The Z on ETHZ is important, ETH on its own is just (loosely) "university", the Z makes it the Zürich one ;D. There is exactly one other: EPFL in Lausanne. (And you can technically call them EPFZ and ETHL if you really want to confuse people.)
(EPF [École Polytechnique Fédérale] is just the French version of German ETH [Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule]. Funnily enough both have pretty good international reputations, but due to the primary regional language being different are rarely recognized to be the same type of Swiss education entity.)
(I mean, it's not super important to understand these two are related, but honestly I feel like it makes them even more impressive. ETHZ already has a MIT-like reputation, with EPFL not far behind. The Swiss are clearly doing something right with their technical universities. And it's a 100% quota too, these two are the only ETHs/EPFs.)
(… to be fair, yes, "Fédérale" translates to "eidgenössisch" when the source is known to be Swiss French / fr_CH, but still. Oh the joys of locale details and translating natural language…)
For extremely latency sensitive applications, I guess they will (e.g. for trading and real-time communications), but for everything else that can wait a few more milliseconds, I'd guess that the operational overhead and reduced reliability will never be worth it, especially if fiber already exists on the same path.
Each submarine cable is 12+ strands which are DWDM multiplexed to 20-40 channels at 100-400gbps.
The entire _planned_ starlink constellation has less aggregate switching capacity than a pair of current generation core routers. The market for terrestrial ethernet _routed_ 400Gbps ports is 10k+ annually and 800Gbps is just getting warmed up.
Satellite is not going to even make the slightest dent in terrestrial networking. Starlink isn't even viable without most of the traffic doing two leg ground-satellite-ground for SP-network connected ground stations. 100% of that traffic is landing on the terrestrial internet.
If you assume a pessimistic 100x over subscription and 50% waste over oceans and non serviced countries * 50mbps (upload + download) * 1.5 million customers that’s still 1.5 TBPs current capacity for customers which then doubles when you include their base stations. And they that’s today when the current 3887 Satilites which mostly v1.0 and v1.5 which have dramatically less individual bandwidth than v2.0.
PS: Also your port estimate overstates total bandwidth as each point to point link requires a port on each side, and packers make multiple hops through the internet.
Total estimate for fully deployed Starlink network is 600 TBps from my pessimistic estimate. And more like 2,000 TBps.
And nevermind that Starlink will run out of ground station / inter-satellite link capacity long before reaching the theoretical maximum.
> The entire _planned_ starlink constellation has less aggregate switching capacity than a pair of current generation core routers.
I generally agree with those estimates based on how they’re defining limits though those definitions really depend on what you care about. Aka predicting actual utilization at one end vs just considering what the satellites could physically do in ideal conditions etc. Thus the theoretical impact of direct customer to customer links for a satellite over the Atlantic for example can vary wildly.
Moreover, with a very tiny exception over antarctica or open ocean, every single packet forwarded by starlink is hitting a terrestrial link after a single ground-space-ground hop.
Nobody is going to be making backbones out of Starlink or anything that looks like Starlink. Only the people who know nothing about modern networking performance think otherwise.
Also, Starlink customer to Starlink customer is very compelling for may applications. Undersea cables for example can create much higher latency between areas than their physical separation for example Australia to Madagascar. Similarly there’s still quite a bit of point to point microwave tower connections etc that can now be cheaply replaced.
For it to be really viable as a backbone it would need to be able to do several 100 Gbit/s from one location and that Starlink cannot do (or is built to do). A single satellite has less than 100Gbit/s of RF capacity and you will only have a couple visible above you at any one time. And after that bottleneck comes the inter-satellite link capacity bottleneck which is less than half of that if the information I have found is correct (4 links à 10Gbit/s). I don't think they will be able to sell more than 10 GBit/s service to anyone and that only in not so populated areas.
A single datacenter can reach low Tbit/s of connectivity _alone_ _today_. I don't see how it could make any dent whatsoever in the backbone market.
The other usecases are a different discussion and not as dependent on very high bandwidth numbers.
First data centers very wildly in size and have connections to multiple networks for redundancy, Starlink would be very appealing from that standpoint. Also you’re underestimating bandwidth here, V2 mini are ~80Gbps full V2 weigh 2.5x as much and presumably the bandwidth difference is even higher, but they aren’t launching hardware yet so it’s unclear. Any given location several satellites above it at the current density, at 42,000 you’re talking 50+. Plus if it’s data center to Starlink customer then you’re effectively replacing a Starlink ground station so they might make such installations very cheap.
Starlink doesn't have nice overview of actual specs of future satellites, so I can only use what people have figured out or what they have published. But you are right about the number of satellites, I looked at the wrong column (it was for phase 1 and not 3), so density will indeed be much higher, so from that perspective it will be somewhat more capable (depending on fast/slow their rollout is). And it's not clear if it would actually be cheaper for SpaceX to have such customers (since some of the traffic would go to the rest of the internet - requiring ground station resources) or go elsewhere on the planet (filling up inter-satellite capacity), but that's not too much different from how regular ISPs have to plan (some customers are cheaper for them than others).
I agree, but look up global IP traffic numbers it’s just crossed 1 Pbit recently and that’s across the globe. No individual router needs to handle anything close to 1 Pbit today.
Being able to pump 40 terabits per second up to a satellite from a single uplink, as they hope, is significant-- exceeding most subocean cables.
Lines have one biiiiig advantage. They're very easy to monitor(liveness), very hard to imperceptibly tap anymore, they don't move once you put them down (generally), and if they do, you know just where to start looking.
The telescopes involved in this are strongly directional, so whomever is tampering would need to be rather close to the real uplink.
a single cable system under construction(which we are buying part of) (there are over 30) has over 120t of capacity @400G waves, but we are already discussing doing 800G waves, which will double that. We currently operate on over 7 submarine cables, one of the landing stations we operate out of has over 10 cable landing which is over 850T of capacity across all cables.
Most of my metro DF backhaul can push 16-19T down a single pair, and most of my builds are 1728 core fiber.
Starlink is very cool, it will connect ALOT of under served or simply not served people across the world, but the notion that it will even have the slightest chance at dinting the Subsea cable market is laughable.
This is not real.
Granted. More path loss, dispersion, potential for interference. The question is how well can you do?
> This is not real.
I believe ETHZ; of course there's more to do to make a practical system.
Fiber slows down Berlin <-> NYC by a lot. I usually use Wolfram Alpha for this and it's like 30ms fiber vs. 21ms vacuum.
So in theory starling could offer less hops and better latency. The detour to space isn't that bad either, ~1100km on a 6500km route, and fiber will need some extra hops and detours too.
How much latency is added by routing and switching on a typical transatlantic journey?
And a followup, are there any promising developments for moving the networking infrastructure fully to light as a carrier signal without any electron-based hardware in between?
There aren't too many common natural disasters that could take out a huge fraction of undersea cables in one go.
The amount of data going through fibres is absolutely staggering, replacing this with intersatellite links is just not going to happen. First you still need fibre to connect your ground stations (and you need quite a bit of redundancy due to weather) and there are still a lot of unsolved problems (tracking and pointing for example). However there are many interesting applications of optical satellite links and quite a few players are investing in it, the big one is actually data connections for scientific space missions.