The way you present it seems to have more problems than the 'not care' use case.
Using the word isn't the issue, it's How you use it.
Like using the word Jew. It's fine if you're saying "I'm a Jew" but not fine if you say "Get a load of that Jew over there".
Is that clear enough?
Very fitting comparison, considering "wokism" is a pseudo-religion.
Criticising something is fine, but doing it by calling the issue ‘work’ just doesn’t seem to add to any argument.
doing it by calling the issue ‘work’ just doesn’t seem to add to any argument.
Well that's what they get for typing with their fingers covered in pudding.Btw, has this subthread been pruned from from the main discussion thread ?
Are you playing a game here?
Do you agree that by using that word in that way it signals a certain type of political/ideological viewpoint?
Do you agree that if someone did not want to signal that viewpoint it they should know?
And you seriously believe this condescending way of talking down to people is great? Your choice, your opinion. Maybe reality will catch up, maybe you will catch up with reality, time will tell.
I think there's a cultural thing where once a group's use of the word is "outed" to the public the in-group doesn't like it anymore. That's how it makes me feel seeing you react like this- you're going out of your way to be on the bleeding edge of in-group linguistic fashion.
> Is it ok to use the word 'black' instead of African American? I wouldn't want to violate anyone's "civil rights".
Does that sentence imply genuine concern for the feelings of black people?
Don't be daft.
1. Did they use scare quotes to make it seem like "woke" is a nonsense concept? 2. Did they use quotes to identify that they are aware that they are perhaps using the term ackwardly, having little experience using it in discussion? 3. Are they putting it in quotes because they happen to already be mostly on your side regarding the word's offensiveness, and wanted to have a shorthand way to express that conviction without getting bogged down in the details? 4. Are they putting it in quotes as shorthand for all the ambiguity of points #1-3 and a myriad of other possible positions?
Your line of reasoning is a moral argument against using this word except in very limited circumstances where the speaker's moral stance is made clear with lots of stated qualifications- with no intent to offend, and with no possible indicated bias against any group that could be slighted by use of the term. This is a hostile norm of expectations that it makes conversations more difficult and less productive.
As far as I can perceive it, the majority of people haven't arrived at the conclusion that woke is a slur. When you are on the front lines of the linguistic fight, you're either gonna have to convince people that the word is hurtful, or at least convince them that if they use the word, bad things will happen to them. I'm not really convinced of either of these right now, and I hope that the majority of people are the same. After all, wokeness is a political stance, and it's pretty rare for descriptors of political stances to get a reputation as such a vile slur that we no longer use the word. After all, Nazi and Communist get thrown around as insults all the time, along with their non-insulting literal denotations.
I gave the benefit of the doubt and a warning that they might be misinterpreted.
> As far as I can perceive it, the majority of people haven't arrived at the conclusion that woke is a slur.
If you feel ashamed for me arguing against you, then you shouldn't as long as you were doing it out of ignorance and in good faith. However just because you are not aware of or don't believe certain things does not make them cease to exist.
You haven't given any indication that you have considered any of my points in any meaningful way. I'm just gonna accept the fact that you want to continue your linguistic mission and disengage. Judging by your comment history you have a habit of winning wars of attrition.
Please at least consider the idea that being the censorious force in the world can worsen the quality of discussion.
You are right. I need to work on not being so dismissive.
I think this correspondence would have been more appropriate and fruitful as an 'essay'/'counter-essay' instead of this social media format which tends to drive me to look for a decisive, pithy 'win'.
Sorry for railroading you and thank you for being courteous.
I like your intention, but that is impossible.
If you do not intend to be respectful, then was there ever any issue in the first place? Your disrespect will be conveyed regardless.
If you do intend to be respectful, then you will know if using it is offensive or not in your given context.
It's very easy to intend to be respectful but misread the context. Also, there are words that are so taboo they are not ok in any context.
I find it particularly hard to navigate the English taboos from a non native perspective. I believe the person asking wants to know how the word is seen by others, which is great in my opinion. Direct communication is much better than trying to guess.
I believe the person asking wants to know how the word is seen by others,
which is great in my opinion.
Unlikely. Their tell is: these “woke” timesWoke was used in line with its most common meaning and scare quotes were added. It wasn't a mistake and the context was made explicit (offending people). It was used out of ignorance, sure, but not the kind of naive ignorance you're suggesting. It was used as a dog whistle.
Unlike "the n word" which, in a familiar context, is used as a term of endearment in some groups, woke as an adjective has long since ceased to be used as anything other than a derogatory term used to vilify people you dislike.
The intent and meaning is pretty damn clear imo.
I've seen people in Brazil
We're talking about an American term (ABCD), not a Brazilian one.Saying "I want the ketchup" at the kitchen table is generally considered rude.
You can call someone else anything they consent to, even late for dinner.
The only thing insulting in ABCD is "confused".