News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by 0dayz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:20AM (#36745045)
What is missing from the article is the reason the startup picked eggs.

The main reason is that eggs are very expensive due to the invasive procedure needed to extract healthy one (and the after effect of the procedure whole not dangerous to my knowledge can require you to stay in the hospital to recover).

But fertility medtech is something that brings I think the reoccurring question of the biggest reason we don't have kids after financial, and that is that the 1950s model isn't sustainable/compatible with modern day lifestyle and no amount of conservative lifestyleshaming will change that.

And the solutions to that can only be done via social ingenuity, something I think in general there's very little research and interest in.

So the question then becomes of course just what solution will be used?

Will we see government run child homes?

Maybe a new definition of family based more of old tradional agrarian communal family structure?

Something entirely new?

Who knows but I think it's equally important to figure out a new more sustainable way of raising kids than the 1950s model as it is to fertility medtech.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by bawolff on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:51AM (#36745184)
> Will we see government run child homes?

It seems like quite a jump to skip right over daycare into gov run child homes.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by 0dayz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:14PM (#36750992)
In a way daycare is a temporary child home.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by inglor_cz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:29AM (#36745368)
From the societal point of view, the difference between TFR 1,5 and 1,8 might be quite crucial. Both translate towards an aging and shrinking population, but one of the slopes is much less steep and more manageable.

Putting political labels aside, the main current problem with fertility is the length of education and career start. For someone who wants to have a good job, it means spending your twenties without actually making money and obtaining property. In the 30s, when this platform is finally built, plenty of people suddenly find that their fertility is no longer sufficient to produce the desired number of offspring.

Given that we are not likely to see shorter career starts anytime soon, IVF improvements seem to be the only way to partially escape this trap.

Also, gametes produced by this method could be cheaper in the long run. Classical stimulation involves a lot of doctors and procedures. Maybe this process could be automated and streamlined; it matters way less if you produce "only" 400 ova out of 500 possible than if you get 4 instead of 5 ova from a living person.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by mschuster91 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @06:35AM (#36745398)
> Putting political labels aside, the main current problem with fertility is the length of education and career start. For someone who wants to have a good job, it means spending your twenties without actually making money and obtaining property. In the 30s, when this platform is finally built, plenty of people suddenly find that their fertility is no longer sufficient to produce the desired number of offspring.

A big part of that is rising life expectancy. I'm 31, and my parents (probably and hopefully) won't die until I'm 60+ myself - which means unlike the generation prior to mine that had a reasonable hope of inheriting some wealth as a kickstarter (i.e. a downpayment or a place to live without having to pay shitloads in rent), I and many others of my generation will not have that.

Related to this is that so fucking many Boomers can't leave the workforce - some (more so in the US) because they literally can't afford to live otherwise, but here in the EU more because they are completely unable to imagine a life without work. The result is that all upper layers of management are filled with old people, and young ones can't rise (and earn more money). Just look at the German Mittelstand - the amount of 80+ year olds still running their companies is utterly insane.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by inglor_cz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:44AM (#36745896)
You are right, healthcare improvements have translated into enormous slowdown of generation exchange on the top.

The average age of CEOs of the largest 500 companies in the world at hire has grown 14 years between 2005-2019 [0], i.e. no generation exchange at all.

Looking at the American politics, the combined age of Trump and Biden exceeded 150 in the last election, first such event in American history. Given that they both may be running again ... oh, well.

And in the Czech presidential election, the winner (61 y.o., with a grandfatherly gray mane) defeated a 68-y.o. challenger.

Putin is over 70, Xi is over 70, the Pope is over 80, the freshly crowned British king only stopped being "prince" at 74.

Now add some more longevity progress onto the table and the once-famously geriatric Brezhnev politburo may start looking like a kindergarten. I can definitely see some members of the American Senate or SCOTUS exceeding 100 by 2050.

[0] https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/01/ce...

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by nonameiguess on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:47AM (#36746932)
We already had a 100 year-old Senator 20 years ago, Strom Thurmond. He was a good illustration of the stultifying effect of gerontocracy on change, too. A man who had supported Jim Crow and ran for president on a segregationist platform still serving as Senate Pro Tem in 2003.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by CorrectHorseBat on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:02AM (#36746545)
>A big part of that is rising life expectancy. I'm 31, and my parents (probably and hopefully) won't die until I'm 60+ myself - which means unlike the generation prior to mine that had a reasonable hope of inheriting some wealth as a kickstarter (i.e. a downpayment or a place to live without having to pay shitloads in rent), I and many others of my generation will not have that.

I'm of a similar age as you but I don't see how that is any different than the previous generation?

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by mschuster91 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:51AM (#36746984)
Because by the time previous generations were 30, at least the grandparents distributed their wealth downwards. These days, even if people get children late(r) in life, you can easily have four to five generations of a family alive at a single time.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by CorrectHorseBat on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:02AM (#36747111)
It probably differs much per country and individual, but in my experience (Western Europe) it's the other way around.

My parents generation grew up with 5 children at home, there wasn't much wealth to distribute downwards and anything that did had to be divided by 5.

Now it's usually two children and there's quite a bit more wealth, most people I know that buy a house do get financial help from their parents.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by bradleyjg on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:27AM (#36746754)
> Given that we are not likely to see shorter career starts anytime soon

I think you are right but it’s a big indictment of the scoliotic nature of our current culture that it’s inconceivable that we could make even medium sized changes to how things work because they are producing suboptimal results.

We are at the civilizational stage where we have massive fights over tiny tweaks at the edges and no longer even dream utopic dreams. I don’t think that’s a healthy sign.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by inglor_cz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:30AM (#36746788)
I think it is mostly a matter of coordination.

It is much easier to develop a new fertilization technology than to get 150+ countries of the world to agree (and actually implement that agreement) that they will limit schooling of their youth and give them career opportunities sooner, so that their fertility rises.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by bradleyjg on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:36AM (#36746844)
Why do all 150 countries have to do the same thing? Why can’t the Swedish people decide they are sick and tired of the Washington consensus with its effects on fertility, among other things, and try something different?

It was less than 100 years ago that a small but not trivial number of people conceived and founded kibbutzim. Not the somewhat pathetic version that exists today, but the original radical version.

I’m not saying it was a great idea but they believed that something different was possible and tried to build it. Who does that today?

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by inglor_cz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:40AM (#36746879)
It is a bit of a Red Queen problem.

Surely you can individually opt out of a certain secular trend, but there may be serious adverse consequences. Same as if you decide not to employ, say, gunpowder or the printing press; how many such societies survived the pressure of their neighbours?

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by jokethrowaway on Sunday July 16, 2023 @07:35AM (#36745843)
> 1950s model isn't sustainable/compatible with modern day lifestyle

I genuinely don't understand what you mean by that (as a parent of three who knows plenty of modern parents).

The whole "your life is over once you have kids" is a falsehood from my experience. I'm working less, making more and picked up all the hobbies I wanted to pick.

The first 2-3 years can be more demanding but nothing like the scaremongering I've heard all my life. Sure, I spend weekends with the family and not partying in Ibiza.

> Will we see government run child homes? Where do you think the clones for the Galactic Empire in Star Wars are coming from?

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by mnky9800n on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:43AM (#36746901)
Jango Fett DNA.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by hotpotamus on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:56AM (#36747039)
That's wonderful for you that you're working less and making more; do you think that's the experience for everyone? Aren't around half of all births paid for via Medicaid these days?
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by bcrosby95 on Sunday July 16, 2023 @10:04AM (#36747134)
A lot probably depends on how much personal time you expect to get, how you spend your free time, and how serious you are about what you do in your free time.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by woleium on Sunday July 16, 2023 @08:53AM (#36746453)
I'd have picked eggs too. Curren process costs around $10k, only works for women under 40 (ish), takes 2 weeks of being pumped full of hormones, followed by up to a week of bed rest after the retrieval operation.

To be able to offer this to men and women of any age with nothing more than a cheek swab sounds like a real breakthrough.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by bradleyjg on Sunday July 16, 2023 @09:48AM (#36746961)
What is missing from the article is the reason the startup picked eggs. The main reason is that eggs are very expensive due to the invasive procedure needed to extract healthy one (and the after effect of the procedure whole not dangerous to my knowledge can require you to stay in the hospital to recover).

The other thing is that even after you go through all that you get 0-30 usable eggs. There’s steep further attrition at every step of the process. A couple is lucky to end with 5 implantable blastocysts at the end of multiple rounds of egg extraction, fertilization, and cultivation.

This makes embryo selection for multiple traits very weak and not really worth it. However, if hundred or thousands of eggs could easily be produced that would open up a lot more possibilities. There’d still need to be other advances—current cultivation, cell biopsy, and genetic testing techniques would not scale—but it would very much open the door.

Scientists are understandably reluctant to make this point, given the Luddism on display even at a place like HN.

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by jacooper on Sunday July 16, 2023 @12:32PM (#36748793)
> But fertility medtech is something that brings I think the reoccurring question of the biggest reason we don't have kids after financial, and that is that the 1950s model isn't sustainable/compatible with modern day lifestyle and no amount of conservative lifestyleshaming will change that.

In the west, eastern cultures aren't suffering the same problems for a reason, they still value families.

The west doesn't seem to do so, and i think it's one of the reasons for the "mental health pandemic".

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by 0dayz on Sunday July 16, 2023 @04:13PM (#36750980)
Not a single Eastern European country has a replacement birth rate[0].

In fact certain Eastern European countries have a worse birth rate than western European countries[1].

It's also makes no sense to proclaim "eastern Europe" as a unified cultural group, as eastern Europe technically includes Austria, despite Austria having a modern history more aligned with western Europe due to not being part of the Warsaw bloc.

And no, even if we take your argument at face value eastern European culture does not value "family" more in practice, outwards it does, but younger people in eastern Europe are just like westerners in that they are seeking out career, social and cultural fulfillment before wanting to settle down.

The only real difference between west and eastern Europe is that Western Europe is aware of the issue and don't know what to do (yet), while certain eastern European countries thinks that you can duct tape conservatism with modern ideals (and cut away anything that doesn't fit their view).

[0]https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/D... [1]https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...

Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by jacooper on Sunday July 16, 2023 @05:07PM (#36751409)
I wasn't talking about eastern Europe.
Re:Startup aims to make lab-grown human eggs from anyone's c... by unaindz on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:22PM (#36760132)
It is actually a dangerous operation, probably most if not all invasive operations are.