News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by izzydata on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:15AM (#36695786)
Honestly I think this makes a lot more sense than Twitter. It always felt wrong to me that Twitter was used for anything resembling official communication. Whether it be a local news network, fire station, local government or the president of the United States. All on the same platform that is filled to the brim with pornography and obscenities. Of course you can curate your feed and only follow what you want, but in my mind Twitter is a single website. I'm used to dedicated forums so when Twitter rolled around I figured it would just be a little bit bigger, but still mostly informal, unofficial people goofing off online. Once everyone and everything started using it I left. I don't want to mix online identities with real life identities.

So, despite Mastodon being a federated system it makes a lot more sense to use a dedicated instance for official purposes like this to me. I imagine they don't federate with anything anyway and don't even allow account creation.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by vidarh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#36695960)
You can see from the fact that there are replies from other instances that they do federate. It'd make little sense not to, as if they didn't people wouldn't be able to follow them.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by seti0Cha on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:01PM (#36696607)
Do they federate with anybody or are they selective? Who makes those decisions, based on what? This seems like a can of worms to me.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by vidarh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:43PM (#36697427)
I'm not sure which part of federation it is that makes you think there's a reason for them to be selective.

The "worst case" scenario is that people on this instance can follow someone undesirable and so that they end up with undesirable content in the local feed. But that's pretty much down to ensuring users act how they otherwise would on any social media, with the expectation it will be seen by the public.

I'm a bit surprised that they allow public access to the federated view of the server [1], because that does mean it potentially could get embarrassing w/respect to people who don't get that the gov. doesn't choose what ends up there, so I'd bet that eventually ends up locked down.

[1] https://social.overheid.nl/public

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by seti0Cha on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:32PM (#36698360)
That's exactly the reason I was thinking they may choose to be selective. From what I understand, it's pretty normal for servers to refuse to federate with other servers. I don't know if they do this transitively, but if so, then the Dutch government might find itself forced to choose which side to take.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by nobody9999 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:31PM (#36701957)
>That's exactly the reason I was thinking they may choose to be selective. From what I understand, it's pretty normal for servers to refuse to federate with other servers. I don't know if they do this transitively, but if so, then the Dutch government might find itself forced to choose which side to take.

I'm not clear on what you mean by "forced to choose which side to take."

You (or anyone else) don't have to have an account on that instance. In fact IIUC, the site linked in the submission only has accounts for the Dutch government and elected officials of that government.

Folks other than that can follow individual accounts on the Dutch government instance, but aren't subject to any moderation decisions made by the site. Only those with accounts on that instance would be affected by blocks/bans of specific users or instances.

And even if the Dutch government instance wants to block other instances from their users, there's nothing stopping Dutch government officials (and/or agencies) from creating accounts on other instances.

As such, please explain what you mean by "choosing a side." I'd expect that this site is on the side of The Netherlands, its government and citizens. Isn't that the way it should be for a site like this?

As such, please explain what you mean.

Edit: Clarified prose. Fixed typo.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by vidarh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:42PM (#36702661)
The issue is that if they're selective they'll prevent Dutch citizens from following government accounts. Most places it'd be deeply problematic if the government started blocking access for constituents without good reason.

They can (and probably should) only show their federated feed to users of their instance, and they can silence other instances to prevent posts from making it into their federated feed even if someone follows accounts there, but defederation would likely be an extreme last resort for a government server.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by tremon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:30AM (#36707128)
The "worst case" scenario is that people on this instance can follow someone undesirable

In my mind, the worst case scenario is what we have for e-mail: 99% of Mastodon traffic might become spam. Maybe it's easier to control because Mastodon is a subscription model rather than a targeting model (the recipient is in control of what to receive, not the sender), but you only need one user on an instance to subscribe to a spam instance, and the local feed will be inundated. And that's manageable as long as that happens once or twice a day, but the same incentives that almost destroyed e-mail are still there for Mastodon.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by andsoitis on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:23AM (#36695899)
Why not just use a website? What advantage do citizens get by going to a social media site to keep a pulse on govt comms?
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by vanilla_nut on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:29AM (#36696021)
No strong reason, but Mastodon allows various goverment officials and agencies to create accounts on the same server and probably has more functionality baked in than most self-hosted alternatives. It's got a better interface than a CMS and even allows those government officials to follow and interact with other accounts in an official capacity.

Personally it feels ready-made for government presence on the web.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by toomuchtodo on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:23PM (#36698193)
Wordpress for one to many.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by heavenlyblue on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:44AM (#36706842)
How would your average user "follow" several wordpress websites aggregated in a single timeline?
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:57PM (#36714321)
RSS? I imagine ActivityPub is the Mastodon analogy.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by cmelbye on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:27AM (#36695971)
The advantage is that the information can be aggregated along with posts from other sources rather than having to visit many different websites individually. It's easier to consume, the same reason why RSS was useful.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by gochi on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:47AM (#36696371)
This advantage doesn't work out when the officials are constantly splitting themselves around different social networks. So this just becomes "if you're a twitter user it's easier than RSS". Yet you still have to create another account to join the fediverse, then another for threads, then another for facebook, list goes on for each network that pops up and gains usage.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by cmelbye on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:56AM (#36696531)
That’s the hard part about standards. I’m not sure how a standard can become one without people taking a chance on it.

Case in point: You actually do not need to create another account on Threads - it interoperates with this standard. Citizens will be able to follow information from the Dutch government on that platform.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by gochi on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:16PM (#36696893)
Technically, they need an instagram account to follow the dutch government on threads. Which kind of illuminates my point, for this to become standard we need far better implementation details than what activitypub currently describes. Until that happens, this is just another "social network" to join and keep up with, or ignoring it entirely to rely on some other social network.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#36698489)
* * *
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:52AM (#36696458)
There is also RSS. https://www.government.nl/rss

Effective outreach means being everywhere people are. It has to be “all of the above” because no one method of distribution captures everybody

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by andsoitis on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:27PM (#36703541)
> Effective outreach means being everywhere people are.

I can agree with that.

Interesting to see social network reach in the Netherlands: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1224092/leading-social-n...

Meta rules the top 4 spots.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:26PM (#36697072)
> This advantage doesn't work out when the officials are constantly splitting themselves around different social networks.

The social media department of any large org would have active accounts on all of the social media in order to get a message out. That's how it is already, not sure what your objection to mastodon, where they own the instance, is.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by __MatrixMan__ on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:29AM (#36696020)
If you publish on a website, discussion about what you posted happens in a fragmented way across the various social sites (like we're doing here). If you publish on a social site you're saying "let's talk about this here". Conversations about what you posted might spring up elsewhere, but they become secondary. That's desirable if you want to have a moment when you're done addressing all of the comments.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by unshavedyak on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:28AM (#36696000)
It's just an alternate implementation of RSS / push notifications / etc.

A "twitter feed" is just a website and propagation of posts, comments to posts, etc. Right?

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by didntcheck on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:45PM (#36699779)
Yeah and you can implement ActivityPub without using Mastodon, if they want to. So you could have something that looks more like WordPress (or actually is, but hopefully not), but is compatible with the "fediverse" ecosystem. And RSS, of course
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bloopernova on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:24AM (#36695915)
Mastodon can be both a website and a federated microblogging platform.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by andsoitis on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:31AM (#36696061)
My thinking is: governments already have a website. So now you’re asking citizens to go to two different places to seek out information instead of one.

Or worse: now the government feels they need to post on: their own website, Twitter, threads, Facebook, mastodon, etc.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:40AM (#36696228)
They already do.

Government has found it easier to go where the people are than to try to lead the people to water they won’t drink.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by gochi on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:51AM (#36696433)
Exactly. So there is no added benefit to this beyond the usual methods of government officials making accounts on every network. Negating the entire original comment about how this "makes more sense than Twitter".
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:53AM (#36696475)
Twitter was rate limiting people and those people affected could not see government posts if they exceeded their quota. So in that strict sense it is quite reasonable.

Several government entities where I am left after the blue checkmark fiascos meant people were trying to impersonate the official accounts.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by gochi on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:06PM (#36696713)
None of this is exclusive to Mastodon. They could have done the same on Facebook or any other network that isn't federated.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:20PM (#36696963)
"They could have done the same on Facebook or any other network that they don't control and can't rely on"

They can however control a Mastodon instance, and starting one is a off-the-shelf operation now.

Another poster described it as "problems of governments relying on the whims of tech players in getting these messages out" which is exactly right. Those other platforms might have decided today not to show you the emergency warning unless you have an account and are logged in and have watched some ads first.

It is - for good reason - conventional wisdom that in order to get a message out thoroughly, you have "outposts" on _all_ the media that you don't own (including Facebook and twitter) and push content to there, but the "home base" is not on some platform where it can be locked, rate-limited or taken from you at the whim of some other company in some other country.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:50PM (#36697535)
They are there too. https://www.government.nl/contact

I think the more pressing thing is that they want to get anyone affected by Twitter, and Mastodon is a similar type of service. I’m sure they’re evaluating Threads as we speak.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:39AM (#36696203)
> you’re asking citizens to go to two different places to seek out information instead of one

The problem was few people were going to the one.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by vidarh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:47AM (#36696362)
People go to a gov website when they know they need to get information or get something done. Social media is a way to push information out about new policies etc.

Governments have whole departments dedicated to getting the word out about things because people aren't all in one place. This is not a big additional effort but it is different in two essential way: They control it, and it has APIs anyone can connect to, including to bridge elsewhere.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by bob-09 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:52AM (#36696456)
You can ask citizens to go to your website to stay informed, but they will turn around and complain that nobody told them about X,Y,Z because they're not naturally going to the website on a regular basis unless they have an immediate need. Elected officials will turn on you and blame you for not meeting the citizens where they already are.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by WeylandYutani on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:44AM (#36706848)
Public broadcasting exists in Europe. In fact they were established precisely for this purpose all the way back before internet in the 1930s.

Really you don't need Twitter to stay informed- very few people actually follow government tweets and most of them are journalists.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by FireInsight on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#36698139)
Well, usually governments don't just have one website. Different entities use different channels for official communications + Twitter which is the one everyone reads. Why not have a governments official mastodon for the governments official communication interoperable with the network everyone else is on?
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by tremon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:24AM (#36707071)
Why can't the government website not have a widget/subpage showing the latest Mastodon posts?
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by izzydata on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#36695949)
If I had to guess it is because it is already developed, in a format people can already understand and is dynamically configurable to do what they want now and could change in the future.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by mr_mitm on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#36695956)
Hosting mastodon instances costs money. It makes sense that the "digital town square" is at least partially funded and maintained by the public, i.e. the government.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:48PM (#36697502)
Commodity small mastodon instance hosting is modestly priced, compared to large org budgets

https://masto.host/pricing/

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by AndrewDucker on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#36695952)
Think of it like RSS, but for tiny updates. You'd visit the site to do website type of things, but you don't want to visit daily in case there's an update.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by rsynnott on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:04PM (#36696669)
Very few people are going to bother going to the Dutch government's website every day to see what's going on with the Dutch government. They might be sufficiently interested to follow an account or two. I follow a couple of the European Commission's accounts (they also have a Mastodon instance), and occasionally find them interesting; I certainly can't see myself regularly going to the EC's horrible website, tho.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by hidelooktropic on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:18PM (#36700241)
Yes. And very few still are going to adopt RSS software and a life workflow to check it only to approximate the aggregation feature already a first class feature of a social media platform.

Let's remember the general public are not the same users as "us"

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by amadeuspagel on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:06PM (#36696711)
Yes, a website with an RSS feed is the most basic thing the government should use for communication. This also avoids the question of who to peer with. Anyone can request the RSS feed.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by DavideNL on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:32PM (#36697169)
Mastodon also provides an rss feed.

“You can follow any Mastodon account via RSS by just adding ".rss" to the end of the account's public profile URL.”

https://mstdn.social/@feditips/108357998963885456

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by DavideNL on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:30PM (#36697139)
It _is_ also a website, hosted by themselves: https://social.overheid.nl/public/local
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by galaxyLogic on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:43PM (#36697430)
Mastodon is a website, which is well-suited for discussion and broadcasting. Yes you could create a website and often the agencies do also that - for presenting more static information. But Mastodon etc. already solve the problem of discussion and "following" some specific party or "thread".

A conventional web-site is good for distributing static information whereas a social media site is good for broadcasting notifications about CHANGES to that (more static) information.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by madeofpalk on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:32PM (#36698367)
what is a mastodon instance if not "a website"?
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by rakoo on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:25PM (#36699408)
Same as tv vs social networks: communication can be bidirectional, and a specific news can be shared and discussed more easily
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by hidelooktropic on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:15PM (#36700199)
What advantage do citizens get by needing to know and personally keep the individual websites for their govt comms

Or rely on each website to format the messages in consistently good UX, typography, etc.

Or lose the ability to discover those updates through social network concepts like hashtags

Or have to employ their own RSS tools and subscriptions to approximate the aggregation already baked into mastodon et al

Or remove the ability to see conversations between government entities natively supported by @ mentions.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by nerdbert on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:31PM (#36701958)
I am not going to go to 41 different government agency websites every day just to see if they want to tell me something important.

But I will follow them on social media so that I can see all their updates in one place.

Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by callalex on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:12PM (#36700977)
It terrifies me how many USA cities and counties use Twitter for their mass emergency broadcasts, since Twitter has now proven itself to be unreliable for even reads. My city pays a company (Nixle) to send out mass SMS and Email, but all it contains is a link to a tweet instead of any actionable information.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by RF_Savage on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:28PM (#36702539)
That must have been frustrating when twitter went behind a login wall.
Re:Official Mastodon server of the Dutch government by stainablesteel on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:48AM (#36709072)
> It always felt wrong to me that Twitter was used for anything resembling official communication

i've come to disagree with this now that community notes have come into play, it makes twitter the best place for them to communicate if they're trying to show their honesty and sincerity