I have a raspi running pretty much non-stop since 2011 and am still able to update its software 12 years after purchase. All "somethings elses" which I bought had 3-4 years of software support and then their usability diminished drastically.
That these devices are useful for hobbyists, doesn't automatically mean that people want to periodically spend hours to have them working with up-to-date software.
The reason is that Linux has no stable in-kernel driver interface, so the drivers often have to change with new kernel release.
Feel free to complain on the LKML why you consider this to be a bad idea ...
Part of the problem here is that SoC drivers are hacked on top of the kernel (and are not merged in-tree). So SoC vendors have this pile of legacy and hacked-on code they need to cherry-pick every time the Kernel changes an interface they used (which is a lot) [0]. The code is also, let's be honest here, low quality and full of workarounds for implementation details (some radio-modem talking over I2C to transmit voice to the SoC???) so there's no way it would get merged into the kernel.
Of course, that costs and fortune and hampers the sales of newer chipsets so it’s not in the SoC vendor’s interest to do so.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Application_binary_interface
On the other hand, it would be in a lot of vendors' cost-saving interests to massively lobby for a (much more) stable in-kernel driver interface in the Linux kernel so that the vendors only rarely have to change their Linux drivers when a new kernel version gets released.
Edit: here's a recent Ask HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34976965
From the linked Ask HN.
Hardware is irrelevant if the software isn't comparable. I'd like to be proven wrong but if nothing has changed in the last years there are no real alternatives to the Pi.
Ex lease mini desktop Dell/Hp/Lenovo Intel machines off eBay can be good, and first class Linux support, and cheaper than raspberry pi.
Some applications can be replaced with a microcontroller like esp32 which has excellent software support.
Many of the machines above have pretty average Linux support but it seems to be improving, depends on your application.
If you mean "gives me a standard linux distro I can install software on that can talk to the network and maybe show a UI on a screen", pretty much anything works (and a lot of things people do with Pis are just that - running things like network-wide adblockers, 3D printer servers, small python scripts for whatever).
If it's somewhere in between, it again depends. E.g. if I wanted a MIPI camera, I'd probably track down a RPi and use that unless I could find someone documenting a precise setup on something else.
BeaglePlay, the newest version of the BeagleBoard:
> https://beagleboard.org/play
HN:
They're available on Amazon, 2GB board is currently $35. Same footprint as the Pi, fits most of the same cases, hats, etc. Decent support forums and community, and the images aren't too esoteric.
That’s a new one for me. I would find it a lot less condescending to be told a straight “this made us the most money” reasoning. Anything else is obviously BS or incompetence.
I really hope the likes of the VisionFive SBC see decent adoption. Their reference manual seems good - but I haven’t really played around with the board all that much.
Sure, if;
- You don't run any other OS then Linux. For example Raspberry PI has pretty decent FreeBSD support. Other boards often don't support FreeBSD or not all hardware on the board has drivers.
- You don't have a custom case which relies on the design of the PI.
- You don't already have dozens or hundreds of PI's in the field and are not that enthusiastic to add a new board to the mix.
- You will probably also have to add a new board to the mix every 3 or 4 years or so since these other boards often have a lot shorter lifecycle.
- etc.
Upton claims that these companies had to use Raspberry Pi…. sounds false to me - lots of other companies changed their designs to handle the shortage.
If anything, Upton should have backed kids and schools above all - they are the one who really needed hobby computing during Covid lockdowns. Upton's justifications don’t ring true.
Also the company has treated hobbyists, kids and schools like garbage.
Buy something else.