News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jiofj on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:17AM (#37542721)
Since there is no way currently of removing CO2, and we don't even know how that technology would work, there is no fair tax amount. Any amount you set will just be a robbery. Might as well make it a cent per ton, or a gorillion dollars per ton.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by ffhhttt on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:35AM (#37542833)
Presumably it would work similar to taxes on cigarettes, alcohol etc. by discouraging excessive consumption and making low CO2 alternatives much more attractive financially.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jiofj on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:49AM (#37542910)
>it would work similar to taxes on cigarettes, alcohol etc

The money that these things cost to the public health service is easily quantified. I expect the taxes to reflect that.

>making low CO2 alternatives much more attractive

If there were "low CO2 alternatives" you wouldn't have to tax stuff, you could just force people to use them, and no one would really complain. Like it happened with CFCs. But taking a train instead of driving your car is not an alternative, it's rubbish.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by oblio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:18AM (#37543085)
Taking a train isn't an alternative because train tracks were literally torn from the ground. As were tram tracks.

Bikes aren't an alternative because instead of adding bike infrastructure that costs 10% of car infrastructure, the freaking 6 lane stroad needs a 7th lane, because that's going to solve traffic!

Walking isn't an alternative because US cities and suburbs are largely devoid of trees and any sort of protection from the sun or rain along their sidewalks, if they even have sidewalks to begin with. Oh, trees also make for a nice view and protect pedestrians from bad drivers, instead of lawns everywhere (!!!!). Plus trees and some bushes contain the crazy, deafening, ear damaging levels of noise cars make at speeds higher than about 70kmph.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by the_cramer on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:20AM (#37542735)
Well trees are a technology to capture co2, are they not?
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rtpg on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:33AM (#37542813)
I think there’s some stats about the amount of co2 captured by planting an absurd amount of trees is pretty negligible

There are other reasons to plant trees (well, plant plants in general), notably around rehabilitating land that is on the verge of desertification or the like.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by uoaei on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:39AM (#37542850)
Trees also cool their environments through evapotranspiration as well as literally converting sunlight into sugars. There's more benefit than just carbon capture per se.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by rtpg on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:10AM (#37543034)
Yes! I like trees a lot. I’m just commenting about how carbon captures scale is not aligned with trees capabilities on this front
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by uoaei on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:59AM (#37543314)
To be fair, all other carbon capture technologies are still net-positive emissions-wise, after accounting for (what's typically dismissed as mere) externalities. The fact that trees, ie forests, are net-negative and also have other benefits (QoL for lots of organisms, increased biodiversity leading to resilience, etc.) puts them at the top of the list in this category for me.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sokoloff on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:27AM (#37543129)
Trees are a way to temporarily store CO2. If you just plant a massive forest and do nothing else, today's trees will eventually die, rot, and re-release all that CO2. That forest will regenerate itself if left alone and be a store of CO2, but any individual tree is lifecycle approximately zero.
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by mrweasel on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:36AM (#37543173)
I mean you're not wrong, but if we take that view the only permanent solution if to capture the CO2 and stuff it back into the ground, preferably as a relatively stable substance such as coal or oil.

Most of the worlds large forests are no more, many European countries are stripped of their old forests, so replanting those are required anyway, for other environmental concerns. They could on a permanent basis capture some percentage of the CO2. It is permanent if you view it as a forest and not individual tree.

Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by sokoloff on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:41AM (#37543204)
[delayed]
Re:Americas richest 10% is responsible for 40% of its planet... by jabradoodle on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:07AM (#37544173)
Well paying 0 is "robbery" in the opposite direction.

Worse, it is common to actually subsidise fossil fuels.