Also, in English there's so much detachment from spelling to pronunciation than even choosing to write it down like a random[1] dialect would be an improvement: the problem with English isn't so much about “long a” vs “short a”, it's about “through tough thorough thought, though”.
[0]: sure there's still some pronunciation differences between parts of France, but not much. And it has very little consequence on the spelling/pronunciation relationship.
[1]: in practice, it could be the most commonly spoken dialect, or the dialect that has the most pronunciation in common with others).
See parisians thinking they're better than anyone else, non-french and other-french included.
Im guessing london didn't implement this method because it's useful for them to keep differentiating themselves from the masses now that everyone can have education
Or freeze it once and for all as the French have chosen to do?
Dutch seems to be quite the opposite: spelling changes a lot. The best way to read old Dutch texts is to sound them out in your head, because the words look totally different, but they sound the same. Hearing medieval Dutch is probably easier than medieval English, but medieval English is much easier to read.
Probably because they go off to colonize very far away places and then develop separately.
Isn't Afrikaans pronunciation shifted Dutch?
I've got the feeling that most of the shifts in English don't come from the colonies, though, but more from mainland Britain. Various city accents rising in popularity and spreading their quirks around the country, like the recent i -> oi shift.
Also, I heard recently that American is actually closer to how English used to be in the 17th-18th century than UK English, which has had more development, including color -> colour and that sort of stuff.
Whose dialect are you going to choose to render phonetically? Mine from the West Country, or that of my friends from Newcastle?
Will you standardise on short a in castle (Newcastle upon Tyne, North East England) or long a in castle (Restormel Castle, Cornwall)?
Or should each person just write phonetically so that we have millions of idiolects?