News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by physicsguy on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:17AM (#37335437)
This was super obvious. We used Slack and Zoom in my old job and then as soon as Teams became part of Office365 we ditched the Slack subscription and didn't pay anything extra. I prefer Slack but I can totally see why a business would make that choice from a financial perspective.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by littlestymaar on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:20AM (#37335467)
And now that Microsoft has stolen a bunch of customer to Slack through their anti competitive practice, they are now making this move to avoid lawsuit, even though the harm is already done…
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by adhvaryu on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:44AM (#37335687)
Why do you think zoom got popular?
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by nicoburns on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:42AM (#37336280)
Zoom got popular by being technically superior (better call quality) during a pandemic when the entire world suddenly needed video conferencing.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by SmarsJerry on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:17AM (#37338536)
Call quality was not the factor. It was that zoom was easy for people to use, no download required, just click a link and enter your name and you’re connected. No logins or downloads so old people could actually work with it.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by johannes1234321 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:55PM (#37340228)
I never used the zoom web version, but for the client: it simply worked. Getting videocalls with WebEx always was a pain, where it was noisy, video hat issues ... switching to Zoom was day and night. Suddenly doing a video call was a click and it worked.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by Spooky23 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:26AM (#37336102)
Zoom is basically a respin of WebEx. Teams is a bunch of modules bolted on to SharePoint and Exchange. A “team” is an exchange artifact, the voice and video is a module and the rest is a SharePoint front end.

Zoom is a better value if you need features beyond the base teams. You pay a simple fee and get the whole shebang. With Teams, you may need different SKUs, including Azure AD, etc to get the full feature set. It’s a funnel to E5.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by janandonly on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:11AM (#37335948)
For one thing: more than 120000 congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses worldwide started paying for a Zoom account in early 2020. As far as I know, most of these congregations still pay for Zoom accounts until now.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by vxNsr on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:53AM (#37336400)
interestingly, they probably all qualify for NFP grants that could significantly reduce their costs
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by CrimsonRain on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:17AM (#37336008)
Slack is harming itself more by being stagnant. Even discord is way better than slack.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dewey on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:41AM (#37336267)
Not sure I want a tool I use all day to evolve very quickly and change much, I don't really feel like there's some big missing features that would change things dramatically. No business is going to use Discord in a corporate environment.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by draugadrotten on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:51AM (#37336381)
> No business is going to use Discord in a corporate environment.

The current crop of students are all using Discord to collaborate during lab work. Wait 2-3 years until they are team leaders at work and there will be Discords everywhere. I can promise you every Fortune 500 already is using Discord in production, just as they are using generative AI.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by formerly_proven on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:07AM (#37336567)
Well if Discord offers an Enterprise version that's tied into the tenant's SSO at least it becomes possible to create an account. Or maybe they'll instantly lock those, too?
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by moojd on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:55AM (#37337206)
Enterprise discord is one of those obviously inevitable things that I can't believe doesn't exist yet
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by yellow_lead on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:24AM (#37336078)
Discord threads seem worse though, or maybe I'm using them wrongly.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by bombolo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:44AM (#37336303)
I thought slack harmed itself ditching IRC bridge.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by jkaplowitz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:49AM (#37336345)
Slack cares less about their stagnation now that they are part of Salesforce than they did when they were independent.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by drewg123 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:54AM (#37336417)
They are worse than stagnant. They just took away what I (and a lot of my coworkers) feel was an important feature -- the ability to leave a thread open as you change to a different channel or DM.

From my perspective stagnant would be better than taking away useful features.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by ballenf on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:07AM (#37336579)
Teams chat has long had an obvious and fundamental feature -- ability to open a thread or conversation in a new window. And have as many of those open as you need.

Slack, by design, makes it painful to engage in more than one conversation at a time. It's so annoying to maintain a "save for later" list of things you need to come back to, or mark things as unread.

You can do this with slack by using the web client, but that has its own annoyances with not being a native application.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by pmontra on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:38AM (#37336968)
If the Slack desktop app had a way to open a workspace in a new window I'd put the Slack window of each of my customers in the virtual desktop of that customer instead of having to move Slack to the workspace of the moment.

Except for that, they could stagnate. For example, what the huddles were for? Did I miss any new functionality that they added to the old calls?

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by no_wizard on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:50PM (#37340134)
Key difference with huddles is you can join in on one without an invite. Previous calls required you to call in the participants.

Its an attempt at making something an open office / standing room type situation so people can wander in and out of huddles to check in with folks.

In practice, I don't see it used much. Everyone wants to setup a Zoom call.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by pmontra on Friday September 01, 2023 @09:12AM (#37350379)
The customer of mine that pays for Slack uses huddles. I never thought about entering one that I was not explicitly invited to. I hope it's possible to make them private.

All the customers that are not paying for Slack are using Meet. One attempted to use Teams once but it's too complicated. Zoom for work calls? It surely happened but I can't remember when. Skype, I had a customer using it and actually screen sharing in Skype is good: it wastes as much of the screen in useless borders and toolbars as all its competitors but at least it's possible to zoom and get a pixel perfect view of what is shared.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by drewg123 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:26PM (#37339763)
I'd never know. Slack does not natively support my platform (FreeBSD), so I use the web client.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by littlestymaar on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:11AM (#37336641)
I hate Slack with passion[1], but it's not a good excuse for Microsoft doing shady stuff with their monopoly position with Office.

[1] mostly because it's slow, their UX is clunky as hell, and it still doesn't support audio/video calls on Firefox despite WebRTC being supported there since 2015.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by kwanbix on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:32AM (#37336901)
Slack is crazy expensive. 15 euros per user! Make it 5 and I might consider it.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dathinab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:10AM (#37337390)
discord is actually really good in a lot of stuff

just not at looking appealing to companies

I mean they have:

- good chat

- new okayish forum feature

- pretty good video calls (better then Teams AFIK)

- many of the same misc features

- good probably better moderation features then slack

- a nice balance between convenience and security wrt. their login

- ways to ad good code highlighting for a lot of programming languages

- somewhat okayish (AFIK better then modern slack) accessibility features

it's just that all of this features are tweaked with small to mid sized hobby communities in mind instead of companies

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by fknorangesite on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:10PM (#37339493)
> Slack is harming itself more by being stagnant.

For better or for worse, Slack has a huge UI overhaul right around the corner: https://slack.com/blog/productivity/a-redesigned-slack-built...

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by TheFragenTaken on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:09AM (#37335917)
This probably won't change much. Slack is priced more than three times higher than what you save by not choosing Teams as part of your MS365 bundle.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by safety1st on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:43AM (#37336291)
Given their history of legal troubles I was pretty surprised at how brazen Microsoft was with bundling Teams into Office for free, a move that looks a whole lot like dumping. Remember, these are the guys who destroyed the market for paid web browsers (and almost killed the open web along with it) when they bundled IE into Windows back in the day.

Notably Brad Smith was their chief counsel back then and he still is now - he's gotten a promotion to President in fact.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dave7 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:57AM (#37336443)
From a certain angle it looks like they're currently trying to destroy the market for paid video games in a similar manner with extreme bundling/giving away.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by delfinom on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:10AM (#37337397)
Hah, everyone was towards that direction even before Microsoft did Game Pass. Wall St wants fiefdoms, every company is forced to turn everything into a subscription model.

Sony didn't help as they are notoriously buying exclusivity with every single game they could (which has worked in their favor)

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by matthewfelgate on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:07AM (#37336581)
Microsoft have gotten away with it in the past.

Bundling is basically their modus operandi.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by formerly_proven on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:05AM (#37336544)
> Notably Brad Smith was their chief counsel back then and he still is now - he's gotten a promotion to President in fact.

All of that stuff back then had basically no consequences, which is probably why MS continues to increase their anti-competitive behavior. They will continue to do so until there are consequences, obviously.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by petesergeant on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:11AM (#37336639)
Looks like they got away with it too? Teams is now something people use. The fine (if there ends up being one) probably won't come close to costing MS what dumping Teams on customers brought them in value.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by fidotron on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:45AM (#37337068)
In the case of Internet Explorer it did at least start as a technically decent product, which I have never seen anyone claim about Teams. The later atrophy is a prime example of the long term problems with this behaviour though.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dathinab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:54AM (#37337199)
Idk. Teams video calls have always issues, but the also tend to always work after some fiddling something I can't say in my experience about either Zoom and Slack which both sometimes plain out refused to work no matter what was tried.

Not saying that market power abuse is in any form right.

Actually I would argue it's wrong no matter how technically decent the product is.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dathinab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:52AM (#37337175)
> Given their history of legal troubles I was pretty surprised at how brazen Microsoft

I mean they won right?

The competitive advantage the bundling has given them is enormous.

And while un-bundling it now will stop "additional benefits" it won't in any form remove the benefits they already got.

E.g. companies which are on a bundled plan and use both are now used to it and their cross integrations (which won't go away) so as long as it's price wise competitive with other solutions they likely will keep it and now pay for both.

As long as anit-monpoly low doesn't 1) penalizes based on the long term benefits gained 2) shifts more to anti-massiv-power-abuse laws in their phrasing/formulation/public discourse we will just see stuff like that happening again and again. We sadly life in a world where huge companies braking the law is the norm as long as it's expected to yield them noticeable more money then the fall out through penalties and publicity. And that isn't just limited to vague laws like monopoly power abuse, e.g. Ubers operation is quite not so fully legal in a lot of countries.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by outside1234 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:45AM (#37339033)
Apple, Google, Facebook - they are all bundling products - why should Microsoft be different?

Asked another way, why is Apple allowed to bundle Music with the iPhone, but Microsoft is not allowed to bundle Teams with Office?

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by throw_nbvc1234 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:02PM (#37339346)
It's because of the outcome not the action itself. Apple bundling music with iPhone doesn't risk putting multiple public companies out of business. If Apple partnered with google (and maybe Microsoft/Windows) to bundle apple music into Android you'd probably have a stronger case.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by kwanbix on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:31AM (#37336878)
We use Google's Workspace (which includes meet and chat and is not forced to unbundle them), and I am totally fine with Meet and Chat.

I might like to use Slack and Zoom, however, the prices they charge are completely off.

Microsoft 365 Business Premium costs 20 euros per month per user.

Google Workspace Business also costs 20 euros per month per user.

There is no way to justify paying 14 for slack and 15 for zoom.

They are not that much better than Meet/Chat/Teams to justify the cost.

If Zoom/Slack was 5 each, I might consider it. At 15, no way.

This move is only protecting Slack and Zoom from having to compete in value.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dathinab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:04AM (#37337309)
But what if companies simple can not compete in value without massively subsidizing their business in ways which are a form of market power abuse? (idk. if that is true)

What if slack cost 14 due to all the features beyond chatting, like especially video calls.

Maybe this change now gives them a motivation to provide a "text only" version of Slack for 5 or 7, because if I would guess 50%+ of their operation and development cost come from this additional features?

> is not forced to unbundle them

because monopoly law sadly sadly only applies if you are somewhat winning, but not if you are somewhat irrelevant to a point people forget to even evaluate you when making a choice (in the EU Microsoft 365 is clearly winning huge and e.g. Zoom and Google Workplace are _much_ less relevant/successful compared to the US AFIK).

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by kwanbix on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:14AM (#37337465)
Well, Zoho, which is a very small player, has a suite with everything, and they are doing just fine. An i am sure they are not subsidizing anything here: https://www.zoho.com/workplace/?ireft=zoffice

According to statista, google suite has 50% vs 45.5% of microsoft 365.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/983299/worldwide-market-...

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by MSFT_Edging on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:37AM (#37336964)
The loss of slack totally grenaded the culture at my company. There used to be a lot of cross site conversations, folks knew each other.

Teams is so dense, it's almost designed to avoid those general chat situations.

Not to mention if you have any amount of Linux users, they're basically second class citizens.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by dathinab on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:44AM (#37337057)
my company is currently considering the same

sadly this won't stop the considerations, as we do use Teams for video calls and idk. why but using slack for the video calls seems to not really be considered

through tbh. I find both somewhat subpar/dissatisfying.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by giancarlostoro on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:46AM (#37337083)
I like Teams, but I hate that the actual chatrooms are all DMs and Group Chats. I don't understand why you cant have a main chat in a Teams Team. This leads to dozens upon dozens of group chats that go stale, and for some reason someone on the team picks a really old one, and says they've got a dentist appointment or something obscure.

Microsoft, at least add a limit to how many normal chatrooms a Teams team can have. This forum for channels approach is annoying, those are useful for like automated messages.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by miked85 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:10AM (#37338400)
> I like Teams

I believe this may be the first time I've heard anyone say that.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by sebzim4500 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:34AM (#37338835)
I haven't used it myself, but I've heard lots of non-tech people say they like it. I think they are probably comparing it to skype/email rather than to slack.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by jimnotgym on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:46AM (#37339043)
I like it because of the deep integration with Office
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by olig15 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:13PM (#37340527)
I actually dislike Teams because of the Office integration. Teams where I work ends up with 10’s of ‘teams’ with 100’s of channels. Each channel having its own set of documents that have been uploaded and added as tabs to a channel. It’s impossible to find anything, but even when you do, you end up with a half broken version of web word or excel that fills the page so you can’t chat anymore.

I’d rather teams did 2 (albeit complex) things; Direct & Channel chats (with one or more people), and video calls with one or many people. If I want to use Office, I’ll use the right app.

It feels like Teams is trying to do too many things, and it’s bad at all of them.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by jimnotgym on Thursday August 31, 2023 @04:48PM (#37343481)
That sounds like a problem of bad management rather than Teams' fault! It doesn't make you start lots of Teams or channels!

I sync my files from Teams using OneDrive, and then they open in the desktop apps...and work like a regular folder in Windows

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by esperent on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:43AM (#37338994)
I also like Teams, clunkiness aside it's a great business asset for the price. Unmatched at even double or triple the price by anything else out there I think.

However, I've only been using it for six months. So maybe it used to be worse and that's where all the hate comes from?

Also, most of the clunkiness seems to hit me the worst as the admin and sole tech person at our company. The rest of that users seem to be doing just fine.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by miked85 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:15PM (#37345620)
For me at least, it seems fairly unintuitive and primitive vs Slack or even various open source options (Mattermost, Zulip). It feels like a product where Microsoft just did the bare minimum to claim they have a competitor in this area.
Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by giancarlostoro on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:43PM (#37340975)
It is nicely integrated wit (not in all but good enough amount of) Microsoft's ecosystem. If you're a Microsoft shop (we've got plenty of .NET, Azure, Azure DevOps, M365, etc) then its also a no-brainer. It could use with some polish, but my biggest peeve is where chats are housed. How can I have a "Team" space and no dedicated chat for it? Makes zero sense to me. At least give me ONE "General Chat" at a minimum.

It smoothly integrates back with Outlook, the experience is slightly different, but we have all our meetings over Teams, and the call quality is always great. If you ever have network issues, it suggests calling into the meeting on a land line, which is a small but really nice thing, even sometimes when watching a screenshare it offers listening from a land line whilst watching from your computer in order to cut down on data.

Teams has an insane amount of potential for complete greatness, but given how Windows itself does as well and it gets overshadowed by marketing decisions that anger power users, I'm not holding my breath on Teams achieving what it could. The infrastructures all there, and it is insanely extensible.

Re:Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to ad... by SmarsJerry on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:22AM (#37338639)
Of all the things that actually need a subscription, video chat and cloud storage of data seems like the one because it uses bandwidth on Microsoft’s end. Charging a subscription for all of the other Office apps has always been a cash grab.