufficiently comfortable text entering/editing experience requires a non zero amount of training, which, considering the consumption devices smartphones are, discouraging for the average user. I believe in the end TTS with LLMs win and speaking in public to text will be accepted as a norm. Because it is literally the easiest possible experience bar brain implants.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by ghusto on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:43PM (#37634697)
I remember the first Android phone. It was small, and had a real keyboard. It's not that it can't be done, it's that it's cheaper to not have one, and they can get away with it because of the lowest common denominator consumer.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by spondylosaurus on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:01PM (#37635535)
The G1! (Or HTC Dream, depending on your locale.) It had a keyboard, touchscreen, and a trackball to boot.

You weren't kidding about it being small, though—in hindsight the 320 x 480 screen resolution was a bit rough.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by ghusto on Monday September 25, 2023 @06:41AM (#37641702)
> 320 x 480 screen resolution was a bit rough

Meh. I remember thinking "but why?" when the "high res" screen phones came out. It did the job, and I didn't really see the point in a higher resolution back then. Honestly, if I had the choice, I'd go back to that device in a heartbeat, low-res and all.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by crazygringo on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:00PM (#37634868)
Current mobile keyboards and screens are pretty much fine -- I have no issues with text input on a phone or with reading.

The problems are with editing only -- precise cursor positioning, precise selection, and then access to basic cut/copy/paste/undo operations that doesn't mess everything up.

My hunch is that we need a button on mobile keyboards to switch to a kind of "edit gesture mode". Some kind of swipe area to move the cursor, some kind of swipe area/mode to extend/contract a selection, some method to handle scrolling as necessary, some kind of magnifying zoom to select tiny things like narrow punctuation, and separate larger button areas for cut/copy/paste/undo. Maybe instead of swipes there are gestures in a kind of dedicated trackpad-type area of the screen, I don't know.

But I definitely think there's a ton of area for experimentation that hasn't been explored yet. The hold-spacebar-to-turn-keyboard-into-trackpad-to-move-cursor mode was a first step the iPhone took towards this, but I think it can go 20x further.

I think it's something that only Apple and Google are capable of developing right now though. I don't think there are enough API's exposed for third-party keyboards to directly control things like text selection, zoom, scrolling, cut/copy/paste/undo, and the like.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by fragmede on Sunday September 24, 2023 @03:03PM (#37636154)
Looking at wordle's mobile interface, where the keyboard is a part of the webpage, I think a lot could be done to demo new technologies.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by silisili on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:20PM (#37635710)
I really miss form factors like the BB Priv or Moto Backflip.

Now that 'work from anywhere' seems more prevalent than a decade+ ago, I wonder if such a design could find enough success in today's environment.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by fomine3 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @10:14PM (#37638995)
Foldable is a way to have a big screen, though the problem is also not much solved for tablets.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by xxs on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:04PM (#37634296)
I have stuff to do I carry a 17" laptop with a full size keyboard. Else I'd just have better things to do.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by TheHappyOddish on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @03:14AM (#37671226)
> since we often need to do stuff on the go

Do we though? It is a fair assumption, but I urge you to stop and inspect. We didn't "need" to do most things we do on the go 20 years ago, do we now? If we're being honest, most people using their smartphones on the go are not for critical situations.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mcronce on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:05AM (#37633800)
If slide-out keyboards were still a thing they wouldn't be nearly as bad but we had to get rid of those because being thinner is the most important thing in the world
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by postmodest on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:38AM (#37634067)
And then because on screen keyboards suck so bad we had to make phones BIGGER which meant they needed to be THINNER which meant cameras needed to stick out, and here we are, in a world where an iPhone Pro Max takes up the full height of my jeans pocket and digs into my hip when I sit down. Yeyyy.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by robinson7d on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:23PM (#37634482)
iPhone mini was a thing for a while. It still has the stuck out camera but otherwise only a bit larger than the iPhone 5 from 9 years earlier. I wish they hadn’t ended it on the 13, because I also feel phones are getting too large.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by fragmede on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:33PM (#37634583)
Or, there just isn't the market for a current gen mini and an SE.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by robinson7d on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:59PM (#37635511)
That’s for sure why it was discontinued. I’m sad it’s gone, but I do understand I’m a minority in that feeling.

I was just offering it as a counter point (from as recent as last year) to the onscreen keyboards necessitating huge phones that the comment I replied to was suggesting. Plus an option that is still modern enough to use. Using the mini keyboard isn’t much worse than the pro. It’s feasible, these minis type well, I don’t think it’s the reason for bigger, thinner phones with cameras popping out. I’d blame content more.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by postmodest on Monday October 02, 2023 @02:23AM (#37734594)
I am going to run my 13 mini into the ground.

I honestly miss the OG iPhone size.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by magicalhippo on Sunday September 24, 2023 @03:07PM (#37636197)
Don't think I'd even need a full keyboard. I had a much easier time writing on my old Nokia 3310 or similar than I've ever had on my newfangled "smart" phone (it's quite dumb).
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dclowd9901 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:31AM (#37634007)
It’s an interesting take. I had to stop and think for a second “is there anything I prefer a phone for”, and yeah the only positive of using a phone (for me) is portability and multi functionality (being a de facto camera/camcorder/recorder).
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by dredmorbius on Sunday September 24, 2023 @11:39AM (#37634077)
[delayed]
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by hackernewds on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:32PM (#37634573)
Reductive argument.

Smartphones are way better platforms for something like TikTok or Twitter than desktop. Or an alarm clock app

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by nonethewiser on Sunday September 24, 2023 @12:59PM (#37634862)
The input is low bandwidth. It’s communication with thumbs.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mhb on Sunday September 24, 2023 @01:49PM (#37635406)
My saw is a bad hammer.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by tgv on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:22PM (#37635734)
But you wouldn't complain you can't use a saw to drive nails in the wall, would you?
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mhb on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:38PM (#37635908)
Exactly. It would be like complaining that a phone isn't a good tool for text editing.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by mrguyorama on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:04AM (#37645023)
Then why is everyone so insistent that the future of house building and nail nailing the saw?
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by prng2021 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:00PM (#37635517)
What an absolutely lazy assessment of technology. I’d say using those two appendages we call legs to move around while still being able to do many things you use a desktop computer for is a revolutionary piece of technology.

Do you really want to carry a Walkman around along with a backpack with a Rand McNally map to guide you so you don’t get lost in a neighborhood you’ve never visited? Maybe watch a portable DVD player on your way to/from work on the subway to pass the time? Carry some quarters so you can call someone at a pay phone or pay for a parking spot?

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by pcthrowaway on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:22PM (#37635742)
> I’d say using those two appendages we call legs to move around while still being able to do many things you use a desktop computer for is a revolutionary piece of technology.

The above poster did acknowledge that smartphones absolutely win out in portability.

Obviously you're stuck with mobile UIs for things like navigation, directions, location information, and a lot review apps, ordering a car, etc. Consequently, the user experience for those things is often better on a mobile phone than it would be on a desktop (if a desktop UI is even provided)

For anything involving typing more than an address, you're almost always better off with a Desktop application. There's nothing "lazy" about pointing this out

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by prng2021 on Sunday September 24, 2023 @04:12PM (#37636688)
> Obviously you're stuck with mobile UIs for things like navigation, directions, location information, and a lot review apps, ordering a car, etc

The "etc" in your statement could be expanded to 100 additional useful things in everyday life. Given that, how can you agree with their original posters statement that mobile devices are terrible for everything except portability? It's such a ridiculous understatement.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by n_ary on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:28PM (#37635799)
> but they really are terrible computers

except for bottom-of-the-barrel androids, most drcent smartphones cost equivalent to a decent computer. I refuse to accept the garbage UX on an equivalent device which charges me such money and then dumb it down with tracking and ad shenanigans over usefulness.

P.S. My own opinion and it is very OK to 150% disagree with me.

Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by chunk_waffle on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:53PM (#37636049)
My "phone" is really just a camera+GPS that my wife sometimes calls me on when she can't find me in a store. I dread typing on it, hell I dread _talking_ on it even.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by larodi on Sunday September 24, 2023 @03:09PM (#37636212)
let's say only large few lines of text are okay, and some images are... okayis. everything else is a magnificent display of massive UI failure, sadly it took us 20 years to actually start talking about this seriously.
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by harlanji on Sunday September 24, 2023 @03:38PM (#37636456)
[delayed]
Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok by hutzlibu on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:01AM (#37644969)
"Smartphones are just for when you're literally unable to use a real computer."

When I am lying on a couch or in bed, I could use a laptop or tablet, but for just surfing a bit, a mobile phone is just more handy. But sure, smartphones or tablets are not really useful for anything productive.