News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:07AM (#37377610)
I think all the focus on PIE derivatives is boring and we should get Europeans some better languages without pointless features like noun genders.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by AlexanderDhoore on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:13AM (#37377640)
Feature creep is a real problem with language design nowadays.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by misja111 on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:46AM (#37377791)
If you don't like noun genders, you should check out Finnish
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:01AM (#37377881)
Everyone in between Finland and Basque Country should try adopting one of those.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by littlestymaar on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:51AM (#37377821)
English is already a good progress in that direction, in many (most?) European languages we have gendered nouns for everything, no matter how nonsensical it is. (la baguette / le pain).
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by jagrsw on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:08AM (#37377921)
English is increasingly using the singular 'they' as a workaround, since alternative options like 've,' 'ze,' 'zhe,' and 'xer' didn't gain traction. This comes with its own set of issues—initially, it was a bit disorienting for me, and even now it often requires a mental pause to parse what the speaker is referring to.

I'd welcome a more authoritarian approach here: globally adopt a new pronoun, go through a transitional period, and then we're all on the same page. Some sci-fi novels have toyed with this concept.

IMO gendered pronouns don't add much value in many languages (with exceptions - poetry etc.). In Slavic languages, it's relatively straightforward to deduce gender from the pronoun, but in Germanic and Romance languages, it's more obfuscated.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by littlestymaar on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:00AM (#37378224)
I actually love “they” because it waves off every ambiguity at once: not only you don't have to care about the gender of the person, you don't even have to bother whether it is an individual or a collective (this super convenient when discussing about open-source projects).
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by tough on Monday September 04, 2023 @07:02AM (#37379278)
they built this and that and did it all by themselves doesn't sound to bad ymmv
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by mcv on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:05AM (#37378250)
English is definitely leading in terms of genderlessness, but that advantage is more than offset by its complete detachment between spelling and pronunciation.

It would be nice to have a language with sensible spelling/pronunciation but no gender.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by kitd on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:36AM (#37378435)
Welsh is about 95% phonetic in spelling. Maybe English with Welsh spelling?
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by kwhitefoot on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:07AM (#37378604)
> its complete detachment between spelling and pronunciation.

Whose dialect are you going to choose to render phonetically? Mine from the West Country, or that of my friends from Newcastle?

Will you standardise on short a in castle (Newcastle upon Tyne, North East England) or long a in castle (Restormel Castle, Cornwall)?

Or should each person just write phonetically so that we have millions of idiolects?

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by littlestymaar on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:54AM (#37378874)
Or you do it the French IIIème République way: you crush all linguistic diversity[0] from your country and standardize it all around the way it's spoken in London.

Also, in English there's so much detachment from spelling to pronunciation than even choosing to write it down like a random[1] dialect would be an improvement: the problem with English isn't so much about “long a” vs “short a”, it's about “through tough thorough thought, though”.

[0]: sure there's still some pronunciation differences between parts of France, but not much. And it has very little consequence on the spelling/pronunciation relationship.

[1]: in practice, it could be the most commonly spoken dialect, or the dialect that has the most pronunciation in common with others).

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by tough on Monday September 04, 2023 @07:01AM (#37379270)
in practice, it's usually the snob/spoken dialect of the capital city.

See parisians thinking they're better than anyone else, non-french and other-french included.

Im guessing london didn't implement this method because it's useful for them to keep differentiating themselves from the masses now that everyone can have education

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:16AM (#37378998)
And then since pronunciation shifts, you’ll periodically want to have international treaties adjusting spelling, hyphenation, capitalization and other rules, as the German-speakers have done.

Or freeze it once and for all as the French have chosen to do?

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by mcv on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:25AM (#37379056)
I think the pronunciation shifts might be the real issue with English. All languages shift, but I've got the feeling that English shifts a lot more, faster and more dramatically than most languages. And I'm not sure why.

Dutch seems to be quite the opposite: spelling changes a lot. The best way to read old Dutch texts is to sound them out in your head, because the words look totally different, but they sound the same. Hearing medieval Dutch is probably easier than medieval English, but medieval English is much easier to read.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:30AM (#37403319)
> All languages shift, but I've got the feeling that English shifts a lot more, faster and more dramatically than most languages. And I'm not sure why.

Probably because they go off to colonize very far away places and then develop separately.

Isn't Afrikaans pronunciation shifted Dutch?

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by mcv on Friday September 08, 2023 @07:05AM (#37432050)
I've got the feeling that Afrikaans is more like old fashioned Dutch. It sounds a bit archaic and sloppy to me ears.

I've got the feeling that most of the shifts in English don't come from the colonies, though, but more from mainland Britain. Various city accents rising in popularity and spreading their quirks around the country, like the recent i -> oi shift.

Also, I heard recently that American is actually closer to how English used to be in the 17th-18th century than UK English, which has had more development, including color -> colour and that sort of stuff.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by rlpb on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:25AM (#37378691)
> It would be nice to have a language with sensible spelling/pronunciation

I get the impression that this is impossible in the long term because pronunciation tends to drift, but spelling is more rigid, so over time they mismatch.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by mcv on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:29AM (#37379084)
Yet there are languages that are much more phonetic than English. In fact, most probably are. But I've been told that Polish is perfectly phonetic without any weird pronunciation surprises. (I don't know Polish, though.)

And spelling is only more rigid in English. Plenty of languages update their spelling over time. Only in English this is useless because there is already barely any connection between spelling and pronunciation, so the break would be far bigger than in other languages.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by rlpb on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:32AM (#37379881)
> But I've been told that Polish is perfectly phonetic without any weird pronunciation surprises.

I don't know about Polish, but I have had conversations where native speakers think that until exceptions are pointed out, because they are unaware.

There's also the issue of accents, where we expect spelling to be universal across the language, but pronunciation in some accents have drifted (ie. it's not a straightforward mapping).

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by OfSanguineFire on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:33AM (#37379883)
Polish orthography – however bizarre it may look to foreigners at first glance – does map pretty closely to the spoken language, but it still isn’t perfectly phonetic. For example, the reflexive pronoun się is written with a nasal vowel, but whether the vowel is pronounced as a nasal vowel or as a non-nasal vowel differs across regions.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by dontlaugh on Monday September 04, 2023 @09:02AM (#37380089)
There's quite a few languages with very good bidirectional mapping between written and spoken forms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonemic_orthography#Compariso...
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:13AM (#37378980)
The fact that English preserves the root bindings in so many cases often makes it easier to figure out what a new word means when you encounter it in text. Just writing the sound would abandon this valuable tool.

Anyway, writing the sound just helps the beginning reader. When you read flowing text you don’t actually read the words aloud in your head, letter by letter.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:08AM (#37378953)
> initially, [they as a singular pronoun] was a bit disorienting for me, and even now it often requires a mental pause to parse what the speaker is referring to.

If it makes you feel better, the use of “you” as both singular and plural pronouns did not become universal until the 60s (thanks to TV amd some school rules); thee and thou remained common in northern regions of England, particularly around Yorkshire, into the 1940s. Yet you use it today without thinking about it.

And I notice the singular “they” in Jane Austin; likely it well precedes her usage as well.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:37PM (#37384795)
> And I notice the singular “they” in Jane Austin; likely it well precedes her usage as well.

It's in Shakespeare.

(If you go back to Chaucer, "girl" is gender neutral for a child.)

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:51AM (#37388009)
That’s a residual germanic influence (Mädchen is still neuter today, while Junge is masculine)
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by totetsu on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:55AM (#37377853)
I heard this was down to Viking raiders moving into the anglish isles and not wanting to be bothered with all that complicated stuff
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by littlestymaar on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:57AM (#37378202)
Given that the Viking's language was itself fairly complex pronoun-wise[1] I suspect that this is an urban legend.

[1]: https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Old_Norse/Pronouns

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by vidarh on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:32AM (#37378739)
And indeed, modern Scandinavian languages have retained gendered nouns.

Though it's gradually being watered down. Eg. in Norwegian Bokmål (there are two official variants of Norwegian, Bokmål is the dominant one) you can now mostly choose whether to use feminine or masculine forms for a noun if a word takes either (but you can't do this for neuter), e.g. en sol (masculine; a sun) vs. ei sol (feminine; a sun) are both valid as long as you're consistent (combining "en sol" (m; a sun) with "sola" (f; the sun) in the same text, mixing genders, is frowned upon, though some of us do that intentionally - "solen" (m; the sun) sounds to stuffy/posh to me, but I prefer "en sol" to "ei sol").

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by Tagbert on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:13PM (#37383248)
The problem was that the pronouns and declensions didn’t match. Since this was a case of large numbers of adults learning a new language, they just learned enough to get by and didn’t bother with the complicated bits.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by OfSanguineFire on Monday September 04, 2023 @08:28AM (#37379837)
Meh, Finnish doesn’t have noun genders, but due to phonological changes obscuring what was, centuries ago, a regular declension, it now has a large number of different noun classes that have to be memorized as such. These are so laborious for foreigners to learn that a Finnish language workbook like Harjoitus tekee mestarin can spend 300 pages just on drills of noun classes.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:10AM (#37378959)
If you don’t like the use of two or three grammatical genders, Japanese would like to have a word with you (so to speak).

There are a lot different classifier systems in language around the world; gender is just a small example.

All these mechanisms are kinds of ECC.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by grozzle on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:42AM (#37379168)
presumably means "error correcting code", to save the next person from looking up jargon.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:36PM (#37384783)
I'm well aware, but kanji and pitch accents are a lot cooler than remembering whether a table is male, female or neuter.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by gumby on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:48AM (#37387992)
Japanese has tons of classifiers, not just the two or three that come with languages with gender.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @03:51AM (#37389027)
The counter words are a pain…
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by edgyquant on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:07PM (#37381799)
Gender nouns are not pointless features.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by astrange on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:15PM (#37383272)
Don't know what a gender noun is, but it sounds different from a noun gender.
Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by tomjakubowski on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:59PM (#37383733)
Eh, gendered nouns are kinda helpful in spoken language. It's an extra bit of redundancy which can help distinguish similar-sounding words in noisy environs. Same deal with verb conjugations and adjective declensions.

Granted they don't have much of a point in written word, at least not today when writing is easy to preserve digitally without accumulating errors over time. (No smudges making it hard to make out a word)

I really do wonder though how English seemingly uniquely in I-E languages ended up dropping those features, for the most part.

Re:We Know Languages Like Proto-Indo-European Existed [video] by retrac on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:38PM (#37385350)
> I really do wonder though how English seemingly uniquely

Not uniquely. Just within the Germanic languages, Afrikaans, an offshoot of Dutch, is without gender, in a way similar to English.

And there are others in the IE family that have lost gender. Persian is a notable example.

English lost its noun gender right after the Norman conquest. The language underwent rapid and extensive change, different populations merged, dialects flattened, and a lot of vocabulary was borrowed from the new French overlords. Many language structures, other than gender, were also lost at that time. Some have argued English almost underwent a sort of creole effect, where the native grammar of the parent languages is lost, and the next generation invent a new heavily regularized grammar to fill the void. That's going a bit far, I think, still there was a great deal of simplification. The lack of gender in Persian and Afrikaans has a somewhat similar history, in terms of social upheaval/displacement/dialect flattening, having an influence on the loss of gender.