News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by kristopolous on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:21AM (#37552512)
Vint Cerf has called the decision of it being 32 bits as silly and arbitrary, like having a car odometer with 40 digits.

The idea of it becoming scarce was laughable.

Also the complaint about ipv6 isn't a technical one, it's a usability one. Extending it to 48 bits would have been easy enough for people - like international calling.

Those 16 bits could be in hex, as a convention, so something like "(4EA7) 8.8.4.2". That's not bad.

However, the 128 bit hexadecimal with colons just looks too complicated and inconvenient.

You might be brilliant and find it easy but to a lot of people ipv6 addresses look like cryptographic hashes

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by nash on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:33AM (#37552563)
Only network engineers should see or care about IP addresses. The fact IPv6 addresses use colons is why people don't use IPv6 is the worst take I've ever heard.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by conradfr on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:40AM (#37552612)
Network engineers are the one making the transition (or not).
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by kristopolous on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:38AM (#37552603)
you've /never/ heard anyone call ipv6 long, confusing, and complicated? I've basically /only/ heard people say that.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by avereveard on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:18AM (#37552862)
I've almost never heard anyone in the general population use ip addresses, with the notable exception of gamers, but that's fading away too now that all major games come with friends, parties and deep linking support

I don't really understand the use case for typing up addresses either, copy pasting is going to be more precise, and if one can't read 8 quartet of letters one shouldn't be near networking equipment either.

Heck ibans are about as complex and the general population is coping just fine

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by kristopolous on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:05AM (#37553172)
right, but this isn't theoretical. ipv6 was finalized 25 years ago and global adoption is around 1/3. There's something seriously wrong and it's not that 2/3s of the world are using Windows Me and 20+ year old devices that don't support it.

It's human and behavior driven and addressing that is a matter of packaging, process, promotion, product, presentation... all those marketing ps.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Qwertious on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:24AM (#37556524)
Nitpicking, but it looks closer to 1/2: https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html

Also it's increasing at ~5% a year, so in 12 years it'll be at ~104%.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by kristopolous on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:16PM (#37562864)
Interesting. I guess it depends on how it's measured. I had just searched "adoption rates" and saw it said 1/3.

China is a laggard again here. I earlier saw that they were the largest windows xp holdout left. Sure it's only. 0.5% but many places are down to 0.1.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by LatticeAnimal on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:53AM (#37552687)
I host a few video game servers for my friends and love the fact that I can say my easy to remember IPv4 address aloud whenever they forgot it.

I have an IPv6 address but haven't bothered memorizing it or giving it out because it would just be more hassle.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ncts on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:16AM (#37553254)
This is even better:

game.latticeanimal.net. 3600 IN A 1.2.3.4

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by snowram on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:01AM (#37553520)
I don't know a single gamer who rented a domain for private use. In fact, I would argue than the hassle of setting one up is the reason why Hamachi got popular back then. You don't have to bother with knowing any technical stuff, just download a software, share a code and play.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by erinnh on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:48AM (#37553770)
You dont?

It was extremely common with Teamspeak.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by josephg on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:56AM (#37553832)
Hamachi was popular back in the day because it meant you didn’t need to forward ports on your router. (Something that still confuses some of my friends).
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Symbiote on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:02AM (#37554624)
People used to use https://www.noip.com/ and similar services for this.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by WorldMaker on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @12:39AM (#37565660)
DynDNS was big among some of my gaming friends way back in the 90s at one point, when it was a free, donation-supported tool. It was quite useful and relatively low hassle.

At the time it provided a real simple desktop tool that you would install, sign in to your account name, and it would auto-update a (very) short TTL DNS A record for you. (Generally in the form of username.dyndns.org, but as I recall donators could also bring their own top level domain.)

We've got mDNS today to fill some of that gap, but I still wonder if it would also still be nice to have a "no click" desktop tool in 2023 that could quickly update very short TTL DNS AAAA records for you on a subdomain of your choice, and sort of lament Dyn's many pivots (and eventual Oracle buy out) because that original idea still has legs even if it didn't survive the 90s. (Though maybe this time as a true non-profit internet service or operating system feature.)

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by nikanj on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:55AM (#37552701)
But only network engineers pick the protocols used. You’re making life harder for the very people who should be your primary audience.

PS: As a developer, I often read logs and go ”oh yeah, that’s just our satellite office IP”. 192.168.1.110 is the network printer, etc. There’s no hope of recognizing IPv6 addresses at a glance the same way.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by terom on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:20AM (#37552869)
No, 192.168.1.110 is MY network printer, you must have gotten confused somewhere!
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by MawKKe on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:40AM (#37553399)
Whoa buddy how did you get into my home network???
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by nikanj on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:51AM (#37553798)
The same way we all do: A shitty modem that gives an ipv6 address to all devices, but only applies firewall rules to ipv4 addresses
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Symbiote on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:07AM (#37554657)
Maybe if you only have five VMs or something, but when there are 100 or more the additional bits in an IPv6 address will be useful. You can recognize a whole subnet as dev, or production, or a different site, or the office LAN.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by WorldMaker on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @12:53AM (#37565729)
There's more hope than you think as a developer to recognize those types of IPv6 addresses at a glance. The :: shortcut alone also acts a shortcut for pattern matching. You may have network designs where things like {prefix}::110 is the network printer and {prefix}::beef is the cafeteria's new meat printer. Whether or not you bother to remember what exactly {prefix} is or if in worst case it changes regularly and you can mostly ignore it (after briefly pattern matching that it looks close enough to other IPs in your network).

There's different "rules" from IPv4, but as a developer those mostly don't matter and if your network engineer wants you pattern matching your network's machines, then you can just as easily pattern match your network's machines as with IPv4. (That said, there's privacy reasons your network engineers might not want that, security through obscurity and all that. That can be just as true in IPv4, but fewer companies have enough IPv4 address space to truly obfuscate the network patterns. Life is harder for network engineers in IPv6 not entirely because it "has to be" but because "privacy and security is 'easier' if we use a more complicated approach to IPv6 than we did with IPv4 where we would just sequentially number machines within our allotted space".)

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:56AM (#37552710)
I can see plenty of situations where colons behaviour might be confusing, let’s start with a http url on a non standard port with credentials embedded, I assume something close to http://01:02@03:04:05:06:07:8000/foo/bar would be a valid url,
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by piperswe on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:58AM (#37552725)
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @04:52AM (#37567164)
Great, so now I have to learn a new uri syntax too?
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by piperswe on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:56PM (#37575587)
Same syntax, IP just goes in [square brackets] to disambiguate.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @05:41PM (#37577186)
$things_i_dont_want_to_need_to_know ++;
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by welterde on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:17AM (#37552848)
If one has to go through the pain of changing everything why not make sure one doesn't have to do it again any time soon?

Also having 64-bit for the network address (and 64-bit for the device) does have certain benefits that make it easier to use than shorter addresses in practice for a single entity, since one can hierarchically model the network and do things like <my_network>:<site-id>:<vlan>. So even in absence of DNS one doesn't quite have to remember 128-bit of information for every device.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by lazystar on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:40AM (#37553001)
> why not make sure one doesn't have to do it again any time soon?

the pyramids in egypt took over a lifetime to build; a marvel of engineering, as theyve lasted thousands of years and noones had to build replacement pyramids. the problem, though, is noone in todays culture needs pyramids.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by tsimionescu on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:51AM (#37553457)
But ever since privacy extensions, that's not how IPv6 is allocated, right? Each individual system is supposed to get a /64. Your household should actually have a /56 or something crazy like that, which few ISPs actually do. SLAAC doesn't even work if it doesn't have it's own /64 per host, I believe.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by welterde on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:18AM (#37553609)
It is. A typical enterprise might get allocated a /32, which gives them 32-bit to nicely design their network and give 64-bit to each individual network where devices are connected.

A typical ISP will get allocated a much larger allocation like a /20, which allows them to allocate a /56 for each of their customers while still having a few bits to play with. But all starting with the same <isp_network> prefix.

With IPv4 you will have many separate fragmented networks that have no numbers in common. And this will only get worse over time.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by tsimionescu on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:33AM (#37556650)
Your initial claim was that a IPv6 address consists of a 64-bit network address, then a 64-bit device address that could be separated into <site-id>:<vlan> as an example.

However, SLAAC demands that each device is given a 64-bit prefix that it then chooses many random 64-bit host addresses from, without any other rhyme or reason. So, if you want to know the IP of a host you want to connect to, you have to remember at least a 64-bit number that changes every day by design. Add to that some extra bits for the particular part of the network you are in.

So your IPv6 is more like <isp-assigned-prefix, 32-56 bits>:<internal-net-prefix, 8-32 bits>:<random-host-address, 64 bits>. Human friendly this is not.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by welterde on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:50PM (#37560340)
No it was not. My claim was that the network address part (the first 64-bit) can be separated into <network>:<site-id>:<vlan>.. etc.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by nerdbert on Monday September 18, 2023 @08:28PM (#37564201)
> you have to remember at least a 64-bit number that changes every day by design

A machine using IPv6 privacy extensions would have two addresses; one that changes, and one typically based on the MAC address that remains constant.

If you are in the local network with that machine or otherwise are supposed to be in-the-know, you'd know it's fixed address and connect to that.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by tsimionescu on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @09:59AM (#37570031)
That's OK if you're directly trying to access the machine, but it's not enough if you're looking through logs to try to understand which of your machines is contacting you.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by k4ch0w on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:31AM (#37554049)
I think this is absolutely one of the reasons. Addresses are very hard to remember in ipv6. You usually just have to remember the first 3 parts of ipv4 and then change the last digit based on the host you want. IPv6 I know it has shorthand but still it doesn’t register in my brain the same way.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Symbiote on Monday September 18, 2023 @08:40AM (#37555339)
[delayed]
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by butlerm on Monday September 18, 2023 @10:01AM (#37556249)
The problem is that adding so many bits to IPv6 addresses, by way of intended integration of the EUI / MAC address in particular is not actually necessary and is a bit of a mistake. As a rule, no one even wants their MAC address propagated across the entire Internet, nor to be registered in DNS either.

There are some technical advantages to doing things that way of course, but they are arguably rather outweighed by the administrative disadvantages. The protocol could have been designed so that typical layer 3 addresses were not much longer, nor harder to type or remember than IPv4 addresses are.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ianburrell on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:37PM (#37560930)
IPv6 having 128-bit is a huge advantage for transition. NAT64 shoves the 32-bit IPv4 address into the host field.

MAP-T shoves the source and destination IPv4 addresses and ports into IPv6 address. This makes IPv4-IPv6-IPv4 NAT possible. Which means it is possible to run IPv6-only network with IPv4 at on the customer network and edges.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by butlerm on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:55PM (#37565443)
There are certainly advantages as you point out, but just because you have 128 bit addresses does not mean it is convenient for 64 bits of that to be filled with semi-random data.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by commandersaki on Monday September 18, 2023 @08:52AM (#37555443)
I don't know why Vint Cerf should or want to take the blame for IP address exhaustion. We knew about the problem for 30+ years, we had a committee in charge of selecting IPng to mitigate such a disaster, we selected IPv6 as IPng, and then we ran out of IP address space. The only reason I could see why Vint Cerf is to have any blame is that he firmly agreed on a clean slate Internet protocol that didn't give any consideration towards a transition plan. Yes that's how the events unfolded, but that doesn't make him some martyr.