News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by atleastoptimal on Sunday September 17, 2023 @03:51AM (#37542561)
Honestly lower than I thought, given that the top 10% own 100% of America's private jets and luxury yachts
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tinco on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:05AM (#37542660)
Do you think that private jets and yachts are a significant portion of CO2?

First of all, such things are of the top 0.1%, not the 10%. You need to be thinking of more mundane things. As someone on this forum you very likely belong to the top 10%.

How often do you order on Amazon? How often do you dine out? Do you have a heated pool? How often do you fly? How often do you eat beef or pork? How long is your daily commute?

Those are the sort of things that influence your CO2 expenditure. Sure you could 10x that with flying private jets, but almost no one does that so it's not as significant.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by pydry on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:14AM (#37542708)
It's not almost no one.

When my boss's boss's boss spends 4 hours on a private jet he creates as much CO2 as I do in a year.

I need a house. He doesnt need a jet. His jet should be banned yesterday.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:23AM (#37542755)
The point being that even though your boss’s boss’s boss has an outsize impact, there aren’t many people like him, whereas there are millions of people like you, so in absolute terms “your” emissions matter too.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by pydry on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:41AM (#37542863)
It's more CO2 emissions than the entire country of Uganda. Because they refuse to fly commercial.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tasuki on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:52AM (#37542927)
> Because a small group of people refuses to fly commercial, more CO2 emissions are produced than the entire country of Uganda.

Commercial flight is not great for CO2 emissions either. Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling, a lot of CO2 emissions are produced.

I bet the sum total CO2 of commercial flight is way higher the sum total of CO2 from private flights. Neither is necessary.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by david-gpu on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:09AM (#37543030)
> Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling

I tried walking across the Atlantic once but didn't get very far.

Yesterday I also couldn't find any commercial flights to the grocery store either, so I had to bike there.

> I bet the sum total CO2 of commercial flight is way higher the sum total of CO2 from private flights. Neither is necessary.

The notion that flying is "unnecessary" ignores those of us who immigrated across an ocean. Unless I never want to see my aging family again I will have to fly every now and then.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by oblio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:05AM (#37543009)
I can't bike across the Atlantic. I can't bike to see my family 2500km away.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by MrYellowP on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:11AM (#37543403)
> Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling

I would love to know why/how you believed that line makes any sense.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by lotsofpulp on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:24AM (#37543480)
Because setting a minimum quality of life as being able to fly anywhere around the world is environmentally untenable for 8B people. So if it cannot be accessible to all 8B people, then it brings up the question for how to determine who deserves it and who does not.

Which then leads to who deserves first class rather than coach, which then leads to who deserves a private jet versus a plane. Or even who deserves a personal car rather than using the bus or having to carpool.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:54AM (#37542940)
Sure, tax the 0.1% in proportion to the damage they are doing, but don’t use that as an excuse for the rest of us to sit back and think we’ve made much of a difference to the overall problem.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tasuki on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:04AM (#37543354)
This is the comment I wanted to make :)
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jabradoodle on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:04AM (#37544139)
Polluter pays would be a pretty significant improvement.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tinco on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:42AM (#37543575)
Climate change is not some game where the goal is to enact petty revenge on people who are trying to lose the game.

It's not about accountability, it's about stopping climate change so our current biomes don't degrade.

Directing your anger and energy at some small group of people that have an insignificant impact as small as the country of Uganda is simply not worth it or even relevant.

While you're whining about rich people, wealthy people in general are destroying the fucking planet. It's them who should be held responsible. It's them who complain when gas prices get high, it's them who vote against participating in the Paris accord. It's them who vote against stopping trade with China. It's them who should have been educated, who should have taken it seriously.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by t0bia_s on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:46AM (#37544478)
So making people poor is solituion for global warming?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ffhhttt on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:33AM (#37542819)
So the societal cost of banning private jets is approximately zero?

Why is it even worth discussing then?

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by forty on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:41AM (#37542867)
I think the reason it's discussed is "if I cannot destroy the planet in your country, I'll do that in another country (which won't change anything for the planet) where I'll go invest my money too (which means less money for your country)". And politians seem to buy on the threat, either because they truly believe it, or because they don't want to piss of the rich guys so they can get an overpaid job in one of their companies after their political career.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:36AM (#37542834)
It’s not, it’s a massive distraction that makes people feel like they’re doing righteous class warfare, while barely making a dent on climate damage.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by SonicScrub on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:17AM (#37543440)
Because it creates an easy scapegoat for our problems. It's much easier to point to the behaviors of a very tiny group of individuals and lay all the blame on the them than it is to grapple with the real truth of climate change: that our modern society is unsustainable. Barring some grand technological revolution, reversing climate change means bringing us all back to a pre-modern society. And that really sucks.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by abraae on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:25AM (#37542771)
I guess the point is there's only 1 of him, and thousands of you (i.e his peons).

So it doesn't matter what he does, it's not statistically significant.

Sidebar: your boss's boss's boss's should be allowed his private jet - he should just pay a fair price for the fuel that reflects the damage he is doing. Like 10x the current price.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sshine on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:26AM (#37543122)
What’s the point of money if everything costs in proportion to how much you have? Then everything costs 1.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by SirSourdough on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:03AM (#37543340)
I don’t think the argument being made is that the cost should be proportionate to wealth, but proportionate to impact or alternatives.

If flying private incurs 10x or 100x the externality costs of flying coach, it should be priced (taxed really) to reflect that a significant portion of those externality costs are an unnecessary luxury benefit.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by inexcf on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:04AM (#37543356)
"Based on the damage he is doing" is not " based on the money he has"
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:19AM (#37545321)
He is already paying like x50 the public jet ticket price.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rglullis on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:03AM (#37542994)
You don't need a house as big the one as you have, and you ( as an example of the average middle class american) don't need to live in the suburbs, with inefficient construction techniques, dependent on a car to go anywhere, ordering ubers to conveniently bring packages of food twice a week, etc.

Between banning private jets or banning parking lots, guess which ones would be better for the environment?

Americans really don't understand (a) how wealthy they all are and (b) how a lot of this wealth is based on completely wasteful spending.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by RandomLensman on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:14AM (#37543062)
Who gets to determine need?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by figassis on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:35AM (#37543166)
As you get wealthier, you believe you need things, like a 3 br home where each kid has their own room. If money gets tight, you realize a 2 br is actually fine. Problem is, when you consider downgrading you feel that need a lot more than if you’d never had it. Same goes for the jet. That 2 hr trip suddenly feels really critical compared to just planning your travel better. Wasn’t there a post here recently where Musk redirected his cousin’s plane to go unplug some servers? Where was he going that was so important in the middle of the night? And could that detour have waited for a normal flight booking? And apparently the decision turned out do be a mistake according ti Musk himself.

So to answer, money determines needs.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by RandomLensman on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:39AM (#37543192)
So each person by itself.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by HeartStrings on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:28AM (#37543137)
Statistics do.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by RandomLensman on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:41AM (#37543205)
We have tried this before and it wasn't great.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rglullis on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:01AM (#37543687)
Credit rating agencies, who never done their job properly.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by pxmpxm on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:04AM (#37543716)
People pushing this agenda, obviously. Think about the regulatory capture poosibilities!
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by trimethylpurine on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:22PM (#37607453)
>guess which one would be better for the environment?

According to who?

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by trimethylpurine on Saturday September 23, 2023 @04:22AM (#37621548)
Flagging won't change the facts. High density housing is bad for the environment, especially high rises.

(Discussing pros and cons, with links to the research.) https://humantransit.org/2010/03/does-highdensity-life-have-...

High density destroys plant life, increases traffic delays for delivery of goods, and increases the number of goods that are delivered. Transporting humans to their jobs is a very small fraction of our carbon footprint overall. And there are more pressing environmental concerns than just carbon emissions.

Larger homes promote sharing. One vacuum cleaner for example.

Stop parroting high density marketing. Stop destroying the environment to enrich investors.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by austhrow743 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:20AM (#37543095)
You need somewhere to live. He needs to get somewhere.

Neither house nor private jet is an environmentally conscious choice. Either way you've both told every other inhabitant on the planet to suck it, you're getting yours.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by shaky-carrousel on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:36AM (#37543172)
A household would need to earn an annual income of around $200k to be in the top 10%. Are you saying most people here earn that amount of money?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by cgio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:51AM (#37543254)
The proportion of people in the top 10% of the general population here is expected to be much higher than 10% but I would expect most probably less than 50%.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:59AM (#37543311)
> How often do you order on Amazon? How often do you dine out?

You took the bait. Swallowed it hook, line and sinker.

I bought shrimp the other day, they were farmed locally, transported to Malaysia, peeled there and transported back. I bought canned pears, they traveleled the world too.

So while you are arguing and pointing fingers at other consumers over irrelevant cocempts like eating out, industry continues its destructing practices that are actually responsible for majority of emissions

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tinco on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:53AM (#37543633)
I'm not pointing fingers at other consumers, I'm just pointing out the sort of things that have impact. I eat out regularly, I have a transcontinental flight planned for a holiday with my family this year. And I'm sure I've bought products that have had less than ideal CO2 footprint.

Industry and consumers will continue these destructive practices until they're forced to not engage in them.

By the way, not that it's relevant. But the locally produced tomatoes that I buy in the super market have a way higher CO2 footprint than your shrimp that have been shipped to Malaysia and back. But that might be a quirk of the country I'm in.

edit: eh unless the shrimp have been cultured in heated pools, that might be even worse than our heated tomato farms.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:08AM (#37544677)
Well, Transcontinental flight, sure.

But your point about carbon footprint of tomato vs shrimp perfectly ullustrates that the issue is too complex to lay on the consumer.

You can't be expected to do hours of research on every grocery item you buy. And most people don't even have the required knowledge for this kind of analysis. And the companies mislead consumer on purpose.

Recently relatives sent me a viseo which claims avocados are terrible because they need much more nutrients per kilo of product than tomato does. Which is not a reasonable comparison because avocado has fats and calories and tomato is mostly water. But they were convinced by this misinformation.

So I think the responsibility lies with the industry first, and consumer second.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by evandijk70 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:57AM (#37543661)
Correct, I'd like to add two big mundane factors; Intercontinental flights and heating and cooling your house - the second one is a big contributor to global CO2 expenditures and is strongly influenced by the size of your house.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jabradoodle on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:02AM (#37544127)
> First of all, such things are of the top 0.1%, not the 10%.

Exactly, the 0.1% are part of the 10%

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mavhc on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:07AM (#37542673)
There aren't that many private jets, the article talks amount their investments causing 40% of their emissions, so not directly causing it.

I suspect house size is mostly to blame.

But the solution is simple, tax everything the amount it costs to clean up the pollution it causes, and then use that money to clean up the pollution. If importing from a country that does not to this, tax the imports.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jiofj on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:17AM (#37542721)
Since there is no way currently of removing CO2, and we don't even know how that technology would work, there is no fair tax amount. Any amount you set will just be a robbery. Might as well make it a cent per ton, or a gorillion dollars per ton.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ffhhttt on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:35AM (#37542833)
Presumably it would work similar to taxes on cigarettes, alcohol etc. by discouraging excessive consumption and making low CO2 alternatives much more attractive financially.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jiofj on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:49AM (#37542910)
>it would work similar to taxes on cigarettes, alcohol etc

The money that these things cost to the public health service is easily quantified. I expect the taxes to reflect that.

>making low CO2 alternatives much more attractive

If there were "low CO2 alternatives" you wouldn't have to tax stuff, you could just force people to use them, and no one would really complain. Like it happened with CFCs. But taking a train instead of driving your car is not an alternative, it's rubbish.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by oblio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:18AM (#37543085)
Taking a train isn't an alternative because train tracks were literally torn from the ground. As were tram tracks.

Bikes aren't an alternative because instead of adding bike infrastructure that costs 10% of car infrastructure, the freaking 6 lane stroad needs a 7th lane, because that's going to solve traffic!

Walking isn't an alternative because US cities and suburbs are largely devoid of trees and any sort of protection from the sun or rain along their sidewalks, if they even have sidewalks to begin with. Oh, trees also make for a nice view and protect pedestrians from bad drivers, instead of lawns everywhere (!!!!). Plus trees and some bushes contain the crazy, deafening, ear damaging levels of noise cars make at speeds higher than about 70kmph.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by the_cramer on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:20AM (#37542735)
Well trees are a technology to capture co2, are they not?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rtpg on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:33AM (#37542813)
I think there’s some stats about the amount of co2 captured by planting an absurd amount of trees is pretty negligible

There are other reasons to plant trees (well, plant plants in general), notably around rehabilitating land that is on the verge of desertification or the like.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by uoaei on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:39AM (#37542850)
Trees also cool their environments through evapotranspiration as well as literally converting sunlight into sugars. There's more benefit than just carbon capture per se.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rtpg on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:10AM (#37543034)
Yes! I like trees a lot. I’m just commenting about how carbon captures scale is not aligned with trees capabilities on this front
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by uoaei on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:59AM (#37543314)
To be fair, all other carbon capture technologies are still net-positive emissions-wise, after accounting for (what's typically dismissed as mere) externalities. The fact that trees, ie forests, are net-negative and also have other benefits (QoL for lots of organisms, increased biodiversity leading to resilience, etc.) puts them at the top of the list in this category for me.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sokoloff on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:27AM (#37543129)
Trees are a way to temporarily store CO2. If you just plant a massive forest and do nothing else, today's trees will eventually die, rot, and re-release all that CO2. That forest will regenerate itself if left alone and be a store of CO2, but any individual tree is lifecycle approximately zero.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mrweasel on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:36AM (#37543173)
I mean you're not wrong, but if we take that view the only permanent solution if to capture the CO2 and stuff it back into the ground, preferably as a relatively stable substance such as coal or oil.

Most of the worlds large forests are no more, many European countries are stripped of their old forests, so replanting those are required anyway, for other environmental concerns. They could on a permanent basis capture some percentage of the CO2. It is permanent if you view it as a forest and not individual tree.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sokoloff on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:41AM (#37543204)
[delayed]
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jabradoodle on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:07AM (#37544173)
Well paying 0 is "robbery" in the opposite direction.

Worse, it is common to actually subsidise fossil fuels.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by imtringued on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:14AM (#37543063)
That would mean a carbon tax of $1000 per ton because direct air capture of CO2 and storing CO2 is on the same order of difficulty as storing nuclear waste. Possibly worse because CO2 is a gas that can leak out through tiny gaps so every storage site has to be inspected for leaks forever. Pumping CO2 underground is the equivalent of letting a tree capture CO2 with a random chance of the tree starting to rot and releasing all its CO2.

The only realistic storage option is solid carbon and that is why I put the price tag so high.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mavhc on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:25AM (#37553650)
Or just change your business practises to not emit it in the first place, suddenly installing solar panels is insanely profitable
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mrweasel on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:29AM (#37543143)
> the article talks amount their investments causing 40% of their emissions, so not directly causing it.

I don't think it's investment in real estate, but more: a 0.05% stake in GM for instance. If the 40% is as a result of investments in companies that pollute, then I fail to see the point of the article. It makes little difference if those positions are held by the richest 10% or the poorest, the environmental impact is the same.

There is a question of whether climate change is a minor concern for the wealthiest individuals, compared to the middle class. Most evidence seems to show that the rich simply do not care or at least do feel like they should make changes to their lifestyle.

Currently taxing seems like the only viable solution, but can we really tax a private jet enough that those who use them the most would scale back? I doubt it. What would the cost of a flight from San Jose to San Francisco need to cost to stop someone like Elon Musk from firing up the jet?

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mavhc on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:16AM (#37553964)
It doesn't matter if they stop, only that they pay enough to clean up the pollution, and then we use the money to clean up the pollution
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sentimentscan on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:38AM (#37543187)
Cleaning pollution is hard, carbon capture is insanely expensive. We could take this take money and instead of storing that carbon (as other comments suggest) we could further the transformation of grid from fossil fuels to green energy, R&D and to make impact more meaningful provide "carbon tax" to developing countries to ditch fossil fuel as so on.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mavhc on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:24AM (#37553647)
That would happen automatically, as no one would buy your products as they were too expensive, the companies would race each other to install more solar and wind, and to massively reduce their emissions.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by olalonde on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:00AM (#37542976)
The truth is that even the "extremely" rich Americans do not consume "extremely" more than the average American. Elon Musk is, give or take, a million times richer than the average American. But he doesn't consume a million times as much food as the average American, nor does he fly a million times more, nor is his living space a million times larger, etc. Sure they consume more, but not orders of magnitude more.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by oblio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:08AM (#37543022)
Jet + yacht + mansions + ... I'm fairly sure that Musk and is entourage's consumption is probably at least 1 order of magnitude higher than the regular person's. Probably 2 orders of magnitude.

Still, there aren't that many of them and we can probably create an overconsumption tax that would handle most of it. At least we could get money from them to repair the damage.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by helpfulContrib on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:48AM (#37543237)
Cute, now factor in the US military (hint: its in the top 5 of the worlds worst polluters...)

https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2022/10/pentagon-cli...

https://theconversation.com/us-military-is-a-bigger-polluter...

Its easy to forget - after all, this particularly heinous polluter of the world operates in near-total secrecy - but it must be taken into account in all of these assessments.

When you add its military pollution, the numbers for the American people are even more atrocious.

(Disclaimer: I've worked on products designed to reduce these emissions .. I know full well how monumental the task is ..)