News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by failuser on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:59PM (#36763996)
Vinyl records also don’t have 0’s and zeroes, it does not make them better than Blu-ray. MLC NAND have more than just 1’s and 0’s, they have 0..7 or even 0..15. Does anyone really want to process analog data?
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by mcdonje on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:17PM (#36764245)
1. Vinyl ridges are much larger than DVD lines. Kind of a silly comparison considering the article claims the density of this scheme would exceed what we currently have.

2. It appears to not be analog.

>An energy barrier is created at the points where the bridges meet the device contacts, and the height of this barrier can be controlled which changes the electrical resistance of the overall material. That in turn is what encodes the data.

That seems to indicate they can have a base-n encoding where n is what they can practically achieve with the barrier/bridge layering scheme.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by failuser on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:40PM (#36764464)
They claim it’s continuous. If continuous values itself were that great then the vinyl records were great for data storage. The problem with continuous values is noise, durability and precision. You can made vinyl disks with incredibly high precision, but preventing damage and reading back those values is not practical. That’s why even the first analog laser medium had discrete pits and lands instead of a continuous signal.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by AnotherGoodName on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:47PM (#36764535)
It can be continuous but still have a limit to data due to noise. In vinyls case the more data you store the higher the error rate (at some point the differences in states is hidden in noise).

The data rate from a noisy channel or storage can be derived from Shannon-hartley theorem.

This is why the old analogue phones could only do 56k for example.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by failuser on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:09PM (#36764744)
Yes, that’s why I hate their headline.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by coldtea on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:19AM (#36768978)
>This is why the old analogue phones could only do 56k for example.

And somehow, on analogue circuit switch phone call mode, still sounded better with less artifacts than most mobile phone calls!

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#36770725)
There's a legitimate reason for that. Tom Scott did a video on it.[0] It basically boils down to telephone switches starting to compress the audio. Compress and decompress multiple times (by various companies) on the way to you, and the quality degrades very quick.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2A8q3XIhu0

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by NavinF on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:39AM (#36771994)
It's been a long time since I've called anyone using a phone number. VoIP apps like Discord took over because they don't sound like crap
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by coldtea on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:05PM (#36774704)
There are billions of calls made using a phone number still.

"Across the world, we make 13.5 billion phone calls every day, using mobile phones. The average person makes or receives around eight phone calls every day, meaning that the US deals with around 2.4 billion phone calls across the 300 million cell phone users" that's from 2023 source.

Here's a 2019 one about US:

On average, people make and receive a total of 178 calls per month Of those 178 total calls, 93 are calls received and 85 are calls made

Not just older people either:

"80% of Millennials and 84% of Gen Z-ers use their phones during 2020 for phone calls".

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by sydbarrett74 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:26PM (#36775090)
Robbed-bit signalling was largely responsible for why voice circuits had a 56Kbps limit. The FCC's regs regarding crosstalk further limited real-world throughput to roughly 53Kbps.

Leased point-to-point DS0 circuits could do a full 64KBps if the whole circuit was 8-bit clean.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by voldacar on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:52AM (#36769625)
There's a Japanese company that makes a laser turntable that can play a vinyl record without any physical contact. It's pretty cool.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by karmakaze on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:51PM (#36764570)
Something that's continuous is analog. I would even say that the MLC/TLC/QLC use analog storage to represent multiple bits per site.

We would already have something similar with SSD and many more bits/levels per site if voltages were precise and stable over time and number of overwrites.

An interesting use would be for storing 1-dimensional data. In effect the errors would be minor and not randomized/scattered as it would be for digital encodings.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by eyegor on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:21PM (#36764874)
Wasn't optane a pretty noticeable leap in voltage stability? They could've eventually pivoted to high density packing if they hadn't given up.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by dragontamer on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:22PM (#36765482)
Optane was never going to reach Flash levels of density. It was always in that awkward zone between DDR4 and Flash. Slower than DDR4 but faster than Flash. More dense than DDR4 but less dense than Flash.

It was a failure of marketing and building. Today's computers use a team of DRAM (like DDR5) and Flash. (GPU-ram like HBM or GDDR6 are still DRAM fundamentally).

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by Eisenstein on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:42AM (#36770755)
What do you call Wifi, or cellular data, or ethernet, or DOCSIS?
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by TylerE on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:08AM (#36768041)
Where it gets interesteing is laserdisc, since that IS the same size (more or less) as a 12" lP, play time is roughly 35 minutes per side, and the video signal is full analog. The audio is analog + an optional PCM or Dolby Digital signal.

Both the audio and video are FM encoded.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by vlovich123 on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:05PM (#36764071)
> Does anyone really want to process analog data?

I imagine at some point in the abstractions it'll get a compat layer. Also, I could be wrong about MLC NAND but I thought it still stored 0/1 and just had more bits stored per cell through stacking.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by whatevaa on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:15PM (#36764222)
No, multi-level NAND has extra voltage levels. Instead of a just regular off (0) and on (1) they have intermediate states too. For QLC, that's 16 levels, it's quite granular, and the margins of error are very small.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by Retr0id on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:48PM (#36764539)
The margins for error are wider than one might immediately assume, since they combine it with error correction codes.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by sp332 on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:17PM (#36764244)
TLC NAND stores one of eight values in the cell. There aren't three separate values like 1, 0, 1, there is only one value, like "5".
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by AussieWog93 on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:53PM (#36764589)
I mean, 101 is just 5 in binary.

So each cell stores either three pieces of binary or one piece of octal. It's the same thing.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by failuser on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:18PM (#36765437)
5 is not stored as 101, it’s stored as charge level number 5 out of 8 other valid charge levels.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by koromak on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:32PM (#36767491)
Its absolutely not the same thing from a hardware perspective. Normal components always operate on bits. We see "5", but the computer sees (at least) 3 bits. It then sends its output as bits to the next one. A 5 must require 3 wires, or 3 cycles of the clock over a single wire.

Building a computer where each wire can encode multiple bits of data at the exact same time fundamentally changes the way operations are done. The entire thing would need to be built in a different way, with different consequences.

It might be a bad idea, or impossible, but it would be different.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by PhasmaFelis on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:15PM (#36764813)
> Does anyone really want to process analog data?

If they can get it to encode binary data more densely than existing systems, with acceptable speed/reliability/cost? Yes, of course they would.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by kstrauser on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:20PM (#36765463)
My understanding is that modern hard drives all use probability and error detection/correction to convert a gooey analog signal into chunky discrete goodness.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by dragontamer on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:27PM (#36765534)
> Does anyone really want to process analog data?

I mean... maybe we should?

All radio waves, such as 802.11, are fundamentally analog data. And then they are converted back into digital with incredible QAM-encoding levels. If you think QLC 4-bits per Flash-cell is big, wait till you see 256-QAM (aka: 8-bits per 802.11 timeslice), or more.

I believe I saw some spec for some fiber-optic cable that is 32768-QAM (aka: 15-bits per timeslice).

--------

Then again, Flash (and other memory) are composed of individual cells. True-analog signals like radio-waves are truly analog, so maybe its not quite the same.

But maybe we should think of things like tape or hard-drives as an analog signal. Or maybe not, who knows? I'm not actually a storage specialist so I don't really know. (Nor am I really in communications, lol).

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by foobiekr on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:35PM (#36765612)
256+ QAM is there but you will almost never see it in practice unless you’re next to the AP. Wifi7 defines up to 4096 so maybe the economics will drive improvements that didn’t land in 6E APs.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by tguvot on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:23PM (#36766103)
docsis. up to 16384
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by Taniwha on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:10PM (#36767346)
You'll see it on almost every cableTV channel these days
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by foobiekr on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:38PM (#36779982)
I was referring to Wifi but yes
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by enkid on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:50PM (#36765782)
I'm pretty sure that Einstein proved that light (including radio) is not, in-fact, analog, but rather has discrete levels of energy in quantum steps.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by tlb on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:12PM (#36766943)
That turns out not to matter, because the noise is always at least several quanta at whatever frequency you’re using so you can’t get close to the quantization limit anyway.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by chrisweekly on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:43PM (#36767175)
Also our physiological sensory and processing equipment (ie, eyes, ears, brain...) translates analog / continuous input into discrete electrical signals; a given neuron fires or doesn't.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by kstrauser on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:28AM (#36768181)
That’s not how that works.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by urinotherapist on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:42AM (#36768285)
Light is produced and consumed in quanta (photons) by reguar matter. Light itself is just radio wave. Radiowave has not such limitation. It's limitation of atomic particles.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by simiones on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:20AM (#36770173)
That's not how quantum mechanics works. Radio waves are photons, and photons are radio waves. Different experiments will reveal different aspects of it, but these are not separate phenomena.

Also, the exact same thing is true of every other particle: just as photons are quantizations of the electro-magnetic waves, electrons are quantizations of waves in the electron field, quarks are quantized waves in the quark field etc. Atoms and molecules are also waves; in fact, there have been experiments showing the wave-like nature of molecules with something like 5000 atoms.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by urinotherapist on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:46PM (#36778850)
I saw water-like behavior of a wave! I have no idea, how much molecules it contains, large waves have many cubic meters of water, but I'm pretty sure that quantum behavior is not limited to 5000 atoms. Waves, even very large onses, are moving energy in "packets". 1 wave - 1 quanta. So, what?

Photon is radio-wave (EM-wave). Typical photon is produced and consumed by a electron, so properties of photon produced by an electron are limited by the electron, also, our abilty to detect photonare limited by the electron. However, EM-waves in general are not limited by electron.

On smaller scale, electron interacts with other charged particles and with EM-field (the medium) via EM-waves. I'm pretty sure that electron is not staying stil, it's vibrating because of thermal noise. Vibration of charged particle produces EM-waves. Those EM-waves are not photons.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by simiones on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @07:52AM (#36784881)
> Vibration of charged particle produces EM-waves. Those EM-waves are not photons.

Yes, they are. In the Standard Model, the photon is the "carrier" particle of the EM field. Any EM interaction between any two charged particles is ultimately the exchange of one or more photons between those two charged particles. When a particle emits an EM wave, in any way, it emits one or more photons. It's impossible to emit 1/2 a photon or 1.3 photons - the EM field / EM waves come in quantities of whole photons.

In the same way, when two quarks interact via the strong interaction, they are emitting and absorbing gluons, the carrier particle of the strong force.

The only fundamental interaction not currently proven to be quantized is gravity. We do know gravity waves exist, but we have not been able to measure them to the required fidelity to verify whether they are also quantized, and thus to know whether they are also equivalent to an exchange of particles (we call these hypothetical particles gravitons, and many do believe that gravitational interactions also occur by the exchange of a whole number of gravitons between bodies with "gravitational charge", i.e. mass).

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by urinotherapist on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:48AM (#36787329)
Unlike regular waves, photons are topologically stable, like smoke-ring kind of wave. Google hopfions for example.

If you like hydrodynamic quantum analogs (walking droplets), then you may see that droplet may escape it pilot wave sometimes. In such cases, pilot wave continue to travel in same direction for some time. IMHO, it's similar to how photons are formed: electron creates pilot wave, then escapes it, similar to Cherenkov radiation.

Anyway, photons have special configuration, so they behaves differently than regular waves.

Gravitational waves, AFAIK, are not topologically stable at all.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by analog31 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:55PM (#36767623)
"Analog" and "digital" do not refer to the physical process of transmission, such as radio waves, but the interpretation of the signal. A digital system has rules for forming and interpreting the signal, so that the transmitted and received messages are identical. These rules typically involve things like signal level thresholds and timing.

Well-engineered systems have "noise immunity" meaning that the thresholds are well above the noise floor, making the likelihood of an error negligible.

If you hang an oscilloscope probe on a "digital" signal, such as the data lines on a memory chip, it might look like a frightening mess, but so long as the rules are obeyed, data transfer occurs faithfully.

In a true analog medium, there's no way that the receiver can make out precisely what was sent, and two receivers will get different information.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by TylerE on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:04AM (#36768012)
All mediums are ultimately analog.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by freedude on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:35PM (#36777249)
"Well-engineered systems have "noise immunity" meaning that the thresholds are well above the noise floor, making the likelihood of an error negligible."

Well-engineered systems also expect noise and compensate with error detection/correction.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by muxator on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:46AM (#36770784)
256-QAM encodes 4 bits on the "phase" component and 4 on the quadrature one. They can be regarded as independent signals. Think about a sin() and a cos() being orthogonal to each other even for the same frequency.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:03PM (#36766867)
I think this is a faulty analogy. The data is still encoded (or, at least, interpreted) as digital data, except that instead of each bit being just 0 or 1, you can have components that represent 0 to n. But each state is still discrete, the only difference is whether representing, say, 0 to 3 requires 2 components (2 bits) or a single component (a qit?).
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by noam_k on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:32PM (#36767091)
> ... representing, say, 0 to 3 requires 2 components (2 bits) or a single component (a qit?).

I think the term you're looking for is trit (ternary/trinary digit).

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by Nursie on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:10PM (#36767349)
A trit is 0,1,2, no? Tri-state.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by spiralx on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:18AM (#36771029)
0 to 3 would be a quat, 0 to 4 a quit, 0 to 5 a hext and so on.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by arcticbull on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:10PM (#36766927)
Isn't that just how MLC NAND works though?

Also the article is just describing memristor memory isn't it? Intel's been shipping Optane memristor based memory (which they deny, but others are skeptical of the denial) for years, so clearly I'm missing something.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by meling on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:48PM (#36767210)
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by cubefox on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:47AM (#36769970)
Optane was PCM , not ReRAM (memristor).
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by ggm on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:15AM (#36767729)
> Does anyone really want to process analog data?

But.. you do all the time. pretty much all the time these binary states are calculated from curves, or approximations. The state isn't 1 or 0, its the set of states which make 1 or 0 depending, under error correcting codes, over-sampling, things like manchester encoding.

We're fundamentally imposing binary on a non-binary state, by making deterministic judgement calls about which side of a divide things fall on, but to do that we have to look at analogue qualities.

I like to imagine people who work in VLSI smile at this statement, but at some level its analogue everywhere. It's higher-states which get to act like its binary, but they map to an analogue signal substrate.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by sydbarrett74 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:19PM (#36774949)
Well, analogue everywhere until quantum effects come into play.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by coldtea on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:14AM (#36768936)
This isn't about analog data. The states will still be quantized/digitized. Besides, currently used transistors in regular CPUs are analog too.

And, does anyone want more than 0 and 1? If it's faster and has largest capacities, with equally feasible manufacturing, then yes.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by quench on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:05AM (#36770098)
This would still be digital (discrete) not analog. For example you can have 4 voltage levels representing 00, 01, 10, 11 This technique is used in modems.

So you can store more information in each memory location resulting in higher density.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by legulere on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @11:00AM (#36773519)
There's an argument to be made, if reality isn't discrete (can be represented exactly by rational numbers) but continuous (can be represented by real numbers) you can represent programs that cannot be represented in a discrete way like a Turing machine. For instance the typical proof that the halting problem is unsolvable relies on there being just a discrete infinite amount of programs.
Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by freedude on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:45PM (#36777380)
The quality of the media is in the perception of the user. Ask any audiophile if vinyl is best or not.

Analog isn't really the issue here as there would be some kind of multiplexing/demultiplexing encoding or device to interface with it. It would still be discrete and have defined levels. as the technology advances you may be able to define more levels in the same bandwidth space thus creating "more" storage by greater efficiency of the spectrum.

Re:Computer memory prototype ditches 1s and 0s for denser da... by kazinator on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @10:11PM (#36781367)
The encoding used on vinyl records has more information density than if zeros and ones were stored, say by two levels of the groove (or a closely related encoding like RZ or NRZ).