Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by tryptophan on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:12PM
(#36594806)
Having 10% not heal isn’t great… Since surgery is much more reliable I see it still being standard of care.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by collinc777 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:14PM
(#36594822)
Surgery is invasive and recovery is rough. Not sure what the data says but I would’ve liked this option
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by Robotbeat on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:22PM
(#36594858)
Standard of care could be bracing followed by surgery if it's not taking.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by ntonozzi on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:14PM
(#36594816)
How reliable is surgery?
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by pgreenwood on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:53PM
(#36595023)
No, 90% is massive if true. Speaking from experience the surgery is an absolutely brutal experience. Even though my graft was successful, if I had my time over I'm very much not sure I would make the same choice. I would at least explore other avenues. Many people do fine without an ACL. In my case my cartilage went from, in my surgeons words, pristine (post injury and before surgery), to tricompartmental osteoarthritis 18 months after the operation.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:10PM
(#36595124)
Surgery involves taking strength from another ligament (and attached muscle group) and a long and painful recovery process.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by brianpan on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:15PM
(#36595148)
Not to mention costs tens of thousands of dollars.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by paulddraper on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:00AM
(#36595385)
Surgery is expensive and ACL tears are not "critical." Showstopper for basketball, soccer, etc, but not for walking, squatting, running, etc
(I've had a re-torn ACL for ~8 months now. I'll get surgery eventually.)
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by gmerc on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:13AM
(#36598247)
You have to remember that surgery comes with very significant secondary risks (MRSA infection, etc, etc).
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by trogdor on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:50PM
(#36595007)
Last I heard, Dr. Filbay is working on a decision aid for patients.
Here’s my guess as to what it’ll suggest:
First, do the bracing protocol. Then do intensive physical therapy. If, after both of the above, you have functional instability that is adversely impacting your quality of life, consider surgery. Otherwise, don’t.
>Would imaging be able to delineate?
Seems like a strong maybe. Check out “Implications of findings” on page 7 of the paper.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by diiaann on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:14PM
(#36595142)
The only thing that's tough about this approach is you work hard at physical therapy but still you end up being the percentage that still needs surgery. Then once you get surgery you have to start all over again. I delayed ACLR personally because of a multi ligament tear and the toughest part was the burnout of starting back up again after surgery.
Re:Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical b...
by bcantrill on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:24PM
(#36595194)
I had a so-called terrible triad (MCL/ACL/meniscus) so in addition to ACL reconstruction, my surgery included meniscus debridement. I unequivocally needed surgery (it was a contact injury playing sports), and thanks to surgery made a 100% recovery (albeit with a ton of PT!). That said, if surgery can be avoided in less traumatic tears (e.g., "stop-and-pop" ACL tears) so much the better!
Edit: would imaging be able to delineate?