News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by pizza on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @01:19AM (#36400033)
I strongly suspect that you don't need to actually get into a sleeping state for an attempted nap to be beneficial. It loosens the bolts of the mind a bit. As long as you can stop attending to the signals of the outside world, you free up a little brain power to do a little relaxation/mental de-fragmentation. The problem is that sometimes people feel if they didn't drift off that it was a waste of their time (usually it's people who are always busy who feel the loss of 15 minutes as the most damaging), and feel worse off after. The key idea is to be able to up-regulate or down-regulate your mental energy expenditure per unit time (or 'power') as you feel necessary. If napping affects your sleep schedule negatively, it's because you feel it gives you too high an energy level at an inappropriate time, i.e. that it negatively affects your ability to manage your energy level better at will.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by reustle on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:17AM (#36400382)
I nap regularly and sometimes even a flash nap (?) where I fall asleep for what feels like only 30-60 seconds, and I can still feel quite recharged.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by euroderf on Sunday July 02, 2023 @11:32AM (#36562393)
Same here. Methinks that even just losing consciousness does something to recharge the mind.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by kqr on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:20AM (#36400394)
One of the things I learned from researching sleep in preparation of becoming a parent is that sleep is sleep. Rest is not sleep. To get the benefits of sleep, you have to sleep.

Resting does give you benefits, but they are not those of sleep. You cannot replace sleep with rest and expect anything comparable. I don't remember the primary source but I do know it was emphasised in sleep management policies in military contexts.

That said, I agree with your overall theme. Get some relaxation and don't worry so much about the sleeping. It takes training to learn how to nap, especially in the high-stimulus environments of today. But if you stress over sleep, well, that surely won't get you to sleep!

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by thefz on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:11AM (#36401046)
> One of the things I learned from researching sleep in preparation of becoming a parent is that sleep is sleep. Rest is not sleep. To get the benefits of sleep, you have to sleep.

I agree with the parent comment you replied to.

There's a middle mental relaxation state that is not deep sleep, which will give enormous benefits for mental freshness aftwerwards. I identify it when my mind is no longer "driven" by my conscious process but is wandering off, and I am awake and aware of this status.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by sporritt on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @05:14AM (#36401507)
>I am awake and aware of this status.

I really enjoy this state, but I find it hard to keep it going for very long. Pretty soon I think about how great it is that I'm not thinking, and it's all over.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by galleywest200 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:43AM (#36403856)
Recognizing that you are thinking of nothing and especially being aware that period is now over is forward progress. Keep at it and you will be able to "meditate" much longer.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by MichaelRo on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:24AM (#36400405)
For me achieving a successful nap means getting to the stage of dreaming. If I wake up from a vivid weirdness (dreams don't make sense most of the time), then it's certain I'll feel energetic in about half an hour.

Otherwise it's some form of rest rest but I still feel tired. It's extremely annoying trying to concentrate when feeling tired.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by firecall on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:27AM (#36400434)
This would be somewhat like meditation, from how you describe it :-)

I’d often sit in my car at lunchtimes and do a guided meditation.

It did help during my corporate days.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by bowsamic on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:43AM (#36400523)
All known evidence points against this
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by JimDabell on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:51AM (#36401347)
I’ve read several articles recently that say the opposite, so I did a quick search and found multiple studies that seem to contradict you almost immediately. For instance:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19379769/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29717187/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29883710/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31852988/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34011516/

I’m certainly not arguing that the science is settled on this, but it seems far too strong a statement to say that “all known evidence points against this” when I could find several studies supporting OP’s point pretty much instantly.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by bowsamic on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @11:21AM (#36405299)
No one said that rest does nothing, but rest is still totally different from actual sleep. You aren't getting the benefits of sleep from resting. People here just want to think that it's true, because it sounds convenient
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by pizza on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:37PM (#36412287)
Not sure if it's worth bringing up but I intended for my earlier comment to be about how rest is not awful just because it's not full sleep. Which, somehow, seems to be the opposite of what people think I said. Go figure.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by bowsamic on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:18AM (#36415840)
It's beneficial in a way that is totally orthogonal to the ways in which sleeping is beneficial. If you just try and rest and never sleep, you will have all the negatives of total sleep deprivation
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by pizza on Thursday June 22, 2023 @04:40AM (#36429498)
That is true
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by Larrikin on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @03:41AM (#36400856)
After years of being on this site I strongly suspect there is absolutely no correlation between being a good software engineer and being able to extrapolate into other fields without also putting in about the same amount of studying time. A lot of people in our field are extremely logical, but there are so many posts like this where decades of research are ignored from other very smart people in favor of conclusions drawn from thinking "logically" about the problem for ten minutes similar to Aristotle. Every so often someone happens upon a good conclusion, but not usually. There are so many studies, over decades, showing these thoughts to have no grounding.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by thatjoeoverthr on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @03:50AM (#36400926)
A lot of words to insult the OP but nothing helpful or clarifying added to the conversation.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by voz_ on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @03:53AM (#36400940)
The HN way.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by keithalewis on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:51AM (#36402733)
The Dunning and Krueger approved way.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by davisoneee on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @05:26AM (#36401595)
I actually find it a helpful reminder. "People spout shit. Don't just blindly trust it". Otherwise, you end up chasing things, thinking they help, when there is little evidence backing it up other than someone's opinion.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by simmerup on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @06:58AM (#36402245)
But very true regardless. Reading HN for health advice is like talking to your barber about stock options. A way to spend time but not to get information to work off of
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by arkey on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:50AM (#36403945)
Personally I really reject the notion that an area of knowledge is strictly reserved only to those who are "officially", if you will, acknowledged as experts. On the one hand, there are many, many studies and bodies of research and so on once accepted that later have been proven wrong and even deceitful in purpose, so there go your "experts". And in the other hand there are countless examples of people sharing knowledge on topics they are "not experts" in. These are maybe more difficult to document, for obvious reasons, but at least at a personal level I've had enough of them to become keen on listening to personal anecdotes and "the wisdom of the village elders" if you get my meaning.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by bb123 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @03:57AM (#36400956)
> There are so many studies, over decades, showing these thoughts to have no grounding.

Can you be a little bit more specific? I'd be interested to hear what the counterpoint is as personally I feel refreshed after a 15 min lie down in the back of my car at work, even if I didn't perceptibly fall asleep.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by TeMPOraL on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:12AM (#36401050)
OTOH, if "simple logic" (or, often enough, thinking from first principles) seems solid, and no one seems able to point out a specific error in logic or a specific faulty assumption, and all the criticism boils down to "smart people write smart papers on this therefore you know nothing therefore you are wrong" - I'll put my bet on the "simple logic".
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by hardware2win on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:21AM (#36401119)
So you are betting on stuff that just sounds OK (because there is huge lack of knowledge)?

You can make as bullshit claims as you want that will be logically sound

The best examples of this are conspiracy theories

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by TeMPOraL on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:28AM (#36401168)
Conspiracy theories make several bad assumptions that are easy to spot once you know what they are. Sure, that's knowledge, but arguably generic one.

What I'm saying is, "you don't know a thing 'cause it's not your field" is a good heuristic in absence of any extra information, but if the logic is sound, the author seems to have high generic skills in reasoning/logic/rationality and good model of the world, and no one closer to the field is raising any specific objections, then that heuristic breaks down, as it's becoming more likely that the author got the gist of it right.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by hardware2win on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:53AM (#36401368)
I wouldnt rely nor use this approach at all, it is not only dangerous but feels useless

>logic is sound, the author seems to have high generic skills in reasoning/logic/rationality and good model of the world

What is good model of the world? The one that is coherent with yours?

Ive witnesses too many stupid ideas based on this "sounds logically" that Im fully against suggestions like this

But there is solution!

Just put effort into learning your stuff, so you aint gonna have to make a guess and waste time convincing yourself how rational your "not so educated guess" may sound

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by lumb63 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:41AM (#36403168)
I think you two are collectively very close to describing “science”. It’s good to acknowledge what we don’t definitively know, but generating testable hypothesis or theories based on experiences and known phenomena is an important step.

There are topics we don’t know the truth on, so we have to theorize. For instance, dark matter, or origins of Covid, or evolution, even. We could throw our hands in the air and say “we don’t know anything”, but part of coming into knowledge is taking an educated guess on the answer, testing it, and being right or wrong. From there, we recalibrate.

The problem comes when people dogmatically defend their old, disproven hypotheses in the face of insurmountable evidence. Not situations where people have valid critiques or are skeptical, but situations which are pretty open-and-shut. For instance, flat earth has always seemed to me to be a very obviously wrong theory.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by hutzlibu on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:55AM (#36401381)
Before the Snowden leaks, it was generally considered to be a conspiracy theory, that the NSA hacks allmost everyone, ignoring any law.

But to technical people, it was a sound theory, that proofed out to be right.

That's the difference between a theory that lizard people invented Covid, or that Kubrick shot the moon landing. Those theories fall apart very quickly, if you apply logic.

So I am no fan of appeal to authority arguments. If the experts are real experts, then they can use logic, to simply show where the layperson's arguments are flawed, where it is missing context or deep understanding of the field and point in the right direction. But if they cannot - then maybe the layperson has a point.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by arkey on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:16AM (#36415394)
Of which many have turned out to be, surprise surprise, very real and true.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by yard2010 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:25AM (#36401144)
I love your logic, but can you provide a source?
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by rjh29 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:39AM (#36401259)
This is a general problem among experts in one field. They think they are automatically experts in everything. HN comments are 90% anecdotes and no more reliable than Reddit comments, just written in an intellectual way with references to stuff like the Overton window.

Many intelligent people are heavily religious, fall for scams or believe in conspiracy theories.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by pizza on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:10AM (#36404231)
Sure, I agree with all that. Although, I have two heuristics:

- 1. listening to my body's tiredness is probably a safer general strategy than pushing myself to the brink as a general strategy. It would be extremely surprising if this was not the case, going in the face of thousands of years of folk wisdom and decades of research. I'd welcome that finding since it'd be a rich source of future discoveries, turning much of common wisdom about sleep and rest upside-down

- 2. it confirms my biases about the ideas I've liked and cherry-picked from [0], [1], [2], and [3] :^) - I'm willing to update my beliefs in the face of new analyses/results, but is there really any epistemological way for me to try to derive real life benefit in a valuation-free way? At some point one makes a lossy approximation of reality in one's desired habits. At some level this is scientism, sure, since it's dangerous to assume one's observations are reality itself, but, it keeps me happy enough with the results. And it's fun to watch the meshing together of ideas over the years, as research pierces deeper into the world's veil..

I'm not the arbiter of the mechanics of internal bodily conscious experience, however, so, grains of salt and all that ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[0] Partial sleep in the context of augmentation of brain function (2014), https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24822040/

[1] The visceral theory of sleep (2013), https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23697225/

[2] Integrated Information and State Differentiation (2016), https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4923128/

[3] Topographic-dynamic reorganisation model of dreams (TRoD) – A spatiotemporal approach (2023), https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01497...

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by playdead on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @01:22PM (#36407374)
Aristotle, well-known for thinking about things for only 10 minutes.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by Melatonic on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#36408188)
So true. And in fact I would argue that it is more often than not the opposite (they apply logic to things that are not, in fact, at all straightforward logical - like biology)
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by lukas099 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @09:32AM (#36418224)
What research says that resting without napping has no benefits?
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by dan00 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:07AM (#36401024)
It was always so draining going for lunch with work colleagues, that couldn't stop talking about work and tried to eat as fast as possible.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by hardware2win on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:17AM (#36401082)
It doesnt work for me

Lying in bed trying to sleep doesnt count as sleep

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by andy_ppp on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:29AM (#36401180)
Huberman is constantly talking about the benefits in the literature of non-sleep deep rest (NSDR) so I tend to believe the science backs you up too. Now if only I could sleep for longer than 6h :-/
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by mejutoco on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @04:40AM (#36401264)
I read somewhere that growth hormone gets released after a proper nap (not just rest, maybe 30 min or so). Body builders, and actors preparing for roles where they bulk up need to take several naps a day. I don't have a source handy, unfortunately.
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by offices on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @06:38AM (#36402081)
That sounds like an plausible excuse of two groups who buy HGH
Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by cout on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @07:03AM (#36402292)
As explained to me by a sleep doctor, sometimes people do feel as if they didn't sleep after a nap, but still feel rested. We often don't remember stage 1 or 2 sleep but that doesn't mean we didn't sleep.

So yes, a nap is valuable even if you feel you didn't drift off, but it is not necessary to invoke mental energy expenditure as an explanation.

Re:A daytime nap is good for the brain by LVB on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:23AM (#36403590)
Whether or not this is “backed up by science” (as replies have focused on), my own personal long term experiment says that for me this is absolutely the case. At a certain lull in the day I can either take some time to relax and feel rejuvenated for the remainder, or I can expect to drag throughout. “Loosen the bolts” is an apt metaphor and exactly how I feel.