News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by LeroyRaz on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @04:15PM (#37589569)
Richard Reeves is originally from the left, and there is a podcast interview of him by Ezra Klein (titled "the boys are not alright"). In the interview he describes how he was drawn to feminism and looking at gender inequality, and by looking at the data became convinced that boys and men were a neglected cause. He was then frustrated as other researchers and policy people had no interest in that form of inequality.

This experience of a researcher starting by caring deeply about inequality, and starting with feminism, and then identifying male issues and finding a total lack of community interest has occurred before. This is exactly what happened to Warren Farrell, who a was once a major figure in feminism (and then largely ignored once he started talking about the issues facing men) (see his Wikipedia page for details).

I think part of what makes getting sociatal buy in on men's issues is that one of the biases men face is a lack of care for men in need of help, and this relates to the idea of male disposability.

For reference, there is a quite shocking list of statistics where men have significantly worse outcomes than women: longer jail for the same crime, higher rates of homelessness, higher rates of suicide, lower educational outcomes, shorter life spans, less friends on average, ...

Obviously women suffer from other issues, but as Ezra Klein is keen to emphasize to any listeners of the interview, empathy is not a zero sum game.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by Jensson on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @04:40PM (#37589848)
> empathy is not a zero sum game.

But we are biased to empathize more with women than men, both women and men are biased that way. That is the core of "toxic masculinity", we need everyone to empathize more with men, but instead due to low empathy for men all they say is "just work on your own problems, it isn't that bad for you!!".

There isn't much you can do in that situation, the low empathy burden men are shouldered with isn't something society wants to deal with, neither the left nor the right.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by JieJie on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @05:05PM (#37590169)
It is a tough cognitive dissonance for most people to hold in their minds: men behaving toxically require more emotional support, not less.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by disqard on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @07:30PM (#37591439)
Indeed! When I see ultra-wealthy-but-emotionally-isolated people (the trio pointed out by Jaron Lanier comes to mind [1]), all I feel is pity at their condition.

What they need is to be emotionally "nursed" back to wellness, but their sheer wealth has isolated them so much that nobody can connect with them on a "normal" human level anymore.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/11/opinion/trump-musk-kanye-...

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by mock-possum on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @04:28PM (#37589721)
plus a rising tide lifts all ships.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by thunkshift1 on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @04:50PM (#37589985)
apparently not this one though
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by mwbajor on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @05:03PM (#37590149)
Can we have an example of toxic masculinity? I've never once received a real definition in a debate like this and when I'm close to it, the other side tries to make it sound like they are sympathetic to toxic masculinity.

For example, I've had it told to me that I shouldnt have my son help me with changing my car's oil because thats putting some sort of burden on him at an early age. Does this sound like something a sane person would say? I would go as far to give the benefit of the doubt and say no, most people are sane and the ones that would make this type of argument are drawn into a social mania.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by conception on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @06:52PM (#37591161)
“Why are you crying?!? Real men don’t cry!”
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by rootusrootus on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @07:25PM (#37591390)
Exactly this. But even worse, this is frequently not said aloud. It is implicit in all of our interactions. Express too much emotion outside of certain narrow contexts, and other people (men and women alike) will look at you like you are a wimp. Nobody has to say a word.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by AlexandrB on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:59AM (#37596976)
I think it's worse than that. Traditional gender norms are perfectly ok with men expressing their emotions as long as those emotions are anger.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by snapplebobapple on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:08PM (#37592473)
That's just the crass version of the actually good advice that goes as follows: Don't react to your emotions, instead notice your emotions wash over you, identify the why and respond rationally instead of emotionally to the why. It's basically good advice given in the worst possible way with deceptive context
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by jmye on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:39PM (#37592956)
Why is that good advice? If my father dies, why is it bad to be sad about it? Why is it wrong to cry when I’m sad?

I think you’re completely off base in trying to make “respond rationally and with no emotion, ever” a universal rule, especially with regards to interacting with other people. It’s weird and robotic.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by cutemonster on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:15AM (#37593460)
Or if a kid falls and hurts their arm. (Instead of shaming them, a hug is an alternative)
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by snapplebobapple on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:55AM (#37596940)
I am going to assume you are misunderstanding what I said rather than intentionally responding to what I didn't say, so here it goes:

I did not say don't be sad. I sad don't react emotionally, instead understand the emotion you are feeling, identify the why and respond rationally to the why. It's not bad to be sad, it's bad to allow the sadness to force you into a stupid reaction. In your example the actual good advice dictates it's fine to cry, but don't let your sadness dictate doing something stupid like drinking too much, getting behind the wheel and getting a dui or worse.

In my reply I acknowledged that someone saying what the op posted was almost always trying to communicate what I have said above and failing at it.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by jmye on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:10AM (#37597103)
But that’s very much not what you responded to, nor is it even similar. What you responded to was “real men don’t cry.”

Whatever you were trying to add was within that context, thus my reply. “Real men don’t cry” is not well-intentioned, nor is it just a poorly worded version of good advice.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by snapplebobapple on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:09AM (#37598790)
I called it the crass version of good advice given in the worst possible way with deceptive context, which is true. I cannot recall a single instance of someone saying the original statement and not meaning some form of what I provided for context in my personal life outside of hollywood movies, where it seems to have become this toxic masculinity trope rather than a failure of explanation likely caused by a failure at heeding the actual advice themselves and reacting emotionally.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by conception on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @06:53PM (#37591168)
Also, that is not something a sane person would say, no. Having children help with chores is a key part of parenting, regardless of gender.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by euroderf on Thursday September 21, 2023 @04:35AM (#37594828)
Furthermore, when children help with chores without expectation of immediate commensurate reward, it cultivates positive values.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by mwbajor on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:52AM (#37596907)
Well someone just said it in this thread, response above. So they do exist.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by snapplebobapple on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:58PM (#37592406)
When all the men got together and voted for women to also have the vote, that was toxic masculinity at work. (this is a joke, but also not really. Women shifting the political map towards larger government and more socialism seems to be the root of most of our current problems. It's kind of a big problem because women should very clearly be allowed to vote but at the same time I don't know how to reconcile that with the also very clear harm it is causing)
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by euroderf on Thursday September 21, 2023 @04:36AM (#37594834)
This begs the question, what do you consider to be socialism ?
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by supertimor on Thursday September 21, 2023 @05:40AM (#37595347)
> When all the men got together and voted for women to also have the vote, that was toxic masculinity at work. (this is a joke, but also not really. Women shifting the political map towards larger government and more socialism seems to be the root of most of our current problems.

This seems like a really flawed and backwards take. What evidence do you have that supports your incredibly vague statement that women’s ability to vote is “the root of most of our current problems.”

The American socialist movement began in the early 19th century and peaked in the early 20th. 1900-1920 saw the height of socialist sentiment in the US. The Socialist Party of America began to lose it’s influence in the 1920’s as socialism began to decline in popularity. Women gained the right to vote in 1920.

Would that not then indicate that women gaining the right to vote led to a decline in socialist sentiment? Saying this is just as disingenuous as saying that women gaining the right to vote massively shifted the political spectrum towards socialism.

A rise in socialism is historically very often a reaction to some sort of societal upheaval (i.e. war, economic crises, high levels of inequality, exploitation, etc).

Forgive me if I’m wrong in assuming that you’re speaking about the US, but my point stands regardless of what country you’re referring to because blaming a century’s worth of problems on women gaining the right to vote (regardless of the country) is not a serious nor intelligent argument.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by snapplebobapple on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:13AM (#37597920)
The claim was that big government was the root of most of our current problems and women in turn tend to vote for bigger government (and socialism but I used the lower case s on socialism which does not mean the Socialist party, it means a diverse group of potential policies that are all characterized by some group that isn't an individual and is usually the government owning some subset of assets and providing some subset of services)

Go look at the polling records across time and you see women voting for bigger government by way of voting for groups that have policies that ensure larger government (they are not the only group doing this, they are just the group we are talking about now. Single men also lean problematic in their voting patterns for example).

Talking about the Socialist party here is the wrong metric to use because it encompassed truly nutty groups that had no chance of being elected (from agricultural commune supporters to straight up communists). If you look at the subsets that actually got elected (i.e. the sewer socialists) they ran on policies like old age pensions, employment insurance, public housing, public health care and other big government welfare programs. Pretty much all this stuff had been subsumed into the big parties by the 1960's and was actually being implemented, so why would you ever expect the Socialist party to continue existing? All their electable policies (that became much more electable with women gaining the right to vote) were adopted by mainstream, usually democrat candidates who subsequently were elected. Subsequently all these programs form part of the big government problem we have today.

You see the above in the USA but you also see it in my home country of Canada, most recently with the current oaf running things federally, who has been kept in power by women voters not changing their vote when it became obvious he was doing likely criminal things while pursuing a suicidal spending platform at home and making us the laughing stock of the world stage with his antics.

Anyways, this is not to say women shouldn't have the vote, they very clearly should have the vote. My original post was mostly about how we integrate the clearly correct idea that women should be able to vote with the clearly correct idea that their voting patterns are causing a lot of our current problems. I think the actual correct solution is some other system of limiting suffrage to only those who clearly have long term skin in the game, as to what that would look like I am not certain. It could take the form of limiting voting to citizens who currently have at least 50 % custody/responsibility for a child of theirs or have X number of years of at least 50% custody/responsibility for a child of their under their belts. Or perhaps requiring citizens to post an income adjust long term bond to vote and have that bond be the first risk of loss if the government runs a deficit of a certain amount for more than 1 year. The challenge with limiting suffrage is having the rule be simple enough that gaming it is very difficult, while being strong enough to actually cut out enough of the people with no incentive to think long term about the country that they can't drive us into bureaucratic ruin.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by supertimor on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @11:12PM (#37684740)
>The claim was that big government was the root of most of our current problems and women in turn tend to vote for bigger government

>When all the men got together and voted for women to also have the vote, that was toxic masculinity at work. (this is a joke, but also not really. Women shifting the political map towards larger government and more socialism seems to be the root of most of our current problems.

Not sure how your statements (and “joke”)above and my statement below are all that much different. Ultimately you’re saying that women gaining the right vote led to the “issues” we have today. What issues? You don’t really say.

>What evidence do you have that supports your incredibly vague statement that women's ability to vote is "the root of most of our current problems.'

It’s not exactly a wonder why women might prefer socialist policies. Women couldn’t even open their own bank account until 1974 (1964 in Canada). If someone’s only recourse from a bad situation is to rely on the state, then socialist policies are going to look all that more appealing.

But that’s even if the premise is true that Canada (or the US for that matter), is being ruined by socialist policy. And I’m sure many would debate you on that.

I can tell you from experience from living large portions of my life in both the US and Canada, having access to universal healthcare is a net benefit.

>You see the above in the USA but you also see it in my home country of Canada, most recently with the current oaf running things federally, who has been kept in power by women voters not changing their vote when it became obvious he was doing likely criminal things while pursuing a suicidal spending platform at home and making us the laughing stock of the world stage with his antics.

>Anyways, this is not to say women shouldn't have the vote, they very clearly should have the vote. My original post was mostly about how we integrate the clearly correct idea that women should be able to vote with the clearly correct idea that their voting patterns are causing a lot of our current problems. I think the actual correct solution is some other system of limiting suffrage to only those who clearly have long term skin in the game, as to what that would look like I am not certain.

You seem to me a bit biased here. You use the term correct a lot here, but just because this position is you’re opinion does not in fact make it “correct.”

>It could take the form of limiting voting to citizens who currently have at least 50 % custody/responsibility for a child of theirs or have X number of years of at least 50% custody/responsibility for a child of their under their belts. Or perhaps requiring citizens to post an income adjust long term bond to vote and have that bond be the first risk of loss if the government runs a deficit of a certain amount for more than 1 year.The challenge with limiting suffrage is having the rule be simple enough that gaming it is very difficult, while being strong enough to actually cut out enough of the people with no incentive to think long term about the country that they can't drive us into bureaucratic ruin.

You are advocating that only parents and rich people should be allowed to vote. Believe it or not, you can, in fact be poor and childless and still care about the future of your country. This scheme would essentially cut out the voices of young people, arguably the people with the most skin in the game in regards to the future.

Your bond scheme would likely result in people (even those who have the means) to not bother with voting. Or the government cutting spending, even when it’s needed.

Do you have to pay every time you vote, in this pay-to-vote scheme of yours? What if the party you voted for loses, do you still have to give up your bond if the other party runs a deficit? What if every party no matter who you vote for runs a deficit? What’s to keep the parties accountable if the citizens are now solely responsible to fund any deficit with their forgone bond? What if every party, no matter who you vote for, runs a deficit? I mean, most governments do run a deficit regardless of the party. The last time the US ran a surplus was in 2001 and since then there have been an equal amount of Republican and Democrat presidents (with the Republicans arguably having more representation in Congress since then). The liberals in Canada had a pretty decent surplus before they lost the election in 2006 and the deficit ballooned massively under the Conservative Harper Government and only until 2018 has Canada seen a surplus, (this year is on track for a surplus as well). So then, would every American lose money every time they vote? Would Canadian conservatives lose more money than everyone else when they vote? Regardless of who they vote for, the citizens are the only losers in this scenario.

So either only rich people vote. Even price adjusted, people who don’t have a lot of money don’t have the luxury of putting “voting” money aside to just sit there waiting to lose it. And if rich people end up losing money enough times, I’m sure they’ll stop bothering to vote as well and instead sink their money into lobbying and back room dealing (even more so).

Or the government cuts spending to save their base from being financially penalized, even if it’s spending the country needs to maintain itself (and even if you might not agree that people need access to healthcare, we still need roads and infrastructure to run as a functioning society).

I highly doubt this would work in a direct democracy but it will absolutely not work in a representative democracy.

So whether you posit that only the rich and people with children (i.e. older) should be allowed to vote or that women can’t be trusted with their vote— either way they are both bad takes, and pretty antithetical to democracy.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by drcongo on Thursday September 21, 2023 @06:31AM (#37595698)
I think you've got the "this is a joke" bit referencing the wrong part of your post.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by badlucklottery on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:01AM (#37593081)
> Can we have an example of toxic masculinity?

A good example is if you your son is allowed help change the oil but you don't allow your daughter or wife to help because it's "man's work".

Or if you force your son to help because it's expect of him as a man.

But, if little dude is curious/eager and wants to hold the flashlight and maybe turn a wrench, go for it.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by kthejoker2 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:52AM (#37596287)
Extreme "pranks"? Hazing culture? Omerta? Gang culture? Wolf of Wall Street / Boiler Room culture?The thin blue line? Church scandals? Basically every domestic terrorist group in history?

Four common patterns

* Recruitment techniques based around achieving worth by emulating some "alpha" male, usually physical and financial, sometimes spiritual

* Approval associated with risk taking behavior. Binge drinking, criminal activity, extrajudicial punishment, etc

* Complicity through witness and increasing levels of participation

And especially

* Code of silence

A heinous fifth pattern is commingling this behavior with family / work culture, creating tension between "the code" and actual codes and relationships.

Ultimately these systems let sociopaths, narcissists, and other mentally unwell men to flourish and prosper precisely because they can easily adhere to these artificial "codes" and power structures vs traditional ones.

Edit: at the risk of coming across of overanalyzing, asking your son to help with the oil potentially contributes to this behavior. You as a male he looks up to is "recruiting" him to do something he has no interest in doing otherwise.

In a vacuum it's benign of course and not toxic but some awareness of the power dynamics and making sure your son knows the difference between a "good" ask and a "bad" ask and how to say no is important.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by mwbajor on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:51AM (#37596881)
I can come up with just as many harmful actions perpetuated by women and yet we don't have "toxic femininity". Thats the key difference.

This line is complete trash: "recruiting him to do something he has no interest in doing otherwise". This is probably the greatest example of the lefts insanity nowadays. How do you know he isn't interested? You know nothing about my family but you assume and then push for policy using said assumptions. And you try to absolve yourself from criticism by saying "I'm just overanalyzing"!

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by conception on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:24AM (#37611073)
We have toxic feminism. It doesn’t get as much air time, perhaps because of the power imbalances between men and women in society. But it’s there and it is discussed.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by em-bee on Saturday September 23, 2023 @09:04AM (#37622898)
if he wasn't interested, my son would tell me. i might still try to motivate him by suggesting that if he helps me then i'll be done faster and we have time to do something else together that he wants.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by gilbetron on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:13AM (#37597141)
Many people (especially men) translate "toxic masculinity" as "masculinity is toxic", which is not the message. Rather, certain aspects of masculinity can be toxic. "Don't share/express your feelings", "Discard/disparage the weak", "real men don't need help", etc. A big part of toxic masculinity is taking aspects of masculinity too far. Teaching your son (or daughter!) how to change the oil and having them help you is fantastic. Calling them a wuss if they don't want to do it and forcing them to do it while they are crying because they are so upset is toxic masculinity. I have a teenage son, and if he was upset about doing chores, I would stop and talk about it with him. Help him understand, by sharing my feelings, that I, too, often hate doing chores, but that if you can figure out the right approach, you can make it an ok thing to do.

Having feelings is natural and good, learning to feel the feelings without reacting without thought is something you can do. Talking about life is good, but complaining about everything is bad.

Independence is great, but relying on others in a community is also great! Being tough is awesome, ignoring others feelings all the time and making fun of people who are struggling is bad.

If you want to find out what toxic masculinity is, why haven't you read about it or watch any of the numerous videos about the subject?

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by BossHogg on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:23PM (#37592197)
> longer jail for the same crime, higher rates of homelessness, higher rates of suicide, lower educational outcomes, shorter life spans, less friends on average, ...

And outcomes are worse for Black men in almost all categories and have been so for some time. Yet the response to negative outcomes for Black people is to blame "black culture." Yet there's no blaming of white culture. Instead this is a crisis we have to do something about. C.f. crack vs fentanyl epidemics.

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by LeroyRaz on Thursday September 21, 2023 @01:52AM (#37593695)
Richard Reeves would agree that black men and boys are disadvantaged (with outcomes significantly worse than black girls say). In the interview with Ezra Klein he focuses quite bit on this disenfranchisement, and says how the political right neglects disadvantages that uniquely impact race, and the political left neglects disadvantages to men, and the end result is that neither care about the plight of black men.

That both parties neglect the cause of black men is (in my opinion) an outcome of a two party system that is so divisive that it leaves no space for nuance (and poor policies and extra needless human misery is the result).

Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by euroderf on Thursday September 21, 2023 @04:38AM (#37594851)
True voting reform (e.g. STV) would percolate thru the system in myriad ways.
Re:Boys and Men in the United States Are Struggling. The Lef... by deejatsplit on Sunday September 24, 2023 @02:33PM (#37635853)
Another good resource for this would be Stiffed by Susan Faludi ( https://susanfaludi.com/stiffed.html ) . Similarly, she started off saying "why are guys resisting the women's movement?" and that lead her to some great insights about the situation of men. I think she has some fantastic insights into why it is hard for progress to be made here. (her observation about the "masculine" approach taken by civil rights and women's rights and being a process that can't be taken to 100% completion has sat with me for years). highly recommended as another thoughtful reflection on the situation.