Edit: would imaging be able to delineate?
(I've had a re-torn ACL for ~8 months now. I'll get surgery eventually.)
Here’s my guess as to what it’ll suggest:
First, do the bracing protocol. Then do intensive physical therapy. If, after both of the above, you have functional instability that is adversely impacting your quality of life, consider surgery. Otherwise, don’t.
>Would imaging be able to delineate?
Seems like a strong maybe. Check out “Implications of findings” on page 7 of the paper.
Patients were considered eligible for this study if they presented within one month of acute ACL rupture confirmed on MRI. The MRI had to show full discontinuity of ACL fibers.
The following is directly from the study: “After management with the Cross Bracing Protocol, 72 out of 80 (90%) participants with complete discontinuity of the ACL at baseline had signs of ACL healing (ACL continuity) on 3-month MRI.”
They showed that for younger patients they can, through physical therapy, replace the ACL stability function with overcompensated proprioception and musculature.
I wonder what the outcome of this would be as patients get older and start to lose muscle mass.
The doctor I saw once a year prior seemed to imply this. He implored me to do specific weight exercises, and claimed if I did it right 'you wont even need that surgery.' So it must have been at least a working theory for a while?
Seems pretty definitive as healing to me.
This conservative approach could become the default for most everyone else, but for professional athletes 90% success is not going to fly.
If the original comment was about casual athletes then none of this applies.
-In November 2022, the principal investigator on this study published the results of a different study which found MRI evidence of ACL healing in 30% of patients who were randomized to physical therapy with optional delayed ACL reconstruction. [0]
-When an ACL is fully torn, the gap between the ruptured ends inhibits healing. Since the ruptured ends are in closest proximity at 90°-135° of knee flexion, this study investigated whether bracing the knee at 90° would facilitate ACL healing.
-This study lasted five years and involved 80 patients. All participants had full-thickness ACL tears (complete discontinuity of the ACL on MRI). The protocol involved four weeks of bracing the knee at 90°, followed by progressive brace adjustments that slowly increased knee range of motion. The brace was removed at 12 weeks.
-At three months, 90% of patients showed evidence of ACL healing on MRI. Moreover, MRI evidence of ACL healing was associated with better outcomes.
This is monumental.
[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9872245/