News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:37PM (#3668462)
There's a lot of scientific-sounded content in this, but unfortunately most of it couldn't be further from the truth. I'm an ex-audio engineer and studied digital and analog audio engineering; this has been debated to death over the last 15 years.

Digitally recording a triangle is the best example of why 48kHz is very limiting. The distinct sound of the triangle constitutes of a high fundamental frequency, ballpark 5kHz and of many very high-pitch harmonics. Most of these harmonics are above 20kHz. The harmonics are what makes it sound like a triangle, not the frequencies below 20kHz. This is why the triangle is one of the hardest instruments to digitally record. It always sounds like crap.

In theory, it's true that the human hear can't hear above ~18kHz, but it can hear the influence of the very high pitch harmonics on a lower frequency.

EDIT: here's more data backing what I said http://www.cco.caltech.edu/~boyk/spectra/spectra.htm

EDIT 2: typos, frequency mistake

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Joeboy on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:49PM (#3668499)
> Digitally recording a triangle is the best example of why 48kHz is very limiting

The article's about distribution, not recording. I don't think anybody disputes the usefulness of higher sampling rates when recording.

> In theory, it's true that the human hear can't hear above ~18kHz, but it can hear the influence of the very high pitch harmonics on a lower frequency.

...and 48kHz audio contains those lower frequencies.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:55PM (#3668525)
Stripping frequencies above 20kHz negates the effect on the lower frequencies since those lower frequencies are not "modified" by the higher ones. The human hear can actually hear the very high harmonics when they're combined with a lower fundamental frequency.

For example, the human hear will hear a 30kHz frequency if it's fundamental is 10kHz. If it's played at 44.1kHz, the 30kHz frequency is gone and all you'll hear is 10kHz, not a "different sounding" 10kHz.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:25PM (#3668658)
For example, the human hear will hear a 30kHz frequency if it's fundamental is 10kHz

You are going to have to provide me with a citation to back that up because that goes against everything I've learned and experience in 17 years of working in acoustics.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:22PM (#3668920)
Here is a Wikipedia article on the subject: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_from_ultrasound

Basically, if you produce two ultrasonic frequencies, they will create an interference pattern at a much lower frequency than either of the individual frequencies. Modulate a signal on the difference between two signals, and you can create a directional speaker, since ultrasonic sounds tend to be highly directional (so long as the diameter of the transducer is greater than 1/2 wavelength, which is almost guaranteed with ultrasonic signals). This is how the "sound cannons" that are being deployed for crowd control work.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:41PM (#3668998)
That article describes hetrodyning which happens because ultrasonic frequencies at high amplitudes interacts nonlinearly with air. You are not going to see that effect with sound waves generated near the audible spectrum, and normal loudspeakers are going to generate ultrasonic sound waves.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:58PM (#3669047)
Yes, but the effects of interference patterns between multiple ultrasonic frequencies is the same, and definitely does affect the audible spectrum. This is why we must filter the square wave that comes out of a DAC. And the limitations of filters (phase shifts and roll-off) are why modern CD players oversample the signal--so that the filtering can be performed well beyond the audible spectrum.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:11PM (#3669210)
This:

Yes, but the effects of interference patterns between multiple ultrasonic frequencies is the same, and definitely does affect the audible spectrum

has nothing to do with this:

This is why we must filter the square wave that comes out of a DAC

The only reason that square waves "must" be filtered is to reduce the potential of damaging tweeters. If you want to record a square wave with the purpose of later reproducing the square wave, than you don't want to filter it - once you filter it, it's no longer a square wave.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @10:27AM (#3671402)
OK, if you say so. I think you're misunderstanding a fundamental concept of digital to analog converters. But if you think it's just to prevent blowing your speakers, that's OK.

The reason that square wave sucks is because it introduces tons of high frequency content (your amp probably won't reproduce the high frequency content anyway, so I don't think most Japanese consumer amps will damage your speakers--that is, the amp will act like a filter anyway). That high frequency content then creates alias effects (think of moire patterns when looking at super high-res photos that are scaled down without anti-aliasing). Those alias effects sound like shit to the human ear.

The point of filtering is to anti-alias the resulting analog signal after conversion from digital to analog. The point of upsampling is to move that filter well beyond the audible range, so you can use a 1st-order filter (gentle slope, but it introduces no phase effects). The fact that a square wave hurts your speakers is inconsequential--the amp will effectively filter the signal anyway. Unfortunately, it will filter the signal without anti-aliasing, which introduces those nasty interference patterns within the audible spectrum (that is, if you feed a straight 44.1KHz sampled square wave to your speakers without upsampling/filtering).

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by juiceandjuice on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:50PM (#3669026)
Recording music is supposed to be a snapshot (with room for interpretation) of the composition at play.

Trying to record an edge case like this is the same as recording in a room with bad acoustics. So you end up with some weird (but not faithful) representation of the sound which is a snapshot of the microphone's characteristics and directionality of the ultrasonic tones. It's not reasonable to assume any microphone will behave exactly like a human ear. Even if you could, you're going to have to mimic the tiny random movements a normal person would make listening to a sound, movements which would definitely impact the perception of the sound, because microphones are much more stationary than any human would be.

The "different sounding" argument two posts above is silly, because sound is almost never that monochromatic, and if it is, it's usually boring. Also I don't understand how missing out on an odd order harmonic would be a bad thing :) The reality is none of these arguments are based in a reality of what people would hear, and because of that, the arguments aren't practical.

In reality, 20 bits at 48kHz (or 64kHz) would be more than acceptable for even the most discerning of ears and probably the most practical in terms of space and fidelity, but it'd be a weird format to distribute in.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by pjscott on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:39PM (#3668991)
That's very cool, but it requires pretty high-intensity ultrasound to be noticeable. I doubt that will be the case with ordinary music.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by zohebv on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:56PM (#3669583)
> Basically, if you produce two ultrasonic frequencies, they will create an interference pattern at a much lower frequency than either of the individual frequencies.

So the interference pattern will be made up of one low frequency sound and higher frequency harmonics. Once again the higher frequency harmonics are redundant, because you only need to record the lower frequency sound.

The only possible way ultrasound can be picked up by the ear is if the ear has a non-linear response to the input sound. Going by the information in the article linked, it is highly unlikely that any significant non-linearity exists in the ear.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by runeks on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:08PM (#3668863)
It's definitely possible for two sounds to be indistinguishable when played separately, but when played together it is revealed that they are in fact different (see link below). Whether this applies for sounds with frequencies above 20kHz I don't know. I'd like to see a citation as well. Doesn't seem like it would be the hardest experiment to set up either.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cent_(music)#Sound_files

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by SpiderX on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:11PM (#3669082)
Me and my brother would sing at each other in certain tones such that we created harmonics in both our ears. It wasn't pleasant, but it was interesting. Regardless, I'd smash my equipment if it made harmonics like that.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:30PM (#3668677)
Humans will hear the impact > 20kHz frequency has on the lower frequencies, not the 30kHz frequency itself. That's been proven a million times.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by bigiain on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:32PM (#3668957)
If that is true, surely in your up thread example of recording a triangle, the "impact on lower then 20kHz frequencies" would already have happened during the recording process in between the triangle and the microphone, and would have been captured perfectly on recording equipment that's proven capable of capturing everything below 20kHz? So we'd "hear" the effect as part of the recording instead of requiring it to happen in our listening room…
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by smallblacksun on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:39PM (#3668729)
>That's been proven a million times.

Then you should be able to provide at least one citation.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:37PM (#3668721)
If you're not going to hear the frequency, then there's no reason to record it, so I don't see what you're objection is.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:27PM (#3668937)
Yes, but if you sample the frequency to create a step wave, then neglect to filter the results, you will end up reproducing tons of high frequencies. That is why we need to filter the output for signals >20KHz...to remove these harmonics that result from reproducing the square wave.

Of course, filters aren't perfect, and result in phase shift and roll-off. So we over-sample the signal to create a signal with a much higher frequency than 20KHz, so that the filtering occurs well outside the audible band, allowing us to filter out all of these harmonics without affecting the desired signal.

Basically, the end result is that by sampling the signal, you are introducing high frequency content that must be removed prior to playback. This high frequency content is one of the reasons old CD players from the 80s and 90s cause "listener fatigue", although I have no sources to back up that last statement.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by dedward on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:56PM (#3669320)
Yup... people need to get very clear in their heads the difference between the recording/sampling/mixing/mastering stages, where high bitrate/width/gear/knowledge is helpful, and playback, which is a completely different thing.

(not for eatmyshorts -you get this I gather) - everyone gets that "upsampling" can't add detail to a recording right? You can't get more than you've got.... no matter what you do. There is no magic. You upsample so you drive harmonics generated in the digital-to-analog process during playback further up in the spectrum so when you get to the analog stage you can use a nice gentle analog filter to filter them out. Without the upsampling, you need a nasty steep analog filter to filter them out, and that can have audible side-effects (or at least measurable) in the audible spectrum. eatmyshorts - correct me if I mis-stated any of that please....

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @10:16AM (#3671339)
You got it 100% correct. You upsample simply to move the frequency of the analog filter higher, with a gentle rolloff (and ideally a 1st order filter, so you introduce no phase effects) to get your final signal.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by shasta on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:45PM (#3668752)
In other words, your theory is that the superposition principle doesn't hold for sound waves.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by kragen on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @12:16AM (#3669743)
Well, the superposition principle only holds in linear media. Sound waves can propagate in linear media, but they can also propagate in nonlinear media, and any medium that can carry sound will go nonlinear at sufficiently high amplitudes.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by surrealize on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:37PM (#3668720)
Note the lack of citation
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by pragmar on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:29PM (#3668950)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overtones

I don't know about the physics of the speaker itself generating the overtone (in cabinet), but it could certainly resonate a wine glass in the room, for example.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by surrealize on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @06:43AM (#3670576)
Yes, overtones exist, and yes, overtones affect the sound, and yes, if you filtered the sound to remove overtones in the audible range then it would sound different. However, if you remove overtones outside the audible range then it will not make an audible difference (this is what xiphmont was saying in TFA).

So no, your wikipedia link is not a citation for the claim that cmer made.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by CamperBob on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:39PM (#3669547)
"A/B or GTFO," I believe is the parlance of our times.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by DanBC on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:33PM (#3668958)
Are they talking about "beat frequency" type effects?
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by qq66 on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:59PM (#3669328)
Yes. A 40KHz tone and a 41KHz tone will interfere with each other and can create 1KHz tones that are audible. Edited to correct error, thanks anechoic.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:11PM (#3669357)
No, Holosonics is not creating sound from beating, they are using heterodyning, which takes advantage of how high-amplitude ultrasonic sound waves interact with the atmosphere, that's different from beating.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by nullc on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @12:59AM (#3669830)
They don't— the air is linear (except at insane sound pressures) so there is no interference. While the ear is not linear, it doesn't respond at those frequencies.

If it really worked that way it would be trivial to demonstrate. Alas, it doesn't.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by xiphmont on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:30PM (#3668682)
> For example, the human hear will hear a 30kHz frequency if it's fundamental is 10kHz.

No. It won't.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by texel on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:00PM (#3669184)
I think you're referring to this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_fundamental

Which, since it's a psychoacoustic phenomenon, wouldn't hold true when the partials involved are above the audible spectrum.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by dedward on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:49PM (#3669299)
I know where you're going with this I think, and I'm not disagreeing outright, but wouldn't this be captured during the high-bitrate (or good analog?) recording and mixing phase if the recording/mixing/mastering engineer were doing things right? At least, as well as possible?
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by dj_axl on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:42PM (#3668741)
> The article's about distribution, not recording. I don't think anybody disputes the usefulness of higher sampling rates when recording.

Didn't read the article, so commenting out of context, however it needs to be said that in sample-based music genres the distributed music gets used as if it were a recording. Maybe then it could be argued that higher sampling/bit rates should be available, if only for those who are sampling.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by untangle on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:29PM (#3668675)
> In theory, it's true that the human hear can't hear above ~18kHz, but it can hear the influence of the very high pitch harmonics on a lower frequency.

That may well be true. But those mixed-down harmonics that are heard "live" would then be captured by the 16/44 (or whatever) sampling. IOW, the recording captures what you heard. Those upper harmonics have no emergent properties. Their effect is captured.

Bob

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by amouat on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:57PM (#3668536)
I'm no sound engineer, but as far as I can tell, the main point of that paper is that some instruments produce harmonics at frequencies greater than 20kHz, not that these frequencies matter to humans. However, section X references other papers that apparently make this claim.

Just because it is difficult to record a triangle does not necessarily mean it is impossible to accurately recreate the sound (to human ears) using 48kHz.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by glassx on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:27PM (#3668936)
> I'm no sound engineer, but as far as I can tell, the main point of that paper is that some instruments produce harmonics at frequencies greater than 20kHz, not that these frequencies matter to humans. However, section X references other papers that apparently make this claim.

Yes, you're right.

In fact, some of the section X references don't even mention hearing, they talk about "alpha-EEG rhytms" (in this case "listeners explicitly denied that the reproduced sound was affected by the ultra-tweeter") and "bone-conducted ultrasonic hearing" trough the "saccule" ("organ that responds to acceleration and gravity and may be responsible for transduction of sound after destruction of the cochlea").

--

In fact, most of the claims of the article are around the fact that there is energy over 20khz and how it can affect recording process.

This is a well known fact, and this is exactly why engineers filter out sub-sonic and super-sonic frequencies, especially today: stuff that you can't hear (or feel) will just suck your headroom and make you lose the loudness war.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:02PM (#3668561)
The only "good sounding" triangles you'll hear are those buried in a mix. Alone, it always sounds weird and "muted".

EDIT: Listen to the triangle at the beginning of Rush's YYZ. It's an old recording, but it sounds significantly worse than the analog version. It's been digitally mastered some time ago so if it was mastered today, it would probably sound better, but still not great. I heard a rumor that Rush is remastering all their albums "for iTunes" at the moment, so hopefully we'll be able to compare soon!

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by TylerE on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:49PM (#3668768)
Not a very good example, because that's a Crotale (A Flat, ~4" cymbal, basically), not a triangle.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:54PM (#3668795)
Wow! I didn't know that! All these years I was convinced it was a triangle just like pretty much everybody I guess. Thanks :)
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by FrankBooth on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:22PM (#3668921)
It's not like it has been a secret: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YYZ_%28instrumental%29
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by eatmyshorts on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:33PM (#3668965)
Yes, but our ears only hear 20Hz-20KHz. So, according to Nyquist theory, you can recreate the entire signal that the human ear hears by recording those sonic artifacts that result from interference between supersonic harmonics.

So while it's true that the human ear can't hear well above ~18KHz, and the interference between high order harmonics are audible, it's also true that a properly recorded signal, sampled at 44.1KHz, oversampled, and filtered, can reproduce the exact signal the human ear is capable of hearing. At least according to theory.

The human ear is capable of detecting sound pressure as well as sound intensity, and while playback of the interference between harmonics can be reproduced faithfully in the sound intensity realm, the sound pressure levels will differ, and it is theorized that people may be able to tell the difference between the two. However, as far as I am aware, nobody has been able to demonstrate this reliably in practice.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by tzs on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:03PM (#3669062)
What about sound outside 20-20k that affects us via mechanisms other than being directly sensed in the air by our ears? For instance, consider frequencies below 20 Hz that we can feel with our feet as vibrations in the floor, instead of hear with our ears? Or what about the possibility of sound above 20k causing a vibration in something other than our ears, which could have a subharmonic in 20-20k that gets conducted to our ears via bone?

I'd prefer recording technology to err on the side of capturing what we need to reproduce all of that, even if we aren't sure that we need it.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by panacea on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:56PM (#3669173)
>I'd prefer recording technology to err on the side of capturing what we need to reproduce all of that, even if we aren't sure that we need it.

Again, this article is about distribution, not recording.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by jwatte on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @01:42PM (#3672230)
Nyquist is true for static signals. Music is not static. Brick wall at 20 kHz and get audible phasing artifacts! (Even if your filter is phase linear)
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by retrogradeorbit on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:26PM (#3669396)
I'm an audio engineer, too, and I agree that this has been debated to death. And I agree that frequencies above the threshold of hearing are more important than standard dogma (based on Nyquist theory combined with Pure tone audiometry) allows. It helps explain how audio gear with a 100kHz bandwidth sounds clearer than gear with a 20kHz bandwidth even when they measure the same in the audible band.

Have you read the Audio Technology magazine interview with Rupert Neve?

Greg Simmons: Geoff Emerick, the famous British Producer ?

Rupert Neve: Yes, he started me off on this trail. A 48 input console had been delivered to George Martin's Air Studios, and Geoff Emerick was very unhappy about it. It was a new console, made not long after I had sold the Neve company in 1977. George Martin called me and said, "please come and make Geoff happy, while he's unhappy we can't do any work".

They'd had engineers from the company there, and so on. The danger is that if you are not sensitive to people like Geoff Emerick, and you don't respect them for what they have done, then you are not going to listen to them. Unfortunately, there was a breed of young engineers in the company ( I hasten to say this was after I sold it !) who couldn't understand what he was bitching about. So they went back to the company and just made a report saying the customer was mad and there wasn't really a problem. Leave it alone, forget it, the problem will go away. They were acting like used car salesmen. I was very angry with it. So I went and spent time there, at George Martin's request, and Geoff finally managed to show me what it was that he could hear, and then I began to hear it, too.

Now Geoff was The Golden Ears - and he still is - and he was perceiving something that I wasn't looking for. And it wasn't until I had spent some time with him, as it were, being lead by him through the sounds, that I began to pick up what he was listening to. And once I'd heard it, oh yes, then I knew what he was talking about. We measured it and found that in three out of the full 48 channels, the output transformers had not been correctly terminated and were producing a 3dB rise at 54kHz. And so people said, "oh no, he can't possible hear that". But when we corrected that problem, and it was only one capacitor that had to be added to each of those three channels, I mean, Geoff's face just lit up ! Here you have the happiness/ unhappiness mood thing the Japanese were talking about.

copy here: http://poonshead.com/Reading/Articles.aspx

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by nwhitehead on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:48PM (#3668492)
The article doesn't suggest only using 48kHz for recording and mixing. I don't think the author would disagree that recording triangles is difficult. He would argue that once you've decided what final audible frequencies you want to present to the listener, the best way to distribute them is at 16-bit 44.1/48kHz. It's a compelling case.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by newman314 on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:58PM (#3668541)
What if you want to sample the song later?

That's one thing I find concerning with the move to digital. With analog media, you can go back, re-record and get an improved result (provided the source is good) but District 9 (which was shot on Red One) will never have improved quality other than resampling because the source is set to a particular digital format with associated data quality.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by shabble on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:19PM (#3668907)
There seems to be some strange idea that analogue means 'infinite detail'. In this particular case, there's no significant difference between being limited by the original digital recording resolution and the grain size of a film recording.

"[...] provided the source is good" is begging the question; it's no different from saying "District 9 could be better if they hadn't recorded in 4k (or whatever the Red One was using) and downsampled it for my DVD" The nature of the source is irrelevant, barring the fact that film might provide a higher resolution, if film scanning technology increases, and you can afford to both capture on film, process and store your film properly (archiving film is rather difficult, I believe), and get the best quality digitisation possible.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by newman314 on Monday March 05, 2012 @08:18PM (#3669230)
Obviously, I am not claiming infinite detail. There is going to be a limit based on the grain and the size of the film (35mm, Super, IMAX). 65mm film shot is going to be of higher quality than what digital is capable of today.

While I have no doubt that digital will eventually catch up and surpass film, there inevitably is going to be a transition period where quality films were recorded (let's just say at 2k) where the input is constrained and extrapolation be the only available option.

4k is the current state of the art. It will not be so forever and because it's recorded at 4k, we can't go back and extract more dynamic range due to the limitation of the sensor. Whereas you can go back, redigitize an IMAX film (say Chronos shot in 1985) that is in good condition and get way more info than something shot on 4k yesterday.

TL;DR IMO input still absolutely matters. 35mm is not the upper limit. We went through this with photography and am now doing the same with video/film.

EDIT: After thinking more about it, here's a more extreme example. I purchased a Kodak DC20 back in the 90s (early adopter yay!), even if the camera had decent glass, there's no way I can go back to an image captured by that camera and magically get the equivalent of 22mp 5D camera by resampling. If I had used a film camera, I can get a much improved scan.

EDIT2: Here's a good example. Slumdog Millionaire was mostly shot on a SI-2K which recorded at 2k. You can't go back and get 4k output on the digital portions. So generations later, we will be stuck enjoying an Academy Award winning film at that level of quality.

http://www.siliconimaging.com/DigitalCinema/News/PR_01_31_09...

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by kalleboo on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @02:16AM (#3670032)
And we'll never be able to go back and "re-film" "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" on 32mm, it'll forever be marred by grain and poor low-light performance of 16mm. I guess I'm not sure what your point is. The best digital can present is currently worse than the best film can present, yes. That doesn't mean we shouldn't use it.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by newman314 on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @02:32AM (#3670071)
My original response was to the effect that the output should be high quality so that data is preserved if sampled.

Digital is the future. Hence it behooves us to have the maximal input & output possible at this time. Unfortunately, this is not common now and the price paid is that content created during this period will be stuck at the same quality level.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by shabble on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @08:14AM (#3670820)
I'm entirely in favour of increasing the resolution/bit-depth for video, but I think the general problem is more complicated by external factors.

The cost of renting a red one and recording straight digital vs hiring a film camera, process lab, and all the other parts needed quite possibly means that some films might never have been produced due to filming costs.

What measure of quality can compare X against X, if it was never made?

I imagine (I have very little actual experience here, so it's perfectly possible I'm wrong) that digital recording might make it easier/cheaper to retake shots/scenes repeatedly to get them right as well, offering another 2nd order quality effect.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:58PM (#3668543)
I completely disagree with the article having heard the difference many times myself. You can't record at 192kHz and hope to keep the same quality by distributing the final mix in 44.1kHz. It just doesn't work that way.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by justincormack on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:40PM (#3668735)
Well there is also the aliasing in that resampling. Recording at 192 for shipping at 48 makes more sense than shipping at 44.1 surely? Some audio seems to do 88.1 but rarely 176.2.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by astrange on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:20PM (#3668636)
Would you like to post double-blind test results?
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:27PM (#3668663)
We actually took those challenges in school :) Lots of fun if you're an audio nerd!
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by roel_v on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @08:17AM (#3670834)
OK well then, what were the results?
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by tompagenet2 on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:45PM (#3668477)
Hey cmer, thanks for posting

I don't think I understand quite what you're saying and wondered if you could explain more. You and the article both say that humans can't hear above about 20kHz. If there are higher frequencies that create a harmonic at a lower frequency (e.g. a 33kHz harmonic that produces a sound at 16.5kHz) then surely that lower harmonic (16.5kHz in this case) will be recorded by the original recording equipment assuming it is recording at a frequency at least twice that of the highest audible frequency (let's say that this would be 48kHz, although there might be other DAC-related reasons to go higher).

I'm possibly being very daft here!

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:10PM (#3668599)
Let's make things super simple. Let's say you record 4 sine waves at a 192kHz sampling rate: 15kHz, 30kHz, 45kHz and 60kHz. All 4 frequencies will be captured and the 15kHz frequency will sound different to your hear because its harmonics.

If you take this recording and master it for a CD (44.1kHz), you'll effectively get up to ~20kHz (since they're a low pass filter starting at around 16-18kHz). This means that only our first frequency will be captured: 15kHz. It will be exactly the same as if you only recorded 15kHz alone. The harmonics don't modify the fundamental frequency, they just trick the human hear. But when they're gone, they have no effect whatsoever.

Hope this helps!

EDIT: the frequency numbers I used are actually somewhat of a bad example. Harmonics are never exactly double, triple the fundamental. Those would be mostly inaudible. But you get the idea.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by tompagenet2 on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:39PM (#3668732)
I don't think I understand how it could sound different to my ear. My understanding is that my ear doesn't have the sensory equipment to detect signals above ~20kHz - this is what I was told at university, and a decent trawl of the web suggests this is still true. If there is any sound that is in the range 20Hz-20kHz then why doesn't the microphone pick it up?

Or am I wrong, and the ear is able to detect frequencies above 20kHz?

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by glassx on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:30PM (#3668686)
> Harmonics are never exactly double, triple the fundamental. Those would be mostly inaudible. But you get the idea.

Actually, they are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonics

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cynicalkane on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:40PM (#3668736)
The second half of the statement is wrong, but the first half is right. Harmonics in real-world instruments are not usually exact multiples of the fundamental. A simple diffeq model of a rigid oscillator will show you this mathematically.

An extreme example is present on modern pianos, where the high rigidity of the loud, heavy piano strings can cause tuners to stretch the lowest and highest notes as much as a half-semitone so that their harmonics are in tune with the note the next octave down or up. In other words, the first harmonic on the lowest note of a piano can be as much as 1/2 of a note sharp.

And when your oscillator is no longer one-dimensional, most harmonics aren't even close to integer multiples. The harmonics of bells, cymbals and drums are all over the place. That's what gives them their percussive sound. (Edit: some of these modes of vibration aren't harmonics in the linear sense.)

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by Anechoic on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:49PM (#3668769)
Harmonics in real-world instruments are not usually exact multiples of the fundamental. A simple diffeq model of a rigid oscillator will show you this mathematically.

That is absolutely incorrect, mathematically speaking, harmonics are by definition "integral multiples of the fundamental." (Fundamentals of Acoustics, Kinsler & Frey).

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by shabble on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:26PM (#3668935)
People from a musical, non-signals background tend to use 'harmonics' as a synonym for 'overtones' or 'partial tones', which is where the confusion arises, I suspect.

There's a measure -- inharmonicity[1] -- of how far the actual overtones of a particular instrument differ from their theoretical fundamental multiples.

[I suspect you already know this. This reply is probably for others' benefit]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inharmonicity

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cynicalkane on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:27PM (#3668938)
Then one would be forced to conclude that many instruments have no harmonics at all, which is obviously not what 'harmonic' is referring to in this thread of discussion. Why be pedantic when it's obvious what everyone is talking about?

Anyway, it's not as though mathematical literature requires you to use a term exactly one way. I had a diff eqs textbook that used the word 'harmonic' in exactly the way I used it above when I made reference to diff eqs...

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leephillips on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @09:43AM (#3671176)
> I had a diff eqs textbook that used the word 'harmonic' in exactly the [incorrect] way I used it above

So you had a textbook with a mistake in it. What book was it?

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by glassx on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:53PM (#3668785)
> And when your oscillator is no longer one-dimensional, most harmonics aren't even close to integer multiples. The harmonics of bells, cymbals and drums are all over the place. That's what gives them their percussive sound.

But those aren't harmonics, they're inharmonic partials.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by kahawe on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:00PM (#3669057)
> The harmonics don't modify the fundamental frequency, they just trick the human hear. But when they're gone, they have no effect whatsoever.

This is the part I really do not understand... either my ear CAN pick up those frequencies, maybe the harmonics are "tickling" the little hairs inside my cochlea and ultimately the frequencies I can actually hear were altered in my perception that way - or I can not hear or sense the harmonics and they physically alter the "original" wave that I end up actually hearing.

Either way, pretty much the exact same thing should happen in a studio microphone. Those all do have frequency limitations and AKG, Royer, Rode, Shure, Sennheiser, Audio Tech, what-have-you pretty much all go up to 15kHz or 20kHz according to specs, if I understand them correctly, but not further than that. If it isn't even recorded, those frequencies I also cannot hear can NOT alter my perception so they HAVE to somehow change the frequencies I can hear and are being recorded... on top of that you are making "room" for frequencies up to, say, 60kHz but I very strongly doubt your mics can go even remotely that high.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leephillips on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:57PM (#3668539)
The linked article was accurate. You are confused.

"I'm an ex-audio engineer"

Hard to believe.

"The distinct sound of the triangle constitutes of a high fundamental frequency, ballpark 10kHz"

That's a pretty high note - higher than the top key on the piano. But an "audio engineer" would know that.

"many very high-pitch harmonics"

Since the next harmonic after the fundamental would be at 20khz, which only young people can hear, and none of the others are audible to any human, I don't understand what you are talking about.

"Most of these harmonics are 20kHz."

OK, you don't either.

"it can hear the influence of the very high pitch harmonics on a lower frequency."

Sure....

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leif on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:05PM (#3668578)
You clearly have little to no musical background, and think that your basic math skills are a substitute. The overtones present in a cymbal or triangle are not straight multiples of the fundamental, they are chaotic, and are very important in determining the timbre. Anyone (and I mean that) can easily tell the difference between a cymbal with and without a low-pass filter with the threshold around 22kHz, because these "inaudible" frequencies are lost.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by mortil on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:54PM (#3668799)
If anyone can hear it, then surely it must have been verified through a double-blind test. Can you provide a citation?
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leif on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:27PM (#3669516)
I don't know of any to point you to. They probably exist, but I haven't read them. Let me know if you stir some up.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by cmer on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:12PM (#3668610)
This is a much more polite response than what I had in mind. Better this way I guess :)
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by jwatte on Tuesday March 06, 2012 @01:45PM (#3672243)
The undertones created by the high overtones are realized in the anti-aliasing filter during recording. That's not actually the reason 44 kHz sampling isn't enough.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leephillips on Monday March 05, 2012 @09:06PM (#3669343)
1: He said "harmonics", not overtones. 2: You can not hear inaudible frequencies. Because they are inaudible.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by leif on Monday March 05, 2012 @10:23PM (#3669504)
1: You're still wrong. One person's typo is not a slight against physics. 2: That's what "sarcastic quotes" are for.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by femto on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:24PM (#3668654)
Playing Devil's Advocate...

The statement that frequencies above 20kHz don't matter rests upon the assumption that the ear is linear. If the ear is not linear (I don't know whether it is not not) then frequencies above 20kHz will matter, as the ear will be able to mix higher frequencies down to less than 20kHz. For example, if we have frequencies of 56kHz and 59kHz, the ear MIGHT be able to discern a difference frequency of 3kHz. No doubt this effect could be reproduced by signal with a sampling rate of 44.1KHz, but only if the analogue systems, before the sampling stage, reproduce any non-linearity in the human ear.

Incidentally, you can get speakers that create a localised beam of sound, that the person sitting next to you cannot hear. They work by transmitting frequencies above the audible range. These high frequencies can be beamformed by a relaitively small speaker array, so the sound is localised. They then rely on the non-linearity of the ear (or maybe the air around the ear?) to mix the ultrasonic frequencies down to audible frequencies. I guess there must be non-linearity in the human auditory system!

On the subject of 24-bits my understanding is that 16-bits is adequate, provided the levels (scaling) are set correctly in the recording. What 24-bits delivers is the ability to do a crappy job of the mixing, and still end up with the full dynamic range of the human ear. 24-bits is probably a temporary solution though, as manufacturers will engage in the usual Loudness War [1], and push the signal to the top of the dynamic range. Before long 24-bit audio will be equivalent to 16-bits (since the 8 least significant bits will be unused) and the next big thing will be 32-bit audio.

Having said all that, I'd guess that the speakers will be the limiting factor in most sound systems, not the recording format.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by waqf on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:52PM (#3668783)
Nonlinearity of the ear is thought to be the explanation for sum and difference tones, which most certainly exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combination_tone.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by glassx on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:29PM (#3668672)
> Having said all that, I'd guess that the speakers will be the limiting factor in most sound systems, not the recording format.

Yes. And DACs, which normally have filters too.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by femto on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:49PM (#3668766)
Yes, though I tend to think of the reconstruction filters as being part of the recording format.

Here's an interesting article:

  http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=E5guAAAAIBAJ&sjid=d6EFAAAAIBAJ&pg=3183%2C2664048
In 1975, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation was using a head shaped microphone, which was presumably an attempt to reproduce the non-linearity of the ear. It would be interesting to do such experiments with digital sampling.

Thinking about it, if every person has a different non-linear response, in theory the only way to reproduce sound beyond a certain threshold of fidelity would be to reproduce the ultrasonic components, so each person would hear their own non-linearity. (That would be beyond what I can hear or care about, but it would be fun to play with. Beyond a certain level we also get to the point where we need to ask what it means to hear a sound.)

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by sjwright on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:17PM (#3668898)

  > the speakers will be the limiting factor
  > in most sound systems
I disagree -- in most sound systems, the room is generally the most limiting factor.

Pardon the reductio ad absurdum, but would you prefer to listen to $1,000 speakers in a dry, padded listening room, or to $100,000 speakers in a tile bathroom? Obviously the room matters; I think most people underestimate by how much.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by femto on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:34PM (#3668966)
Probably. I should have left it at "it's not the recording format" and not nominated a limiting factor.

I'd take the bathroom, given that my singing voice sounds less worse there! :-)

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by davesims on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:42PM (#3668739)
Another "ex audio engineer" here, you can believe or not at your leisure. Many hours spent in high-end recording and mastering environments.

I'm not sure what your background in audio is, but everything he says is correct. High end frequencies well past 15k and up (22.1k actually) are widely acknowledged to influence the lower frequencies and play a huge role in the perception of the quality of a recording. This is an old debate with pros and cons on both sides, but in general you'll find the "Golden Ears" mastering engineers (Stephen Marcussen, Bob Ludwig, etc.) come down on the side of higher sampling rates.

Now, if your original recording was mastered to 16/44.1, then a transfer by way of 24/192 will probably actually hurt the recording. But if you're mastering from an original analog or high-quality digital, in my experience there's no question, higher sampling rates deliver better experiences.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by sjwright on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:10PM (#3668873)
I have also spent many hours spent in high-end recording and mastering environments, and it's my observation that most engineers suffer from confirmation bias just like everyone else on the planet.

I've caught engineers using L1-Ultramaximizer (or similar) to bounce a recording down to 16-bit/44.1khz as part of the mastering process, and they're always surprised when they're completely unable to hear the difference even in the most simple cover-the-screen-and-toggle-bypass test.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by davesims on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:38PM (#3668985)
Audio, perhaps like the wine industry, is a vast bastion of confirmation bias and subjectivity, no argument there.

But I know what my ears hear, and IMO there is absolutely a vast different between 44.1 and 192. I'm not sure how you can even question it. Someone else on the thread was saying it's impossible to hear the difference between 16bit and 24bit. I don't even know what to say to that. It's like telling me the glass of Gallo "Table Red" you're drinking is as good as my '75 Lafite. All I can say is "cheers" and just enjoy.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by jff on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:47PM (#3669149)
Regarding your wine anecdote: http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2011/10/you-are-no...

If I gave you a bottle of "Table Red" with a '75 Lafite label, I'm sure you'd tell me how rich and wonderful it was. The problem here is that, as you said, "I know what my ears hear". You know you're listening to 192, wow it sure sounds great!

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by nitrogen on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:14PM (#3669087)
You just need to consider more plausible explanations for the difference you are hearing, such as low-quality sample rate conversion on the playback devices you are using, clock jitter that is less audible at 192k than 44.1k, no dithering on the 16-bit output resulting in quantization noise on quiet sounds, etc.

If you're listening to quiet music in a quiet room at high volumes on very low noise equipment, you can hear a difference in the noise floor level between dithered 16-bit and 24-bit, but at that volume level if that music (or movie) also has full-amplitude signals you'll be reaching peaks over 110dB SPL.

Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by sjwright on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:59PM (#3669051)

  > I'm not sure how you can even question it.
With evidence.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by xiphmont on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:58PM (#3668820)
As much respect as I have for Bob Ludwig's hard won mastering skills, he also strongly believes in $n,000/foot speaker cable, which is what he has installed at Gateway. So by all means give him well deserved props, but don't assume he's an expert on all aspects of audio theory or practice.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by sjwright on Monday March 05, 2012 @06:13PM (#3668887)
I've always thought the most expensive speaker cable sounds a lot better... to the wallet of the salesperson.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ... by colanderman on Monday March 05, 2012 @04:56PM (#3668529)
That data doesn't back your point at all. That data concerns what frequencies are present, not what frequencies can be heard.