This lack of consensus in the empirical findings indicates the inherent difficulties with measuring such correlations [between government spending and GDP] in a complex economy.
And most fiscal conservatives have better things to conserve than food stamps. Let's talk about where the money really goes. Oh, wait, white elephant in the room.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870447150457444...
As I've quoted elsewhere, this is from the study by Romer and Romer. http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~cromer/RomerDraft307.pdf http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~cromer/RomerDraft307.pdf
You (mostly) had me up to the first point.
How are food stamps a positive / negative on crime?
I think this hypothesis has sociological and psychological merit, and I'm sure its been tested before, though I don't know of any studies off-hand.
Obviously that's conjecture, and all poor people aren't criminals (and all criminals are not poor), but it's not a leap of logic to say poverty can lead normally straight people to mentally justify committing a crime. Welfare programs can and do help people get back on their feet.
Living in Michigan, almost all of my family became unemployed as a result of the factories closing down. Some took the assistance to get retraining and find another job, and some took maintaining the assistance as their new job or as a retirement package. Some just weren't able to get back into the job market no matter how they tried. I got out of my state's "No Worker Left Behind" retraining assistance just before the new governor shut down the incredibly successful program.
It's a combination of willingness to work and ability to work. Welfare programs can do no more than take basic survival off your "worries" list.
Government spending isn't a drain. It is another piston in the financial engine. It also happens to be one of the most reliable and most pliable pistons in the engine.
You can think of the government as Herouku. Most of the time you're going to want to run as few instances as possible. When you make the front page of hackernews, you either need to jack up the instances or your site crashes.
We're drawing our lines in the wrong places. Some government spending is good. In some cases, massive government spending is good. A lot of the time the private markets do a better job. Sometimes they don't.
Paying food stamps is a great way to reduce crime and bolster the stability of your country. If you ignore the root causes you get long term issues. We need to fix the underlying problem and keep paying for food stamps. You can do both at the same time.