Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ...
by tzs on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:03PM
(#3669062)
What about sound outside 20-20k that affects us via mechanisms other than being directly sensed in the air by our ears? For instance, consider frequencies below 20 Hz that we can feel with our feet as vibrations in the floor, instead of hear with our ears? Or what about the possibility of sound above 20k causing a vibration in something other than our ears, which could have a subharmonic in 20-20k that gets conducted to our ears via bone?
I'd prefer recording technology to err on the side of capturing what we need to reproduce all of that, even if we aren't sure that we need it.
Re:There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz ...
by panacea on Monday March 05, 2012 @07:56PM
(#3669173)
>I'd prefer recording technology to err on the side of capturing what we need to reproduce all of that, even if we aren't sure that we need it.
Again, this article is about distribution, not recording.
So while it's true that the human ear can't hear well above ~18KHz, and the interference between high order harmonics are audible, it's also true that a properly recorded signal, sampled at 44.1KHz, oversampled, and filtered, can reproduce the exact signal the human ear is capable of hearing. At least according to theory.
The human ear is capable of detecting sound pressure as well as sound intensity, and while playback of the interference between harmonics can be reproduced faithfully in the sound intensity realm, the sound pressure levels will differ, and it is theorized that people may be able to tell the difference between the two. However, as far as I am aware, nobody has been able to demonstrate this reliably in practice.