Moreover, the main ingredient in making plastics is derived from fossil fuels (specifically crude oil and natural gas).
Heck I wouldn't trust paper food packaging because I'm not sure they would use a wax liner instead of some fancy PFAS forever chemical.
I think the most common sources are:
* Plastic netting * Plastics from countries without any/lacking waste infrastructure
There are differences in statistics between EU countries, they might tell something interesting.
I'm not- show me the direct harm it is causing on an individual level. We can all agree they are a nuisance but it is hard to show how they are outright harming people. Studies like this are a step towards that proof.
The harm should be obvious to the layman IMHO in order to be legislated away. Otherwise, it should be left up to personal choice.
I'm not sure if this is sarcasm but if it's not, this is really the peak of anti-intellectualism ideology, i.e., that if a thing is not immediately obvious without studying then we should remain ignorant of it. I don't think that kind of opinion is a good fit for this forum to be honest, which has learning and information sharing as an important goal, so I will have to flag your message, which is an extremely rare thing for me to do (actually this may be my first time ever)
I'm not sure if you're willfully ignorant or just saw an opportunity to pass a pejorative and took it.
I didn't say we should "ignore it". I said we shouldn't allow scientists to exclusively decide what should or should not be legal.
Individual scientists are wrong a lot. Science as a process continues to be the (imperfect) reigning world champ of truth discovery, no matter what contrarianism du jour memes are spreading over the internet.
Tell the horrifying plastic story (if there is one)
These were uncovered over the course of years by statistical analysis, prompted by suspicions created by (noisy, often non-human) information about the mechanisms.
Similarly, we have tons of data supporting a bunch of theories of micro plastic harm in the lab. The waiting revelation isn’t going to be “omg all these people are sick and we didn’t know it,” it’s going to be “all these people have been sick and we didn’t know why.”
Which is exactly the form of the sperm quality/fertility theory as well as obesity. We know these compounds cause fertility and metabolism issues in cell cultures and in animal models. We know we are facing civilization-scale problems with obesity and fertility. Drawing the connection between these types of observations is always extremely noisy because there are obviously trillions of variables affecting “does a specific individual become infertile or obese,” or “does a person have an elevated risk of birth defects.”
I’m not necessarily on the side of an immediate and total ban, but this “we’ll see the problems if they exist” attitude is profoundly ignorant and arrogant. The historical examples appear obvious to you because you saw the results of extremely deep study prompted from initially low-quality suspicions.
> The mice in the study began to move peculiarly, and to exhibit behaviours reminiscent of dementia in humans
I know this is only _in mice_ but the policy we have of "let industry do what they want and if we find out it's harming humans in 30 years we'll do something about it" has not proven to work out so well in the past (lead, DDT, CFCs, cigarettes).
That's the thing. Plastic is modern lead. It's easily moldable, but causes subtle health problems.
These comments read like Reddit/TikTok. Lots of frantic fearful hand waving, not a lot of evidence presented.
There are thousands of plastics, and a blanket statement like this is simply false. We should be working to figure out which plastics are toxic, and why. You're essentially looking at lead and coming to the conclusion that "Metal is toxic, we all know this."
If it was comparable to lead in terms of identifying toxicity, we wouldn’t be having this debate.
So actually plastic is worse than lead in that it’s more insidious, some want to slowly kill things but it’s nearly impossible to tell which. If only it were like lead and upfront about it.
So no, they are not saying “metal is toxic”. That is extending the analogy to another topic: identification
The parent hand-waved away the substantial differences between various plastics and made bold blanket statements on plastics as a whole that may or may not be true.
There's plenty of material out there to cite with and providing a cite that supported your understanding would help the discussion. Here's a random one:
According to the European Parliament, ~63% of microplastics come from laundering synthetic clothes and car tires [1].
1. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/society/201...
https://news.unl.edu/newsrooms/today/article/nebraska-study-...
And they're everywhere. I bought a sweater a couple of years ago. It's made from recycled PET bottles. It felt like a nice thing a couple of years ago. Now I realize that every time I wash it I'm releasing micro plastics into the sewer that might not get filtered out.
The charger I bought this weekend was in a cardboard box. Inside that cardboard box was a plastic shimmy bracket, keeping things in place. The charger had a plastic film adhered to it, but not the whole thing, just like the on the sides kind of. The cable was tied together with a velcro band (plastic from the futor!). On the plugs of the cable were little plastic protector caps. The box itself was wrapped in plastic of course. There was a booklet, not plastic.
The material world we've surrounded ourselves with really is made of plastic, disposable trash.
This proliferation of plastic is not rational, certainly not wholesome. It is purely the downstream effect of plastic being cheap to produce, it is primarily a technological phenomenon.
For other applications plastics are an outright miracle material though. Imagine if all drinks came in glass bottles; all cases and other structural parts were made of metal or wood; all elastic members were made of rubber or treated wood. The added need for shipping alone would probably outweigh the CO2 impact from current plastics production. As it is you get plastics almost for free while refining oil. Not to mention the insane demand there would be for metals, wood and rubber.
> Imagine if all drinks came in glass bottles
I can totally imagine. Glass bottles with deposit. Return them when empty, reclaim deposit. Most plastic bottles are also, I don't know, for crap products (?). Sodas, energy drinks. We could just drink more water.
> plastics are an outright miracle material though
Absolutely. There's certainly "good" applications of plastic. I don't dispute that.
On the other hand, this system incentivised using plastic bottles instead of glass, because of less hassle with returning.
> Everything I've read about plastic recycling points to it being ineffective...
There is one effective way to recycle plastic into energy called "waste incineration".
Also, glass is heavier, and requires a lot of energy to be made, so it would require a production chain that ships back empty containers.
The best silver bullet solution would be to have local canteen, a bit like in the army or at school, where you just get a subscription with a calendar (not on demand, you plan the meals you'll get), so it reduces waste and costs.
We should just stop eating at home, with individual fridges, ovens, kitchens etc, this is highly inefficient.
Yes, this is collectivization, but it's the best solution for an economy of scale. Individualism was never a good solution, individualism is often very wasteful.
Call me a communist or a socialist, I don't really care.
We shouldn’t be borrowing from a dead communist dictator’s playbook. Clearly it didn’t work out for him and the vast majority of people didn’t want that.
I didn't think I needed to elaborate that any idea coming from communist dictators (let alone the self-styled Genius of The Carpathians) should not be the basis of our policies.
Weird that you're getting downvoted for this. HN is on a weird one recently
Blame people like Reagan and Milton Friedman for this. It's a highly political problem.
Inequality is already somewhat caused by individualism, but climate change is also caused by climate change. For example, if China wants to reduce its co2 emissions, you only have to convince Chinese leaders, and it's done just by snapping fingers.
In the US, you have to make it profitable, which is doable, but it's more complicated and lobbyists will also be a big barrier to change.
I loathe the chinese leadership, but being a democratic modern industrialized nation doesn't mean you will see decisions that make sense.
You also have to keep in mind the American entrepreneurial culture or DNA which has born fruit unlike any other system, and is even responsible for the very platform we're using right now. That's all about this idea that any individual can change the world.
A big lunch and a small dinner would probably be a good change for lots of us.
And if you think something is a good change, make it for yourself and don’t impose it on someone else. Vast majority of people given the choice will pick independence and purchasing/making their own food whenever they want, not being dependent on their work or state cafeteria.
Parent is getting downvoted because the vast majority of people won’t agree with that nonsense. Leave it in the 1900s.
Germans have a meal called Abendbrot which means "evening bread".
When COVID hit, Germans struggled to cook food at home, even leading to house fires https://www.dw.com/en/coronavirus-pandemic-reveals-germans-p...
My wife's startup does not have a canteen, so the Germans order in fast food. She is British like me so she has a small lunch and a big dinner.
> How expensive is food in Germany that people have no independence to buy and prepare food?
It is cheap but the work canteen is also often cheap. People have independence to buy and prepare food, they just don't want to.
> vast majority of people won’t agree with that nonsense. Leave it in the 1900s.
I don't think this is worthy of a response.
I.e. we can still follow your idea but at a village or family level. So why buy butter in a plastic tub when your neighbour next door has a cow and butter churning machine? Heck have a big enough multi-generational household compound and you can keep it all in-family!
The vast majority of people don’t want to choose your wet dream when they have the choice between their own private house versus a local canteen on a schedule. Nobody likes other people so much that they’d choose to be stuck in a school cafeteria environment for their food or their children’s food forever. Life is not perpetual kindergarten where everyone’s together all the time. Life is competition and mutually-beneficial cooperation in some things, and friends are made on the basis of mutual desire. Not forced socialization and collectives. What you are proposing results in mass starvation when the systems of incentives and motivations collapse.
More local farms and more vertical farms and more greenhouses and more victory gardens are the best path. I leave it to families and individuals to choose what options they want and to buy food whenever they want. With more production, all the options will get cheaper as we flood the world with more fresh produce from better and more localized supply chains owing to incoming innovations in vertical and greenhouse farming. Not interested in going back to top-down control structures from the 1900s.
What’s next? Restricting the caloric intake of political pariahs? Restricting the options available at the local canteen to give the best options to the friends of the party and everyone in charge? Lol
This is a really sad, myopic view of life. Thankfully, it is wrong
It is ironic that you are peddling such fearful narratives given your name
https://24.kg/english/272281__Production_and_sale_of_plastic...
https://24.kg/english/272323__Kyrgyzstan_to_fine_for_sale_an...
https://fortune.com/well/2023/08/24/paper-straws-harmful-for...
CFC's coming out of your hairspray is WAY different than removing the plastic keeping your food fresh.
Stop with the black and white thinking. There is NO alternative that is free of some negative consequence. You're already seeing this with EV's. Every single "green" replacement introduces new problems that are often worse than what they've replaced.
I think it's because those two things can be used to scold consumers and thus inculcate the belief that the final link in the production-consumption chain bears all the blame.
I mean I have seen signs encouraging people to use reusable bags at the checkout line. But is it a problem that literally everything in the store (except mushrooms I guess) is wrapped in plastic? Apparently it is not.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/08/28/paper-...
Everything I've read about plastic recycling points to it being ineffective and requiring massive amounts of fossil fuel to move the waste around the globe, often with much of it just getting burned or dumped into the environment anyway. Despite that, the aisles of grocery stores are still packed full of single-use plastic bottles, containers, wrappers, etc.
Are any countries making a legitimate effort to drastically reduce the use of plastics? It seems like we had a pretty good system years ago in requiring people to leave a deposit for bottles when purchasing beer or pop to incentivize return + reuse.