News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by AlexandrB on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:58AM (#36211326)
It's interesting to watch Reddit lose control of the narrative on this. If you read the relevant threads Reddit admins swear up and down that the new API pricing is reasonable and not intended to kill third party apps.

Whatever their intent, it's definitely a failure on the PR front.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:41AM (#36211745)
* * *
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:50AM (#36211849)
> I'm sure the number crunchers have Declared that it's reasonable

They would have to come up with a very hard to understand reason behind it though.

Even napkin math shows their numbers to be undefensible and malicious. The very obvious reason behind them is to kill 3rd parties and force people into the official app.

The apollo dev for iOS said 50 million queries was 166$ on imgur which is owned by the same company as reddit and has higher server costs due to images being more expensive to host. Reddit is asking for 12,000 for that many queries.

166 < 12000 and that 2 orders of magnitude are incomprehensible in terms of any technical reason to serve some comments and text posts...

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by pixl97 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:58AM (#36211936)
Heh maybe they are giving us insight into how out of control their operating costs are.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by krageon on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:51AM (#36213711)
Such corporations don't price things based on operating cost. They price them based on what they want to have. The two are only tangentially related (though you can bet that if the costs go up, the price will too. It's just that the price also rises if a middle manager was annoyed with their toilet paper that morning).
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:30AM (#36214374)
> The apollo dev for iOS said 50 million queries was 166$ on imgur which is owned by the same company as reddit and has higher server costs due to images being more expensive to host. Reddit is asking for 12,000 for that many queries.

imgur costs $3k per 50m requests: https://rapidapi.com/imgur/api/imgur-9/pricing

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:34AM (#36214427)
From the Apollo creaator himself

https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/13ws4w3/had_a_ca...

Citing the specific piece of text

> For reference, I pay Imgur (a site similar to Reddit in user base and media) $166 for the same 50 million API calls.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:41AM (#36214551)
He may have some negotiated heavy discounted plan for now from whatever reason, it doesn't mean all internet owes him discounted plans too.

Or he is just not truthful, we can't check.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by sputter_token on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:37PM (#36215430)
I believe he mentioned elsewhere that he is grandfathered into an older price but even the non-grandfathered price is much lower than what Reddit is going to charge. Another issue he mentioned in an interview is that the price changes are going into effect in 30 days and he can't pass the cost onto annual subscribers for another year. Other companies have given longer time frames when making changes to API pricing.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:42PM (#36215512)
> price is much lower

4x is not much lower given difference in capital investments and complexity of product

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:01PM (#36214818)
He also presents his math, related to cost per user in terms of revenue and reddits proposed API cost is 20x average reveneue per user in any similar business model plan.

Now I get not every platform users spend the same, and notoriously Apple users can be charged more (see doordash and uber being caught with charging more to those users). I however doubt that reddit users, notoriously hard to monetise, are somehow 20x more valuable than any other user in any other social media that is ad revenue based...

Whether you believe the apollo cretaor on his imgur pricing, or you beieve him or not on any other part of his post. The numbers very much point towards malicious pricing. And they are, in so far as they are presented, indefensible.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:12PM (#36215000)
> He also presents his math, related to cost per user in terms of revenue and reddits proposed API cost is 20x average reveneue per user in any similar business model plan.

he gets traffic and potential Ads views from reddit, and can't monetize it well enough. Sounds also not like reddit's problem.

> The numbers very much point towards malicious pricing. And they are, in so far as they are presented, indefensible.

this is pure handwaving without any supporting evidence. Counter-example has been provided: imgur charges similar price on standard plans.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:18PM (#36215079)
Reddit makes 12c per user per month and are asking for about 2.5$ per user per month for 3rd parties.

> Counter-example has been provided: imgur charges similar price on standard plans.

Imgur presents 1/4 of the price for a more expensive hosting option. Even if you refuse to ignore his own quoted price, Reddit still comes off insanely overpriced.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#36215189)
> Reddit makes 12c per user per month and are asking for about 2.5$ per user per month for 3rd parties.

How did you arrive to 12c and $2.5? Also, is it expensive? Okta for example charges $2 just for sign in: https://www.okta.com/pricing/

> more expensive hosting option.

this is again your speculations without any evidence. Reddit is much more complicated product with img and video hosting.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:30PM (#36215305)
> How did you arrive to 12c and $2.5?

You could just read the link of what was sent to you, idk might help with having an actual conversation.

here is the relevant text.

> the average Apollo user uses 344 requests per day, which would cost $2.50 per month

> https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/reddit-users-are-the-least-v...

> So at generous estimates of $600M and 430M monthly active users, that's $1.40 per user per year, or $0.12 monthly. These own numbers they've given are also seemingly inline with industry estimates as well

In other words the expected price for reddit per user is 12 cents but their pricing model for APIs is retaliatory at 20x that price.

> Also, is it expensive?

Charging 20x what you make yourself, and again 4 times more than a similar offering?

> Reddit is much more complicated product with img and video hosting.

No it fucking isn't. 90% of reddit is text by volume and most of it is super short tokens too. Reddit is so uncomplicated you can make it a 1st year uni proyect to make a backend and front end with nested comments and a text post saved in a db.

it is so uncomplicated most of its work behind the scenes for the apst 6 years has been on monetisation, such as the new ads, the nfts, the reddit premium, the reddit awards etc. thats where all dev time has gone, because the actual website itself is uncomplicated

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:37PM (#36215432)
> the average Apollo user uses 344 requests per day, which would cost $2.50 per month

I think you comparing very different users: power users with 344 reqs per day, many of who are moderator, and some monthly user who visited reddit once a month.

Internet says reddit has 50m daily users, I think you should compare that number.

Also, for 344 reqs we would need to trust apollo dev words, which I don't from obvious reasons.

> No it fucking isn't.

sorry, dont want to comment your unsupported claims anymore.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by nemothekid on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:55PM (#36215742)
>Also, for 344 reqs we would need to trust apollo dev words, which I don't from obvious reasons.

That number was corroborated by Reddit themselves.[1] There is no reason to assume malice on the side of Apollo. Regardless, $2/user is still a ridiculous ask for a social media site. That is $24/year/user. If you divide Facebook's entire expenditure for 2022 (where they pissed away billions on metaverse), and divide that by their MAU, you get a cost of $21/year/user. You really think Reddit's cost per user is higher than Facebook+Instagram+Whatsapp+Metaverse combined? The number just isn't realistic.

[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/13wshdp/api_update...

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:05PM (#36215897)
> That number was corroborated by Reddit themselves

Ok, and it says other apps do 2.5x times less than that.

> There is no reason to assume malice on the side of Apollo.

There are very strong reasons: guy is trying to protect his business, he uses discounted imgur numbers as basis and doesn't mention standard plan numbers, so he is working hard to distort facts.

> Regardless, $2/user is still a ridiculous ask for a social media site

Its hyper active user given 345 daily requests, not just your regular user with few monthly visits.

For example 345 reqs * 1% CTR * 10c per click will give you $10 of monthly Ads revenue if you put one Ad on each page.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Arkhaine_kupo on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:18AM (#36225864)
> Ok, and it says other apps do 2.5x times less than that.

They also have less than 2.5 the number of users. Counting the total is a very silly way to pretend the usage is high...

> There are very strong reasons: guy is trying to protect his business, he uses discounted imgur numbers as basis and doesn't mention standard plan numbers, so he is working hard to distort facts.

Those are not strong reasons. He uses the current best availeble data he has, which is comparable API plans he is working with.

He is very, very generous when calculating Reddit revenue. When they published their 100 million revenue quarter Fidelity valued their investment in reddit at 100million, they now value it at 60 which is a 40% drop since then.

Despite this, Christian considers their quarterly revenue 2x what it was at their peak, and adds 150 million on top to round the number to 600 mill annual. Most industry estimates do not go past 350. He borderline doubled their revenue for his napkin calculations.

So no, there are no strong reasons to believe he was lying about his math when he goes out of his way to be unexplainably kind to reddits revenue numbers.

> Its hyper active user given 345 daily requests, not just your regular user with few monthly visits.

Depending on how the api is set up you can have. 1 request for the front page, 1 request for the post itself, 1 request for the top 100 comments. scroll a bit, anoher request for the next 100 comments.

That is 4 requests for 1 user by checking one post and seeing a bit of what the conversation is. 34 requests a day is about 10 posts and some frontpage/sub scrolling. That is pretty light use for someone who uses Reddit daily, and its basically patheitc use for Mods who have to put in hundreds of monthly free hours at keeping communities civil.

> For example 345 reqs * 1% CTR * 10c

You have 0 chance of getting those rates on reddit, for a number of reasons.

One is that many reqs are on posts with no ads embbeded. two is that 1% ctr is high for reddit. and 3 is because reddit has awful conversion metrics and you are not getting 10c per click.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/reddit-users-are-the-least-v...

They have tried soo hard to increase ARPU and so far they havent cracked past 0.6$ when industry leaders fly past 7$ per user.

So reddit is losing fuck all from those 345 requests, and instead is gonna lose a huge hosts of mods, which will make the site more toxic, harder to advertise and crater their ARPU again making Fidelitys 40% loss since 2018 look like child's play.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Deathmax on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @04:54AM (#36224490)
> Okta for example charges $2 just for sign in: https://www.okta.com/pricing/

You're looking at the wrong product, $2/user/month is for their Workforce Identity Cloud, so auth for employees, not end users.

For a comparable market segment, Auth0 (acquired by Okta) which serves the B2C market charges significantly less [1]. Taking the B2C Professional plan at 1000 MAU which has the highest pricing per user due to lack of volume discounts costs $240/month for 1000 users ($0.24/user/month). Scaling up to the limit of publicly available pricing, at 10000 users Auth0 will only charge $0.15/user/month.

[1]: https://auth0.com/pricing

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:04AM (#36225749)
> so auth for employees, not end users.

and what is the difference in context of this discussion?

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by causi on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:55PM (#36216617)
Imgur is also highly anti-user and went through its own "if you don't use our app we will strangle you to death" process a few years ago where they slowly stripped features one by one from the mobile site.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by lkjdsklf on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:22PM (#36215169)
Not that it's really relevant to your point, but imgur is not owned by the same company as reddit.

Reddit is owned by advanced publications which is a huge media conglomerate. Sort of. They have the largest stake in reddit. Reddit spun off of conde nast a few years ago.

imgur is owned by medialab who also own things like kik and worldstar.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by tjpnz on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:38AM (#36211712)
That might be true for the admins but for people further up the chain things are going exactly to plan. Third party apps absolutely aren't going to be part of Reddit's future, as evidenced by their ridiculous pricing model.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by guidedlight on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:05AM (#36211392)
The timing is interesting. I’m convinced their API’s are either being abused, or will be imminently abused by LLM training.

I wonder how much third party apps are being caught up in this other issue.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by skeyo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:08AM (#36211410)
My initial thought on the timing is how much it coincides with the timing of Twitter's API becoming ridiculously expensive ($42k/mo). That maybe Reddit thought they could hop on that bandwagon and make some coin. But LLM also makes a ton of sense.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by nicce on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:11AM (#36211442)
LLM does not make much sense anymore to be fair. Too late. They should have closed the APIs years ago.

Biggest parties have already mined the data, which is enough for models for long time.

Unless you want the model to find some specific comment yesterday.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by d11z on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:19AM (#36211514)
It makes sense to me, but for LLM spam bots, not training. I’m assuming it’ll only increase as time passes.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by CTDOCodebases on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:44AM (#36211782)
Reddit is good for product recommendations and in that regards recency matters e.g ask ChatGPT what ODE you should get for a Sega Saturn.

By allowing LLMs low cost or free access to their users data companies like Reddit are essentially helping companies like OpenAI choke their traffic.

Over time as people realise it’s quicker to ask ChatGPT a question than it is to post a question on reddit they will start losing content also.

Also think about the difficulty of policing content generated by swarms of LLM bots with API access for PR campaigns.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by nicce on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:52AM (#36211864)
At which point you need API access, and the crawled indexes are not enough enough? Is Google also required to start paying for API access for indexing pages and showing them in the search results?

I am just wondering, where is the limit, since in that case the model might not be trained anymore and instead it is used for similar purpose than search engine. I guess Bing is already doing this, without Reddit API.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by pbj1968 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:26AM (#36212349)
Fenrir.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by CTDOCodebases on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:50PM (#36218218)
For price and ease of install sure I would agree.

I just asked Chat GPT this very question and it didn't mention the Fenrir. It mentioned the other contender (MODE) but it failed to differentiate it from all the other offerings i.e it has the ability to connect a SATA SSD and hold the entire Sega Saturn library on the device.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Frost1x on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:02AM (#36211989)
I'm not sure this is true in all cases. As far as grabbing enough language data to produce useful language, it's probably enough for awhile until cultural and language shifts happen (slang, word usage distribution, new terms, etc.).

The cases LLM will need this data in is compiling together more modern useful human knowledge as our knowledge base grows. Information in existing LLMs could shift. This is sort of the issue even academic textbooks deal with when publishing what is considered foundational knowledge: sometimes we discover something new that makes it either not quite correct or invalid.

These are the sort of obvious failures and disconnects that should become apparent if training lags behind. LLM services interested in revenue without plans for continuously updating training data are somewhat betting that not too much will change from most end users perspectives for awhile and for some use cases that might be true but the limits of training data over time for public instances of GPT for example have already hindered some.

Much of prompting, from my anecdata, needs to take that into consideration as one of the base constraints (does this model even have up-to-date information it could query and dump something useful from). To some degree those training limits also help expose "hallucinations" or interpolation/extrapolation attempts of LLM models. If I know it doesn't have this information in the training set and test the system against it, I can observe how well it interpolates, extrapolates, and is transparent about when that's happening. For example if I ask existing models about new syntaxes and structures introduced in Java 21, most should return something back like it doesn't exist, it lacks that newer information, or something to that effect. If instead it starts producing code samples that it couldn't possibly have knowledge of, then I know it's passing back garbage. If it's being continually updated at some frequency, I'm no longer so sure and it may actually be providing new useful information.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by throw_nbvc1234 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @05:23PM (#36219298)
How many of those biggest parties do you expect to give/sell the data to new players if it'd even be legal for them to do so. Closing the gates can still provide a revenue stream for Reddit, especially if they do it early enough into the hype cycle.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by plagiarist on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:21AM (#36211535)
LLM trainers can just scrape the content. It would only slow them down. I wonder if reddit imagines they would pay for the data.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by dageshi on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:40AM (#36211736)
There's maybe a handful of sites that people explicitly append to their google search results in order to cut out the SEO spam, reddit is probably the one that covers the most subjects.

So I think they are thinking that and I don't think they're wrong.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by tensor on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:34AM (#36213428)
I think they're wrong. I was building a product search app using the reddit api, but with their API pricing it isn't remotely feasible financially so I shuttered it. They may see $$$$ but I suspect they'll find very few takers.

Yes, the data is valuable for product recommendations, but not at the price they are asking. And if they ever block traditional scraping then all those "append reddit to google" searches will be gone too. Google is not going to pay them either.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by saynay on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:47PM (#36215601)
Unless they are entirely delusional (which is possible), they have to had priced it with a specific few customers in mind. If they think they can get a cut of ChatGPT money going forward, I think they would be entirely willing to sacrifice all 3rd party apps and a decent chunk of their mobile users.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by rightbyte on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:48AM (#36211814)
Why would you train with the API? Just render the site to scrape it.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Ekaros on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:00AM (#36211969)
After killing the old reddit. I don't think scrapping is very effective, at least for the comments. Visibility of comments on web site is pretty horrid.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by _-____-_ on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:18AM (#36213193)
The API is still there, and it must still be usable without paying, since the mobile app is using it. So setup mitmproxy on your iPhone and sniff the traffic to figure out how it gets its key, and then replicate that in your scraper.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by moffkalast on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:32PM (#36217142)
No need, there are already several projects that have been scraping and downloading posts and comments for archival reasons for years. It's just a one click download.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Sol- on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:58AM (#36211937)
If that's the case, whitelisting the most popular apps might be somewhat of a solution, no? Also I think being transparent about the fears that LLMs take from your site without returning any value would probably be met with understanding from the userbase.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by saynay on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:43PM (#36215522)
On the flip side, if they wanted to kill the popular apps, why wouldn't they just block them directly instead of doing so indirectly through crazy API pricing?
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by rightbyte on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:10PM (#36215964)
Maybe they think an obscure way to close down apps will lead to less dissent?
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by saynay on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:19PM (#36216085)
Clearly it isn't. Could be a miscalculation on their part, but I still think it more plausible they are hoping to find a big customer who will actually pay those prices.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by philjohn on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:11PM (#36218483)
The issue is, Reddit is ad supported. The popular apps bypass showing ads.

The problem goes away if the apps charge for a subscription, which covers their API access.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by graftak on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:00PM (#36220270)
This could have been solved by only allowing Reddit premium users to make use of the API (they don’t see ads). in addition, the API cost is about 20 times more lucrative than a user seeing ads, which is an insane upsell. Then there’s the issue that Reddit won’t allow NSFW content over the API, which is just total BS in the picture you drew.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by bloopernova on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:46AM (#36214635)
How difficult is it to rate limit API requests? Just Fibonacci the increasing slowdown.

And require something like a public key to access the API so you can track requests coming from multiple hosts.

Then any rate of access above that of a power user can be charged for appropriately. And make it so that activating API access is something that can't be automated so people can't create thousands of API dummy accounts.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by manmal on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:12PM (#36217674)
> track requests coming from multiple hosts

The problem here is that many users are behind CGNAT, meaning many end users share a single IPv4. Unfortunately the days of counting distinct users by their IP(v4) are over.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by bloopernova on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:12AM (#36227023)
I think that could be mitigated by using a public key of some variety.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by manmal on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:35PM (#36230214)
Every user would need one.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by celestialcheese on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:20PM (#36215120)
While the APIs make it significantly easier to ingest for LLM training, scraping will still work.

Unless they put 100% of content behind a login-gate, it's currently legal* to scrape and use for derivative works, as long as you have the money and the chutzpah to deal with lawsuits that may or may not come.

- https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2022/12/hello-youve-be...

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by saynay on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:40PM (#36215485)
This is my read as well. I don't really understand the argument that Reddit wants to kill 3rd party apps, so makes an unaffordable API. If they want to kill 3rd party apps... why wouldn't they just kill them directly? Why leave any ability to purchase API access unless they have a customer in mind that can afford to buy it at that price?
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by sorenjan on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:26AM (#36211583)
Reddit's messaging is focusing a lot on how moderators aren't going to be affected. Reddit derives value from the unpaid moderators' work, but they doesn't seem to care about the user experience for the regular users, so it still feels a bit self serving whenever they swear mods will still be able to use certain tools.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by masklinn on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:34AM (#36212489)
> the new API pricing is reasonable and not intended to kill third party apps.

It’s quite obviously not the case given the numbers involved, but it’s completely implausible when you add that NSFW content will be removed from the API entirely, and that third party client will not be allowed to be ad-supported.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:39PM (#36215462)
> NSFW content will be removed from the API entirely

Wow. I didn't know about that. That would prevent browsing /r/cigars via API calls. Because every post in /r/cigars is marked as NSFW. Why? I'll give you one guess. https://old.reddit.com/r/cigars/comments/ubu6b2/why_is_rciga...

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by masklinn on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:00PM (#36215828)
> Wow. I didn't know about that.

According to the Apollo dev's recounting of the call this is "sexually explicit content only, not normal posts marked NSFW for non-sexual reasons".

I assume there's a flag at the subreddit level or something, because Narwhal doesn't show the "cheeky narwhal" on /r/cigars (something it does on NSFW subs). I don't know how they'll handle SFW subreddits where NSFW is used for both spoilers and dodgy content though. That's assuming they even care.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by elil17 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:15PM (#36217715)
It is really strange which drug-related subs are NSFW and which aren't. Like why not alcohol related subs?

I think they probably all should be marked NSFW but it is weird.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:22PM (#36217820)
None of them should be IMO. It's dumb. "I smoked a lovely cigar over the weekend" is fine safe-for-work chit chat.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by esperent on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:28AM (#36223206)
The problem is labelling, in that case. It should be NSFM (not safe for minors) as that's what it really means, but the NSFW label caught on and we're stuck with it now.

The obvious suggestion is multiple tags (drugs, sex, violence, gore etc.). But actually that's a really bad idea because it's a slippery slope of censorship - each flavor of the month bad thing gets banned over a decade or so until there's nothing left to ban.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:39AM (#36226041)
Of course it's safe for minors. My son is a minor and he's seen me smoking a cigar on multiple occasions. As far as I can tell, nothing about his safety has been compromised.

Respectfully, I think you've lost the plot here. The problem isn't labeling. The problem is overreaching in the first place. And the problem is an inconsistent application of that labeling.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by elil17 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:26AM (#36227188)
Exposure to tobacco consumption drives tobacco consumption:

-Children of tobacco users are more likely to be tobacco users (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5084564/)

-People who watch TV/movies with characters who use tobacco are more likely to be tobacco users (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2770193/)

-People who are friends with tobacco users are more likely to be tobacco users (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3691293/)

-People who see tobacco use on social media are more likely to be tobacco users and, critically, have an increased susceptibility to tobacco even if they are non-users (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35816331/)

The reality is that tobacco use disorder is a socially transmitted disease, and one of the best ways to prevent it's spread is to protect people from viewing tobacco use. By making it so that you have to opt-in to seeing posts about tobacco on their platform, Reddit is helping people avoid tobacco-related content.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:33PM (#36245581)
That doesn't make r/cigars "not safe for work." It also doesn't make it "not safe for minors." It makes it "something that reddit admins want to force users to opt into seeing."

You're also really really really missing the broader point here. By what metric should something on reddit be "opt in"? There are some things that are obvious that we all tend to agree in, and those fall into the useful mental model of "would you look at this at work?" But r/cigars does not fit into that model, yet it is still labeled as such. That means there is some other model being used to force users to opt into "sensitive" content. So what the fuck is it and why doesn't it apply to marijuana? Or fast food? Or one of a number of other unhealthy things for you?

And how many of your links apply to cigars? When was the last time you saw a 15 year old smoking a Padron? Fucking never buddy. It's a non-issue. It might play if it were cigarettes or some other trendy thing, but that's not the case here.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by elil17 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @09:27AM (#36340148)
I agree with you that it should apply to other unhealthy things and that the "NSFW" label is a misnomer.

However, I have seen children smoking cigars (albeit cheap ones). Evidence suggests that they are doing so because they are imitating their parents or characters in the media.

Tobacco use disorder is on track to kill a billion people by the end of the century. 20% of men die from it. Hiding tobacco use from people who don't have tobacco use disorder is one of the best tools we have to prevent the spread, and I'll gladly voice my support for any measure to do that - even if it isn't applied in the most consistent/fair way.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:32AM (#36358329)
Clearly we live in different realities. You briefly acknowledge children smoking cheap cigars, but then immediately leap to "tobacco use disorder" without forming an obvious connection between the two. One does not obviously follow from the other.

> Hiding tobacco use from people who don't have tobacco use disorder is one of the best tools we have to prevent the spread, and I'll gladly voice my support for any measure to do that - even if it isn't applied in the most consistent/fair way.

"any measure" ... really? Wow. I can't imagine you actually meant that.

And one wonders how anyone could come to the conclusion that labeling something NSFW is in any way effective at hiding something from minors.

> I agree with you that it should apply to other unhealthy things

Noooooo.... I'm saying it shouldn't, but also simultaneously asking why it isn't.

As soon as you go down this route, the next thing you know, people like you will be marking r/lawncare as NSFW because it's principally about mowing grass which is in turn unhealthy for humans by virtue of it being bad for the environments. And that we should totally hide lawnmowers from young impressionable eyes.

Yes, obviously lawnmowing isn't the same as tobacco use disorder. But cigar smoking isn't the same as vaping or cigarette smoking, which is where I'm sure the vast majority of tobacco use disorder comes from. And the point of my analogy here is to communicate just how utterly ridiculous your position looks to me. And I say that as a father.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by burntsushi on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:22AM (#36389753)
All I have to say is that we disagree, and I think your logic is deeply flawed. You're lumping all tobacco use into one category and also seem to be in favor of "any measure" to "hide" it, regardless of its costs and effectiveness. Overall, your position looks incredibly unreasonable to me. I also think that if your reasoning were applied consistently, it would lead to a complete disaster.

Basically, this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3D8670smTI

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by axelthegerman on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:29PM (#36217918)
I think some people are mixing age control with what is "not safe for work".

Everyone I work with is old enough to drink or smoke, so posting about cigars or beers could be appropriate but also could not be.

Tldr NSFW != age controls

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by austhrow743 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:46PM (#36220139)
In a general office context people can talk about going wine tasting the previous weekend.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:03PM (#36220867)
Not Safe For Work means "reasonably likely to offend your boss/coworker." Nothing more, nothing less. It's not a value judgment.

People get super weird about this. Like, "this is an artistic nude, how dare you condemn it as NSFW."

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by Genbox on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:44PM (#36217292)
I've done my best to research this and I'm unable to find any numbers on the matter besides one app developers miscalculation of 20 mio. for billions of requests.

I can however find official documentation that backs up what the admins are saying. The new Data API terms says they no long allow commercial use of their APIs and might implement a cost pr. request. It links to the Data API docs that says 60 req. pr. minute are free as long as it is non-commercial. I would think unofficial reddit apps goes under the non-commercial clause.

To me it looks to be a complete overreaction by the Reddit community because of a miscommunication on parts of a single developer and the Reddit orgs too slow reaction to stop it from spreading.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by axelthegerman on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:31PM (#36217954)
> 60 req. pr. minute are free

I don't think that will get a moderately used app very far. These limits would most likely be per API key and not per user

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by LawnGnome on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:55PM (#36218997)
It's going up to 100 req/m, but the new limit is indeed per key, not per user. (See https://old.reddit.com/r/redditdev/comments/13wsiks/api_upda... for more detail.)
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by renewiltord on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:24PM (#36221040)
Is there a reason a user can't just paste in their key into the client? That seems to be the right model.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by proamdev123 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:15PM (#36218526)
Can you elaborate on where the miscalculation was in the Apollo dev’s math?

The numbers he posted seem to add up.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by austhrow743 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:47PM (#36220155)
Why would third party reddit apps all under non-commercial?
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by themoonisachees on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:27PM (#36221080)
I don't see how you expect 3rd party apps to stay below 60 r/m, that is abysmally low for anyone but a single user (even still, it'd be faster to scrape the website at that point). Third party apps have all requests made by every user use their one API key, not one key per user. Even so, third party apps aren't non-commercial, the devs want to get paid at some point.

If it were a complete overreaction, all it would take is a single reddit admin going "he misunderstood, actually it's going to be x".

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by hackernewds on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @03:14PM (#36231974)
> It's quite obviously not the case given the numbers involved

why is this assumed? In my assessment, Reddit is offering a quite reasonable charge per API call. If this will somehow cause a third-party app to ride up $20M in costs, it behooves them to optimize. As far as I can see, Apollo caches an absurd amount of data pre load which is not a mandatory advantage any app needs to offer

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by commandlinefan on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#36215176)
> control of the narrative

This also kills off apps like 'removeddit' that sheds light on rampant moderator abuse - it will be even _harder_ to see what the moderators have been up to behind the scenes after this, which is an aspect of the narrative that reddit has been trying to get a handle on for quite a while now.

Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by moffkalast on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:30PM (#36217112)
And also kills all bots working through the API in a legitimate way. I hope reddit likes being spammed by puppeteer.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by ariym on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:30PM (#36216246)
it's fascinates me how social platforms are never able to control their own narrative, most YouTuber's hate YouTube, most Redditors complain about Reddit. the volume of negative sentiment must be enormous for them not to have configured their recommendation algorithms to suppress content that is anti-them
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by mrguyorama on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:02PM (#36216716)
There's just no need. Negative sentiment doesn't hurt the balance sheet, and users will be back to get their fix tomorrow, every time. Youtube keeps making ads more intrusive and people keep watching. What people say they care about, and what they are actually willing to take action to change, are extremely disconnected.
Re:Reddit’s plan to kill third-party apps sparks widespread ... by midoridensha on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @05:29AM (#36224717)
>Youtube keeps making ads more intrusive and people keep watching.

How many of the complainers are actually watching the ads? It's trivial to block ads on YouTube; just install uBO, or use an app like Revanced.