News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by bluenose69 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:11PM (#36249133)
Perhaps this is true in the field discussed in the essay, but in my field (a natural science) formatting is taken care of with latex stylesheets, so the effort of switching to another journal format usually amounts to changing a few lines. Of course there can be small details such as whether a given journal wants keywords, but dealing with such things doesn't take much time.

The problem of switching to another journal is also overplayed in the essay, at least in my field. I don't know of many people who "shop" for journals to accept their work. Usually you know the right journal, and if the paper is rejected you just give up on it. Perhaps this is discipline-specific, though. (The essay is restricted to biomedical fields.)

As a reviewer, I've never spent any time on journal rules. If the paper gets accepted, it's up to the technical editor to impose rules.

Most authors employ the proper latex stylesheets from the first rough draft. They also use section headings that fit the journal's conventions, and so forth.

I suppose it is possible that people in biomedical fields (are there any here on HN?) tend to submit to multiple journals before their work is accepted. But I sort of doubt that reviewers reject papers based on things like italics or citation formatting, so if folks are submitting to a lot of journals, maybe their work just isn't highly regarded by their peers.

Basically there is no issue here, at least in my field. It's an unconvincing essay, and not one that encouraged me to waste time looking up the original work.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by Al-Khwarizmi on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:33PM (#36249475)
In my CS subfield we use latex, but switching journals still tends to be a huge pain, as many use extremely brittle templates that can easily create incompatibilities and make the paper not compile if you don't spend considerable amounts of time debugging after making the change. In addition, different journals have different length limits, word limits, structural requirements, one vs. two column (which may make your figures overflow), what goes in the main text vs. supplementary material, etc., so basically what the post says. At least, ChatGPT seems to be very good at cutting text to try and fit length limits.

And no one gives up with a paper, although this might have more to do with location than discipline (the academic evaluation system in my country is heavily metrics-based, having indexed papers is what makes or breaks careers). People resubmit and resubmit and resubmit, typically to venues with a progressively lower bar, until the paper is accepted.

In CS we also have competitive conference publications and, at least in my subfield, they don't have these problems to such a great extent as journals (as at least their latex templates tend to be decent, and some of them have the same length limits). One of the reasons why I prefer conference to journal publications.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by physPop on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:20PM (#36249256)
It’s a huge issue in most fields. No one uses latex anymore outside of niches like math and physics.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by dev_tty01 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:28PM (#36249407)
>No one uses latex anymore

Not true. IEEE, one of the largest professional orgs, accepts Latex. So does ACM, a huge comp sci org. I'm not familiar with others, but wouldn't be surprised if many others still accept Latex.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by eldaisfish on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:40PM (#36249562)
How many IEEE papers are submitted using the latex template? I wonder, because word-style formatting can be spotted in several of their papers.

Latex is a giant pain to use - and i say this as someone who still uses it to write scientific articles. Services like overleaf exist but that is sometimes not an option with proprietary work.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by jvanderbot on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:31PM (#36249437)
Aiaa, aaai, many others follow as well. Its ubiquitous.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by eddieh on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:45PM (#36249628)
Depends on the specific publication/conference within the org. ACM accepts LaTeX or Word. I always write in LaTeX, but got a paper accepted to an ACM conference that wanted Word and my beautiful photo ready paper got borked in the final print. I guess there is significant interest in authoring ACM papers in Word[0].

[0] https://www.acm.org/publications/proceedings-template

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by jvanderbot on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:30PM (#36249430)
Roboticist here: we use it.

Aerospace generally does too.

Computer vision seems to.

In fact I think most tech related journals do, iirc.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by pbasista on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:25PM (#36249339)
> No one uses latex anymore

That is a very broad statement. Do you have any data to back it up?

Do you suggest that it was used in the past but that has changed? If so, why?

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by noslenwerdna on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:28PM (#36249397)
Wait, math and physics are niche?
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by tut-urut-utut on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:33PM (#36249478)
Of course, if the person comes from the gender studies background.

/s - because people with that background have broken sarcasm detector.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by dang on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:29PM (#36251409)
Your account has continued to post unsubstantive and flamebait comments to HN, a lot of them, after we asked you to stop. We're going to have to ban you if you keep doing this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by ashton314 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:32PM (#36249456)
CS PhD student here. Everyone uses LaTeX.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by PartiallyTyped on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:22PM (#36249297)
Well, we should go back to that, or something that is easier.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by sebzim4500 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:25PM (#36249348)
I've been shilling https://typst.app/ to anyone who will listen (and some who won't), it's great.

There are still missing features compared to latex, but what exists seems so much more intuitive.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by abdullahkhalids on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:32PM (#36249451)
[deleted]
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by Al-Khwarizmi on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:35PM (#36249497)
It seems to be on github with an Apache license (https://github.com/typst/typst). Is there a catch I'm not seeing?
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by sebzim4500 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:46PM (#36249651)
He's probably upset that the online editor is closed source. Personally I think that's a reasonable monetization strategy long term.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by Al-Khwarizmi on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:30AM (#36254531)
In Latex, the online editor i know (Overleaf) is also closed source.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by stevejpurves on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:13AM (#36254394)
The fast pdf generation is great but I lament on their choice of markup language, why create yet another? I'm a fan of writing content in markdown and there is at least on markdown flavour (MyST markdown) that gives the essential writing features needed for papers. (citations, cross references, figures, tables)
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by PartiallyTyped on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:40AM (#36256352)
I can see why! Many thanks fren, this will likely make my life easier. Much appreciated!
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by ls612 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:01PM (#36250476)
Latex is ubiquitous in Economics.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by jltsiren on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:47PM (#36249656)
> Perhaps this is true in the field discussed in the essay, but in my field (a natural science) formatting is taken care of with latex stylesheets, so the effort of switching to another journal format usually amounts to changing a few lines.

That doesn't sound like the LaTeX I use. When you switch to another stylesheet, it often changes key dimensions such as page size and the number of columns. Then you have to reformat and possibly even redesign the figures, tables, equations, pseudocode, and so on. And it's quite likely that some packages you are using don't work properly with the new stylesheet, or even don't work at all, so you get some weird issues to debug.

But that's about the technical layout, which isn't the concern here, as the publisher is usually responsible for that. In biomedical fields, manuscripts are usually just Word documents with some basic formatting. The real issue is that different journals have different ideas about the length, content, and structure of the paper. When you switch to another journal, the paper itself often needs a major revision.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by rowanc1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:57PM (#36250421)
One possibility is to use a tool like MyST Markdown, which can export to many different LaTeX templates, or create a website.

https://myst-tools.org/docs/mystjs/creating-pdf-documents

Then the switching of templates actually is one line. There is also hope to get a bit further in the publishers system (which ultimately needs JATS XML), because MyST can also export to JATS (which is used for pubmed etc.).

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by ketzu on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:53PM (#36249709)
In my CS field, it is common to submit to different conferences at least if a paper gets rejected (because rejections can be very superficial). Fitting for a new conference template often also imposes rewrites, because of different length requirements, changes in length in the new latex template, different accessibility support (e.g., image descriptions in acm) and many more subtle changes. It was a major pain for me. Conferences especially have this problem because they lack major revisions and instead reject. But they are the goto way of publishing.

The journals I interacted with were less of a problem, as they just handed out major revisions. The only rejection I remember was with a recommendation for a more fitting journal.

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by ricksunny on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:09PM (#36249916)
>(are there any here on HN?)

While I'm not slinging manuscriots left & rught, my coauthor and I got the below linked one into Frontiers last year. The reviewers' feedback was all based on the substance. The formst we had submitted was Google Docs printed to PDF. There might have been a standard Frontiers template or font choice I started from from the outset, I can't remember but I definitely wasn't using their standard reference format in-line in the manuscript, as doing so would have made some sections and tables nigh-on unreadable for the reviewers without a lot of formatting effort.

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphar.2022.9099...

Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by TechBro8615 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:15PM (#36251866)
Anyone in CS will use LaTeX with no problem. But the average biologist who is publishing a paper doesn't want to also learn some esoteric pseudo programming language just to format their papers. They'd rather write in Word.
Re:Millions of dollars in time wasted making papers fit jour... by hedora on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:22PM (#36251922)
It hadn't occurred to me that dealing with sleazy publishers also implied wasting huge amounts of time on some not-Latex submission format.

I hope PLOS (and whatever similar things have sprouted up) take the hint, and allow non-time-wasting submission formats.