News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by jrm4 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @01:54PM (#36974399)
Good, because this is an awful and stupid and terrible and ridiculous and exploitative idea.

On its no-pun-intended face.

Let's be clear, it does not matter at ALL if Sam Altman or anyone presently involved has good intentions; the goal is biometric crypto, and biometrics -- which is to say, unalienable IDs, is by default an awful idea and should probably be dismissed outright.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by kevinventullo on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @01:59PM (#36974496)
I do think this project sounds scary and dystopian, but aren’t SSN’s effectively unalienable IDs?
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by afavour on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:02PM (#36974524)
You could issue someone a new SSN. I know it rarely ever happens but it is certainly possible. Eyeball scans... less so.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by discodave on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:38PM (#36975069)
As a thought experiment, could a witness protection program (i.e. an arm of the government) issue a new/fake SSN? Yes.

Could they change your retina? Maybe some surgery exists to do this, but it sounds risky/complicated!

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by taeric on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:50PM (#36975254)
This is somewhat weak with the argument here, though? The idea would be that you could get a new "world coin address," and I see no reason that couldn't be doable.

That is, the thought experiment here is not that people interact with your retina identity, but with an address that has been confirmed to be associated with a living person. There will have to be ways to build "collective" groups in this landscape, as such there will have to be other webs of trust on top of it. Right?

To be clear, I'm not convinced world coin is a good idea, but I'm not sure this is a clear take down of it?

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by CrazyPyroLinux on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:47PM (#36975212)
See: Minority Report :)
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:21PM (#36974776)
I would argue that in our current identity theft riddled world SSN's are as much a liability as anything. At some point they became used as both the id and the password.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by soligern on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:45PM (#36975175)
Absolutely not. There is nothing tying a number to your genetics.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by fsckboy on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:50PM (#36975259)
ok, but your genetics are a number (turns out 64 bits will not be enough)
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by pessimizer on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:23PM (#36975813)
And also an unnecessary, bad idea. We don't need a special code to ration retirement.

They were also, by law, not an identifier, because people then were smarter than people now. You can still refuse to give your SSN under any circumstance other than employment, and people cannot deny service based on that refusal.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by landemva on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @04:31PM (#36976941)
SSN is voluntary. USA passport application has a spot for SSN and it may be left blank or may contain rando numbers (I have done both). TSA full body scan is also voluntary, along with voluntary showing ID at their (Soviet era) checkpoints.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by subsaharancoder on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:04PM (#36977433)
> SSN is voluntary. USA passport application has a spot for SSN and it may be left blank or may accidentally contain rando numbers (I have done both). TSA full body scan is also voluntary, along with voluntary showing ID at their (Soviet era) checkpoints.

I had to do a quick check on this TSA scan just to confirm that an opt out was possible, seems they changed the language back in 2015 https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/privacy... (page 3) to make it less optional. Basically it sounds like you can say NO, but they can override your NO for whatever reason..

"TSA is updating the AIT PIA to reflect a change to the operating protocol regarding the ability of individuals to opt out of AIT screening in favor of physical screening. While passengers may generally decline AIT screening in favor of physical screening, TSA may direct mandatory AIT screening for some passengers as warranted by security considerations in order to safeguard transportation security."

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by landemva on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @06:04PM (#36978348)
That is what Thousands Standing Around say, but it's not the law. And there are ADA considerations (hint).

I have never done more than metal detector or massage, and have been 1K flier.

A friend flies with no ID and a federal ankle bracelet. Also opts out of full body scan.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by walrus01 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:50PM (#36978147)
Unless you literally live in a wood shack in the forest like the Unabomber good luck existing in modern USA society without an SSN. I suppose you could probably do it if you inherited generational wealth and lived from birth to death only spending cash on things.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by landemva on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @06:06PM (#36978385)
Usually doesn't even get that far because IRS bribes parents with a small deduction if they voluntarily get a beast number for their child.

A motivated person could set up an LLC and do everything through that EIN. Few are motivated to protect their privacy.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by pjmlp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:59AM (#36981958)
Most countries have a required ID, there is no way around it other than living illegally.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by jrm4 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:00PM (#36977346)
I'd say "effectively" is doing the heavy lifting here.

Which is to say, we could undo that database if we wanted to. If society decided it collectively hated SSNs, the work to obscure that system, or to poison that well, would be far easier than with irises.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by freitzkriesler2 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:12PM (#36974664)
Agreed. Unfortunately the reality is Sam didn't "pay" the right officials so this ban is less altruistic than we're lead to believe.

Edit: the down v00ter clearly doesn't understand how African countries work (China has made inroads as well as they have because of bribes). This is the reality on the ground whether you like it or not.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by CrazyPyroLinux on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:49PM (#36975237)
You say that like it doesn't happen everywhere. See-also: the other crypto Sam.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by mike_hock on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:52PM (#36975296)
In what way would we ever expect the ban to be altruistic? Kill the cancer before it grows. It's in every country's best interest to destroy this scam as early as possible.

So the cancer didn't pay the right officials to disable Kenya's immune response. Good news!

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by pessimizer on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:27PM (#36975880)
Again, whenever we do stuff, it's somehow China's fault. It would be nice if we could refer to the bad things we do without calling them Chinese.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by jrm4 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:06PM (#36977450)
In theory, I agree; it wigs me out. It feels almost racist when I describe their social credit score -- but, sorry -- facts are facts.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by acheong08 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @11:42PM (#36981093)
“Social credit score” is pure western propaganda. It’s called “trust score” and it’s by companies like Tencent (at the behest of the Chinese government) instead of directly from the CCP. Having a low score prevents usage of public facilities (transport, vending machines).

Mine was so low I can’t buy a drink via WeChat

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by alienthrowaway on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:48PM (#36978118)
Your comment adds nothing to the discussion, and is a digression.

I noticed you casually implied people familiar African countries wouldn't dare down vote your comment. Take this exotic downvote[1], it is straight out of Africa.

1. for lowering quality of discourse with an off topic shallow dismissal

Edit: if you want me to reverse the downvote, you know "how things work" :) Paypal deets are on my HN profile

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by dcsommer on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @01:59PM (#36974493)
Why are unalienable IDs an awful idea? Unalienable IDs seem to me to be the "default" of human societies. Before technology, everyone had "unalienable IDs" -- if you saw Bob, it was Bob.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by majormajor on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:07PM (#36974592)
There's two things going on - technology, like you mention, but also scale.

Scale brings trust problems. Got a million people in your city? Even without technology, you probably don't know Bob. Bob can rip you off without realistically expecting repercussions, unlike in a small village where everyone depends on each other, and Bob would get kicked out and have to try to find somewhere else. So scale also breaks a lot of the value of permenant IDs, and things like outsourced trust (credit reports, etc) will never be perfect. And in a big society, even a 99% success rate would be A LOT of people getting fucked over.

Can this eyeball-thing fix that? Largely, no - any errors in the system that aren't identity theft will still be there. And potentially worse: even fancy technological systems are almost always vulnerable to technological exploits. And then if too much trust is placed in the validation mechanism, a bad actor could potentially go nuts.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by jacquesm on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:03PM (#36974532)
Or Bob's twin brother. Or someone that really looked like Bob.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by afavour on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:04PM (#36974556)
I'm always skeptical of "before technology" comparison because they rarely account for the radical differences of the world today, like scale.

But in this case the comparison doesn't really work. If Bob went to a new town he could introduce himself as Dave and no-one would be any the wiser.

By comparison eyeball scans are owned by a private company, infinitely replicable and reusable. They could follow you absolutely everywhere you go without your permission.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by joe_the_user on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:57PM (#36976401)
Also, biometrics aren't like people recognizing each other. They eventually have to be become data sent over a network so they're basically a password/id designed/assumed to not be alterable or spoofable - but that assumption is generally false. Hacking can happen from anything from someone getting private info to someone walking around with a mask. And here, as mentioned, there's no password resets available.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by crimsontech on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @08:07PM (#36979612)
I wonder how we handle stolen biometric data? Do we invalidate it like a stolen certificate?

Sorry sir, your eye has been revoked, you can no longer authenticate to this, or any of our partner services.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by soco on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:18AM (#36982865)
It's difficult to have your eye stolen (let's not get into gore please). But they could simply hack the backend, and say your eye belong to someone else. The app now shows Bob the bank robber being Dave the bank manager, just long enough to empty the vaults. Oh it was on blockchain so you can see afterwards that it was actually Bob?
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by psd1 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:33AM (#36983000)
Or the inept might trade their IDs for instant cash, as is actually happening (reportedly). Since Worldcoin is bribing 3rd-world grannies to sign up.

I know that HN is crawling with individual-responsibility people. To those people I say: do you shrug coldly when your aged mothers get scammed? Are villages without electricity fair game?

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by salad-tycoon on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @04:15PM (#36976711)
Worse still,

Your eyeballs are scanned now everyone will think you are Bob, even if you actually are Dave, because that’s what the app says. Doesn’t matter what you say or argue because the app says you are Bob and the app is never wrong.

I was at Walmart buying some heavily discounted gel blasters. I ordered them for pickup originally but then thought “Walmart employee will misplace it “accidentally” and then buy it when the shift is over” (it happens, a lot). As such, I decide to go myself and pick them up. Turns out Walmart online vs in store clearance price is a big difference so I ask for a price adjustment at the register. I wait for the super user trainer expert person who then calls more super expert backup. They proceed to explain to me that they could do a price adjustment but the app says there are none in stock. Mind you I have the blasters right there at the register and explain to them that these products actually are in stock and say “can we all agree that we are all seeing the same thing right here?”

Answer: sorry, no because again the app says it’s not in stock and we no longer have that product.

The app says no and what the app says is final. Dammit. You are Bob and these gel blasters in front of us don’t exist. Goodluck Bob.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by pschuegr on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @04:39PM (#36977044)
Kafka wept
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by evolve2k on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @05:42PM (#36978021)
My mistake, I’ve just remembered these must already be mine. Proceeds to walk out with them.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by spiderfarmer on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:00AM (#36983212)
That’s what I would have done.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by Obscurity4340 on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:45AM (#36997660)
Take as many as you like
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by riversflow on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:34PM (#36974989)
Before technology, Bob could skip 3 towns over and change his name to Rick.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by Tanoc on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:25PM (#36975854)
Which was useful. If Bob was the subject of a targeted attack by Larry that unjustly sullied his reputation or opportunities, moving from Aton to Ceeton and changing his name to Rick means that Larry's erasure of Bob's standing is effectively reversed.

Sure, it could be abused. But literally everything has the potential to be abused. Life is about weighing the risks of abuse against the reward of opportunity. And honestly I think we've gotten really bad at assessing that risk in the past half century, with powerful individuals muddying our perception even further to pursue their own goals.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by callalex on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:24PM (#36974829)
If eyeballs were unailienable then safety glasses wouldn’t exist.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by kwhitefoot on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:55PM (#36975333)
Not everything old is good.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by bloqs on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:02PM (#36975486)
Backalley eye replacement surgery
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by whatshisface on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:07PM (#36975557)
The "If you saw Bob" identity was limited to a few hundred people if you were a king, and a few dozen otherwise. Biometrics in digital systems will allow the most disagreeable out of a billion people to positively identify you.
Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by aorist on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @09:26PM (#36980201)
Unalienable IDs might be the default of small-scale face-to-face societies, but not ones which operate at scale. Not even "Bob" can serve as a fixed identifier without intentional state action — (sur)names were very often intentionally assigned to make administration (e.g. taxation) easier:

> Campaigns to assign permanent patronyms have typically taken place, as one might expect, in the context of a state’s exertions to put its fiscal system on a sounder and more lucrative footing. Fearing, with good reason, that an effort to enumerate and register them could be a prelude to some new tax burden or conscription, local officials and the population at large often resisted such campaigns.

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/james-c-scott-seeing...

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by goodbyesf on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @10:20PM (#36980579)
> Unalienable IDs seem to me to be the "default" of human societies. Before technology, everyone had "unalienable IDs" -- if you saw Bob, it was Bob.

Interesting. That makes me wonder if cultures around the world feared twins precisely due to the fact that ''unalienable ids' were the default of human societies'. In 'Things Fall Apart', identical twins are automatically 'dispatched' in the evil forest as soon as they are born because they are deemed 'evil'. I never understood why. But since identical twins break the natural default id system of human societies, maybe some societies felt it better to sacrifice the few to preserve the system.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by apienx on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:14PM (#36974680)
Biometrics (as a way to identify people) are used by plenty of governments around the world.

There are plenty of people who don't care about privacy (as evidenced by the rise of social media). Why wouldn't such people be allowed to profit off their biometric data?

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by landemva on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @04:36PM (#36977004)
> Why wouldn't such people be allowed to profit off their biometric data?

And legalize selling kidneys. My body my choice.

Re:Kenya suspends Sam Altman’s eyeball-scanning crypto project by tim333 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:03PM (#36992657)
Got my scan. I'm happy. Worldcoin's happy. Who's exploited?