I'd imagine that would either change, or people would start buying up the lowest-cost EVs just to pull the battery out of them (like "shucking" external drives) and resell all the other parts.
That sounds amazing.
Business models and soft vendor lockouts cause price drift.
Start with 50 km range at beginning, end up with 500 km range by the end of the year.
Would also enforce positive replacement and recycling procedures by creating a standard modular power unit.
Arguably doable, but I doubt any manufacturer or EV will ever tolerate such easy mod-ability or repair-ability. They live to destroy any attempts by the consumer knowing how to service their own property.
This is an enormously exaggerated statement, bordering on entirely false. Yes, the company has done this from time to time, including on some current Model S/X models, but the vast, vast majority of Tesla cars sold (the 3/Y) almost always have a different sized battery pack in reality, not just in software (~50kwh or ~75kwh - there is genuinely ~1/3 less cells in the 50kwh cars almost always).
The Model S/X sell in very tiny volumes, relative to the 3/Y too. There absolutely is not the same pack in "all their cars". Even the type of cells used varies between model packs, typically 2170/4680 in the 3 or Y, 18650s in the S/X. I think there are even some BYD blade batteries in some European Y variants, but I'm not as familiar with the German or China made cars.
I have no experience with electric cars, much less disassembling/repairing them.
Any chance you have a source for this info?
people buying a kit aren't building a tesla, they're building a kit car. When you buy a kit, you're not expecting the same thing you get from a dealership. You're expecting something you can build yourself, which is fundamentally different
This is a privilege that in a decent society ought not be available at any price.
It's silly to say that they are under no obligation when what we are talking about with right to repair is literally whether we ought to create such an obligation.
If you disagree you must explain why such an obligation is a net negative for the millions not the few.
I await your argument to that effect.
Tesla didn't push EVs out of the goodness of their hearts. They did so because they thought they could build a profitable company. Tesla's execs and shareholders are being compensated quite well already for their investment of money/time/work. No need to give them a blank check to do anything we (as a society) don't want them to do.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxkPuEmIX4U&list=PL0vZL9uwyf...
Despite the untold expense and full on car workshop... it felt very accessible and possible. Ridiculous hubris on my part obviously hah! I doubt I could change a tire on humvee without help.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-jnhh1P86vQ&list=PL0vZL9uwyf...
If imagining a kit car then you won't be worrying about the custom designed elements you highlight.
A hobby project I've wanted to do is to convert older cars to electric. The more iconic, the better, for troll value :-)
I also think that most car manufacturers will hate this idea since it directly competes with and shows how incredibly un-repair-able current vehicles are. They don’t want to change. They just want to pretend to change.
The difference, of course, is that for obvious reasons, aviation has developed a pervasive culture of safety and rigorous root-cause analysis whenever an accident happens, and deadly crashes frequently result in regulatory corrective action. If car accidents were as rare as aircraft accidents, the NTSB brought a team of investigators whenever one happened, and the results of that investigation led to stricter laws and enforcement, we'd probably be OK with kit cars, too.
The sad truth about automotive is that crashes are so routine that police won't even get out of bed unless there are injuries. And, there is basically no penalty for negligence that leads to a car "accident". It's almost impossible in the USA to lose your driver's license, even after dozens of repeated DUIs. Totally different cultures.
An EV burns down. The chassis maker points its fingers at what they claim were low quality electronics used, the electronics manufacturer points its fingers at the sharp edges left on the chassis that could create chafe points.
Technical interoperability too aside from standards; in a collision it's difficult to model/simulate/test a car that may have 20 different motor options, placement options, dozens of batteries, etc. They'll all fail differently, how do we regulate that kind of safety? I'd love for it to work.
https://ftp.txdmv.gov/pub/txdot-info/vtr/title_manual_book_4...
>On page 376, under 'Eligibility for Title' it says "Homemade vehicles are not eligible for title or registration. Homemade vehicles are described as vehicles that were not previously manufactured by a NHTSA approved manufacturer..."
(I also know people building planes in their garage. I think Georgia just has a lot of this.)
https://dor.georgia.gov/assembled-and-unconventional-vehicle...
More often than not, you’d want your own charge controller anyway to for example run at a lower voltage (different series). At least for the Model S/X modules. The 3/Y modules are a little bit trickier to re-use because they are higher-voltage and not as modular.
Perhaps you could buy the preassembled chassis and modify the rest of the car as you'd like.
Maybe you could tear down the whole thing and rebuild it.
In theory this should be super accessible. You might see a whole community spring up over it. It's potentially a huge market ranging from teenagers to retirees. Lots of people love cars and modifying them.
There might be lots of companies that get in on the action and build a full ecosystem of compatible parts.
It'd be really neat.