News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by arbuge on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:40AM (#37445969)
All those people in this thread saying to just login to these accounts to reactivate their deletion timers are off track.

It is virtually impossible to login to an old Google account for which you never set a recovery phone number - and completely impossible if you did set one but no longer own it.

And there is no human support of any kind at Google that you can discuss it with.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:43AM (#37445998)
Google has plenty of human support. Simply subscribe to Google One and they will chat, phone, and email you to your heart's content. They're very responsive and wait queues are very small.

Please don't spread FUD about "Google has no humans" because time and again it is simply, provably, false. Just because many people bang their heads up against walls of AI and ML and "final decisions with no appeal" doesn't mean everyone has the same experience.

Unfortunately, they may not assist with a defunct account if you tell them that you need help with an account other than the one currently subscribed to One. But I'm not entirely sure about that; you can always try. The barrier to entry there is low.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by invalidname on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:46AM (#37446026)
I paid 400 USD per month for their support and this is completely untrue. Google has a culture of unhelpful support. They might have someone that answers the phone. But they will NEVER help you. It's against the Google DNA to help individuals.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by VHRanger on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:01AM (#37446181)
We have AdWords accounts that spend 6-7 figures a year and it takes 3 weeks to escalate a ticket correctly.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by guraf on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:49AM (#37446059)
How do you subscribe to Google One if you can't sign onto your account?

Create a new account just to give Google some money and pray that they'll give you support about another account?

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by bbarnett on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#37446200)
Not to mention, google is the flakiest company ever. Even if you paid for supoort, the second you tried to use it, you'd likely find it canceled, google having moved on, distracted by some new shiny.

Oh, that support was for google video, but we transitioned your account to Android TV and then Play Video and that support isn't valid, because I'm a vapid airhead called google!

Jesus Google, the average person doesn't want a soap opera and drama, just to use core services.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by DistractionRect on Saturday September 09, 2023 @12:14PM (#37447017)
Except we see this all the time on HN. Google support is yelling loudly into HN/Twitter and hoping a Googler picks up your case internally.

The way Google has proven to work, is you have support until the AI/ML model says terminate the account. Essentially, support exists until you need it most. There's no warning, no explanation, just one day you're done, locked out. You can't even export your content off the platform once terminated. I don't see how Google One is expected to help users when developers for Android/Stadia which pay Google a heck of a lot more end up the same creek [0] [1] etc. You even concede it probably won't be helpful.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37224391

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26061935

They eventually get reinstated (looks like d4rken got reinstated last night), but not before they take to social media and Google gets requests for comment from a handful of news outlets. And still, they usually have no idea what they did/didn't do to cause it. They're left guessing but ultimately could have the rug pulled again at anytime.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by d4rken on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:00PM (#37447503)
Your description is pretty on point. It was eerily casual in relation to how much turmoil it creates for me. One day it was gone, another day, it was back. I have no idea why anything happened.

I also think that social-media reach has helped my case.

It feels very dystopian that this is de-facto way to approach these issues with mega-corps.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by DistractionRect on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:49PM (#37448088)
It's ridiculously dystopian. At a whim they can end a person's livelihood, and depending on how integrated one is in their ecosystem, just erase their whole interface with the world. Unless you get a personal comment from a Googler on social media, there isn't a drop of humanity in the whole thing. Heck, it's almost ritualistic, like how some religions pray/yell out to the God's and craft offerings to appease them. Instead of rain, we pray for access.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by 0x0000000 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:44AM (#37446009)
I'm in this boat. I have valid credentials for my (now deceased) dad's Gmail account. But I can't login because Google doesn't trust my valid credentials and insists on sending a recovery code to a phone number that hasn't been in service for a decade.

His hotmail account I can get into no problem. There used to be a time when you would trust Google ten times more than Microsoft not to mess with your account, lock you out, delete you for inactivity. Those days are long gone, fuck Google.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by toomuchtodo on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:46AM (#37446022)
Have you considered filing a complaint with the FTC?

I’ve contacted them recently with regards to how Big Tech unilaterally handles account security with no consumer recourse for these cases, so follow on complaints from those experiencing this would be helpful.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by kamilm on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:01AM (#37446171)
"Federal Trade Commission | Protecting America's Consumers" - what about the rest of the world? Does anyone know whether it makes sense to exercise this option for non-American citizens?

I can't log in into my Google account either. And yeah, the account was free (money-wise) - judging by FTC's forms, the paid accounts are the ones that matter.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by basisword on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:08AM (#37446267)
Most countries have an equivalent body and given Google operates globally they could help.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lazide on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:39PM (#37447945)
Might be worth trying since Google is headquartered in the US. More complaints on the pile get more attention.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by dataflow on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:01AM (#37446179)
Long shot, but have you tried contacting the person with that phone number?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:57AM (#37446832)
Seems legit:

<Total stranger> Hi, when you receive some TOTP codes on your phone, those are supposed to be mine. Could you be a lad and just forward those on to <random number>? Thx!

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by dataflow on Saturday September 09, 2023 @12:03PM (#37446899)
If you want to sabotage your chances, that's one way to do it. Or you could write something else that's more likely to be successful.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lazide on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:42PM (#37447986)
“Hi, my Dad died a number of years ago and this was his old number. I’m trying to reactivate one of his old accounts as there are a lot of old memories that mean a lot to me in there. Any chance you could forward the signin texts you get so I can do that? I’d greatly appreciate it, and I’ll change the info as soon as I can so you stop getting spammed. Thank you for any help you can offer!”
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by dataflow on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:22PM (#37448539)
And you can get a lot more creative than that. Even paying them, verifying your identity for them, etc. See the thread from the last time I mentioned this for a few ideas:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32862891

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by NoZebra120vClip on Sunday September 10, 2023 @12:49AM (#37452996)
“Hi, I'm a Nigerian Prince, and my Dad, the King, was brutally assassinated by the opposition a number of years ago and this was his old number. I’m trying to reactivate one of his old accounts as there are a lot of evidence that mean a lot to me in there. Any chance you could forward the signin texts you get so I can do that? I’d greatly appreciate it, and I’ll change the info as soon as I can so you stop getting spammed. Thank you for any help you can offer!”

"Oh and I have $500 to sweeten the deal, just send me your bank deets."

In seriousness, it is not impossible to envision a near future when it would be illegal to share TOTP codes or other secrets related to security/authentication. If someone is the target of your scam and shares these things, perhaps he can just be sued into the Stone Age by the allegedly dead grandfather with all the nice photos.

I don't care how you sugar-coat your cutesy text messages, this sort of scheme sets off every social-engineering red flag possible. How rude, to ask a total stranger to share secrets. Many of these texts are explicit: "don't share this with anyone!"

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by ck2 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:54AM (#37446104)
There is one way but it's not easy, maybe impossible.

Use the same ISP in the same city you created the account.

Google security seems to sees that as one step in the validation of ownership.

If you've moved or your ISP is gone, well that's impossible of course.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by judge2020 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @10:55AM (#37446129)
Human support of any time opens up tons of social engineering situations that enable account takeovers - and these hurt Google’s reputation more than any abandoned account story.

What do you suggest would be sufficient proof to the Google human support representative that would verify that you actually did own that account? They already have a process in account recovery that includes inputting the last password you know, entering the month you think you opened the account, and answering some extra questions, after which a human reviews your answers to determine if it’s really you. I’ve had this done for one of my old accounts and I was granted a link to reset the password for that account and set up new recovery details.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by dotnet00 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#37446197)
>Human support of any time opens up tons of social engineering situations that enable account takeovers - and these hurt Google’s reputation more than any abandoned account story.

That's an absurd assertion to make. Amazon makes it very easy to get a hold of a human for support (particularly compared to Google), they have no issue with social engineering driven account takeovers despite that it'd be pretty easy to cause significant financial damage within just a few hours.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by morpheuskafka on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:54PM (#37448148)
All Amazon accounts that have ever purchased something are linked to a name, payment card, and address. A random Google account might not have any of those. How could Google possibly tell who has access to it?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by dotnet00 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:53PM (#37449007)
For example, if an account has been inactive for years and suddenly someone is trying to login, is consistently making an effort over a reasonably long period and is willing to prove their own identity in some official way (such that if it turned out they were lying they could be trivially identified and prosecuted), then they can reasonably allow access.

On the other hand, if an account is still actively logged into, it would be obvious that anyone else trying to get access should not be allowed to do so.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by judge2020 on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:45PM (#37476481)
This happens all the time via credential stuffing - or even after credential stuffing someone's email inbox and searching through all relevant account activation emails. Just saying "lower the security if it's been x years" isn't adequate and could cause serious harm if the abandoned account has important or secret information on it. Better to keep it secure and inaccessible if there is any doubt that the human is an attacker.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#37446205)
> It is virtually impossible to login to an old Google account for which you never set a recovery phone number

Define impossible? If you've forgotten the old password obviously you can't get in. I don't see why it would otherwise be impossible.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by SamBam on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#37446282)
Because Google can unilaterally reject valid credentials if it doesn't feel it's certain it's you.

Although I can see why this would be impossible if you have a phone number set that you no longer own. I'm not sure what exactly Google would ask for if you never had a phone number set.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by headsman771 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:17AM (#37446360)
I never gave a recovery phone number for any of my accounts. While they regularly ask for one to improve my security, I've never given one and they continue to accept my logins from all over the US as well as granting some apps (thunderbird) access to the account.

I do however get notifications on my phone asking if the login was me.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by duskwuff on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:10PM (#37447625)
> Because Google can unilaterally reject valid credentials if it doesn't feel it's certain it's you.

Unbelievably, this even includes rejecting credentials for a non-GMail Google account, even after the user has clicked a link to confirm ownership of the email account the account is associated with.

Ask me how I know!

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lawn on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:08AM (#37446262)
Clearly you haven't done this yourself, because it's not enough with just your password.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:08PM (#37448352)
So what happens? If there's not a backup phone number or email set, what could they possibly ask for beyond the password?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by bassdart on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:47PM (#37448901)
They ask for your current mobile number -- at least in germany and without any anonymization beside standard browser configuration like e.g. uBlock Origin. So it's simply to suck in numbers. I have not tried if they ask for more data after giving a phone number and so I can't log into two google/youtube test accounts any more since a few years.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by jacekm on Saturday September 09, 2023 @09:18PM (#37451997)
The phone number is the last step, at least it was for me. I had luck with virtual phone numbers, not the freely available ones, but paid apps like e.g. Vyke.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @12:33AM (#37492223)
So what happens after you use Chrome and type in your number?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by epc on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:49AM (#37446728)
I have an ancient alternate identity Yahoo account which I used as the recovery account when I created a similarly named Gmail account.

Have used each every few months.

Each specifies the other as the recovery or backup account.

Neither has 2FA set up because I did not want to tie my cell phone to the identity.

I am now locked out of both accounts because…each sends a second factor code to the other.

It isn't a huge loss to me…though recruiters trying to recruit the related but obviously fake LinkedIn profile may be saddened to never get a reply.

I totally understand why Google, Yahoo, and others are purging inactive accounts. Between GDPR and widespread account takeovers it's an expensive nuisance (and if the account is "inactive" then it's not generating meager advertising revenue to pay for the nuisance).

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by jacekm on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:09AM (#37446275)
This is only partially true. I have many GMail accounts (I often create a new one per each service where I create an account) and went through all of them a couple of months ago to make sure that they are not deleted. All I needed was a recovery email address (to which I luckily have access) and a brand new phone number (whatever number you have access to, does not have to be associated with the account in any way).

The part that is true though is that you're out of luck if you set a recovery phone and you no longer have access to it (same for recovery email). But even then I was offered a possibility to contact support to resolve it. And if someone is desperate they may try calling the new owner of the phone number and kindly ask for the code (you'll sound like a scammer, but hey, it's worth trying ;))

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by arbuge on Saturday September 09, 2023 @12:23PM (#37447112)
No, it's all true... personal experience, several times over.

Even if you do everything right in the new phone number case, in many cases Google will just deny you entry for no stated reason at the final step. Sometimes you get lucky, as you did (and me too in some cases), but many times you don't.

As for being offered an option to contact support, I've never seen that myself.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lazide on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:57PM (#37448186)
I was recommended ‘OneGoogle’ awhile back on a similar thread, which turns the account into a paid one, and gives access to (some) support.

Obviously not helpful once the account is locked, but might be worth considering for worthwhile accounts before something like that happens.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by ghusto on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:39PM (#37448793)
So the best thing to do is pre-emptively delete the recovery number from the account (providing you have alternative recovery options set up)?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by odyssey7 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:20AM (#37446384)
There was a related Tell HN post about this situation that led to me recovering my pre-undergrad gmail account recently.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36335975

In my case, I had a record of what my password on the gmail account had been when I last used it, but when I tried logging in with that password years later, it didn’t work, and there was no way I could figure out to recovering access. A few months after seeing that Tell HN post, I tried again and the system allowed me to log in.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by gnu8 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:42PM (#37447991)
The thing that baffles me the most is that literally no one at Google has thought of this. They should be having meetings where they come up with scenarios like this and plan out realistic ways of dealing with them. Google isn't responsible enough to run an email service, it's a toy business where techbros fuck around all day.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lazide on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:02PM (#37448268)
They have and do. The issue is fraud and account compromises are so common (due to password reuse being the norm and every other site under the sun getting compromised), that they’re in a catch-22.

Support can be Social Engineered easily (especially if you don’t spend massive amounts of money on it). Making support not socially engineer-able is essentially impossible too with their user base, as the user base is too diverse.

Technical solutions currently suck, even if we ignore that most of the population is unable to effectively use them.

There is no consistent way across their user base to even verify a person exists, let alone that they are who they say they are, let alone that they are who created or owns the account!

And no one even puts the closest local equivalent into their Google account for legitimate reasons anyway.

Like who would want to upload their Birth certificate? Or passport? Or DL/ID? That’s a terrible idea. And many people don’t have the US equivalent to one anyway.

Not to mention, deep fakes have gotten really good. Not that a US company is going to have much luck identifying a fake (or real!) Belgian equivalent for instance anyway.

So they go with heuristics, which always have edge cases, try to hide what rules they use to avoid being gamed at scale, and hope for the best. Not great. But seriously, what else are they going to do?

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by gnu8 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @03:46PM (#37449557)
Thank you for the thoughtful reply. I will admit I was fulminating a bit. I'm just extremely frustrated that their solution to edge cases is to drop them on the floor and there's nothing to be done. No individual Google user actually matters to the company, but many people actually need their email account. The asymmetry of power and money here just isn't sustainable.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lazide on Saturday September 09, 2023 @03:55PM (#37449634)
I get it. It really sucks. Banks doing it too is also really shitty. I didn’t take it personally, I hope you didn’t either.

At some point I’m hoping a sane plateau becomes apparent. Or at least a realistic ‘plan B’ for how to recover from this.

Generative AI though is really poisoning the online well, and I don’t know what we’re going to do about it.

Captchas were never great, but near as I can tell they’re literally only stopping real humans now, for instance.

When someone can easily gin up thousands of impossible-to-tell-they’re fake IDs for people that never existed?

That breaks almost every verification process anyone has right now. Except in person ‘show up and provide the actual physical ID’.

and that’s the reality we live in.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by guilhas on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:42PM (#37447994)
My gmail somehow allows to click some options, show the last digits of the number, and just type the complete number to login
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by thiht on Saturday September 09, 2023 @04:39PM (#37450041)
Heck, I have trouble connecting to my work Google account from my personal laptop. I have the username, password, 2FA and I’m connecting from the same IP, but Google somehow knows better.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by leipert on Saturday September 09, 2023 @05:38PM (#37450545)
Oh, that’s just the a work-life balance feature!