Highly annoying these services, they don't do even the most basic verification that the person signing really is the person that should be signing.
In neither case is there any real additional identity verification.
When you sign a mortgage or take out a loan and it’s all online, lenders will pay someone to come to your house, take a photo of you, verify it, and then video tape you signing.
It’s just not convenient.
This is the problem with things like account recovery. If you really want to minimize social engineering etc., you'll do something requiring a physical presence and various sorts of government issued ID and will probably cost money. And people won't like that. (And the companies won't like it because there's a lot of overhead.)
Many years ago, possessing the values on a passport constituted verification. This data was stored and after a significant number of leaks, this data alone was useless as it became public knowledge. The next step was requiring a photo of the document. The photos were stored, and after a significant number of leaks, the same thing happened. The next step was ID selfies. Then the same thing happened. Now it’s selfie videos with the ID. This too will become useless when those videos are leaked.
It’s a never ending battle. A passport is a physical document and should only be used physically.
Online, we need public/private key authentication. It’s the only way.
I'm having trouble imagining a scenario where a high level of assurance is required but is not worthwhile to meet in person.
Can you name a few examples?
In general, I rarely do anything related to financial accounts in person.
Requiring physical presence is a pain but it's probably tolerable for sufficiently high value transactions. Only works within the US. There's a related process with more hurdles for international.
Your credit card already has contactless chip and it's been ID verified. So does your smartphone. Why can't we just marry the two together?
It's true that you can physically go to the institution in question and prove your bonafides to them so no intermediate is involved but you start to add a lot of friction to all but the most serious transactions.
If you care enough to get it really signed, pay the notary.
To the degree that signing a lot of documents is something of a formality, most of us don't want to have to go to a notary every time we need to put our signature on something.
What actually needs to happen is that things like Docusign need to be contextualized and treated as the appropriate amount of evidence of a contract. Which is to say not much, just like a piece of paper with a signature on it these days.
A "signed" Docusign is evidence that someone opened an email link and clicked a box from a certain IP. It does not prove that a specific person did this. It does not prove that the person in question read and understood the words in the document. In fact, a Docusign that didn't allow marking up the document is itself evidence that the person in question was coerced into accepting unilateral boilerplate terms, rather than being able to make modifications.
Like many legacy systems in the US, the jankiness from using an antiquated system is actually preventing a much more draconian system that would develop if the abstraction was made solid (for a straightforward example, see "identity theft").
I lived in a country like this and all my electronic signatures were linked to my natural person. Most documents were signed this way - from rental agreements to tax returns. It was very uncanny to start using things like Adobe Sign or DocuSign afterwards which is very popular in the UK and US.
For the curious - look up m-signature and e-signature in Lithuania.
It's a nice convenience, but some of the costs are insane.
To provide m-signature services, mobile carriers in Lithuania burn a client biometrics-linked key into the SIM cards they provide. This setup allows the use of phones with these special SIM cards for two-factor authentication, which can be considered three-factor with some caveats due to the inclusion of biometrics. The mobile signature technology has good UX where a user, while signing a document, usually enters their tax ID and phone number into a web form. They then react to a prompt on their phone by inputting one of two memorized PINs. It's easy, cheap, and secure.
I also don't believe this technology is subsidized by the government. Though it's challenging to find specific legal language around subsidies for m-signatures, the price of this tech seems to be asymptotically approaching real costs through free market competition. In the Western world, a similar demand for electronic signatures exists. Although the market is currently dominated by costly certificate providers, they seem to lack moat, and it brings hope that this technology may be more widely adopted in places like the UK and US, once prices naturally fall.
Lithuania is N=1 but it's an interesting case study for how mobile signatures can be made user-friendly (or at least "user-reasonable") and mass-adopted.
Fortunately they've introduced smartphone app just few weeks ago where you can finally use your national ID. It has to be pretty new one and I'm not sure how long before it expires (IIRC it used to be a mere 2 years until you need to physically renew), but it's a start.
It's probably one of the biggest mission of Lithuanian diaspora.
p.s. do you have a source that biometrics are "burned-in" into your SIM card? When I set mine up I don't remember anyone scanning it, just visually verifying.
p.p.s. above doesn't work with eSIM (not that any Lithuanian ones are useful, i.e. offering free wifi calling when roaming)
p.p.p.s. buying anything online in Lithuania is becoming near impossible - barely anyone offers option paying by card, only by a few selected online banks and no you can't just pay IBAN via some no-name digital bank.
So you email it back without comment, which shows you received it and understood what it was, and then started work… I suspect that’s binding in many jurisdictions, and the lack of an actual signature is simply an inconvenience
If they emailed you terms beforehand and you still started work, then most courts would take that to indicate your acceptance of the terms.
There’ll be explicit case law but it’ll come down to “would a reasonable person think the changes to the contract had been accepted”
The returned copy was accepted by HR via email (not sure if they ever read it or not)
What will be interesting is if this ever gets to be tested as not ever sheet in the contract was signed.
* https://www.adamsdrafting.com/making-sneaky-changes-to-a-con...
I don't think it has a direct legal basis, but like most things to do with contracts it builds the picture of intent and acceptance and understanding of what they were getting into.
Seeing how you’re first action in each of your new jobs is done in bad faith I think I see why you’ve had to fill out six of them…
I'm also not really sure which situations an employment contract would really hurt you in tech besides maybe some IP stuff. NDAs are usually separate.
IANAL,but they're still enforceable, especially in the grandparent's situation where the grandparent's work product was accepted and they were paid. There are realms of contract law where signature compliance is more prescribed like probate.
In my first contract for a dev job:
- noncompete
- agreement to work for a minimum amount of time, while my employer could terminate me at will (I don't think this one was actually enforceable where I live, since I didn't get a signing bonus, but I didn't know that at the time)
- IP stuff
- agreement to arbitration for any disputes (and employer chooses the arbitrator of course)
I would probably dispute some of those now, but as at the time I was naive, fresh out of college. And even if I had pushed back, I didn't have much leverage. I had just moved, and had no money, I couldn't afford not to take the job.
I always wondered WHY ARE PEOPLE IN THE US ASKED TO SIGN A RECEIPT WHEN THEY PAY BY CREDIT CARD? I can draw literally any scraggles and they’ll accept it. Are they supposed to compare to the signature I put on my card?
Signature comparison is a line of defense.
More broadly, There's a whole set of practices that assume a relationship. You scoff at signatures, but in their heyday, my local banker knew me and knew my signature and he could spot a general forgery or even unusual patterns. Every economic transaction I engaged in came with a relationship that helped mitigate fraud.
Even voting in the US today carries remnants of this. If you go to a small town to vote, you know the election workers and they know you. There's no need for an ID and there's no question of fraud. Everybody knows everybody. If you try to vote and nobody knows you, if you've got the paperwork, you'll get a smile and you'll vote, but you can bet your ballot is flagged for extra scrutiny afterwards.
We need more of this system in the modern world.
Probably historically; I think I've had it rarely in the distant past.
It's fairly uncommon these days. And the places where you sign a pad you just swipe a finger and no one blinks an eye. I'd say it was just outmoded POS systems but I've seen it on newer systems too. It probably does, as someone else wrote, constitute a bit more assent than clicking a button does even if not much.
This is because we have video recording, PIN input, card not present payments and lots of other ways to prove the cardholder approved the payment. That said, if you are a merchant and want lower fees by requiring signatures, make sure you compare signatures with the back of the card, and make damn sure the card is actually signed (no by looking at a driver's license). An unsigned card signature dispute almost always ends up costing the merchant.
I doubt the parent did this in his first job, once you get to your 4th job, I can totally understand.
Plus why is it bad faith? The employee is presumably expected to read the contract, or should they just trust the employer? By the same token, the employer should be expected to check that the employee actually agrees to the terms.
This behavior is not bad faith, unless it is done with the intent to deceive the employer. It's on the employer to make sure documentation is done correctly. In my company, we catch these kinds of things when we are setting up payroll. Most of the time the employee genuinely forgot to sign, or read some creative advice on the internet. Most of the time, the employee signs, and life is good. When they don't sign, we often find that that person has accepted an offer elsewhere and is milking us for a check.
This is called a notary public. Its a routine requirement with immigration documents. .They can also certify copies as true.
In UK for sone reason it costs over £100, and noone uses them, but in eastern europe its common and notarising documents is like €5 - they just check you identity
They may give you the run around saying “the notary isn’t in today”, options here are ask them to tell you which branch you could visit where the notary is available, or what day and time is best that you’ll surely catch the notary. They will be uncomfortable about this pressuring but they are required to provide this service.
If you need to sign something then you sign it with your ID. Same ID can get you into your accounts online.
No different to Estonia’s digital ID scheme a decade ago.
I think the real reason was that it sounded like it’d cost £60 (or close to that) per ID, which is pretty damn expensive when it’s mandatory. Most of that money would have been sunk into the black hole that is the IT consultancy industry in the UK, with literally no guarantee of a working solution being built.
Usually when you travel you keep at least one form of ID on you - probably not your passport but a local ID or driving license or something.
You may assume anything you like indeed.
Due to the track record of the RIC, the British police prior to independence (and something that continued in NI until the 90s with the RUCs to keep the idea fresh), there is decently strong opposition to ID cards on the idea that police could demand them to harass people. It's also why most Gardai (Irish police officers) are unarmed, though I think the rising perception of petty crime in Dublin has swung the pendulum somewhat on that topic.
H.Can you use them at home to sign lime a rent agreeement or something? What equipment do you use them with?
Some JPs take payment in the form of a box of beer or some small thing like that.
I've wondered about this from the first moment I scanned a copy of my signature to feed in to Acrobat for signing PDFs. There seems to still be an unreasonable amount of trust in the idea that a squiggle on paper is difficult for other people to reproduce. But then, it's never been about preventing forgery, because forgery has always been relatively simple. Signatures are just a ritual performed between honest people to help them remember that they're honest.
That doesn't necessarily mean that you don't have a contract. Barring specific law regulating the form (such as often happens for property exchanges), the contract is sealed with acceptance. An act of acceptance can be overt such as via signature, but it can also be implied.
By returning the contract as if signed, performing the work specified under the contract, and receiving pay, both you and the employer are acting as if you both have accepted the contract. If a court was asked to adjudicate a dispute (such as over a termination issue like severance pay), a judge could reasonably hold you and the company bound to the terms.
> It must be the full document plaintext and date signed with your private key and should be verifiable with your public key by a court before a claim is even approachable.
Why? Most contract disputes don't turn on whether the text of the contract is authentic. That's resolved by a full PKI-based signature, but such a signature can't decide whether the interpretation of the terms is correct, or whether the contract has been performed, or whether the contract was signed under duress (perhaps making acceptance invalid), or whether the contract is conscionable and consistent with public policy.
I hope you mean they just lost their job or something...
Ultimately I learned that a signature is definitely not proof that someone explicitly signed anything or what the state was at the point of signing it. It must be the full document plaintext and date signed with your private key and should be verifiable with your public key by a court before a claim is even approachable. Docusign sort of does a half-assed version of this but there needs to be a full legal PKI system on this planet and people need to understand it too. That's the most difficult problem to solve.