A large number of freelancers & agencies have built a stable clients on Upwork from years together. It will be a little revenue shock for them. Or eventually clients will pay more to cover the costs.
Let's assume you are a freelancer with a client relationship of 40k
* 20% fee for the first $500 earned from a client - $100
* 10% fee between $500 and $10,000 earned - $ 950
* 5% fee after the first $10,000 earned - $ 1500
New model - 40k
Am I missing anything here?
* 10% fee of any amount - $ 4000
I guess the problem is that I haven't had any luck finding any serious client, due to the competition and race-to-the-bottom.
Some clients want quality, of course, but in this economy if it's a lottery to find a job in the real world, it's a lottery for those billing upwards of $100/h on Upwork.
So what's left is small contracts where being a seasoned expert to deal with emergencies is more important than being cheap.
See https://support.upwork.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043210654-Mo...
If you want to convert sooner, it's a percentage of the income for that specific client/freelancer relationship, and not total work for the freelancer. So it is probably a more palatable amount, assuming the freelancer has multiple clients.
This sounds like something a pimp or a mob boss would say.
These seem like real concerns and failures of the market. I know Upwork has strong network effects, so this seems like a justified government intervention
That incentive always was there, but it was small. It isn't small any longer. The trajectory makes one wonder what this fee will be in another year or two. Clearly they won't be lowering it.
Upwork is not an independently sustainable company. Upwork shares are worth less than at their 2018 IPO. They've never really been profitable. They rarely have a positive free cash flow. They've increased outstanding share count 26%. The things they've done only reduced the value customers receive from them (like when they decided to charge extra money to view contractor reports.)
How did they never make any money? Companies spend billions of dollars a year on recruiting. This isn't a tiny market. Someone grossly mismanaged Upwork -- for their customers, for their contractors, and their shareholders.
90% of the job I apply for, on Upwork or otherwise, are always looking for an expert in a particular niche technology, and hire only based off that small nugget of information.
I have been doing Elixir full time since 2016, and got a contract with someone that was looking for a Phoenix.Socket expert—a small WebSocket server module part of a larger framework—and the interviewer spent 30 minutes drilling down how much I know that small piece of logic. In this case it's like hiring plumber asking them how much experience they have in square zinc kitchen sinks. Given that I couldn't convey how dumb that is, I had to lie and say that in all of my 7 years with Elixir I have been using Phoenix.Socket pretty much daily. And as expected, it was a bog standard job doing nothing more complicated than an intermediate Phoenix tutorial.
If someone has a lot of experience in databases, and in competitors to ClickHouse they might be good or better than someone that claims to be a world class expert in ClickHouse and nothing else.
(Not to pick on you in particular, but as a true generalist this hiring pattern has been bugging me more and more as my breadth of experience grows.)
When I'm hiring a contractor, I'm not really interested in paying them to learn, I'm interested in getting my need fulfilled as efficiently as possible. If the problem I have is my square zinc kitchen sink it makes sense to find someone who already knows about them.
In my 11 years of experience as a consultant, people hire me because they need a square zinc sink fixed, but as soon as they see that I know much more than that, they ask me to redo the living room wall and trim the topiary.
Being an expert gets me through the door, being a generalist keeps me around.
The problem is that the square sink expert filter is the biggest obstacle to getting a contract. Reason why with 16 years of experience, I'm still without a job after 4 months, my longest jobless stint in my entire career (to be fair, I'm pivoting towards starting my own business rather than keep being rebuffed by clueless recruiters)
This doesn't apply to everything, but Clickhouse is not so different from other analytics tools it requires a specialist.
At around 2-3 weeks of work paying a someone that’s very close but not quite what you’re looking for saves your time and means at the end of it you have someone that you can go back to with the exact skill you’re looking for.
It really doesn’t take long before the contractor’s overall competence dwarfs how much specific time they have with some niche thing.
Looking at their site now, it looks like they've grown a lot and aren't a just boutique Clickhouse consultancy, but offer managed clickhouse cloud instances. There's still a reference to their support contract on the site though, so might still be worth a chat with them.
I have no affiliation with them, just an extremely pleased ex-customer. That was a long time ago though, so I take no responsibility if they've gone to shit now :D.
With business-related things it's better to have it upfront in my experience.
In theory only partially if the freelancers are competing with those who are not using the platform and just bill their clients directly.
Yes, Upwork are moving everybody on the 10% fee. But they previously had a progressive fee:
* 20% fee for the first $500 earned from a client
* 10% fee between $500 and $10,000 earned
* 5% fee after the first $10,000 earned
Those figures are per client. Start a new job with someone else, you start from the lower bracket again.
So they were basically living off short term contracts and low paid freelancers. Now it penalises everyone the same, but 10% is much more reasonable than 20%
I've been trying to stay afloat in this terrible hiring market through Upwork, and I'm ambivalent. Without it, I'd pretty much be broke. But even with a profile that has been created in 2012, has $50k billed, I've only been able to find short term consulting or sysadmin jobs paid terribly, and lost 20% off each of them because of the prohibitive lower bracket.