News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:37AM (#36588096)
> I can look out my window and straight into my neighbour's bathroom. Is that public information?

Yes. And there have been numerous court cases confirming this (why we have paparazzi taking topless photos on people on private beaches from public vantage points).

I think this is a feature, not a bug, as without a straightforward rule I don’t know how society solves this without causing more harm. If something is public, it’s public. Restricting you from looking in your neighbors open window isn’t something that can realistically be “fixed.” Other than if I don’t want my neighbor to look in, I draw the blinds. This works for paupers and billionaires.

If I don’t want people to see things, I don’t make them public. I can’t set a limit of “only people making less than $20k are allowed to view this.”

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by dawnerd on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:47AM (#36588242)
What if someone leaks info is that public now? What if someone shares my private info without permission? Should Google be allowed to train on it? How would their systems know? What about pirated other illegal content? The lines are not quite as clear to computers.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:30PM (#36589856)
IANAL, but leaking is a crime, accessing once public is not. There was a lot of this back during the height of Wikileaks where there were questions about reading classified material being a crime. It is, but once it’s leaked, it is no longer classified, so public.

So the crime would be on the leaker, not on Google for training on it.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by dawnerd on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:09PM (#36592528)
But the question is should google train against it not if it’s legal. Just because it’s public doesn’t mean you have the right to use it, I think that’s the real question we’ll need to figure out.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by snerbles on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:43PM (#36592873)
IANAL either, but I have held a security clearance and this is very dangerous advice.

Unless explicitly declassified the leaked information remains classified, and those who hold security clearances are legally required to avoid all classified information outside of their need-to-know [0].

Now if you have never held a U.S. security clearance, you're less likely to be prosecuted but the history and precedent is murky [1]. The average Joe Sixpack checking out Wikileaks is probably safe, but if I were a journalist publishing the next round of Pentagon Papers I would much rather have a small army of lawyers and a friend or two in Congress.

EDIT - Google has federal contracts, so they are probably bound by similar agreements to at least make an effort to avoid any such leaks in their training data for public-facing models.

[0] https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Foreign-Policy/2010/1207/US-to...

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/03/22/521009791...

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:18PM (#36595160)
I have a security clearance and the guidance I received (and was explicitly asked about during my recertification), is that I cannot view Wikileaks at all, and any classified material leaked there.

So I didn’t view Wikileaks or any material as I don’t want to lose my clearance.

But the question was about whether it’s legal or not to view leaked material. Security clearances are a different matter and are going a step beyond what’s legal or admissible in court or what someone would be prosecuted for.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by humanistbot on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:52AM (#36588311)
> Yes. And there have been numerous court cases confirming this

In the US. It is different in the EU. I know HN is US-centric, but tech is global and there are more people in the EU than the US.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by adventured on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:03PM (#36589438)
> but tech is global and there are more people in the EU than the US

Why would population number be the determining factor on anything? The world obviously doesn't operate based on direct democracy. India having 1.4 billion people doesn't give it a greater ability to dictate anything vs the EU, US or China. It comes down to power (always will, always has). For example, the US - for now - has the ability to dictate certain things to China on trade restrictions, given the US technology advantage. China is a legitimate superpower economically, has four times the population, and yet the US can still do that.

If the premise is consumer numbers: the US still has the EU beat even with fewer consumers, with a far larger, far more valuable economy.

Besides all of that, naturally each country (or as a union), to the extent it can, will attempt to set its own rules for tech. The US will do so, the EU will do so, China will do so, etc.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by flangola7 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @02:49PM (#36591041)
I can't think of a better metric than individual count.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by halJordan on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:42PM (#36592276)
What are the substantial differences? (I dont think there are)
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by littlestymaar on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:09PM (#36589534)
> > I can look out my window and straight into my neighbour's bathroom. Is that public information? > Yes

Not in my country at least, but if you will I van suggest another exemple: does broadcasting a movie or a song through to the public make it public good? No. We have laws (highly variable between jurisdictions) that set the rules for these “published data”, and they are actually dependent on manu factors including whether or not you're making money out of it (you can lend a DVD to your friend for free, but you cannot start a DVD-renting business without a licence from the copyright owners).

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:32PM (#36589887)
> broadcasting a movie or a song through to the public make it public good

Movies and songs are copyrighted and can’t be rebroadcast or copied without license. But viewing is perfectly legal and does not require a license.

And you can certainly start a DVD-renting business without a license from copyright holders (assuming you bought the DVD). You can’t start a dvd streaming business without a license.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by littlestymaar on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:33PM (#36591551)
> Movies and songs are copyrighted and can’t be rebroadcast or copied without license. But viewing is perfectly legal and does not require a license.

That's exactly the point: “publishing” something only gives you some limited rights (an in certain jurisdictions like mine, most of these rights are limited to individuals only, and organizations are excluded).

> And you can certainly start a DVD-renting business without a license from copyright holders (assuming you bought the DVD)

Not in my country, again.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:43PM (#36592291)
What country are you in? It sounds unusual that you can’t sell property that you’ve bought (a DVD).

Publishing are rights for the publisher, not the viewer. As a viewer, I can view the material and don’t have restrictions on whether I can remember it or not (ie, run it through an algorithm to train a model as part of the viewing).

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by littlestymaar on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @03:25AM (#36596836)
> What country are you in? It sounds unusual that you can’t sell property that you’ve bought (a DVD).

France. You can re-sell the DVD all you want, but you cannot lend them for money (because it means sharing the copyrighted material) without permission.

> As a viewer, I can view the material and don’t have restrictions on whether I can remember it or not

In m'y country you even have legal right to record it (=run it through an algorithm that “trains a model”, be it an overfitted one) for your own use, if you're an individual but not an organisation. And even for an individual, you can remember every lines of the movie, but if you make a new one with the same dialogues, then it's plagiarism.

Making something public (aka: publishing it) doesn't mean giving up all rights on it.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by abwizz on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:09PM (#36589537)
> paparazzi taking topless photos on people on private beaches from public vantage points

this is illegal almost everywhere.

e.g. in germany it is even illegal to take a picture of a person (one specific) in a public space without their consent (unless they are a person of public interest).

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:28PM (#36589822)
As long as the photo is taken from a public location, it is legal almost everywhere.

US [0] “ In the United States, photographs that are taken for editorial use in a public place generally enjoy Constitutional protection under the right of free speech.”

Denmark [1] “ you can almost without restrictions shoot anything as long as what you're seeing is visible from public property. You are allowed to shoot people, including police officers or other government officials.”

In Germany [2], you can photograph people from public locations but not if they are nude or vulnerable or in their home. “ You can’t take photos of people if it shows their helplessness.1 For example, you can’t take photos of accident victims, drunk people or nude people without their permission.”

[0] https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/what-are-the-laws-regardin...

[1] https://law.photography/law/street-photography-laws-in-denma...

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by mcbutterbunz on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:43PM (#36590048)
The link you posted [0] states there are limitations on the use. Places where you would have a reasonable expectation of privacy are not allowed to be photographed. Like at an ATM or in a public restroom.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:37PM (#36592233)
Indeed. There are limitations. Restrooms aren’t public, they are places where privacy is expected. The link I posted describes how in the US it’s perfectly legal to take a picture through someone’s open window (as long as you don’t trespass or do anything illegal to take it).

My point isn’t that there are no limitations on photography or use. My point is that if you make something public, people can view it and use it. And that’s legal. People seem confused about this that somehow consent is required for use. Not for things publicly released. (In the US and many countries at least)

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by onli on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:47PM (#36590123)
> In Germany [2], you can photograph people from public locations but not if they are nude or vulnerable or in their home. “ You can’t take photos of people if it shows their helplessness.1 For example, you can’t take photos of accident victims, drunk people or nude people without their permission.”

Not how I learned it. You can take pictures of public spaces as long as a specific person is not the focus of the picture. The other aspects, like the invasion of privacy when a person is nude, only come on top of that.

The law around questions like this is not definitive, so a lot depends on recent court decisions.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:40PM (#36592258)
The actual law is cited, so perhaps law changed since you learned it. Or you are just incorrect. According to German law and court decisions, it seems quite definitive. Although I know very little about German law, perhaps there’s some local law that supersedes regional, national, and EU law.

What I try to do is track to the actual source rather than relying on my own memory of things.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by onli on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @05:13PM (#36592550)
I see no link for the [2] in your comment. I sincerely doubt I'm wrong about this, you can read about it for example here: https://hoesmann.eu/fotos-von-gebauden-personen-und-marken-i.... It also explains under which exceptions pictures of a single person can be valid anyway, without explicit permission.

> According to German law and court decisions, it seems quite definitive.

That's impossible. Basically nothing is definitive in the german Medienrecht.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by prepend on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:15PM (#36595150)
I’m so sorry, I left out the citation and had in my clipboard.

Here is is: [2] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/photography-laws-germany

And it actually references the same article you posted.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by onli on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:09AM (#36597256)
No problem. There is https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/kunsturhg/__22.html plus https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/kunsturhg/__23.html - note that it is about distributing and publishing, but that just taking a photo can trigger this somewhat, from the article I linked above:

> Nach dem Bundesverfassungsgericht (BverfGE NJW 2000, 1021) ist bereits ab diesem Punkt [that a photo is taken] ein Kontrollverlust der ohne Einwilligung abgebildeten Person über das Bild gegeben, und dieser mögliche Kontrollverlust rechtfertigt sogar unter Umständen ein Fotografierverbot.

But that is debatable and actually the point that could be outdated.

In practice, the guide is not completely wrong: You can take pictures in public spaces and they can show people, but those people should not be the focus of the image and you might want to make them unidentifiable if you publish the image.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by vincnetas on Sunday July 09, 2023 @03:14AM (#36652348)
one thing is to take pictures of things that you as a person see. i doubt that you can use these pictures any way you like. for example use them as magazine covers without consent of depicted person. provided its a portrait. or for example for tracking people that regulary walk through same place.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by VirusNewbie on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:22PM (#36589735)
so if I take a picture of my wife on vacation in germany with someone in the background I'm breaking the law?
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by mxscho on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:31PM (#36589874)
Not necessarily, as there are other exceptions to this rule. A person can also be "Beiwerk" [1] (= accessory/props) which in the context of personality rights means that you are not the main focus point of the picture.

[1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beiwerk

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by nicbou on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:27PM (#36589819)
There are clear exceptions for people who happen to be in the picture.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by tyfon on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @01:47PM (#36590133)
It's the same in Norway.

Taking a photo of a public square with a lot of people in it is still legal without asking everyone for consent. But the topless photo example would not be legal at all without consent or even just a photo where one specific person or small group is the focus.

Edit: taking the photo itself might be ok in the latter case, but publishing it (like posting to facebook or a blog or forum) is not.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by SoftTalker on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @02:39PM (#36590895)
What if you're on the beach and taking a photo of your kid and there's a topless woman in the background. Very common in Scandinavia. And if there are German tourists there, they might be completely naked.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by wukerplank on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:06PM (#36591246)
Taking a picture vs publishing/selling a picture are separate issues.
Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by darkclouds on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @03:30PM (#36591525)
I dont think so as Kate Middleton future Queen of England found out.

******Warning****** NSFW pictures of the future Queen of England at this URL --> https://theoutsidersadi.wordpress.com/2012/09/14/click-here-...

The (UK) press get around the law, by reporting a story and then relying on the reader using search engines to get the information from other jurisdictions like I have just done here, located in UK, EU google servers, and where ever the wordpress server is located.

It kind of makes me think, what is the point of law?

You need a lot of money to fight these entities and fight them in multiple jurisdictions where relevant laws exist.

What also makes a mockery of the legal system at least the Royal lawyers is, whilst Kate Middleton has some injunction to block press publication in the UK, they cant stop the search engines from publishing the data to users in the UK, as I have just demonstrated with the link above and the search term "kate topless holiday photo" and then clicking the images option!

Now what if I meant "kate beckinsale topless photo" instead of "kate topless photo"? I just got someone elses topless photos without even expecting them, ie the future Queen of England.

Are the Royal lawyers from the stone age, do they not understand search engines or do they buy the targeted filter bubble narrative highlighted by Eli Parsier in his Ted talk?

I like German privacy, they even stood up to Google and the Streetview project, however Google have edited me from their Streetview images where I'm giving their car the bird as it drove past me so there is some human oversight, but they still have that data and refuse to hand it over via GDPR DSAR requests.

To many big entities including the Police, fulfil GDPR DSAR requests by relying on being able to identify the individual using todays existing systems.

If someone cant be identified, like my giving the Google Streetview car the bird in their streetview data, Google will say no data exists.

Yet GDPR law doesnt address developing and future technology which will be able to identify me giving the Google Streetview car the bird if they run facial recognition over their streetview data.

So the GDPR DSAR is useless law as is, although I havent read it, but I suspect Google's privacy policy is as well.

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by DropInIn on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @03:20AM (#36596790)
Yea no...

That ends up being a prohibition on taking photos in public at all except in areas devoid of others as it is impossible/unreasonable to get the written consent of all parties who would be photographed in the background of a photo of a person who requested thier photo be taken....

Re:Google's updated privacy policy states it can use public ... by scrum-treats on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @02:23PM (#36604785)
This is why situations like VisualMic and visual-based cryptoanalysis tools are troublesome (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36331446). All you need is a decent smartphone (e.g., Samsung Galaxy S22) and open-source software.

Quite a vulnerable place humans are in at present.