News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by tlogan on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:40PM (#36273526)
So rich people (who really do not care about few dollars) will be able to drive to downtown just for run while poor ones which need it will suffer.

This is an unfortunate reality of life: wealth often equates to more available time.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by krasin on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:45PM (#36273586)
> So rich people (who really do not care about few dollars) will be able to drive to downtown just for run while poor ones which need it will suffer.

The first part is true, the second part not necessarily so, if combined with improved subway. Theoretically, it should be even possible to setup the system, where these taxes on cars to downtown directly fund subway expansion and modernization.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by aqme28 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:47PM (#36273616)
Public transit has always been the cheaper option. This just makes the difference a little larger.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by tharne on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:46PM (#36274312)
> Public transit has always been the cheaper option.

Only if don't value your time.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by crazygringo on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:06PM (#36274522)
In NYC at rush hour? Public transit is absolutely faster.

The rich lawyers who commute from Connecticut value their time, which is why they take the train. They're not driving.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by mgbmtl on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:49PM (#36273633)
There are also rich and poor people using the subway. Improving it will improve the situation for everyone.

I'm (sincerely) curious though, who are the poor people affected? Parking downtown is crazy expensive, and there are already expensive tolls around Manhattan.

There are east solutions though: charge by the weight/size of the car (the weight should already be on the car registration).

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:37PM (#36275934)
> There are also rich and poor people using the subway. Improving it will improve the situation for everyone.

Exactly. Just like more parking would improve it for everyone.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by mgbmtl on Saturday June 10, 2023 @07:21PM (#36276338)
Parking doesn't scale well. It would just improve the situation for a few people, temporarily.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by okennedy on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:50PM (#36273654)
NYC, and Manhattan specifically, is one of the rare places in the country where having a car is almost virtually unnecessary. In downtown, cars are already playthings of the rich: Just parking the car during peak hours can run you hundreds dollars of per month.

The core of NYC has walkable infrastructure and an amazing public transportation infrastructure (at least compared to much of the rest of the country). For those commuting in from suburbs, park-and-rides are already a far more cost-efficient option.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by pclmulqdq on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:13PM (#36273954)
It is now over a thousand per month for a dedicated space in Manhattan, and that seems to be about the right price.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by _rs on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:20PM (#36274059)
There are plenty of garages in Manhattan with monthly rates around 500. It really depends on neighborhood
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by jcranmer on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:47PM (#36274341)
A parking space takes up about 200 ft² (not counting things like the width of the travel lane between parking spaces), and office rent in Manhattan runs about $7-8/ft² each month.

Chances are, even at well over $1000/month, the parking infrastructure is still effectively below the cost of the space it takes up.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by NovemberWhiskey on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:33PM (#36275368)
On the other hand, a parking space is a bare concrete slab, or even a lift holding several cars over a bare concrete slab; and an office building is ... not.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by tmnvix on Sunday June 11, 2023 @07:38PM (#36286872)
As I understand it, parking buildings are actually more expensive to construct due to the engineering requirements
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by fooker on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:58PM (#36274452)
>NYC, and Manhattan specifically, is one of the rare places in the country where having a car is almost virtually unnecessary.

As long as you are okay with spending all your time in the city.

The medium to long distance public transport for going out of the city is horrible.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by dml2135 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:41PM (#36274875)
Compared to the rest of the world maybe, compared to the rest of the US, I struggle to think of anywhere better.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by fooker on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:57PM (#36277861)
The point is you still need a car, and approximately half the people (instead of 60-75% like in other cities) own cars in New York.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by MisterTea on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:07PM (#36274541)
Greyhound Buses and Amtrak don't count? I take the Amtrak to visit friends update and Maryland all the time. There's boat loads of stuff on long island as well, LIRR get you out there but it's not very walk friendly but awesome for biking.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by fooker on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:19AM (#36278372)
>Greyhound Buses and Amtrak don't count?

They work as long as very few people take them.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by insanitybit on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:10PM (#36275697)
> The medium to long distance public transport for going out of the city is horrible.

Airports are far, but we have tons of buses and trains that take you out of the city (including a train that takes you to the airport).

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by fooker on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:17AM (#36278364)
>Airports are far

That distance would be a 15 minute drive almost everywhere else.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by lotsofpulp on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:54PM (#36273702)
This “poor people will be affected more” is a tired refrain. That is always obviously true, given the consequences of being poor.

Not every solution can or has to solve the wealth/income gap. Solve congestion with one solution, solve wealth redistribution with another.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:22PM (#36274070)
Also, at least with congestion pricing, those rich drivers will be funding the public transit system that the rest of society relies on.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:29PM (#36275873)
Trickle down?
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:38PM (#36275948)
Quite the opposite, I'd call it a tax on the rich.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:48PM (#36277497)
There's no evidence the taxes will be used to improve the public transit. Where are the current improvements to the public transit? Oh right, the subway hasn't been updated in 100 years.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by rileymat2 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:05PM (#36273854)
Rationing by payment is only one strategy though. Choosing that strategy brings in wealth disparities. So it is fair to bring it up when that is the chosen strategy.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by lotsofpulp on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:26PM (#36274737)
Everything brings in wealth disparities, except for redistributing wealth. That’s an inherent part of one person having more wealth than another, it allows them to buy more.

It is a waste of time to bring it up every single time. We know being poor sucks, but that is its own issue with its own solution separate from solving too many vehicles in certain parts of Manhattan at certain times.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:30PM (#36275882)
How does increasing free parking bring in a wealth disparity? Or increasing capacity or lowering the price of public transit?
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by lotsofpulp on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:32PM (#36277069)
> How does increasing free parking bring in a wealth disparity?

Increases distances between destinations, which means more energy and time to travel between them, which means higher cost.

> Or increasing capacity or lowering the price of public transit?

This would qualify as redistributing wealth.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by grumpy_coder on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:57PM (#36275034)
The actual dollar amount also matters. London's charge has tripled since it was introduced. The unforeseen consequence of this type of charge is it becomes a lever to reduce traffic by forcing poorer people off the roads everyone pays for.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:31PM (#36275894)
How could this toll be anything of not that?
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by paganel on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:34PM (#36274200)
> is a tired refrain.

Only non-poor people can say something as reactionary as that. Or people who are not friends or relatives with poor people. A populist backlash that will bring some of the middle-class egoism down is long over-due, and not only in the States.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ethanbond on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:51PM (#36274379)
I grew up quite poor in rural Arizona, now live in NYC, and I think they should congestion charge the absolute daylights out of anyone driving through Midtown. “This will hurt poor people” is a very very bad argument in this case.

There you go, point disproven.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by jeroenhd on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:17PM (#36274635)
Setting the price based on income can help prevent the problem without disparaging the poor. It works for traffic tickets in vaeious countries so it may just as well work in anti congestion systems. That's just one approach. You can also use monthly quotas that you can't buy your way around or other restrictions.

Of course I don't expect such approaches to be a very popular approach in America, but there are ways to do it. All you need to do is let go of the idea that anything can be gained through purely monetary means.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by lotsofpulp on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:21PM (#36274682)
That is needlessly convoluted and leads to many externalities and unintended consequences.

Straight forward, simple, easy to implement and audit solutions are best for society.

Sure, let’s take wealth from richer people and give it to poorer people, but handle that via taxes, not via the road congestion pricing in certain parts of Manhattan.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:28PM (#36275865)
It’s obviously true though, isnt it? Poor people cant afford the ~$20 toll like a rich person can.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:40PM (#36275970)
If you're poor, you probably aren't driving in Manhattan in the first place.

And in all honesty, if you are driving in Manhattan, you should probably stop doing that.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:51PM (#36277509)
If you're poor, you probably aren't eating anyway. And in all honesty, if you are eating, you probably should stop doing that.

If you're poor, you probably aren't getting your cancer cured anyway. And in all honesty, if you are getting chemotherapy, you probably should stop doing that.

See how none of this makes sense?

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:58AM (#36279809)
No. As far as I'm concerned, nobody should be driving in Manhattan. Private vehicles shouldn't even be allowed here.

Congestion pricing is a compromise.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Sunday June 11, 2023 @07:01PM (#36286633)
It’s a bad compromise, one that leads to gentrification instead of betterment. Just rip off the bandaid by banning cars.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Jcowell on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:01AM (#36280982)
in the context of the area it does make sense. the Poor are majority in the outer boroughs and uptown manhattan with the only poor community I can think of near the area is in Chinatown and you would have to question: What is someone from chinatown doing with a car in FIDI? they’re not going to brooklyn since they would’ve taken the Williamsburg bridge or even the Queens Midtown tunnel. No way they’re looking to just chill at Battery Park or the seaport since the 6 train is right there.

Someone from the Bronx or Harlem could drive there for work but both places have public transportation options that makes driving not make much sense and neither places require going through downtown in order to access south brooklyn.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Sunday June 11, 2023 @10:20AM (#36281657)
You seem to be making the argument there is no one like this. But if there is no one like this, what good will banning it do?

I think we all know people find it, for one reason or another, more appropriate to take a car despite the already large cost of doing so in Manhattan. People aren’t just behaving completely illogically. If someone is driving, it’s not because they just didn’t even consider taking public transit.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday June 11, 2023 @12:34PM (#36282857)
> If someone is driving, it’s not because they just didn’t even consider taking public transit.

And in the process, they are polluting the air, making busses run more slowly, and (on average across the population) killing pedestrians. On an individual level, this person may indeed have concluded that driving is better for them than taking public transit. For society at large, however, public transit is almost always the better choice.

By making driving in Manhattan more painful for individuals, we bring it in line with the real cost for society.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Sunday June 11, 2023 @04:37PM (#36285394)
Without ceremony, you have changed arguments. Originally you were saying those people simply don’t exist. As many a police investigator has noted, changing one’s stories is the surest sign of dishonesty.

But even if we ignore this, by induced demand, open streets will simply invite more traffic. The difference is the wealth distribution of the present traffic.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:03PM (#36285646)
> Originally you were saying those people simply don’t exist.

Sorry, when I said "if you're poor, you probably aren't driving in Manhattan in the first place," I didn't mean to imply that zero low-income people drive private vehicles there. However, I do believe that the population of drivers in Manhattan is overwhelmingly higher income.

Separately, I believe that the vast majority of private vehicles should be banned in Manhattan anyway (which is what I meant by "if you are driving in Manhattan, you should probably stop doing that). If I was God Emperor of New York, I would close 4/5 streets in Manhattan to vehicles, and restrict the remaining streets to commercial trucks, busses, taxis, ambulances, and individuals who can park in handicapped parking spots. This would ensure that those who actually do need to drive can do so efficiently.

If congestion pricing gets us partway there, that's a huge win in my eyes.

> But even if we ignore this, by induced demand, open streets will simply invite more traffic.

Great, then NYC can raise the price. They should keep raising the price until the roads are clear. Then they should give that money to the MTA to improve public transit, and further tip the scales against driving.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by ironmagma on Sunday June 11, 2023 @06:53PM (#36286556)
Doing that you’ll get a couple billionaires per hour. Why not just ban driving in the city altogether? (This isn’t just a rhetorical question, really, why not just do that instead of this BS?)

Ironically I think everyone knows the answer which is that this isn’t about congestion. This is about lining pockets as much as possible.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by sigstoat on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:56PM (#36273728)
if you’re rich enough you just pay somebody else to run the errand or drive you around in an even larger vehicle.

stop freaking out about rich people being able to get something nice. they can already afford nice things. look at the overall costs/benefit analysis of the policy.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:36PM (#36275930)
You bring up a good point. It makes door dash even more expensive and even more a luxury for well off people.

Also, the argument was never that rich people cant afford nice things. So while concluding they can is easy and correct, its not accomplishing anything.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by dragontamer on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:57PM (#36273738)
Every time I go to NYC, I say F### the traffic, I'm taking the subway.

Traffic is horrible, subway is more than usable. Just walk.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by paulcole on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:00PM (#36273782)
Yes, rich people do things for fun. Poor people struggle.

It’s a particularly deep or useful insight.

What do you think should happen here instead since you’re so disappointed with the current plan? No charge for drivers going downtown? A dynamic charge based on social status/wealth?

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by BoorishBears on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:19PM (#36274030)
> A dynamic charge based on social status/wealth?

That's one I like actually, maybe something like the blue book value of the car?

I recently moved out of NYC but I remember looking forward to the congestion charge because I loved taking my greyhound to the union square dog run, which was driving distance for me. 20$ wasn't enough to affect my plans to do that, and less traffic would actually make my life way easier when I took him there.

There were plenty of people like that: totally unaffected by whatever a reasonable toll is, and actually more likely to drive if they enact it.

-

At the end of the day I don't buy that in a city like NYC we'll see the type of effect congestion pricing has had in other less connected cities. Here owning a car is already expensive, parking already cost more than people pay in rent in some places, etc. It's like stacking a regressive tax on a regressive tax, it doesn't really have the same effect.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by wcarron on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:39PM (#36274257)
> That's one I like actually, maybe something like the blue book value of the car?

Suppose two people make the same amount of money. One chooses to buy a cheaper car and pays higher rent for a nicer apt. The other, the opposite. Under your pricing scheme, you're unjustifiably charging two persons of equal means different rates.

You can adjust this many ways. One person gets a cheaper car but spends more on luxury vacations or invests more aggressively or spends large sums eating at nice restaurants often or buys expensive clothes or or or etc.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by BoorishBears on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:35PM (#36274819)
You'll always be able to imagine cases where a broad toll doesn't perfectly align with a narrow goal, why even waste energy listing them out?

Instead consider how you get the toll to actually do something: in the case of a congestion charge it's by making driving in Manhattan expensive enough to reduce how much it happens for as many people as possible.

Regardless of the corner cases you can imagine, there are more people who drive an M4 that would be unaffected by a $20 charge rate than there are people who drive an 430i. So increase the cost for the people with M4 and you've made your toll strictly more effective... even if there are people who can afford M4s and chose to drive a 430i.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by wcarron on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:09PM (#36275131)
One could also just make the base rate $150/day and then you'll definitely make it untenable for as many people as possible, which is apparently the goal. This leads to an outcome which is you think is an unfair distribution. But luxuries are necessarily for those who can afford them.

The 'cost' of the action is the same. A vehicle in the city is a vehicle is a vehicle and therefore the toll should be flat, unless that type of vehicle in particular causes more damage to roads or empirically worsens outcomes like traffic or pollution relative to other types of vehicle. Charging people more because they are wealthier is unfairly discriminatory.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by BoorishBears on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:29PM (#36275327)
Their goal isn't to make it impossible, it's to reduce it. They want you to really need to drive, not just do it because it's convenient.

It seems you might not familiar the actual toll to start, it carves out a lot of special cases for that reason: people with certain incomes are exempt if they already live in the area, ride-shares have special rules, they excluded corridors around the edges of the city, etc.

You're also confused on cost here. It's not cost to the city they're trying to change with a toll (that'd be nonsensical) it's cost to the driver. If cost is hard for you to follow, think of it as "attractiveness".

They want driving to be unattractive, not impossible, not untenable... just unattractive.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by TheCleric on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:46PM (#36274918)
> regressive tax

I don't think that word means what you think it means.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by BoorishBears on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:31PM (#36275345)
It does, but if you'll elaborate on your incorrect understanding I'd be happy to educate you: https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/fhwahop08040/cp_prim5_...

> most forms of transportation finance—fuel taxes, sales taxes, and tolls—are regressive forms of taxation in that they burden the poor more than they do the rich.

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by TheCleric on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:50PM (#36277824)
I agree with you, and the source, that most transportation taxes are regressive. Where you lose me is that THIS one is. Driving into Manhattan isn't something the vast majority of poorer commuters are doing.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by bradleyjg on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:02PM (#36273811)
Where are these poor people who truly need to come downtown by car parking?
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by MengerSponge on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:13PM (#36273963)
I imagine there are literally thousands of them (/s)
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by jupp0r on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:12PM (#36273951)
Not sure how familiar you are with the realities of driving a car in Lower Manhattan, but as somebody who has visited the place a few times, I can assure you that poor people cannot afford parking there on a regular basis already.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:12PM (#36274597)
Midtown when I was there had free street parking (maybe it still does?), and it made more sense financially for my girlfriend at the time to drive rather than grab a train from Harlem to Hawthorne (north of white plains, the office wasn’t near the train station so that last link wasn’t really covered). I was honestly surprised driving was…so convenient in that part of NYC at least, but midtown is definitely not Manhattan, and also a reverse commute.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by rafram on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:59AM (#36281441)
> I was honestly surprised driving was…so convenient in that part of NYC at least, but midtown is definitely not Manhattan, and also a reverse commute.

Midtown Manhattan isn’t Manhattan?

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 11, 2023 @11:41AM (#36282413)
I’m not sure why I knew it as midtown then, but the area I’m talking about is the north side of Central Park where Columbia university is. Harlem is the closest train stop to get to Westchester county. According to wiki it’s called the upper west side of Manhattan.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by rafram on Sunday June 11, 2023 @12:44PM (#36282943)
Harlem is also a neighborhood of Manhattan. Manhattan is the entirety of Manhattan Island plus Marble Hill (a tiny neighborhood on the mainland to the north).
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by m3kw9 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:39PM (#36274250)
If you are so poor with a car but can afford gas that a few dollar toll will wreck you, you really should just take public transportation. There will be rare legit cases but when was the last time they made everyone happy with decisions?
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by kepler1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:51PM (#36274383)
What's your point?

Everything with a price is unkind to poor people.

So you can't do anything that affects poor people? What rule/principle are you suggesting then, to get anything done?

Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by nonethewiser on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:26PM (#36275835)
It is literally this. Decongesting the streets for rich people.
Re:New York City will charge drivers going downtown. Other c... by sacnoradhq on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:10AM (#36278985)
This is the problem of toll roads and express lanes and creating a pseudo private system that monetizes the public commonwealth. Public-private partnerships are another cash grab.