News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of US wetlands lost federal protection. Their fate i... by aksss on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#36500189)
> 45 years of precedent

What is this 45-year-old precedent of which you speak? The CWA itself? It's worth noting that the Sacketts have been wrapped up in challenging the agency decision in the courts for nearly 20 years. Regulatory agencies stretching the bounds of their authority until they come to a head in the courts is not unique to the CWA or the EPA, but is a phenomenon typical of the interplay between the Judiciary and Executive branch. A regulatory agency claiming their decisions are not subject to any judicial review is.. a position, I guess.

> Radicalized illegitimate SCOTUS

That comment seems quite radical. SCOTUS unanimously decided this case, FWIW. SCOTUS looked at the plain language of the statute, which seems like a great place to start and end the review. What has been determined to be illegitimate is the breadth of EPA's claimed authority under the law as written.

There are no comments on this comment yet.