My point isn’t that there are no limitations on photography or use. My point is that if you make something public, people can view it and use it. And that’s legal. People seem confused about this that somehow consent is required for use. Not for things publicly released. (In the US and many countries at least)
Not how I learned it. You can take pictures of public spaces as long as a specific person is not the focus of the picture. The other aspects, like the invasion of privacy when a person is nude, only come on top of that.
The law around questions like this is not definitive, so a lot depends on recent court decisions.
What I try to do is track to the actual source rather than relying on my own memory of things.
> According to German law and court decisions, it seems quite definitive.
That's impossible. Basically nothing is definitive in the german Medienrecht.
Here is is: [2] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/photography-laws-germany
And it actually references the same article you posted.
> Nach dem Bundesverfassungsgericht (BverfGE NJW 2000, 1021) ist bereits ab diesem Punkt [that a photo is taken] ein Kontrollverlust der ohne Einwilligung abgebildeten Person über das Bild gegeben, und dieser mögliche Kontrollverlust rechtfertigt sogar unter Umständen ein Fotografierverbot.
But that is debatable and actually the point that could be outdated.
In practice, the guide is not completely wrong: You can take pictures in public spaces and they can show people, but those people should not be the focus of the image and you might want to make them unidentifiable if you publish the image.
US [0] “ In the United States, photographs that are taken for editorial use in a public place generally enjoy Constitutional protection under the right of free speech.”
Denmark [1] “ you can almost without restrictions shoot anything as long as what you're seeing is visible from public property. You are allowed to shoot people, including police officers or other government officials.”
In Germany [2], you can photograph people from public locations but not if they are nude or vulnerable or in their home. “ You can’t take photos of people if it shows their helplessness.1 For example, you can’t take photos of accident victims, drunk people or nude people without their permission.”
[0] https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/what-are-the-laws-regardin...
[1] https://law.photography/law/street-photography-laws-in-denma...