Maybe a good start is to believe people who tell us they're suffering, even if what they're suffering from isn't obvious and physical.
Hard to explain to people that she's not just lazy. Thankfully a relatively easy procedure helped and now she's on the road to a slow recovery.
Edit: Maybe it is just empathy. It is hard to see my tax money going towards turning brown kids into skeletons, and not making people who's life already sucks suck a lot less.
It was a heering experience to get this diagnosed. One day all of a sudden my head started hurting and didn't stop, for months. But I had no other symptoms so doctors didn't take me seriously and my neurologist appointment was several months AFTER the onset of the symptoms (yes, months!).
That was until I accidentally went to an ER ophthalmologist who saw my optic eye nerves and went holy smokes. I went through so much pain. All of this at a very young age. I developed severe anxiety and depression.
I haven't done well academically speaking compared to my peers. I feel shitty about this everyday, since all of my friends are better off than me.
I'm on HN but not in IT (I am inept at programming, tried several times, I am just not capable of it), but various friends of mine are in IT and make 5x my salary and it makes me feel worthless, because they enjoy life at a different level than I do because of their income. Nicer homes, cars, stability in finances, etc... It makes me feel like I'm just not worthy of life because hey, if they can make it, why can't I? I am supposidly as capable as they are... right?
Thank you for making me aware I have an illness that can make me a bit less capable compared to my peers.
I'm going to use this to be less harsh on myself and hopefuly find something in which I find myself better off one day within my own limitations.
Thank you.
Take care of yourself and always be your own advocate at the Doctor's!
Honestly though, nobody should have to earn a decent living, regardless of level of ability. They're alive, and not by choice, so they should be able to enjoy it. Meritocracy is just cruelty when extended to the conditions of one's life - we want those with the fewest intrinsic resources be made to suffer? I don't.
But but but but I thought that could only happen in SOCIALISM countries! We pay arms and legs because we get MORE TIMELY care, right?
https://web.archive.org/web/20230212152245/https://www.gigab...
and
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfkem5e5Iqg
(https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=EchoReflection)
In 2013 I was in a very serious motorcycle accident (coma for 1 month, 2 broken legs, broken hip, broken left arm, several broken ribs, collapsed lung, multiple skull fractures, inner ear bones damaged on both sides. My brain damage was such that my short-term memory was basically zero for a long time, as well as damaged nerves that control vision. The road to recovery was/is long, I still have what are referred to in the medical world as "sequelae", which just means "ongoing effects or symptoms", but, long-story-short, I really, really, really believe that we can all improve our lives and our brains if we A: want to, and B: try. I highly, highly recommend the book "Atomic Habits" by James Clear: https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/atomic-habits-an-easy--proven-...
Audible: https://www.audible.com/pd/Atomic-Habits-Audiobook/152477926...
And Jordan Peterson's books "Maps of Meaning" and "12 Rules for Life" were pretty life-changing.
Jordan Peterson has a LOT of really helpful content on YouTube (a lot of people don't like him bc I guess he's kind of "conservative", but I think it's more the case that he thinks postmodernism and "wokism" are detrimental to a healthy society.
https://www.youtube.com/@JordanBPeterson
Andrew Huberman has a lot of great, helpful videos as well. https://www.youtube.com/@hubermanlab
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequela
Good luck on your journey.
A thing a lot of people don't seem to be aware about modern medicine. We can treat many things, we know a whole lot more than we used to, but a lot of this knowledge is often incomplete. Many of the body's systems are very badly understood. Treatment for most of those issues is symptom management more than anything else.
what really makes me see red is the fact that how we do healthcare is worse, more expensive, and less helpful than were it given to all, and STILL, people vote against universal health care. The only benefit to our system as yet is its ability to enrich a few rent seeking billionaires in the middle of us and our doctors. But because crab in a bucket Billy Joe in rural kansas "don't wanna pay for sum un elses helfcare". Evil, stupid, individualistic self harming fucking animals we are in the US. Barbarians to let our citizens in the richest country in the world go bankrupt because they got sick. Evil.
Any system can be hacked, including empathy. We call it "fraud" and unfortunately it seems that the number of humans who can keep two concepts in their head at the same time are vanishingly rare. So you end up with a useless "empathy vs fraud" debate repeated endlessly, roughly corresponding to the left and the right, and it doesn't go anywhere. Of course, what we need is a synthesis. The left needs to be more attuned to fraud that targets empathy, and the right needs to stop using the risk of fraud as an excuse to do nothing.
Being poor or disabled is effectively a character flaw.
One side : use our immense wealth as the richest nation on earth to provide basic services to all citizens by maybe taxing billionaires so they only have 1/10 b instead of 100.
Other side: if you're poor, it's your fault. Get fucked.
Laughable you can consider those two positions in any way comparable or equitable. Absolutely silly the enlightened centrism I'm seeing here. Gross and dishonest to even pretend like there's more than one viable non ecology destroying, democracy preserving political position in the us.
Stop obsessing over what marxists think of profit, consider what they want to do with the wealth they redistribute. Make all our lives better for literally zero quality in life change for the rich who we'd tax. Tell me who's going to have any discernible decrease in quality of life if wealth was capped at 1b or 10 vs infinite and I'll call you a silly little child.
I miss the cultural norm that privileged debate over zealous advocacy, leaving the latter to lawyers and politicians.
The issues the parent poster brings up are policy choices. I think it is good to believe people when they say they are suffering, but a better start is to vote for folks who are willing to treat people like people.
I deal with chronic migraine and it's extremely difficult to get on SSDI for that disorder (unless it is secondary to something more visible, like a TBI). Other invisible chronic pain conditions (e.g. fibromyalgia) are similarly dismissed.
My experience suggests that the transactional nature of modern medicine is part of what makes these types of investigations so hard. A doctor will be booked solid all day without time to reflect or investigate and that really only works with one-off problems.
A chronic condition is not transactional, it's narrative. Someone needs to manage that narrative and mine it for insights. The only way the American medicine system was eventually able to help me was after I started managing my own narrative, but that has challenges for most people -- especially when experiencing reduced functionality due to disability.
But that doesn't nearly account for everything. It is also true that the system is set up very transactionally, and that this makes it difficult to address many chronic issues as well as they could be.
If you are lucky, you have an involved general practitioner who has a long history with you, good notes, and time to get into difficult analysis. For many people currently this is a pipe dream. Hell, many people are reliant on ER for basic care - a system that is fundamentally incompatible with this sort of baseline and evaluation.
When I say transactional, I mean that each interaction has a cause (“what brings you in today?”) and an action (“try this medication”, “see this specialist”); each visit is like a full story arc from start to finish.
Compare that to psychotherapy where each visit is more like a continuation of the previous session — a narrative. IMO, people who suffer from chronic conditions would benefit from a model that draws on the narrative aspect of therapy.
I'd argue that has more to do with the sheer number of variables and our limited understanding of how they interact.
Patient resilience is also a factor. Few have the resources to eliminate all possibilities at their own expense while accepting the risk of having nothing to show for it. The opposite end of the spectrum are people who show up expecting to walk out with Vicodin and SSDI after the initial consultation.
Using chronic migraines as an example, that shit is a response to something-- and it may not even be medical in origin. Worst case: if you're a diabetic homebody living with six cats' dirty litter boxes, have mold in your basement and bats shitting in your attic, drink no water, smoke meth and eat only takeout Chinese food, any single one (or combination) of these could cause chronic migraines, and are far from being the only causes. Stipends and Oxy won't fix any of this.
Doctors are not investigators. They are scientists. Trained investigators are presumed unqualified to "manage that narrative and mine it for insights" because they are not Doctors (credentialism/"you're not a doctor" is literally the response any disability attorney would suggest you raise against skeptics, failing to notice the irony in a non-doctor attorney/client team touting the validity of a self-authored medical narrative).
Sort of. I think the _chronic_ aspect of chronic migraine often ends up being a response to something, but migraine itself is considered a primary condition.
In my case, I respond to many stimuli that are out of my control or hard to control all the time — weather, seasonal allergies and stress to name a few. I also have stimuli that I can control, and by controlling those I reduce the impact to those things I can’t control.
FWIW, I’m not shitting on doctors, here. I actually think that there is some evolution of our medical system that takes the narrative into account, perhaps by process or an intermediary that helps a patient manage their “case”.
I suspect the problem is more systematic than a general lack of interest or willingness.
https://www.webmd.com/migraines-headaches/cgrp-inhibitors-fo...
Like many folks with chronic migraine, though, my approach has multiple facets.
Emgality is part of my management strategy and it significantly improved my total number of headache days per month. It got me to the point where I could start realistically making some lifestyle changes that helped as well.
Botox has also been great. It seems to do less for total number of headache days but it does a lot of duration and intensity. Many days I’m functioning even though I’m dealing with some pain in the background.
It’s not perfect but it’s still a much better place than I was before. :-)
I have a child with autism. The American system is cruel beyond imagination.
To qualify them for social security and Medicaid I have to leave them impoverished. They can't have more than $2k worth of assets in their name. Instead it's a complex lawyer game of trusts to give my child any sort of inheritance. Yet they are basically guaranteed to end up in a group home (Even though I own my own home) because a caretaker after I go is unlikely. Further, what the trust can pay for is things not covered by Medicare and SS. So housing and food are limited to what the government would pay for.
And then there's the concern of how this all plays out if I get dementia or disability which requires substantial finances.
There's a reason people with autism tend to end up homeless.
The issue with able accounts is they are under the sole control of the account holder with few checks in place. Further, crossing that 100k line really sucks. If they let the funds ride and they appreciate past that level, they can lose their qualifications for Medicare/SS.
For now, there's no rush, but it's something I've considered.
Able works if my kid can make ok financial decisions. It's a bad idea if they can't.
There are 2 choices:
- Either you set it all up ahead of time and they have someone you trust to watch over them after you are gone.
- They get shunted into the system and whatever happens, happens.
An able account, if mismanaged, can disqualify my kid from Medicare. That means costly and time consuming legal intervention to correct while my kid misses out on medical care they need.
The third option is waiting on the able account (not the SNT). There's little harm in waiting.
Obviously, if you go over the limit, they would be disqualified while the balance is over.
Again, I think you are way over-thinking this:
- If the kid is responsible enough to handle it, then there is no problem.
- If the kid isn't responsible enough, then someone will be the responsible party.
- If you don't know if the kid is responsible enough yet, then you assume they aren't for the time being.
No problem arises regardless of the state of their financial responsibility. It's not rocket science.
As for waiting or not, that's your call, but you want compounding to work in your favour.
Our current plan is ABLE and start the SNT hassle up as we approach the limit(which hopefully will go up before we reach it).
I want millionaires to be using government aid to help their children: just like with free education, when everyone who needs help uses it, the richer parents will demand, and ensure we pay for, higher quality for all. Everyone who is currently able to can all just pay a bit more in taxes to cover everyone’s accessibility and aid needs. I don’t want it to be possible for a child’s needs not to be met just because the state thinks the child’s family has too much money.
Aid services should be treated like sidewalks and fire departments: almost everyone is going to need them at some point, why would you want to make it difficult to access?
Beautifully summed up.
I don't want people to have to impoverish themselves, burning through entire life savings, to 'qualify' for small assistance. IME, it reinforces a 'why bother trying' attitude amongst people struggling on the lower end, and reinforces an 'I got mine, I'll protect it at all costs' attitude from people who've managed to save more.
Money saved from reducing means-testing from the administration of benefits/services might not be massive, but it would be a move towards "more efficiency", something many folks claim to value/support.
You see this every day in public school, where the more well-off families pay for math tutors or extra coaching or other out-of-school opportunities for their kids.
(A very similar thing applies to things like public school "free lunch" programs. The poor have to do a bunch of paperwork to qualify every year and lots of real poor people fall through the cracks of the system because they miss the paperwork or get some small detail wrong. The rich are generally going to pack better, healthier lunches anyway, so in some cases the time and cost of that paperwork would be better spent on "free lunch for all" programs, even if that means a few rich kids get free lunch sometimes.)
(A sentence that is not seen very often.)
Of course, the problem isn't really the rich. There aren't enough of them to strain the assistance budget even if they do all take the free lunch. The problem is the people who are richer than the ones who are eligible, but aren't actually rich. There are a lot more of them, and the money to give them all free things may just not exist.
Welcome to the squeezed middle. Don't make enough to be truly comfortable but too much to be eligible for government assistance.
> and the money to give them all free things may just not exist.
Though if we had a functional legislature we could make this money exist simply by bumping the tax rate in the relevant income bands so that the extra expenditure is covered by the higher taxes.
But it does though, because those are the people the existing system is screwing the most.
If you're all the way at the bottom, whatever the government provides is what you get because you have nothing else.
If you're all the way at the top, you have the resources to buy whatever the best of the best is.
But if you're in the middle, you can't afford to pay the taxes to fund public schools you don't use and pay for private schools, so you get stuck with public schools. And then we end up with this catastrophic districting system where you buy into a better public school system by spending more money on housing -- and making sure that there is more political support for keeping housing unaffordable because it's the way the middle class gets their kids into a better school district.
If you just give everyone the same amount of money, someone at the 40th percentile income doesn't have to massively overpay for a house, they can just add 20% more of their own money to send their kids to a better school. And someone at the 25th percentile income who is willing to sacrifice more for their kids can do the same thing, instead of having no path to do it at all because it would require them to get mortgage approval for a single family house in a suburban school district which is forbidden at their income level.
The problem isn't the means testing the problem is it's applied with broad strokes like all well meaning but inevitably awful government work. First, everyone pays into disability. So everyone should be able to get their share when necessary. Second, means testing includes things like housing, retirement accounts (which will be penalized severely if accessed), assets, and other things than just raw cash available. Just having a half decent computer is enough to make you fail means testing. So people who are on disability are almost universally forced to be poor. Don't try to hide your assets either. Shifting money/assets/etc to a family memory will still disqualify you.
In a practical sense we also need to prevent the exploitation of disability programs. For example, self-inflicted disability (morbid obesity for example) should be subject to a different test of means than birth defects. If you're only disabled because you eat too much and can't be bothered to exercise I question whether you're actually disabled. Every "class" of disability is not equal and so we shouldn't treat them exactly the same. But, like all things, because the government runs it disabilities must be treated this way and as a result everyone suffers.
I don't really agree with this.
First, I don't see "abuse" of the system being a major problem that needs to be defended against. If someone wants to destroy their future health by Homering, let 'em. They aren't extending their life by eating themselves to death.
But even if that's the concern, I'm pretty sure we could circumvent a lot of those issues simply by subsidizing disability causing conditions (such as building/maintaining public gyms). We can prevent people from getting there in the first place which would greatly reduce the problem of "abuse".
Strong means tests are expensive to run and ultimately will filter out people that actually need assistance. If we are going to apply a social filter, I'd rather side with letting those that don't deserve it in than keeping those that deserve it out.
This is born out with homelessness studies. Applying sobriety or religious tests before sheltering the homeless ultimately keeps people homeless. Housing first, on the other hand, has a tendency to make people sober.
It's silly to bill people twice for the same product to make sure the underserved aren't accidently helped.
Absolutely. No one should have to pay for it, though.
That's not how insurance works. Everyone pays with the expectation that few will need it.
Everyone gets disabled to one degree or another as one gets older.
So what we have is a Ponzi scheme, where early participants get benefits but the majority get screwed.
> Every "class" of disability is not equal and so we shouldn't treat them exactly the same
Agree 100%. You should be expected to take care of yourself if you can.
Okay... how do you then prove this? Is preexisting medical issues considered legitimate? What about medication changes? What about [insert any of many possible causes]? What if you have one of those causes but are missing one piece of paperwork to prove it? What if what if what if? I worry that trying to put legitimacy tests on disability just leads to "you're not disabled enough to deserve health" the way it does now.
Perhaps there's a distinction between chronic/permanent disabilities and transient disabilities? If I'm obese to the point where I can't walk, I am, indeed, disabled, but don't necessarily have to be for the next 20 years. Diet/exercise/surgery/etc could all reduce the obesity, but in the immediate 'now', I'm disabled and need assistance.
Also, to cite an HN darling[0], obesity is, at the very least, a lot stranger and more complicated than CICO.
> we also need to prevent the exploitation of disability programs
What if we _encouraged_ the "exploitation" of disability programs? What if everyone who wanted or needed it got help, regardless of whether someone thinks they "deserve" it? What if people didn't have to worry about failing to re-prove they still need help? I would rather that myself & my disabled friends live in that world.
That's always the ideal surely. But there are at least some cases where simply providing people with material necessities and access to medical care etc. doesn't always feel like it's really helping them - I have one such friend, and while I genuinely sympathise with his very real mental illnesses, it's hard not to think sometimes the fact there's no expectation he will ever need to provide for himself at all might be part of what's stopping him turning his life around.
The idea that obesity is self inflicted runs contrary to our current understanding not just of psychology but of physiology. Most people don't have a constant struggle to maintain a healthy weight generally people with obesity even if they lose weight have to work extremely hard to not regain that weight and most fail.
Eating your feelings (emotional eating) is commonplace. I'm saying it's a uniform cause, but common enough to pass the bar of "contrary to current understanding of psychology".
Controlling the motion of your hand to your mouth is entirely within the powers of even amoeba. No one forced you to eat yourself to death.
It's strange how we are so tolerant of the obese but alcoholics who climb into a bottle because of PTSD are considered derelicts. "Healthy at any size" has been the most effective form of long term population control.
You're making the argument for this dystopia:
https://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html
The point of government assistance isn't to make everyone the same, it's to provide a baseline. Someone in such poor state that they can't work at all still gets a roof over their head.
Someone else can use the money to go to college or start a business, and society has an interest in promoting that because it yields returns. There is even an argument for investing more in people with more potential.
But in both cases the government is terrible at doing the evaluation as a result of politics and bureaucracy, so the right answer is for everyone to get the same.
I'm certainly pro universal health care, it would GREATLY simplify mine and my son's life. Private insurance is simply garbage when it comes to services for people with disabilities. With that in place, a much simpler trust system would work for my kid. It wouldn't be this complex system of checks to make sure they stick in line with current legislation standards. I wouldn't have to spend a large chunk of my child's funds on lawyers and trust administrators just to ensure legal compliance. I could cover basically all my kids needs other than medical, that stuff is just too expensive for anyone to afford.
This was an argument for "libertarian" universal income.
Huge government edifice which exists to determine who, where, and how aid is distributed. Much glad-handing, acrimony, and inefficiency.
Just cut out the middle-man and cut everyone a check, or implement something like Richard Nixon almost did, the reverse income tax.
Let's say we set the level at $1k per month for everyone. Great, until it's 2050 and that level is still $1k. Without inflation adjustments it eventually turns into giving people the equivalent of a penny, only now there aren't other safety nets in place.
But also, you'll have politicians saying "This is a huge cost to the government and everyone should just take care of themselves. So let's cut back the spending for people born in 2023". Just like they did with SS.
Yes, one of the most important parts of making a healthy, empathetic, caring, and functional society is removing those people from office.
Completely the opposite. Because everyone gets it, lowering the funding requires you to fight everyone. The average income is moderately higher than median income, so the median person (i.e. the majority) receives more than they pay, even if it's funded with a flat tax. (Which also allows you to vastly simplify the tax system, because flat tax + UBI is progressive but requires much less privacy-invasive financial tracking than other forms of progressive taxation.)
> Let's say we set the level at $1k per month for everyone. Great, until it's 2050 and that level is still $1k.
So index it to inflation, or better yet, GDP per capita.
> But also, you'll have politicians saying "This is a huge cost to the government and everyone should just take care of themselves. So let's cut back the spending for people born in 2023". Just like they did with SS.
They only get away with that because the people born in 2023 wouldn't have received SS until ~2088, which doesn't concern their parents, and the infants are too young to put up any resistance.
With a UBI, everyone gets it, and then every parent will object that they're cutting funding for children.
Growing up one thing I realized was white privilege, for lack of a better term, was my families access to welfare programs.
My father passed when I was young and my mom was left to raise us on our own. When he passed she made just barely above the poverty level, and you know what the government agent did? He fudged a couple things on the paper work and my mom got SSI and Medicaid for us until we turned 18.
I’ve heard the hell non white families go through in similar situations in my home state and I don’t imagine they got that privilege
Means testing is not only inimical to the concept of shared benefits, but it's actually expensive to perform the means-testing. And some people who should qualify don't get the benefits.
https://www.medicaidplanningassistance.org/medicaid-eligibil...
> The assurance of a certain minimum income for everyone, or a sort of floor below which nobody need fall even when he is unable to provide for himself, appears not only to be wholly legitimate protection against a risk common to all, but a necessary part of the Great Society in which the individual no longer has specific claims on the members of the particular small group into which he was born.
-- Friedrich Hayek
Milton Friedman argued the moral case for universal public insurance against severe deprivation as well, along similar lines.
Yep, SSI disability is a system designed to keep you in poverty. The current max benefit is a little more than $900 / mo. That's basically unlivable unless you also happen to have section 8 housing, which when I asked, had such a huge waitlist it was unusable. $900 / month is certainly not enough to have any sort of dignified life. It's a grim existence punctuated by constant worry over every purchase.
I was on it from 18 to my mid 20's. Thankfully voc rehab helped me scrounge enough grants and scholarships together to pay for me to get a CS degree in '08. I've done quite well for myself since, but it's been a long road.
So many people in America who are on government benefits for life would LOVE to work odd jobs or part time and contribute to the economy and buy like an xbox or something but they cannot, because they would then be kicked out of their housing program. It's absurd.
Then these people on fixed, abysmal incomes are preyed upon by an entire industry who exists to skim off fees from the poor for everything from cashing checks, to hounding them for debts, to things like Dollar Tree where you can pay double the unit rate to buy a small portion of a normal product.
It seems like you're implying that Dollar Tree is unethical for putting forward an investment in order to take advantage of economies of scale and then paying for overhead, shipping, and retail space to sell their goods at a profit.
What do you propose as an alternative to this? Should these goods be taken from those who are able to produce them at a wage set by the government and then distributed to those who need them, as prescribed by SSI, after nationalizing Dollar Tree and its ilk? How will the amount that the producers are owed for their labor be determined, or does this even matter?
Or maybe if this kind of discount store is immoral, maybe it should be banned. Are you suggesting that the customers of Dollar Tree would be better off if they simply went without whatever wares Dollar Tree has? Or that individual consumers should somehow gain access to the economies of scale that arise with being able to afford, eg, an entire container ship full of junk coming from east Asia?
In the best possible world, their niche would not exist (would not be profitable) because they would have no target market, because everyone would be able to acquire basic necessities at regular grocery/big-box stores. A UBI scheme is far more productive in achieving that world then either of the (likely facetiously suggested) ideas you mentioned.
However, I'm not about to go tell everyone on SSI the way out of that poverty trap is to simply 'learn to code'. I'm fully aware that 'learning to code' isn't even an option for most of the able bodied population, much less those dealing with disabilities.
I simply don't hold out much hope that governments will ever allow those 'on disability' to live a dignified life.
That accommodation? A fucking tall stool for the lab bench.
These days, I've done well enough for myself that I can push back. Remote interviews are especially nice. My current boss didn't even know I had a disability until we met in person months after I started.
> We need to see disability as a cost to society we must pay
Nonparticipating Product Hunting lifehacking hustlebros don't see things that way. They are the worst voters: they don't care about other people's problems and they don't care about problems that are even likely to affect them personally. They only care about the now.
ACA enabled nonparticipation. 18-26 year olds got insurance and checked out. Why do you think Republicans supported it? It got passed but it wasn't radical. That's the point.
> My dream is to see this sometime in my lifetime.
Make the radical thing happen by picking a side. If you feel strongly about this, align with something that activists have been advocating for for decades instead of "pain oriented policy" or something idiosyncratic like that. You have way more agency than you think.
The Canadian system has been systematically dismantled by the conservative movements for decades. Long term care was privatized and has been in a slow decline. I've been writing our ministers here for years urging them with solutions to fix the system. Meanwhile my Nan in her 90's, living with Type 1 diabetes, had to go hungry during the pandemic when they couldn't get workers who understood her dietary needs to prepare food she could actually eat. It's been a huge drain on her health in these years of her life and has left a terrible mark.
Definitely worth advocating for and joining movements to push for social programs and human rights. When everyone's quality of life improves so many other things are raised up with it.
Building our entire society and physical space around cars is a poor choice, or set of choices: https://jakeseliger.com/2019/12/16/maybe-cars-are-just-reall...
Bit by tick and get Lyme disease. Get virus and get chronic fatigue syndrome. Get hit on head and get TBI. Don’t even know what causes fibromyalgia.
I have chronic vestibular migraine, which means dizziness and fatigue, but can work most days.
You frame this as a binary choice, but it's clearly both.
I understand the desire to destigmatize and focus on systemic problems. But I really hate when health issues are framed as only societal/systemic problems. Doing so is factually incorrect and worse, robs individuals of their sense of agency.
One of the main failure modes I see of progressivism (which I am otherwise happily a member of) is treating all problem's as society's fault. And then progressives wonnder why they feel so dispirited and defeated all the time. Maybe it's because we adopted a worldview that gives us no sense of agency over our own lives?
(Of course, one of the well known failure modes of conservatism is blaming individuals for everything.)
The right answer is that it's both. Like the serenity prayer says, do the stuff you can and accept the stuff you can't. Both are equally important.
We need to see disability as a cost to society we must pay, not a failure of individuals which is more or less what were treating it.
The American disability system is basically proving (very painfully) that life is barely livable to get scraps of help. Like below poverty levels.
I really wish that we moved away from pain oriented policy - - how much pain are you willing to tolerate so we can get you basic assistance and into some sort of way to guarantee that people live an okay life as a default. My dream is to see this sometime in my lifetime.