News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by asah on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:38PM (#37575261)
Before HN jumps all over this, I worked at Google and other ads and search companies... and this is technically true (in selected cases) ! There are certain categories of websites and search results pages, where ads actually improve user experience, measured by nearly any metric you want to pick, from user perception to CTR/conversion, etc.

There's lots of random categories, but the obvious ones are commercial/product searches where you're looking to buy something.

And this isn't new: over history, there've been magazines and other media where the ads dominated the content, e.g. trade publications such as _Computer Shopper_ during the 1980's PC revolution.

Thanks for listening to my TED talk, let the downvoting begin!

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by chinathrow on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:43PM (#37575358)
> There are certain categories of websites and search results pages, where ads actually improve user experience, measured by nearly any metric you want to pick, from user perception to CTR/conversion, etc.

I'm left for words, is this satire?

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jrockway on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:45PM (#37575397)
I don't think you deserve any downvotes, but there is also somewhat of a tragedy of the commons effect at play. I hear people Google "Facebook" to find the Facebook login page. No doubt, Facebook has ads for that search so that people click the right link. This ends up being expensive; people should have just clicked their bookmark, but don't really understand URLs, so there is just a tax on big companies to have that link available. I don't think this is particularly evil, but I also don't think it's amazing. At the end of the day, you're providing value for not making people type "www" and "com", but many think that should just be free. (Of course, before search was integrated into the address bar, I feel like typing "example" in there went to www.example.com. That feature mysteriously disappeared when browser vendors realized you could make money by displaying an unrelated webpage with ads instead.)

Meanwhile the alternative is mobile apps and an icon on your homescreen, an effect that makes Apple and Google rich for taking a % of the revenue from those apps, and one of the largest job programs ever for software engineers.

At the end of the day, I can see why people are uncomfortable with the whole situation, but I also don't see an easy solution. It is fun to railroad rich people in front of Congress, but at the end of the day, what really changes? The rich person has slightly less money, the politicians get a photo op, and some lawyer has a little more cash. Only better technology will end today's quirks. (Remember when Microsoft got sued for anti-trust violations? Did the government end IE's reign on the Internet, or did Chrome?)

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by willsmith72 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:54PM (#37575557)
That makes it sound like we just need a new UX for web browsing without a traditional search engine. It doesn't sound unrealistic to be able to recreate the "app homescreen icon" experience for the web. One of the biggest blockers is that the speed of google search (and success rate for things like "facebook login") means it's barely even a pain point for users, or not one they're aware of anyway.

At the end of the day I strongly believe the web is a better future for the world. Letting the future of the internet sit behind 2 mega gatekeepers seems to be an objectively worse path looking 10+ years down the line.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by vidarh on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:57PM (#37575607)
>I hear people Google "Facebook" to find the Facebook login page. No doubt, Facebook has ads for that search so that people click the right link.

This reminds me how back in the dark ages, Yahoo! Search got sufficient searches for Google that someone decided it was worthwhile to return a second search box in the results before the real results to trick those users into inputting their real search instead of clicking the link to Google...

Users failing to remember trivial domains is sadly not a new thing...

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by wlesieutre on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:50PM (#37575492)
> Meanwhile the alternative is mobile apps and an icon on your homescreen, an effect that makes Apple and Google rich for taking a % of the revenue from those apps, and one of the largest job programs ever for software engineers.

Not to mention that you suffer the same problem in the App Store when you go searching for the Faceboook app. They have to bid for ads against competitors that want to show up when users try to find Facebook in the app store.

Though at least it's only the one time and then it's installed, unlike users who don't add .com to their URL bar and search for Facebook every time instead.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jrockway on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:58PM (#37575619)
Something I think about a lot is what the world would look like without advertising, i.e., you'd have to make every decision on its merits, and never rely on bought opinions. Like imagine you walk into a grocery store, and every shelf is lined with plain cardboard boxes with the name of the product on it ("chocolate-covered breakfast cereal") and a nutrition label. You walk in and there is nothing other than the merits of the product itself to guide your purchasing decision. Nothing else would influence you.

Would that world be better than today's explosion of colors and brands and talking heads and size 100 font "NEW FORMULA!!!"? In today's world, if you're not sure what to buy, you just pick the thing with the most colorful box or whatever you heard about on TV, and you probably end up with something that's fine. (Occasionally, the thing you heard about on TV is actually good, and you wouldn't have thought to buy it otherwise. It's almost a win-win though I am somewhat hesitant to use that term to describe advertising on HN ;)

Advertising is that; you don't care what brand of light switch you buy, you just want a light switch, so there is a race to convince someone you trust to recommend their brand to you. They pay someone money, you buy a light switch, it switches your lights, you're happy, they're happy, and this random third party ad company is happy. Multiple people are bidding against each other for this recommendation, and so advertising ends up costing a lot. (You, of course, pay the cost, not the company doing the advertising. But if everyone is doing it, it's not like you can choose.)

That's the app store thing; Apple prides itself on how every iPhone app is the greatest thing ever created, and because sometimes that's true, you trust them. Well, what if they just approve everything and let people pay for recommendations? Now you have ads in the app store. Someone looking for a random app gets a random app. They're probably happy with their $0.99 purchase. They never think about it again and move on with their life, and Apple's execs get a cooler yacht, and some random software engineer also got 10 cents or whatever. This all seems a little wrong -- ideas and products should only be popular because of their merit in the global marketplace of ideas -- but is it actually? It's really just making a lot of money from making decisions that aren't worth making.

It does sound really dystopian... don't think about anything, just CONSUME what we say to consume... but is researching light switches so that the true best light switch maker gets your money actually better than spending an hour playing with your dog or whatever? I don't know. It's difficult. I should think about it less.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by wlesieutre on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:13PM (#37575848)
Funny you use light switches as an example because I have indeed spent some hours looking at light switch options. Decided not to blow a bunch of money on smarthome stuff (yet…), but for anyone who likes to tinker with that kind of thing the Inovelli switches look pretty fun.

Time well spent? Who knows. But I know more about smart light switches than I used to!

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jrockway on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:56PM (#37576464)
Something else I think about a lot. I have Lutron Caseta but would probably choose something Z-wave if I were starting from scratch today. Proprietary stuff is generally not as flexible as the more open-ecosystem stuff, but Caseta works perfectly with Home Assistant.

The worst part of smart lights is how I've forgotten the tactile sensation when flipping a light switch. Sometimes I see regular light switches outside of my house and play with them, which probably makes me look like a psychopath with a mental age of 6. But so clicky!

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by wlesieutre on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:12PM (#37576752)
Caseta is definitely the non-tinkerer's premium option, I have family members who have used it for years with no complaints.

I don't like their weird button pads, but more recently they also come in a normal looking rocker version. Don't know how tactile it feels but I would bet nicer than the original Caseta controls.

https://www.casetawireless.com/us/en/product/diva-smart-dimm...

Inovelli makes a Z-wave version (red series) as well as a Zigbee (blue series) which is supposed to support Thread/Matter eventually. Among other things, they can operate either as a switch to turn off a circuit, or in "smart bulb mode" where the circuit stays powered and on/off commands are sent to the bulb.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jrockway on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:38PM (#37577140)
Yeah, I have the rocker switches ("Diva") and they are not particularly tactile. To me the worst feature is that they aren't instant off when you press the off side of the rocker; there is like a 500ms ramp down time. This has no negative effect on my life, of course, but it does bug me. I bought this system before I knew that anything hacker-friendly even existed, so I'm always slightly disappointed, but at the same time... they work really well and I wouldn't replace them at this time. Also, no neutral wire required, which is quite convenient for my older electrical system. (My apartment was apparently completely remodeled in 2017. The electrical system is original to the 1950s building, though. Weird stuff. I'm very jealous of the smarthome YouTubers in their brand-new house with 200A electrical service and those blue plastic wall boxes.)
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by asah on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:30PM (#37576078)
interesting points.

one comment: growing up, we have Pathmark groceries, with the "generic" aisle of all (literally) white labeled products. It was depressing and uninspiring.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jrockway on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:00PM (#37576537)
Yeah, I also find it depressing. I think it's conditioning from exposure to advertising, though. It's good to be rich and bad to be poor, and if you're poor, you can't afford name brand stuff. So open your wallet and impress your friends with NAME BRAND BAKING SODA. WHOA WOW! I'm not sure it's objectively depressing to not be able to choose from 300 brands of household essentials, but the explosion of color and creativity and eye-popping packaging that's the result of multiple companies competing is certainly a sensory experience.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by 20after4 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:19PM (#37576887)
A long time ago, brands used to mean something. They invested a lot in advertising (branding) to promote their products but they also invested a lot in their products so that brand would mean something. There was a tangible difference between the brands and people acquired brand loyalty because of it. That has almost entirely disappeared. Most products are all the same shit with different packaging and color schemes. But that is relatively new development.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by 20after4 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:09PM (#37576711)
Firefox, not Chrome, dethroned IE. It was just short lived because very soon after, Google hired half the Firefox team away from Mozilla and created Chrome.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by Gud on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @08:42AM (#37583417)
That’s not really why people switched to Chrome. Google started to push Chrome aggressively on Google.com.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by 20after4 on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @09:33PM (#37592264)
Yes this is also true. I was pointing out that people switched to Firefox before they switched to Chrome. Chrome didn't even exist for quite some time after Firefox was already thriving and putting a serious dent in IE's dominance.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by figmert on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:46PM (#37575398)
I'm not going to downvote you (I can't even), but you've made plenty of claims but haven't got anything backing up those claims. So I'd love to ask for some citations on these claims.

I can get behind "ads keep the internet free" narrative, but it seems rather odd to suggest something that someone who doesn't exactly know you wants you to see is better than relevant result.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by shalmanese on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @12:32AM (#37580396)
It's funny to see in this thread simultaneously the sentiment that Google's search results have gotten awful over the years due to widespread gaming of the free channel of delivering results to you and also immense skepticism that any other channel could be better than the free channel.

In general, I've found any query that's blogspammed to death, the ads are actually surprisingly useful. eg: I turn off my adblocker for any query that is "Alternatives to X (dropbox/xero/notion/figma etc.)". Every organic search result is some generic comparison website that is scraping from the same public data but the ads are generally actual product companies. I figure the companies paying their way to the top of ads have their LTV to CAC figured out and are generally going to be the ones with the highest predicted retention for me.

In this case, I have a specific intent to buy and the bid/ask mechanism for ads is much more predictive of my intent than the SEO algorithms of the organic results.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by timeon on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:46PM (#37575404)
> And this isn't new: over history, there've been magazines and other media where the ads dominated the content

Was it better user experience than if it was not dominated by ads?

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by asah on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:24PM (#37575998)
Nobody was forced to buy Computer Shopper... people bought it for the ads.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by vidarh on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:50PM (#37576373)
In some cases the ads were one of the product. Some catalog businesses charged you for their catalogs. Some other magazines were also entirely for ads. In both cases there's be no user experience without the ads.

But an important caveat was of course that buyers chose this. You got those magazines when you were looking for an ad for a specific product.

If Google let you search specifically for their ads, I'm sure some searches would be specifically for ads, but most wouldn't be.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by Terretta on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:46PM (#37575412)
Ads improve conversion?

You don't say.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by asah on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:22PM (#37575969)
don't be snarky - I mean compared with lower quality free/organic content.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by mentalpiracy on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:15PM (#37576817)
if ads actually were an improvement over organic content, why does everyone append “reddit” to their searches to find anything remotely useful?
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by hn8305823 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:46PM (#37575415)
> And this isn't new: over history, there've been magazines and other media where the ads dominated the content, e.g. trade publications such as _Computer Shopper_ during the 1980's PC revolution.

Wired magazine was heavy on ads but they must have exerted some creative control over them because he entire experience was this unified techno-futurist thing.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by valine on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:47PM (#37575427)
If you fill the search results with enough SEO garbage eventually ads will look better by comparison. If ads are making your user experience better you have a serious problem.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:49PM (#37575464)
Okay, sure, build a better search engine that functions and is better without ads.

Easier said than done.

The internet is 99.99% scams and trash. It's easier said than done to find the signal in the noise.

Some times - willing to pay (and being vetted not to be a scam) is a good indication of signal.

Unfortunately, Google could do a little better on vetting their ad partners. Too often these days, ads are scams.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by Terretta on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:49PM (#37575476)
> build a better search engine that functions and is better without ads

https://kagi.com

> The internet is 99.99% scams and trash. It's hard to find the signal in the noise.

https://blog.kagi.com/small-web

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by janalsncm on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:01PM (#37575660)
Spot on. However I do wonder if the cost of indexing the internet would be prohibitively expensive for a company looking to bootstrap without ad money.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by tqi on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:49PM (#37576347)
> We gather new content, published within the last week, from a handpicked list of blogs

imo this only only works because it is a niche product? If Google went away, and Kagi became the #1 search engine overnight, I think this approach would immediately become a source of criticism for being too restrictive, gatekeeping newcomers or biased towards a narrow perspective (as Google itself already is).

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by Terretta on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:41PM (#37578610)
To be clear, overall Kagi is not limiting itself to the small web.

That's a passion project of the founder who coded it himself to the consternation of his team.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:13PM (#37576779)
Strange to define something as better with ~0% market share and not meaningfully growing, but sure.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by Terretta on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:43PM (#37578631)
Strange to define market share as a gating criteria for better.

So not sure I trust definition of "meaningfully" either. Perhaps a better word would be "sustainably".

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by EA-3167 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:17PM (#37575905)
> Okay, sure, build a better search engine that functions and is better without ads.

As others have said, Kagi. It's a great search engine, even if it's less powerful than Google, because unlike Google it works with you and for you, not against you and for advertisers.

The fact that alt-search companies can flourish and grow even with Google's 800lb gorilla in the room should be a massive red flag to Google execs.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by lukev on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:47PM (#37576307)
> The internet is 99.99% scams and trash.

Mostly because of Google.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by thdc on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:50PM (#37575481)
> (in selected cases)

The tweet presents the quote without context so I interpret it to be a sweeping statement and therefore disagree based on that. If someone could provide a transcript of the cross-examination (I couldn't find it easily), then that could help with making a more informed opinion.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by roughly on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:50PM (#37575497)
The point of Google (or, of search engines, at least) is to surface content relevant to a query. If the content exists, it should be surfaced, and it should not require an advertiser to suggest you surface it to the user. If the content is not surfaced except by ads, that's a failure case for Google (or, for search engines, at least). Saying "Ads improve the user experience of a search engine" could only be true in the case where the search engine is already failing, and one might suggest spending the money and resources one is spending on an ads engine on improving the search engine, if the search engine is actually trying to optimize for delivery of relevant information.

There's certainly one metric that'll always be improved by showing ads, though, and I suspect it's that one, and not any of the others, that's driving the decision to put ads on the page.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by duped on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:52PM (#37575523)
> There's lots of random categories, but the obvious ones are commercial/product searches where you're looking to buy something.

I believe that you believe this while also believing that your metrics must be so horribly biased towards indicating that "ads are good" that you miss the forest for the trees.

I have entirely stopped using google to search for products because of ads. It is impossible to research products when the vast majority of what you see are ads for competing products. It has made the signal to noise ratio so bad that I can't actually trust Google to collect information and make it useful to me.

Google is the absolute worst way to discover information about products you want to buy, because it is so front loaded with bullshit ads for things that others want me to buy.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by meiraleal on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:58PM (#37575616)
I google for one app and google store shows a paid app with similar name and colors as the first result, leading me to install other apps by mistake and deleting just after while google still gets the money from the installation. I'd call this a scam to both the customers buying ads and the customers of the play store.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by stcroixx on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:49PM (#37576334)
It's this failure to engage with reality that will be their downfall. Hubris is at the root of it really, reinforced by the way they hire.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by azemetre on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @06:52PM (#37578163)
I always wondered if the rise of ds&a/leetcode style interviews often hurt these companies more than helped? You are definitely screening for a certain type of engineer when hiring this way, especially when you want to hire 10,000 of them.

You're basically filtering people who care more about optimizing their career than wanting to make a good product (nothing wrong with putting your career first, but you can't have the entire company made up of these people), but then again all the incentives at these companies reward short term thinking so it's probably beyond the interview level.

Either way there needs to be way more competition in the entire tech space in all sectors. Competition would solve a lot of these issues if Google was forced to break up Chrome, Search, Ads, Android, and YouTube; same for the other big tech co's too. This amount of consolidation is bad for everyone.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by meiraleal on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:55PM (#37575571)
> Before HN jumps all over this, I worked at Google and other ads and search companies... and this is technically true

Only a very small percentage of bad people acknowledge it. Most evil people create mental models where they are actually working for the greater good. Your defense of the google exec quote is one of the ugliest attempts of turning bad into good that I have seen and knowing that this is the normal at Google I'm hoping for a good outcome of the antitrust trial (for society).

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by jsbisviewtiful on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:57PM (#37575597)
I'm sure ads bring something to be experience, but ultimately when I have to scroll past 5 somewhat relevant ads before even seeing my results and once I finally see that my results are not very good because of SEO abusing blog spam... I'm going to use another service.

I was not on the "google sucks" train until very recently. It sucks now.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by janalsncm on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:58PM (#37575610)
Another second-order benefit is the fact that innovation in ad tech has bled over into other kinds of content recommendation. If you can figure out which ads I would likely click on, you can also probably figure out what news stories I’m interested in.

That being said, while ads may improve certain kinds of content, it is strictly negative for other kinds. For example, pretty much every kind of ad online which is intrusive. It’s intrusive because it’s not wanted. I don’t want a full screen Dior ad in the middle of an article about the auto worker strike.

So sometimes the interests of advertisers and users are aligned, but many times they are not. And ad tech companies know which kinds of content are improved with ads and which damage the user experience. They could measure this if they wanted. But because they are trying to maximize ad revenue rather than user experience, so the ads win.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by preommr on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:07PM (#37575780)
Downvoted for not only having a bad point but also trying to lampshade it as just an unpopular opinion by pre-empting downvotes.

Ads can be good depending on some metrics (e.g. conversions) or usability if a person is looking for a certain product - I check flyers for deals near me for when I want to eat out sometimes. But to claim "by nearlly any metric you want to pick", is hyperbole.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by gorbachev on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:22PM (#37575976)
Yes, but Google puts ads on every search result, even the ones for which the context makes it pretty clear ads would be detrimental to the user.
Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by throwaway14356 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:36PM (#37576155)
> Thanks for listening to my TED talk, let the downvoting begin!

that you didn't eat some of the babies doesn't make it okay?

my favorite shops have such tiny margins they couldn't afford buying ad slots. If they organically took the top of the search it wouldn't be very interesting to advertise the same only more expensieve along side of it?

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by WWLink on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:42PM (#37577203)
I disagree. Not once has "sponsored result" ever helped me in my shopping process. If anything, algorithm steering and "sponsored results" hurt because I'm searching for product X while you're pushing (sometimes quite hard) for me to buy something else.

Fuck that noise. If I were on the board of directors I'd push for a vote of no confidence in the CEO over saying something this idiotic.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by phendrenad2 on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @07:55PM (#37578724)
You haven't proven that it's true in any case, not even "selected cases". You conflated CTR with user experience quality (rookie mistake) and then tried to say that the existence of ads throughout history somehow proves your point (lol?)

The fact that you knew your point was ridiculous, and had to say "let the downvotes begin!" is just icing on the cake.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by musicale on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @02:36AM (#37581085)
I like magazine ads, such as ads for computers/software/accessories in computer magazines, ads for games in game magazines, or ads for guitars/amps/effects/etc. in guitar magazines.

But I hate web ads - for some reason they are universally terrible.

And the only thing worse than youtube ads is drugs ads on cable TV.

Re:Google ad exec: “it is a worse user experience to not hav... by raxxorraxor on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @05:42AM (#37582263)
> measured by nearly any metric you want to pick

Which in conclusion should question the quality and meaningfulness of such metrics.

Of course conversion rates are only meaningful if you indeed have any ads. That doesn't lead to any indication of positive "user experience", which admittedly is another soft term.

Sure, if I go shopping, I mind ads far less. Although I find them to be mostly devoid of information.