News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by xyzzyz on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:16PM (#36499434)
The recent decision didn’t so much “strike down” the protections, but rather ruled that the relevant law does not apply to the wetlands the EPA used to apply it to. There was previous ruling, which according to SCOTUS, was erroneous, and so it reversed it.

This is perfectly reasonable if you look at the original law and intent behind it, and the wetlands the federal agency no longer can claim control over. The original law was passed to protect the “navigable waters of the United States”. The agency claimed that wetlands around random creek flowing into a lake are covered, because there is a “significant nexus” between it and some navigable waters, somewhere. If you disagreed, tough luck, your best option was to appeal to the same agency, making it both judge and prosecutor in the same case, and in any case is not a practical option for a random person without deep pockets, who just want to build a house on a lake.

The ruling said that when the law says it applies to navigable waters of United States, you can apply it only to waters or wetlands that actually are navigable for purposes of interstate commerce, or are so connected to these waters to be practically indistinguishable. This is perfectly reasonable: if given wetlands are not connected to interstate navigable waters, why should they be under federal jurisdiction in the first place, especially given the plain language of the relevant law? If the state wants to protect its own waters and wetlands, it’s certainly free to do so.

Now, I believe that federal government could actually argue that the random wetlands actually can be under its jurisdiction, if they affect the water in other states, eg. through ground water flows etc. However, they will need to pass a new law to assert that, instead of leaning on old law that clearly did not mean to cover this.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:32PM (#36499599)
> Now, I believe that federal government could actually argue that the random wetlands actually can be under its jurisdiction, if they affect the water in other states, eg. through ground water flows etc. However, they will need to pass a new law to assert that, instead of leaning on old law that clearly did not mean to cover this.

You can also raise the counterpoint here: 45 years of precedent says they're included, and if you don't like it, pass a law saying it doesn't.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by zdragnar on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:42PM (#36499707)
Congress shouldn't have to constantly pass laws just to tell the executive branch that they are abusing their powers. That's what the judiciary is for.

My uncle has a small stream running through his back yard, counted as "navigable water" despite the fact that I could jump across it as a child and it wasn't deep enough to support anything but a paper boat.

I'm also not saying we shouldn't have protections for the environment, but loose interpretation of rules is how you get corruption and abuse.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by Retric on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:01PM (#36499900)
> constantly ass laws just to tell the executive branch they are abusing their powers.

Nobody is suggesting that. The basic argument is if both the executive and the judiciary misinterpret a law for decades then it’s the legislative branch’s job to correct that “misunderstanding” not the judiciary. This is why it’s called a common law, past court cases clarify the rules. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law

When president exists it’s the judiciaries job to maintain the status quo not to arbitrarily change the rules after it’s already made up its mind, unless there is some clear conflict. The fundamental principle at play is if the judicial branch can flip flop arbitrarily then president is meaningless and everything can be relitigated endlessly.

Edit: There’s many sources of conflict even without changes to the law as lower courts should be self consistent but there’s independence between them. Which might seem strange but creates some redundancy as consistent rulings reinforce precedent while conflicting rulings invite intervention by a higher court.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by ralusek on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:07PM (#36499958)
> arbitrarily change the rules after it’s already made up its mind.

It is often the precedent which was arbitrary.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by Retric on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:11PM (#36499999)
Sure, but that’s not an inherent issue. If things are arbitrary and you decide based on a coin flip then the coin flip needs to be binding or you just keep flipping coins.

There’s many other systems we could use, but existing case law has the benefit of being extremely detailed. If navigable waterways in your state is public land, what happens after a dam is installed and they’re no longer navigable? That’s the kind of thing you want to find out before you buy some property.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by ralusek on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:16PM (#36500047)
An issue down to coin flips should be seen as a signal of a bug. However, I would argue that more often than not, it's not actually down to a coin flip. There is a default position in a liberal society, and that is that of minimal authority. Every legal question is fundamentally one of "does the state have the authority to do this, and if so, at what level?" If the answer is unclear, this should always resolve to no, or if yes, at the most localized level specified.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by Retric on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:27PM (#36500133)
I edited the above comment for clarity so I don’t know if you saw it, but the benefit is allowing people to make decisions without court cases.

Most legal questions aren’t about state power but what exactly the rule is. Contracts are a huge area that has little to do with the state. Even when stuff involves the state people want to know the legal/liability/tax implications of doing X vs Y before doing something.

Ie: Do I need a permit to build an outdoor pizza oven? It doesn’t matter how arbitrarily the rule was created, you just want to know the rule and often the penalty for breaking it.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by cmh89 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:45PM (#36499731)
> That's what the judiciary is for.

Right, and the judiciary has 45 years of precedent that the wetlands are included. This radicalized illegitmate SCOTUS just threw out the protections because their corporate owners benefit from it.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by ksherlock on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:26PM (#36500121)
You don't you just hate those radicalized 9-0 SCOTUS rulings?

Chantell and Michael Sackett went to the Supreme Court twice. Twice! Unanimous rulings in their favor both times. Sacketts: 18, EPA: 0.

Due to court turnover they had 13 unique SCOTUS justices find in their favor.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by cmh89 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:27PM (#36500137)
You mean the 9-0 that says they don't have a corruption problem despite mounting evidence of decades of bribes?

Am I supposed to pretend that the liberal justices aren't also corrupt?

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by paulddraper on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:40PM (#36500261)
So what percentage of SCOTUS "legitimate"
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by cipheredStones on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:15PM (#36526088)
This is very misleading - the regulatory changes introduced by the ruling were 5-4 along ideological lines, even though the judgement in favor of the Sacketts was unanimous. In the case this year:

> The court voted unanimously to reverse the Ninth Circuit, but split 5–4 on the rationale. The majority opinion, by Alito, introduced a new test to define wetlands, which reversed five decades of EPA rule-making and limited the scope of the Clean Water Act's authority to regulate waters of the United States. Justice Brett Kavanaugh joined the three liberal justices in agreeing that the CWA did not apply to the Sacketts' property, but argued that the majority's new definition was incorrect and will have significant effects on regulated waters.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by nostromo on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:00PM (#36499881)
The whole point of a supreme court is to set precedent, as they have with many other decisions that you probably like, like Brown v. Board of Education and Obergefell v. Hodges.

Besides, laws matter. If you want something done, you have to pass a law. If you don't have the votes, then go do the work and convince more people to vote with you.

Edit: it actually wasn't set precedent from the supreme court anyway. The previous decision was split and was sent back down to the lower court, before being settled:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapanos_v._United_States

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by knome on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:14PM (#36500028)
Our laws are supposed to be interpreted via precedent. We are not a fly by night French civil system. Our legal traditions are rooted in maintaining centuries of stability within the law, altering those interpretations only in accordance with new laws.

If the courts cannot be expected to consistently interpret the law, how can citizens be sure what that law means?

To turn over fifty years of precedent on a whim is certainly within the power of the supreme court, but only in the same manner that doing a poor job of running the federal government is within the powers of the executive.

There is nothing to stop them from doing their job poorly, because they are themselves the ones responsible for setting and maintaining high standards.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by nostromo on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:53PM (#36500389)
I’m curious then if you also oppose Brown and Obergefell?
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by knome on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:20PM (#36500607)
This seems to be a sort of "gotcha" question, wherein you pose points of precedent breaking for which I am likely to support the outcome but not the process.

And you are right.

I absolutely support both same-sex marriage and the casting out of the vile separate-but-equal doctrine.

And I think both would have been better done as legislation.

When the supreme court struck down 50 years of precedent supporting the right of women to use abortion as a tool in reasonably controlling whether they would choose to go through the dangers of pregnancy, they showed precedent alone is not a dependable bulwark for the rights of the citizenry.

I also admit I find it far more reasonable for the courts to expand rights and protections than I do seeing it strip them away.

You might argue this is an expansion of rights for those that would prefer to be unhindered by regulatory oversight while destroying, polluting and mismanaging the wetlands now under their control, and I suppose it is. Though I doubt any good will come of it.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by hayst4ck on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @04:18AM (#36503758)
A lot of the conversation in this thread is "cargo cult justice." The rituals of justice are being performed, but justice isn't to be found.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult_science

> In the South Seas there is a cargo cult of people. During the war they saw airplanes land with lots of good materials, and they want the same thing to happen now. So they've arranged to imitate things like runways, to put fires along the sides of the runways, to make a wooden hut for a man to sit in, with two wooden pieces on his head like headphones and bars of bamboo sticking out like antennas—he's the controller—and they wait for the airplanes to land. They're doing everything right. The form is perfect. It looks exactly the way it looked before. But it doesn't work. No airplanes land. So I call these things cargo cult science, because they follow all the apparent precepts and forms of scientific investigation, but they're missing something essential, because the planes don't land.

You don't get democracy for participating in a voting ritual. You don't get justice for just following precedent. These things are a summation of the beliefs, norms, and actions of a society as a whole.

It is myopic to frame the conversation around precedence or individual cases. When you frame the conversation around justice, it becomes clear why it's OK to break precedence to protect rights granted by nature, but not OK to break precedence to enrich some business that pollutes the environment.

Here is one of our great founding father's (Thomas Paine) take on justice:

> Man, with respect to all those matters, is more a creature of consistency than he is aware, or than governments would wish him to believe. All the great laws of society are laws of nature. Those of trade and commerce, whether with respect to the intercourse of individuals or of nations, are laws of mutual and reciprocal interest. They are followed and obeyed, because it is the interest of the parties so to do, and not on account of any formal laws their governments may impose or interpose.

> But how often is the natural propensity to society disturbed or destroyed by the operations of government! When the latter, instead of being ingrafted on the principles of the former, assumes to exist for itself, and acts by partialities of favour and oppression, it becomes the cause of the mischiefs it ought to prevent.

Our government was acting on behalf of the citizens with brown and obergafell and is acting on behalf of corrupt individuals with citizens united, this, the overturns, or any other number of things our federalist society junta is doing.

So when the court operates on behalf of the weak and oppressed it is fulfilling it's purpose, but when it operates on behalf of the powerful and corrupt, it is denigrating the institution it claims to be and spitting in the very face of justice and crushing the idea of rule of law.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by Retric on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:04PM (#36499936)
No every level sets precedent, making precedent is a side effect not their role.

Historically only a small fraction of Supreme Court cases have overturned precedent without a conflict at lower levels.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by baryphonic on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#36500194)
Brown and Obergefell each overruled prior Supreme Court precedent. Brown overruled several decisions, including Plessy (itself one of the most asinine decisions in history).
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by liquidgecka on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:13PM (#36500025)
You use the term "This radicalized illegitimate SCOTUS" but you realize that the court was unanimous that the EPA had overstepped its authority under the law right?
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by banana_feather on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:30PM (#36500161)
There was most certainly not unanimity on the redefinition of wetlands, which is what they were talking about.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by liquidgecka on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:35PM (#36500722)
> While the nine justices agreed that the Sacketts should prevail, they divided 5-to-4 as to how far to go in limiting the EPA's authority.

https://www.npr.org/2023/05/25/1178150234/supreme-court-epa-...

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by banana_feather on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:11AM (#36502921)
I'm sorry, did you not read past the ad break? The very next paragraph is about four dissenters taking issue with the wetlands definition:

> Justice Brett Kavanaugh, joined by the court's three liberal members, disputed Alito's reading of the statute, noting that since 1977 when the CWA was amended to include adjacent wetlands, eight consecutive presidential administrations, Republican and Democratic, have interpreted the law to cover wetlands that the court has now excluded. Kavanaugh said that by narrowing the act to cover only adjoining wetlands, the court's new test will have quote "significant repercussions for water quality and flood control throughout the United States."

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by aksss on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#36500189)
> 45 years of precedent

What is this 45-year-old precedent of which you speak? The CWA itself? It's worth noting that the Sacketts have been wrapped up in challenging the agency decision in the courts for nearly 20 years. Regulatory agencies stretching the bounds of their authority until they come to a head in the courts is not unique to the CWA or the EPA, but is a phenomenon typical of the interplay between the Judiciary and Executive branch. A regulatory agency claiming their decisions are not subject to any judicial review is.. a position, I guess.

> Radicalized illegitimate SCOTUS

That comment seems quite radical. SCOTUS unanimously decided this case, FWIW. SCOTUS looked at the plain language of the statute, which seems like a great place to start and end the review. What has been determined to be illegitimate is the breadth of EPA's claimed authority under the law as written.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:00PM (#36499888)
> 45 years of precedent says they're included

Not quite.

As recently as in 2006, Rapanos decided "the CWA’s use of 'waters' encompasses 'only those relatively permanent, standing or continuously flowing bodies of water ‘forming geographic[al] features’ that are described in ordinary parlance as ‘streams, oceans, rivers, and lakes.’"

Also: "More recently, the agencies have engaged in a flurry of rulemaking defining 'the waters of the United States.' In a 2015 rule, they offered a muscular approach that would subject 'the vast majority of the nation’s water feature' to a case-by-case jurisdictional analysis. Although the rule listed a few examples of 'waters' that were excluded from regulation like '[p]uddles' and 'swimming pools,' it categorically covered other waters and wetlands, including any within 1,500 feet of interstate or traditional navigable waters. And it subjected a wider range of other waters, including any within 4,000 feet of indirect tributaries of interstate or traditional navigable waters, to a case-specific determination for significant nexus.

The agencies repealed this sweeping rule in 2019. Shortly afterwards, they replaced it with a narrower definition that limited jurisdiction to traditional navigable waters and their tributaries, lakes, and 'adjacent' wetlands. They also narrowed the definition of '[a]djacent,' limiting it to wetlands that '[a]but' covered waters, are flooded by those waters, or are separated from those waters by features like berms or barriers. This rule too did not last. After granting the EPA’s voluntary motion to remand, a District Court vacated the rule."

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-454_4g15.pdf

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by User23 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:03PM (#36499915)
This reminds me of how a court declared that San Diego's overgrown drainage system was a protected wetland and they had to offset it in order to dredge it out and keep a century flood from happening.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by panny on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:09PM (#36500508)
And on the other side, farmer suing the German government because of climate change, while she is plowing wetlands...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21407836

In fact, here's video of her plowing wetlands,

https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/its-my-home-isl...

She won her politically correct case BTW

https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/its-my-home-isl...

Hopefully Germany outlaws her existence and kicks her off wetland island. It would be poetic justice.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:40PM (#36500769)
> Hopefully Germany outlaws her existence

Welp.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by User23 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:15PM (#36501042)
And let’s not even start on how much wetland the Dutch have destroyed with their dykes.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by oatmeal1 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:35PM (#36500207)
Is it truly 45 years of precedent, or has the executive slowly taken a less strict interpretation over the years, expanding what it thinks the Act gives it jurisdiction over?
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by paulddraper on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:38PM (#36500242)
> 45 years of precedent says they're included, and if you don't like it, pass a law saying it doesn't

So.... Not a fan of Oberefell vs Hodges, I take it?

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by loeg on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:41PM (#36499699)
I don't know why you say this doesn't "strike down" protections. Isn't this exactly what "striking down" means, in the context of the US judicial system?
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by canjobear on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:17PM (#36500058)
Striking down usually means a law is invalidated because it is found unconstitutional. In this case, the issue was whether EPA's policy matched the language of a particular law or not, not whether that law itself was constitutional.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:26PM (#36499545)
> they will need to pass a new law to assert that

Exactly. The law as written was misinterpreted. Write a new law.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by willcipriano on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:28PM (#36499563)
They won't because their donors and friends don't want one. So all you'll get is impotent complaining about the supreme court.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by EMCymatics on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:33PM (#36499609)
You could argue that it was the same for roe.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by EMCymatics on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:34PM (#36499616)
They really should but it will be difficult to fund.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by winter_blue on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:43PM (#36499718)
Congress has been deadlocked for 12½ years (i.e. since January 2011) due to the Senate filibuster. Don't expect any meaningful¹ non-budgetary law to be passed until the filibuster² is gone.

Since Congress is in a comatose state, executive branch agencies have come to rely on Chevron deference and related doctrines, and the people on the courts to expand executive branch authority.

¹ Congress manages to pass a few non-budgetary laws that have broad³ bipartisan appeal, but this has the effect of excluding most meaningful legislation

² the repeal of which Sinema and Manchin blocked; so its repeal is contingent on Democrats winning a few more Senate seats

³ broad, due to the Senate filibuster, and the Hastert rule in the House: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hastert_Rule

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by nostromo on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:52PM (#36499807)
This is false. Congress continues to pass a record number of bills, and often does so with broad bipartisan support.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acts_of_the_117th_Unit...

The current situation is not at all special or ahistorical.

Every president since the founding has probably felt tempted to become a dictator and work around congress out of frustration -- thankfully we have the court system to (usually) shut them down.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by winter_blue on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:14PM (#36500029)
Many of the significant bills in the Wikipedia article are budgetary bills, which are not subject to the Senate filibuster.

I suspect the current Congress has not passed any meaningful non-budgetary legislation.

Some of the most important pending bills include restoring the Voting Rights Act (which was crippled by the conservative wing of the Supreme Court in the Shelby County v. Holder decision). That bill is still being blocked by the Republican party. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Lewis_Voting_Rights_Act

The Voting Rights Act used to be a bill that was renewed with bipartisan support, but once the Republican party realized that the invalidation of this bill made it easier to suppress minority votes in red states, they've been opposed to its renewal.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by feoren on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:16PM (#36500050)
> if given wetlands are not connected to interstate navigable waters

How many endorheic basins do we even have in the United States? And one of the major ones, the basin of the Great Salt Lake, is clearly navigable for commerce purposes (although obviously not for "interstate" commerce, which may be what matters here).

> if they affect the water in other states, eg. through ground water flows etc. However, they will need to pass a new law to assert that

Why do we need to pass a law to assert something patently obvious to everyone? All waters are connected to major U.S. rivers except those in small endorheic basins. If some random person wants to build a house on a lake (which is a euphemism for: some major corporation wants to dump toxic waste in that lake), of course that affects all downstream waters of that lake, all the way to the ocean.

Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by oatmeal1 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:03PM (#36500469)
I'd like to add to the discussion the specifics of the case that was brought to the Supreme Court: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBETD_SlpVU

This case has been 10 years in the making. In this case the EPA threatened to fine a family that wanted to develop a plot of land in a residential subdivision up to $75,000/day. The EPA claimed that because it had not yet fined the family, it's determination that their plot of land was a protected wetland under the Clean Water Act was not subject to judicial review. So the family would have a sword of Damocles hanging over their head if they decided to develop the land, but they couldn't challenge proactively that the land they wanted to develop was not in fact a protected wetland.

The Supreme Court unanimously held that the compliance order threatening the fine was subject to judicial review, leading to the second case involving this plot of land, as to whether it was in fact a protected wetland.