News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#37446205)
> It is virtually impossible to login to an old Google account for which you never set a recovery phone number

Define impossible? If you've forgotten the old password obviously you can't get in. I don't see why it would otherwise be impossible.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by SamBam on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#37446282)
Because Google can unilaterally reject valid credentials if it doesn't feel it's certain it's you.

Although I can see why this would be impossible if you have a phone number set that you no longer own. I'm not sure what exactly Google would ask for if you never had a phone number set.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by headsman771 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:17AM (#37446360)
I never gave a recovery phone number for any of my accounts. While they regularly ask for one to improve my security, I've never given one and they continue to accept my logins from all over the US as well as granting some apps (thunderbird) access to the account.

I do however get notifications on my phone asking if the login was me.

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by duskwuff on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:10PM (#37447625)
> Because Google can unilaterally reject valid credentials if it doesn't feel it's certain it's you.

Unbelievably, this even includes rejecting credentials for a non-GMail Google account, even after the user has clicked a link to confirm ownership of the email account the account is associated with.

Ask me how I know!

Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by lawn on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:08AM (#37446262)
Clearly you haven't done this yourself, because it's not enough with just your password.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:08PM (#37448352)
So what happens? If there's not a backup phone number or email set, what could they possibly ask for beyond the password?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by bassdart on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:47PM (#37448901)
They ask for your current mobile number -- at least in germany and without any anonymization beside standard browser configuration like e.g. uBlock Origin. So it's simply to suck in numbers. I have not tried if they ask for more data after giving a phone number and so I can't log into two google/youtube test accounts any more since a few years.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by jacekm on Saturday September 09, 2023 @09:18PM (#37451997)
The phone number is the last step, at least it was for me. I had luck with virtual phone numbers, not the freely available ones, but paid apps like e.g. Vyke.
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by flangola7 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @12:33AM (#37492223)
So what happens after you use Chrome and type in your number?
Re:Ask HN: Will Google delete inactive gmail accounts that f... by epc on Saturday September 09, 2023 @11:49AM (#37446728)
I have an ancient alternate identity Yahoo account which I used as the recovery account when I created a similarly named Gmail account.

Have used each every few months.

Each specifies the other as the recovery or backup account.

Neither has 2FA set up because I did not want to tie my cell phone to the identity.

I am now locked out of both accounts because…each sends a second factor code to the other.

It isn't a huge loss to me…though recruiters trying to recruit the related but obviously fake LinkedIn profile may be saddened to never get a reply.

I totally understand why Google, Yahoo, and others are purging inactive accounts. Between GDPR and widespread account takeovers it's an expensive nuisance (and if the account is "inactive" then it's not generating meager advertising revenue to pay for the nuisance).