News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pipo234 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:02AM (#37417188)
The bigger picture of why UK is hell bent on surveilling their citizens, communities is that the number one problem is that governments are losing control over society.

Off course the whole point of democracy is that governments should fear their citizens, rather than vice versa.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by mcpackieh on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:08AM (#37417236)
Are they losing control, or are they becoming control freaks who want more control than they've traditionally had and have any right or business having? Both would manifest as the government thinking it has insufficient control, but the cause is very different.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by slashdev on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:13AM (#37417280)
I think it’s very much this latter.

The multiplying force of technology has made it extremely difficult to overthrow a government by force. I do not think it is possible in the West.

Governments have never had so much control over money and information. They’re not losing control, they just keep tightening their grip.

I don’t know if this Democratic experiment can survive in that environment. I certainly hope it does, but bills like this give me doubts.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by robertlagrant on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:44AM (#37417527)
> Governments have never had so much control over money and information. They’re not losing control, they just keep tightening their grip.

Well - East Germany must've had worse, surely? All money controlled by the state and state-sponsored spying?

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by mcpackieh on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:53AM (#37417610)
I've heard the Stasi were breaking into people's homes and stealing their underwear to store in archives of scent jars for their dogs, but as extreme as that is I don't think that and their other tactics gave them anything close to the surveillance capabilities modern governments now have thanks to everybody carrying a smartphone 24/7.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by robertlagrant on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:36AM (#37418720)
Well, sometimes they'd have someone crouched in the room next door listening and looking. That seems fairly invasive even by today's standards.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by mcpackieh on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:57PM (#37422923)
Yes, the things the Stasi did were insanely paranoid. But I think they still got less "bang for their buck" than modern western democracies. The latter have a far more complete map of who associates with who, logs of where people have been even months before they become subjects of interest, etc.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by robertlagrant on Saturday September 09, 2023 @04:12AM (#37443255)
I think it was probably better - if people can turn in their neighbours or family for a small reward that's a lot cheaper than mass surveillance, and it induces compliance as a bonus!
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by CaptWillard on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:22AM (#37418536)
By 1980s standards, maybe. In their wildest dreams, the soviets couldn't have imagined the access and leverage most western governments have today.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pydry on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:13AM (#37417272)
Theyre authoritarian control freaks. The UK is undergoing progressive Russification with bipartisan support (Labour under Starmer and the Tories are both on board with it).

Protesting is now effectively illegal thanks to a new law criminalizing it if it's a "nuisance".

You're still technically allowed to hold up a blank piece of paper but the police will threaten to arrest you if you write something on it. That happened during the coronation.

I'm fairly sure theyre going to borrow a whole lot more from Putin's playbook in the next few years - especially now the two parties have ideologically aligned.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by NoZebra120vClip on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:20AM (#37417341)
Yes, it is, in fact, illegal to pray in many locations of the U.K., and people have been arrested and charged for it.

Think about it: prayer, an interior orientation of the mind to God; not even any audible speech is necessary to commit a heinous, treasonous act.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by robin_reala on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:22AM (#37417352)
[citation needed]
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by flir on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:09AM (#37417752)
I'll bet you 50p it's the abortion facility buffer zones. Public space protection orders.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by tescocles on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:08AM (#37417742)
Not even close.

The specific case I know you're talking about is the woman who was in an exclusion zone that was in place to stop people harassing women entering an abortion clinic.

If she doesn't want "praying silently in her head" to be interpreted as harassment, maybe she should think about the behaviour she and her cohorts have engaged in that might have lead to this interpretation.

Sure, you can disagree with that as well, but she wasn't arrested for praying. She was arrested for intimidation and harassment. She doesn't get a special pass just because of the method.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by sjducb on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:41AM (#37418787)
This is a common misunderstanding. Harassing people near abortion clinics is a separate offense. The lady in question has harassed people in the past, but she was specifically arrested and charged for prayer in this case. This offense of prayer is separate to her harassment of people.

It’s like if you had drugs in your pocket while harassing someone. They’re separate offenses.

This video explains the situation and references the original police and court records.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FS5FT-4Kx7E

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by flir on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:00AM (#37419031)
If anyone wants to jump straight to the order itself, it's the first link under that youtube video.

> the council is satisfied on reasonable grounds that there are a number of activities, carried out or are likely to be carried out in a public space namely the area within and surrounding Station Road, Birmingham, B30, shown outlined on the map attached ( the restricted area) that have had, or are likely to have, a detrimental effect on the quality of life of those in the locality. The effect or likely effect of these activities is of a persistent or continuing nature such as to make these activities unreasonable, and justifies the restrictions imposed in this order

[...]

> The Activities prohibited by the Order are:

> i Protesting, namely engaging in any act of approval or disapproval or attempted act of approval or disapproval, with respect to issues related to abortion services, by any means. This includes but is not limited to graphic, verbal or written means, prayer or counselling,

> ii Interfering, or attempting to interfere, whether verbally or physically, with a Robert Clinic service user, visitor or member of staff,

> iii Intimidating or harassing, or attempting to intimidate or harass, a Robert Clinic service user, visitor or a member of staff,

> iv Recording or photographing a Robert Clinic service user, visitor or member of staff or

> v Displaying any text or images relating directly or indirectly to the termination of pregnancy.

She was protesting. It's a persistent pattern of behaviour. It's harassment.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by sjducb on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:18AM (#37419244)
By specifically calling out prayer the order does ban prayer...

In that case the woman was arrested for silently praying by herself. Her prayer was to stop the abortion clinic, but it was silent and in her own head.

I understand that the intent of the law is to ban prayer near an abortion clinic to stop harassment, but they have banned prayer.

(I support everything else in that order, I’m pro choice. I just don’t think we should ban prayer)

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pcrh on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:52AM (#37419757)
She would have been guilty of harassment even if she were not praying.

Edit, these pictures show that "silently praying" is not an unobtrusive as it sounds:

https://i2-prod.birminghammail.co.uk/incoming/article2379330...

https://i2-prod.birminghammail.co.uk/incoming/article2379331...

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by sjducb on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#37419920)
Is silent prayer illegal outside some abortion clinics in the UK?

Has the UK banned some prayer and arrested at least one person for thought crime?

The answer to both of those questions is yes.

It’s not about whether she would have been convicted for something else anyway.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pcrh on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:04AM (#37419976)
Any form of harassment is illegal. See the pics I posted in an edit above; the protestors make their opinions clear to visitors to the clinic, even while being silent.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by sjducb on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:35AM (#37420514)
Do you agree that the UK has banned some silent prayer?

Do you think it is right that silent prayer was banned in this case?

This whole discussion started because people from other countries didn’t believe that the UK would ban silent prayer.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by growse on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:02PM (#37420998)
> Do you agree that the UK has banned some silent prayer?

This is true in the same sense that the UK has also banned breathing, because murdering people is illegal and some people happen to be breathing whilst doing their murdering.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by flir on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:10PM (#37421117)
Pretty sure I could walk through that area while praying and not get arrested. I'd do it by making no outward signs that I was praying.

Also pretty sure I could get arrested in that area by kneeling on the pavement and meditating, rather than praying. I don't think "but I was meditating" would cut it as a defence, either.

I think it's the kneeling she got arrested for, which happens to be coded as "prayer" in our culture. In other words, she was arrested for protesting.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by growse on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:59AM (#37420931)
If she was "silently praying by herself" in her own house, or literally most other places in the country, she wouldn't have been arrested.

The context matters.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by DonaldFisk on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:57AM (#37420896)
Thanks for providing the reference. In the specific case referred to, she was acquitted: https://news.yahoo.com/british-woman-priest-acquitted-charge..., https://adf.uk/not-guilty/
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:11AM (#37417254)
> The bigger picture of why UK is hell bent on surveilling their citizens

It's just their culture. It probably won't change till they get rid of the anachronistic monarchy.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by garblegarble on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:26AM (#37417389)
>It probably won't change till they get rid of the anachronistic monarchy.

It's nothing to do with the monarchy - indeed, if anything I think the consensus amongst pro-monarchy folks is that the monarch is a constitutional escape hatch in the event of a government getting out of control.

Both the Conservative and Labour parties have an authoritarian streak to them when in government, and a solid percentage of the population seem to trust that our institutions know what they're doing and can keep their databases secure (although I hope that's been shaken in the last month with a number of police and electoral register database leaks).

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pipo234 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:27AM (#37417403)
I don't understand enough about UK to see why anachronistic monarchy would be at the heart. (To lesser extent) we see a lust for surveillance in many other democratic countries too.

Isn't an easier explanation that society is getting more complex while politicians double down on managing their reputation, which inevitably results in loosing trust in institutions? (Or something along those lines.)

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:45AM (#37417535)
> I don't understand enough about UK to see why anachronistic monarchy would be at the heart.

Not saying the monarchy is at heart, just that the culture won't change until they have some sort of cultural revolution and get rid of it.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pipo234 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:06AM (#37417718)
Yikes! Historically, revolutions are bloody and generally do not end well. Cultural revolutions less so.

Having said that, I would not mind seeing King Charles abdicate; England, Wales, Scotland, N-Ireland become proper republics; help the remnants of upper class strongholds adapt to reality, if that's what you mean. :-)

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by sph on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:41AM (#37418069)
> Historically, revolutions are bloody and generally do not end well. Cultural revolutions less so.

Historically, major changes only come with a bloodshed, you forgot that part. We speak highly of Gandhi because he's an exception to this rule, not the norm. (And blood was shed in that case as well)

The corollary is, don't expect much to change until there's a major societal break and pushback. That is, unless you have drunk the kool aid of modern politics and think your party will fix things for real, this time.

In Britain, I'm less concerned about King Charles III and its effect on the populace, than Starmer, Sunak, and any other idiot in Westminster. They're the ones writing the government laws and budget for their own interests.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:54AM (#37418210)
> Yikes! Historically, revolutions are bloody and generally do not end well. Cultural revolutions less so.

I specifically said cultural revolution because I tried to imply a non-violent revolution. Not all revolutions are violent. Think technological revolution.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:00AM (#37418281)
Unfortunately the usual referent of "cultural revolution" is the Maoist one which was extremely violent. You could try referencing the colour revolutions or the Portuguese "carnation revolution" maybe.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:08AM (#37418355)
Generally when I've seen cultural revolution being used it has been in reference to the 60s or similar, but upon searching you are definitely correct; I just wasn't aware of that. There's still a lot of history I've yet to learn about.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jjgreen on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:31AM (#37417439)
The other way around I'd say, the expense and misbehaviours of the monarchy are tolerated by the ~ 70% of the population who are authoritarian minded.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:44AM (#37417525)
That's not the other way around, that's perfectly consistent with what I'm saying and I agree.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jjgreen on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:53AM (#37417609)
If the monarchy were to vanish into thin air for some reason, that 70% would still be there.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:53AM (#37418194)
Sure, but I wasn't talking about it vanishing into thin air, but a cultural revolution that would result in people willingly wanting it gone.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by tcldr on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:47AM (#37417553)
You realise the 'anachronistic monarchy' is just a tourist attraction/diplomatic lever at this point, right? Britain is a parliamentary democracy. I'm pretty confident Charlie doesn't have a hand in enabling sweeping snooping powers. More hacking scandals are the last thing his poor family needs!
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:50AM (#37417581)
> You realise the 'anachronistic monarchy' is just a tourist attraction/diplomatic lever at this point, right?

It's not. It still has power, and it's still costing tax payers a shitton so one family can live above everyone else. More importantly there are plenty of royalists who support it.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by bananapub on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:32AM (#37417975)
christ alive buddy.

the royal family costs the UK tax payer ~100m a year[0], which is about the cost of the three nuclear bombs in the US or less than one of the ill-advised F-32 purchases Australia is making. it's also maybe a 1/10th of the amount of money stolen by Tory mates for their various PPE crimes during the early pandemic.

every country has very very dumb shit they piss money up the wall over, but it's not a game changing amount of money.

0: dodgy source: https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/how-much-royal-family-cos...

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:56AM (#37418235)
That's ~100m that could be put towards things that actually help people and improve peoples lives.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by BookhouseGames on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:23AM (#37418550)
India could put a craft on the moon for that.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by bananapub on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:44AM (#37418823)
if the UK government had an extra £100m, rest assured they would not use it to help anyone or improve anyone's lives
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by OJFord on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:54AM (#37418949)
They are net contributors even before tourism. (Massively so after it, but I suppose it'd be hard to say how much of that would remain, especially in the short term, if we had no current monarchy but still the history, buildings, military, etc.)
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:09AM (#37419125)
> They are net contributors even before tourism.

Explain your reasoning, please.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by tcldr on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:58AM (#37420922)
You can argue that even greater than the tourism revenue they generate (which is significant) it's the soft power they yield; all the heads of state want to grab a selfie with Lizzie, less so with Rishi. (Time will tell with Charles.)

I don't doubt you're well intentioned, but there's probably more useful things to be fighting over. Especially as what you're fighting for will generate negligible incomes at best and negative incomes at worst. The last thing the UK needs after Brexit is a referendum on becoming a republic.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:07PM (#37421075)
> I don't doubt you're well intentioned, but there's probably more useful things to be fighting over. Especially as what you're fighting for will generate negligible incomes at best and negative incomes at worst. The last thing the UK needs after Brexit is a referendum on becoming a republic.

I disagree. The UK is still backwards in many ways, hell, they still have an unelected upper house. Getting rid of the monarchy sends a strong message and allows other reforms to follow in its wake.

I'm also skeptical the monarchy generate any tourism. People come to see the palace that would remain regardless, and the funny guards that trample over children. They don't come to the UK for that stuff, they see it while they are there, and they certainly don't come hoping to see a member of the royal family.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by tcldr on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:09AM (#37417758)
What interests do you think they have in boosting surveillance powers?
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:55AM (#37418227)
What interest do UK authorities have in being so petty as to charge people for 'stealing' less than 10p in electricity?

I'd say the answers are related.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by tcldr on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:50AM (#37420791)
> I'd say the answers are related.

How so?

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by PrimeMcFly on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:05PM (#37421038)
Provide the answer to the question I asked and we can discuss it.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:50AM (#37418176)
It's more the press. The monarchy are irrelevant, but the press massively support authoritarianism as long as it's against other people.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by hcfman on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:54AM (#37417622)
It's not just the UK. The Netherlands is like that as well and it's lost it's democracy. They can now hack anyone, not just criminals, without a judge being involved or even any evidence. They can shutdown speech that they don't like and they regularly commit criminal acts against non-criminally involved citizens organised by non-accountable organisations.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by hcfman on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:03AM (#37417689)
Oh, and the Netherlands also holds provably completely sham court cases where the authorities pervert the course of justice in order to shutdown repercussions of criminal activity that they have been involved in.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:58AM (#37418254)
[citation needed]
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jacquesm on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:20AM (#37417871)
This is a bit over the top, don't you think? Case in point: we will have elections one of these days, that seems to be proof to me that we still are a democracy. Or do you believe in widespread vote fraud?
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by master-lincoln on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:22AM (#37418547)
Elections alone don't make a democracy. Fair and free and secret elections are necessary but not sufficient for a democracy. Free press, protection of minorities, free speech, separation of powers, fundamental rights are other parts I think are necessary for a liberal democracy.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jacquesm on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:49AM (#37418890)
To a large degree we have all of those, I'm not sure which countries rank better on those parameters but there can't be all that many of them.

- #6 press freedom ranking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Press_Freedom_Index

- #9 freedom house https://freedomhouse.org/countries/freedom-world/scores

- #11 freedom of speech https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/countries...

And so on. Now: this isn't saying that NL is perfect, not by a long shot. We have seen some absolutely terrible behavior by politicians, most notably on the right extreme part of the spectrum. Emboldened by Trump's election populism is on the rise here as well and we see just the same idiotic behavior as in the USA. Including word-for-word translations of talking points (which are utterly ridiculous in a Dutch context, but never mind that sort of detail), attempts (and some success) at polarization and so on. For that reasons alone the next elections are pretty exciting in that we can either further derail or - hopefully - that there will be some pushback against this.

But it is usually the people arguing the loudest that there is no democracy, freedom of press and separation of powers here that are the ones that are trying to destabilize things further.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by master-lincoln on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:55AM (#37418968)
Totally agree with you.

OPs complaint about the police being able to gather private information of their citizens without a judge having to agree to it first might be seen as violating separation of powers, but as long as a judge still decides what the punishment is after seeing the evidence, I merely see this as a state not respecting individual's privacy, which is probably not a common thing to require for a democracy.

Sadly those erosions are to be seen in many EU countries currently...

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by kwhitefoot on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:55AM (#37420861)
> a state not respecting individual's privacy, which is probably not a common thing to require for a democracy.

Surely invasion of privacy is a violation of the CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION.

" Article 7

Respect for private and family life

Everyone has the right to respect for his or her private and family life, home and communications.

Article 8

Protection of personal data

1. Everyone has the right to the protection of personal data concerning him or her.

2. Such data must be processed fairly for specified purposes and on the basis of the consent of the person concerned or some other legitimate basis laid down by law. Everyone has the right of access to data which has been collected concerning him or her, and the right to have it rectified.

3. Compliance with these rules shall be subject to control by an independent authority."

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by EvertBouw on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:16PM (#37422259)
How is the press free? Even the ANP nieuws is owned by some hedgefund that calls itself 'fuck off'. Do you think they will ever print something against the status quo?
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jacquesm on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:26PM (#37422427)
A free press means: you can go buy a press, issue a newspaper as of tomorrow (or a website, for that matter) and write there whatever you want, and until a judge is involved nothing can or will be done about barring some emergency order.

Who owns ANP nieuws has nothing to do with whether or not the press is free.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by vaylian on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:48AM (#37418878)
As long as most people are not aware of these problems, they will not vote against the politicians that make these laws. This is really not a question about democracy but a question about how well-informed the population is.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jacquesm on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:17AM (#37419229)
Except of course the bit that these problems are overblown. But the people pushing these as problems are exactly the ones that stand to benefit from trying to grab power. There is a substantial amount of money pumped into the destabilization of the Dutch political order, a massive powershift is expected and the direction we are headed in is the wrong one by any objective measure. To a large extent this anti-EU, anti-climate and anti-press sentiment originates from both the very wealthy agricultural lobby in NL as well as the right wing. The interesting part is that you'll find the parties that would like to deport foreigners fomenting civil unrest and these are now in bed with the farming lobby.

It's with some anxiety that I'm looking at the next six months here, it could well go the way of Italy, or possibly much worse (think 'Orban' or something like that).

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by nonrandomstring on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:57AM (#37417648)
I try to take a charitable, open-minded position in this.

Two of us in the cybershow are parents. Taking on analysis of this bill was a tough decision, but something we felt obliged and qualified to do as parents and security experts.

There are obviously grave harms around digital technology, plus its obvious myriad benefits. Covert communications enabling criminal and anti-social activity is just one small part.

Our thought experiment is to assume good faith. To assume the government is sincerely invested in doing it's job of protecting citizens. Then to figure out how this has gone so wrong.

Who are the marginal influencers? Why is the standard of technical expertise and computer science in our government so woefully inadequate. Why has saving face become more important than actually tackling difficult issues?

I would characterise our UK government as confused and frustrated.

Perhaps we should be pleased our government is tenacious in pursuing a bill whose aims we broadly support. But a mixture of prideful ego-politics, poor advice and technologically laughable solutionism has led us into a corner. That's not a good look for a country that started the industrial and digital revolutions.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by jacquesm on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:19AM (#37417860)
That's a very mature stance. Inside the government there are a ton of people doing really hard work who are frustrated by the rise of encryption, so they can no longer do the work that they were doing in the past effectively (some outside of government see this as a good thing).

In those same governments there are those that dream of having access to all of this data with less honorable intentions. Because both are part of the same entity and once the capability is there it is pretty much a given that checks and balances will fail when you need them most I find myself both sympathetic to those that keep us safe and to those that object to this level of invasiveness, and I find myself opposed to those what effectively use terrorism and CP as a way to shepherd us into an authoritarian society.

And then there are the consequences of finding yourself with a really bad instance of government at some point in the future, it could easily happen.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:57AM (#37418248)
> Our thought experiment is to assume good faith.

At this stage, and in the dying days of a flailing Tory government, that simply makes you a mug.

Also from today: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-66720994 ; this is specifically to protect murders carried out by and on behalf of the state in Northern Ireland. Along with historical matters such as the "spycops" scandal, and the abuses of PREVENT, there is a strong risk that mass surveillance will be used in political ways and in the service of misconduct. Accountability is poor and therefore trust is poor.

> Who are the marginal influencers?

The Daily Mail. Well, that and the security services who've clearly been pushing this.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by nonrandomstring on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:24AM (#37418568)
> in the dying days of a flailing Tory government, that simply makes you a mug.

TBF let's take longer view than the incumbent freak show of throwbacks and incompetents.

> "spycops" scandal, and the abuses of PREVENT,

Do please give the podcast episode I linked a listen. You'll appreciate that we took that precise case (the Bob Lambert case) as an example for discussing mission-creep and the impossibility of containment of digital privilege or other special powers.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by gottorf on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:03AM (#37418301)
> to assume good faith. To assume the government is sincerely invested in doing it's job of protecting citizens.

Five thousand years of recorded human history should serve as adequate evidence against making this assumption. And we all know that even if the current government is sincerely invested in doing its job in good faith, any powers that are given to the current government can and will be abused by a future government that may be invested in doing something else.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by skinkestek on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:31AM (#37418658)
> And we all know that even if the current government is sincerely invested in doing its job in good faith, any powers that are given to the current government can and will be abused by a future government that may be invested in doing something else.

Exactly this.

For starters, and using the U as an example:

If you are a Democrat (or whatever), think if you want these powers to be available to the next Trump.

And vice versa: if you are a republican (or whatever) think if you want these spying capabilities and what not to be available to the next Democrat president.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by eesmith on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:14AM (#37417813)
> the whole point of democracy is that governments should fear their citizens, rather than vice versa.

I think that's more an optimistic interpretation of democracy.

After all, it's the government that gets to decide who is a citizen, and who has the franchise.

Historically the US said that African Americans were not citizens, within the meaning of the Constitution. In 1858 your statement might be 100% true about the US, but it would exclude a lot of people - who indeed were justifiably fearful of the democracy they lived in.

While the 14th amendment made many new citizens, for many decades after the end of reconstruction these citizens feared their government far more than vice versa.

You can see the variable concept of "citizen" when considering that a minor may be a US citizen for many purposes, but does not have the voting rights of full citizenship. Before the 26th amendment even 20-year-old adults were not full citizens.

Something like 2% of US adult citizens cannot vote due to being a convicted felon, further showing how shaky your assertion is.

There's also a large number of immigrants to the US who are not citizens, but ideally should not fear the government any more than citizens do.

Perhaps the US doesn't count as democracy, but that sounds too much like a No True Scotsman response. Switzerland, with its famous direct democracy, didn't allow full women's suffrage until 1971-1990, depending on canton, again highlighting that "citizen" and "those who can vote" are not really the same thing in a democracy.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by gottorf on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:06AM (#37418337)
To be fair, the GP said governments should fear their citizens, not that they do and always have done. It's an ideal end state, I guess.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by eesmith on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:31AM (#37418662)
I think that veers too close to the No True Scotsman fallacy.

It's like saying that in a {a benevolent dictatorship, real communism, true anarchy} the citizens will not fear the government.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by marcosdumay on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:46AM (#37420712)
That a goal. Equating it to a logical fallacy is meaningless noise.

(Personally, I'm not sure how much it's an actionable or desirable goal. But it's a goal.)

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by eesmith on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:47PM (#37422777)
Hence "I think that's more an optimistic interpretation of democracy."

I don't think it's a goal of democracy, and I highlighted what I think are flaws with thinking of it that way. In your ideal democracy should non-citizens fear the government? Are children full citizens and, if not, should they fear the government too?

It's also a goal of communism and of anarchy, yes?

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by marcosdumay on Thursday September 07, 2023 @02:01PM (#37423000)
Yes, it's a goal of (Marxist) communism, and (AFAIK) the one largest goal of anarchy.

You can criticize it as a goal as much as you want. There's plenty of things to disagree in it. But you just can't go and state it's a no true Scotchman, that is meaningless nonsense.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by eesmith on Thursday September 07, 2023 @02:30PM (#37423469)
Are there democracies now? Yes.

Do they have the goal you describe? No.

Will they ever? Very unlikely, for reasons I listed.

Does that make them democracies? If you say they are not democracies then I'm calling No True Scotsman.

We have 2000 years of history where the most vocal proponents of democracy deliberately restricted full citizenship from all its population.

It's therefore hard for me to think your goal is a core part of democracy.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by bananapub on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:29AM (#37417944)
the UK has a weird culture of conformism and authoritarianism, and the weirdo party of the Tory party is deeply into that sort of thing, and is in power now. it's not very mysterious.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by cimi_ on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:43AM (#37420654)
It's not only the tories:

'Labour pledges to toughen ‘weakened and gutted’ online safety bill' https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jan/01/labour-pl...

It's very disheartening to see no opposition to this.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by bananapub on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:10PM (#37421122)
yes, the rightward authoritarian shift of the Labour party is also depressing, just less pressing since they're not the ones orchestrating these bills. I don't really know how Britain will become less like this.
Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by chimprich on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:38PM (#37422633)
Labour don't oppose it because it makes no sense for them to do so.

If they did oppose it, then the still-powerful right-wing press would be immediately printing LABOUR SUPPORT PAEDOPHILES on their front pages.

Most people wouldn't care, but because of FPTP, elections are determined by a small number of swing voters. Anyone slightly left of the Tories is almost certainly going to vote Labour anyway, because they don't really have any political choice.

It's just posturing for the media, I think. I suspect most people involved realise that what the bill is trying to do is unworkable.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by andyjohnson0 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:20AM (#37418522)
> The bigger picture of why UK is hell bent on surveilling their citizens, communities is that the number one problem is that governments are losing control over society.

I suspect theres a bunch of things going on.

They've come down so hard on recent protest movements like Just Stop Oil, Insulate Britain, etc because as you say they feel like they've lost authority and they want it back. National-scale surveillance is a way to remind everyone who really runs the country, and who just does as they're told. The uk has almost always been governed by essentially the same elite group, and they have a lot of experience of keeping it that way. Not by Spectre-style secret meetings, just by convergent overlapping objectives.

I think part of their fear comes from seeing how popular devolution has been in the UK. And partly how successful the EU has become, hence brexit. Theres also a part of the tory party that wants to nope out of the ECHR jurisdiction, and this kind of legislation potentially sets-up a fight with the court that could be used as a pretext for withdrawal. Some of them undoubtedly also simply see the potential to make some money from a surveylance society.

I also suspect they've finally woken up to the climate-related crisies that are now just down the road and they've decided that a more authoritarian society is the only way to keep their position at the top.

> Off course the whole point of democracy is that governments should fear their citizens, rather than vice versa.

Err... nope. Can't build stable societies on fear. The "whole point of democracy" is how to negociate the divergent desires and opinions of the nation's citizens.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by pipo234 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:22AM (#37420283)
> Can't build stable societies on fear.

Yes, you're right. I meant to paraphrase Thomas Jefferson: “When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. When the government fears the people, there is liberty.” And indeed democracy isn't liberty, it's just the least bad attempt to achieve a bunch of laudable goals.

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by bee_rider on Thursday September 07, 2023 @02:26PM (#37423419)
Ideally “the government” wouldn’t fear the people any more than, say, my computer fears me. It is a tool. It exists to implement my will.

Fear derives from things like our sense of self-preservation, and other concerns that our goals might not be achieved. Since the government ideally has no goal but to serve the people, it should have no fear (perhaps other than the fear of failure).

Re:UK drops 'spy clause' for scanning encrypted messages, ad... by kmlx on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:55AM (#37418969)
> The bigger picture of why UK is hell bent on surveilling their citizens

because it's been asked for by various ONGs, civil society at large, even the opposition parties want it strengthened.

it's not the government that is forcing these things. it's voters.