News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:23AM (#37542755)
The point being that even though your boss’s boss’s boss has an outsize impact, there aren’t many people like him, whereas there are millions of people like you, so in absolute terms “your” emissions matter too.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by pydry on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:41AM (#37542863)
It's more CO2 emissions than the entire country of Uganda. Because they refuse to fly commercial.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tasuki on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:52AM (#37542927)
> Because a small group of people refuses to fly commercial, more CO2 emissions are produced than the entire country of Uganda.

Commercial flight is not great for CO2 emissions either. Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling, a lot of CO2 emissions are produced.

I bet the sum total CO2 of commercial flight is way higher the sum total of CO2 from private flights. Neither is necessary.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by david-gpu on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:09AM (#37543030)
> Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling

I tried walking across the Atlantic once but didn't get very far.

Yesterday I also couldn't find any commercial flights to the grocery store either, so I had to bike there.

> I bet the sum total CO2 of commercial flight is way higher the sum total of CO2 from private flights. Neither is necessary.

The notion that flying is "unnecessary" ignores those of us who immigrated across an ocean. Unless I never want to see my aging family again I will have to fly every now and then.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by oblio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:05AM (#37543009)
I can't bike across the Atlantic. I can't bike to see my family 2500km away.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by MrYellowP on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:11AM (#37543403)
> Because a small group of people flies instead of walking or bicycling

I would love to know why/how you believed that line makes any sense.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by lotsofpulp on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:24AM (#37543480)
Because setting a minimum quality of life as being able to fly anywhere around the world is environmentally untenable for 8B people. So if it cannot be accessible to all 8B people, then it brings up the question for how to determine who deserves it and who does not.

Which then leads to who deserves first class rather than coach, which then leads to who deserves a private jet versus a plane. Or even who deserves a personal car rather than using the bus or having to carpool.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:54AM (#37542940)
Sure, tax the 0.1% in proportion to the damage they are doing, but don’t use that as an excuse for the rest of us to sit back and think we’ve made much of a difference to the overall problem.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tasuki on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:04AM (#37543354)
This is the comment I wanted to make :)
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jabradoodle on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:04AM (#37544139)
Polluter pays would be a pretty significant improvement.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by tinco on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:42AM (#37543575)
Climate change is not some game where the goal is to enact petty revenge on people who are trying to lose the game.

It's not about accountability, it's about stopping climate change so our current biomes don't degrade.

Directing your anger and energy at some small group of people that have an insignificant impact as small as the country of Uganda is simply not worth it or even relevant.

While you're whining about rich people, wealthy people in general are destroying the fucking planet. It's them who should be held responsible. It's them who complain when gas prices get high, it's them who vote against participating in the Paris accord. It's them who vote against stopping trade with China. It's them who should have been educated, who should have taken it seriously.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by t0bia_s on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:46AM (#37544478)
So making people poor is solituion for global warming?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ffhhttt on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:33AM (#37542819)
So the societal cost of banning private jets is approximately zero?

Why is it even worth discussing then?

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by forty on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:41AM (#37542867)
I think the reason it's discussed is "if I cannot destroy the planet in your country, I'll do that in another country (which won't change anything for the planet) where I'll go invest my money too (which means less money for your country)". And politians seem to buy on the threat, either because they truly believe it, or because they don't want to piss of the rich guys so they can get an overpaid job in one of their companies after their political career.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jl6 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:36AM (#37542834)
It’s not, it’s a massive distraction that makes people feel like they’re doing righteous class warfare, while barely making a dent on climate damage.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by SonicScrub on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:17AM (#37543440)
Because it creates an easy scapegoat for our problems. It's much easier to point to the behaviors of a very tiny group of individuals and lay all the blame on the them than it is to grapple with the real truth of climate change: that our modern society is unsustainable. Barring some grand technological revolution, reversing climate change means bringing us all back to a pre-modern society. And that really sucks.