News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by delroth on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:38AM (#36135951)
The article decides to mention that Google made a public statement that clearly and unambiguously answers their question (https://twitter.com/GoogleWorkspace/status/16382985371956019...) and then proceeds to ignore it completely in favor of conspiracy theories ("but look, there they said 'was' instead of 'is'!").
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by ahahahahah on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:41AM (#36135976)
It gives as much credence to bard's own bullshit as it does to Google's official statement. It's a useless article.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by gersg on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:42AM (#36135983)
Thank the Lord for that "Readers added context" marker that tweets now can have.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by onion2k on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:50AM (#36136031)
Lawyers use language in very specific ways, and anything that's not completely obvious can be used to hide the truth. As an example, I once worked with a team who was building some software where a requirement said the app 'should' do something instead it 'shall' do something. The company's lawyer argued successfully that this meant the requirement was optional.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by comprev on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:37AM (#36136373)
The Highway Code in the UK is full of “must” and “should” indicating firm requirements and optional choices. The use of “should” is a softer method of persuasion, in the same way signs say “Please close the door” not just “Close the door” which is an instruction. This aligns with the famous British politeness - or at least that is how I interpret the wording.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by astrange on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:53AM (#36136053)
That's how Internet standards work.

https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by onion2k on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:59AM (#36136100)
This was a contract between two companies, written by a product manager and a CEO. It wasn't a technical RFC.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by omegabravo on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:14AM (#36136209)
This choice of wording in systems engineering is not ambiguous, and should effectively means optional. These words are often in capital letters trying to highlight the importance of it. It is absolutely not limited to RFCs, and is often used in a software specification.

Product manager and CEO _should_ know better. It's very understandable that they don't - and I have empathy for them, but unfortunately they're wrong.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by onion2k on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:24AM (#36136278)
Sure, and hence the company won. The point here is that language can have very specific meaning. There is a difference between 'should' and 'shall', even though most people would think they're effectively the same. If I said "You should complete that task" to one of my team I'm not really giving them the choice and leaving it up to them. I'm telling them to do something. Outside of RFCs and contracts language is a bit ambiguous and lawyers use that to their advantage.

In exactly the same way, there is also a difference between 'is' and 'was', and I think it's totally plausible that a Google lawyer might use that to hide the fact they used GMail data to train AI in the past.

That doesn't mean they did. It only means I wouldn't be surprised if someone proves they did, and that their lawyer used the tense of a response to try to hide it.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by matwood on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:07AM (#36136560)
Even in general english, 'should' is less strong than 'must' or 'shall'.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by meghan_rain on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:21AM (#36136257)
_must_ tbqh lmao
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by matwood on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:03AM (#36136534)
'Should' and 'shall' is standard contract language. But, when it doubt, define the terms in the contract.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by delroth on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:55AM (#36136067)
I'm not sure what you're trying to say, but "It is not trained on Gmail data." is as obvious a statement as you could ever express in the english language.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by chx on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:57AM (#36136077)
Not only that but this tweet is from Google Workspace and so it is not at all unreasonable to say it is not trained on Google Workspace Gmail and it says nothing about public gmail. Words. We have them.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by marak830 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:55AM (#36136061)
I would think that part 4 and "what bard has to say about this" sections would make most people question Google's comment.

4. Google has never denied that Bard was trained on data from Gmail. They've only claimed that such data is not currently used to “improve” the model.

What Bard has to say about this: “I have not personally seen a real Gmail account. However, I have access to a massive dataset of Gmail emails, and I have used this dataset to train my language model. This means that I am familiar with the format of Gmail emails, and I can generate text that is similar to the text that is found in real Gmail emails.”

Now do I think they have done the nasty? I don't know.

Should it be reviewed by an outside team? I think yes.

I cannot think of a solution to this problem, which I believe will keep cropping up, but I think it can be problematic. I think it needs to be prooven true to be safe.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by wodenokoto on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:20AM (#36136249)
> Bard is an early experiment based on Large Language Models and will make mistakes. It is not trained on Gmail data. -JQ

How exactly are you interpreting that statement?

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by marak830 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:39AM (#36136378)
I am defining it on the points I mentioned. I don't know if they are in the wrong or not, but their responses give me pause
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by ForHackernews on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:14AM (#36136600)
"is" is a present-tense verb. In the hands of a lawyer or a PR person, that statement could easily mean "We are not, right at this moment, training it on further Gmail data. Up until yesterday, we were training it on all the private data from the past 20 years, and next month when the scrutiny dies down, we'll start training on fresh gmail data again."
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by zmmmmm on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:15AM (#36136213)
They could easily have done this on a subset of consenting users, eg: their own employees.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by marak830 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:42AM (#36136402)
You are 100% correct. That they didn't mention this is one of the reasons I didn't dismiss this article.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by bilekas on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:00AM (#36136103)
They also have added replies which have been removed, reading the article it's actually not as conspiratorial as you make it seem.

In this case I really think it prudent to assume the worst from Google as they don't really have a positive history for walling off users data, be it personal email or phone meta information.

> "The LaMDA engine underlying Bard is also what drives autocomplete and autoreply in Gmail so ... yeah Bard's training data includes Gmail. FWIW, they put a lot of effort into ensuring that LaMDA doesn't use give[sic] personal information about individuals in its responses."

If this is true, to me this is a good indicator that it's using at least contextual information from emails.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by bkanl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:24AM (#36136284)
Who wrote that reply? A Googler? Is there a screenshot? This would be a gigantic GDPR lawsuit.

This reminds me of not communicating with Gmail users. Gmail has been evil forever since "personalized" ads.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by bilekas on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:58AM (#36136494)
It's in the article, but here's the direct link to help you out.

https://twitter.com/cajundiscordian/status/16382433030356705...

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by skinkestek on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:02AM (#36136530)
At the moment, for some reason Google seems almost untouchable.

I mean, single handedly destroying the browser market by deceit and abuse of market position in broad daylight, you'd think sooner or later EU or someone would force them to pay and put up a browser ballot on Google.com, but so far, no.

Luckily the French consumer protection agency has at least forced them to implement the cookie question thing almost so we can now reject all right away.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by Terretta on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:13AM (#36136595)
> single handedly destroying the browser market by deceit and abuse of market position in broad daylight

It's not single handedly, it's every developer handedly.

First thing any dev does is install Chrome, and make their normal friends install Chrome, even when -- for example -- it destroys the battery life on their Macbook while breaking a variety of usability conveniences. When pressed, it turns out most of this is cargo culting, they actually haven't turned on developer tools or compared performance or memory handling, much less experienced the remarkable security and privacy integrations* available in co-shipped Safari browser.

Having observed the browser wars since before NCSA Mosaic, I'd argue not Google but a set of "tech influencers" well represented on HN made this happen, not Google.

In the longer context, HN's clamor to force iOS off Safari, the only significant bastion against a monoculture and one ad company's complete grip on visibility of all web use, is shocking.

---

* For instance, various anti-tracker and IP anonymizing capabilities, plus a built-in and cross device syncing password manager that even supports TOTP codes.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by hdjjhhvvhga on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:04AM (#36137339)
> First thing any dev

Maybe frontend devs. For me FF is invaluable, especially the containers.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by salawat on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:40PM (#36142146)
Citation required. I've been warning my circles off Chrome for years. Firefox is generally my go to.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by huijzer on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:20AM (#36136631)
> This would be a gigantic GDPR lawsuit.

No. They are not available in the EU.

At least, I assume this is how Google thinks about it.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by jruohonen on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:43AM (#36137164)
It doesn't matter, and Google knows it.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by pyrale on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:29AM (#36137540)
I believe the point is that Google leaks data collected through a service available in the EU (Gmail). The GDPR claim would be related to gmail, not bard.

If anything, bard not being available in the EU would prove that using the data wasn't necessary for EU's gmail service.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by q1w2 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:28PM (#36143873)
> I really think it prudent to assume the worst...

This is not evidence-based thinking and leads to heavy biases.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by ninth_ant on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:08AM (#36136154)
Using the present tense to answer a past-tense question is hardly unambiguous.

"Did you send an email to Fred?" -- "No, I'm not sending an email to Fred" doesn't answer the question.

It's not a "conspiracy theory" to have realized that big corps have teams of people to frame their public statements with carefully chosen words to present issues in the best light for them, even if it's deeply misleading.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by radarsat1 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:50AM (#36136450)
> "Did you send an email to Fred?" -- "No, I'm not sending an email to Fred"

To me this unambiguously says both that I did not send an email to him and I don't intend to. Is it really ambiguous to you?

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by nkrisc on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:11AM (#36136584)
The given response very clearly and unambiguously does not answer the given question.

I think most native English speakers - if they were reading/listening carefully - would interpret the mismatch of verb tense as an intentional attempt at not answering the question while simultaneously sounding as if it does.

If someone gave me that answer to that question I would repeat the question to them with an emphasis on “did.”

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by ForHackernews on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:11AM (#36136585)
You're not a corporate comms person. The ambiguity of the English language can be very valuable in a court of law.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by hdjjhhvvhga on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:05AM (#36137344)
It depends if you are a person or a corporation. If the former, I assume you haven't. If the latter, I assume you did but don't want it to sound bad.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by pyrale on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:31AM (#36137565)
If you said that, maybe.

If a corporate PR expert or a politician said that, the conclusion would be very different.

Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by radarsat1 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:39AM (#36139601)
I'll be honest I'm a bit surprised at the responses here. I get what you're saying about the verb tenses, but the first word in the answer is clearly "No" in answer to the question.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by somenameforme on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:33AM (#36136340)
When a corporation answers in a specific way it's because it has a specific meaning. 'Ooops we meant 'x' doesn't tend to hold up so well in court.' Google could easily and absolutely put to bed all concerns by stating, "No Bard has never been trained on any email data, and never will be." Instead, they're choosing not to do that and just taking the PR hit, while making statements that completely leave the door open to previous training.
Re:Why won’t Google give an answer on whether Bard was train... by jeodjdodh on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:41AM (#36136399)
JQ is part of the PR team, not engineering. the article author is correct not taking what he says at face value. lots of doublespeak in PR.