News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by martincmartin on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @07:42AM (#35523677)
The experiments are now so sensitive that if an electron were the size of Earth, they could detect a bump on the North Pole the height of a single sugar molecule.

This new bound is sensitive to energies above roughly 10^13 electron-volts — more than an order of magnitude beyond what the LHC can currently test.

Wow.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by wkat4242 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:35AM (#35580510)
Yeah how do they manage to get that kind of accuracy. Mind boggling.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:04AM (#35580733)
That's precision, not accuracy.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by lifeisstillgood on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:20AM (#35580849)
hang on - what?

Yes it is precise ... to 17 decimal places or whatever. But it is also I believe accurate? I mean are they wrong and the electron is as bumpy as my chin on a weekend?

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by delecti on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:26AM (#35580898)
It's not that the experiment is not accurate, "accuracy" is simply not the aspect of the measurement being discussed. The sentence "That's precision, not accuracy." should be read to mean "we are discussing precision, we are not discussing accuracy" rather than "it's precise, but inaccurate".
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:28AM (#35580921)
...but aren't we discussing both, if one implies the other?
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by Mezzie on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:36AM (#35580982)
Precision and accuracy are slightly different mathematical concepts, as demonstrated by this image [0]:

[0]: https://wp.stolaf.edu/it/files/2017/06/precsionvsaccuracy_cr...

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by rektide on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:50AM (#35581111)
To be honest accuracy Vs precision has always kind of makes sense to be but also not.

If something is extremely accurate, it will also be extremely precise by necessity, it seems like? The difference between low precision but high & low accuracies is that points are closer to center. If you keep getting closer to center, more accurate, don't you necessarily get more precise too?

Precise has always felt like a shitty alternate of accuracy. It's accuracy but with drift, accuracy to not the right place. But if you're accurate, you're both.

Am I missing something? And, here specifically, if this is a case of very high precision but lower accuracy, can someone explain what the drift from center is about? Isn't a radius a radius? Where is the drift off center in these measures?

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:10AM (#35581319)
Something is accurate in this sense if the "true" value (ignoring any philosophical implications thereof) is contained in the error bounds of the measurement. What you're noting is that a high accuracy measurement will, upon application of statistics, allow you to derive a new measure which is both high-accuracy and high-precision, regardless of the low precision of any inputs. Not all things being described with accuracy and precision are the result of processing large amounts of data though.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by alexpetralia on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#35581267)
I wrote about precision here if you are interested. You first need precision before you can start even talking about accuracy (otherwise there is no "center").

https://alexpetralia.com/2023/01/31/what-does-it-mean-for-da...

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @01:05PM (#35582429)
I don't like the lower left quadrant of that diagram, because it's not clear that it's not centered on the target. It would have been more clear if the cluster was smaller so it could be moved to not be centered on the target.

Accurate but imprecise means we can throw more and more shells down range and eventually hit the target. Inaccurate and imprecise means we may never hit the target. Inaccurate but precise also means we may never hit the target, but if we could introduce a second, different measurement that was accurate, we could compensate.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:51AM (#35581118)
That's a great image, thank you for that—but I'm not sure what the significance is in this context? I feel like the measurement described would be about both accuracy and precision, unless I'm misunderstanding what we're able to do.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by spiralx on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:12AM (#35598803)
I saw a Greek food stall in town a couple of years back with the statement "Food delivered with mathematical accuracy" which just bugged the hell out of me lol.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by PezzaDev on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:36AM (#35580983)
No. Precision and Accuracy have very specific definitions in the world of science and engineering. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accuracy_and_precision
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by jvanderbot on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:51AM (#35581131)
So, when one uses statistics to rule out deviations below 1E-17 radians (or whatever), you're all saying that's not accuracy, it's precision.

I'm also surprised, since IIRC precision is a measure of variance from a set of measurements, and accuracy is a measure of deviation of a value from true.

The statistical aggregation to get an estimate should (I think?) increase both the accuracy of that estimate (it will converge to the true value) and it's precision (the spread of subsequent estimates with more measurements converges to zero or some noise floor).

Here we're measuring something like eccentricity, which has a value and error bars. And the claim is we have eccentricity zero with precision high enough to rule out deviations below 1E-17 radians. So yeah, precision seems to be the better of the two, but accuracy matters.

Either way, this is insanely pedantic.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by zmgsabst on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#35581404)
Consider the case where there’s a configuration error — say, a cable not properly seated.

You can have results that are highly precise, but due to cable issue, not baselined correctly and therefore systemically inaccurate. Eg, faster than light neutrinos.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light_neutrino_a...

I think people get confused because they forget that systemic bias can impact precise measurements: if your system is wrong, you’ll precisely come to the wrong conclusion.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by alexpetralia on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:28AM (#35581492)
Yes, exactly: bias + imprecision = inaccuracy.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by jvanderbot on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:09PM (#35584542)
You're talking about a specific measurement, not a derived measurement from statistical analysis, though, right? Is there an instrument? If not, we're not talking about precision or accuracy, we're talking about variance about the mean, and the mean is assumed to move towards true.

In that case, the assumption is zero mean error b/c systemic errors average out, so the accuracy is the mean minus true, and the precision is established by the Cramer rao lower bound, and estimated my the posterior variance about the mean. My point is that calling it anything but a statistical certainty (e.g. confidence interval) is just jargon.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by zmgsabst on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:51PM (#35584919)
You can’t derive the correct value if all your measurements are (eg) +1ns due to inaccurate path length in your model.

Your collection of measurements will converge, just as if you had built the device you intended to — but they’ll converge to the wrong value, because you’re measuring the time incorrectly every measurement, and so averaging that out doesn’t do anything.

Your test is precise but inaccurate.

The whole context of this is about a specific instrument measuring electron properties — or in my example, timing neutrino flights. So… yes, we’re talking about precision and accuracy.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by jvanderbot on Sunday April 16, 2023 @12:49AM (#35587352)
You're explaining accuracy vs precision, which I get.

The answer actually was: Yes, there's only one instrument. So yes, you can't average out systemic biases. So yes, I guess you can say something about

"We measure eccentricity zero with 1 part in 1E+17, which is really precise, but you'll just have to trust us it's also accurate."

Anyway, we know what everyone meant.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by georgyo on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:54AM (#35581155)
I can say Pi = 3 and be accurate but not precise.

I can say Pi = 3.0000004 and be precise but not accurate.

But that's not where the confusion comes from. It comes from measuring equipment.

Example, if I have a scale that is sensitive enough to give several decimals of precision, it is very difficult to calibrate it so it is accurate.

Anyone who owns a gram scale knows you basically have to recalibrate it after every measurement. It will gladly give you many decimals of precision that is just wrong.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by shagie on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:12AM (#35581328)
On the subject of scales calibration and really small wights:

Veritasium - How To Measure The Tiniest Forces In The Universe https://youtu.be/pXoZQsZP2PY (it gets into measuring piconewtons and femtonetwons)

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:03AM (#35581242)
And for today's rant, you can also say Pi = 3 and be precise. Significant figures are a common shorthand for in-band signaling of error, but they're not the only tool and are really only useful insofar as they're pretty easy to do mental math with and relatively well known.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by kgwgk on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:59AM (#35581207)
When they say "they could detect a bump on the North Pole the height of a single sugar molecule" is not about the accuracy of the measurement?

If my measurement device always measures 42 it may by hyper-precise - but it won't helping me to detect a bump on the North Pole the height of a single sugar molecule nor anything else.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:16AM (#35581368)
But the thing being concluded is that it's not very bumpy, and for that conclusion to hold water the data needs to be both accurate and precise within some very small bound. Spitting out precise measures of electron bumpiness isn't very hard without that accuracy. Right this second I used the "gut feeling" measurement device to conclude that the electron is round within 1024 bits of precision, and yet the authors have a publication and I don't. Is their conclusion over-blown?
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#35581756)
I don't think so. They're not measuring the radius to precision 10^-31 cm. They're measuring the differences in radius against zero, and they know the value of zero to infinite precision.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:05PM (#35581885)
Sure, but it's precisely that difference which they claim to be measuring. Why does it matter that they don't also know some other value (the radius) to high accuracy? It's kind of like how a balance can measure the difference in force to high accuracy (and precision), but that doesn't mean we know anywhere near that much about the masses on the balance, and...it doesn't have to; you can just state that you know some delta accurately and not have to explain why that means some auxiliary measurement is probably precise.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:39PM (#35582194)
* * *
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by klausnrooster on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:32AM (#35581533)
My (mis-?) understanding of the Central Limit Theorem is that the average of >30 measurements increases the accuracy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_limit_theorem
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:54PM (#35582330)
No, that's increasing the precision, not accuracy. Many imprecise measurements can be averaged to a more precise measurement.

Say we had a perfect ruler to measure the length of something. It's absolutely precise and accurate. All measurements from it return the exact, same value, and preternaturally we know it's the "correct" value.

Now say some bandit comes in while we're not looking and adds a small chunck of diamond to the end of the ruler without telling us. Our ruler is still precise, but no longer accurate. If we take many measurements with it, they always come back with the same value. Averaging those values does not improve the accuracy at all.

Alternatively, say the bandit starts randomly changing the temperature of the room we are in. Thermal expansion is constantly changing the length of the ruler. The average length of the ruler is still the same, so it's still accurate, but it's no longer precise. We could average the measurements we take with it and get a more precise measurement.

What the central limit theorem says is that the averages of our measurements will be normally distributed, even if the change in temperature is not.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by kelseyfrog on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:30PM (#35583830)
This really doesn't make much sense in the context of the measurement which is bounding the value(0) with 90% confidence[1].

1. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11841.pdf

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by random314 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:13PM (#35585584)
I think op is talking about bias vs variance. In some cases we have a bias variance trade off.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by kelseyfrog on Sunday April 16, 2023 @12:24PM (#35591425)
Yep, and I'm talking about hypothesis testing which is what's being done in the paper.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by random314 on Sunday April 16, 2023 @07:11PM (#35595045)
Hypothesis testing cannot rule out systemic bias errors present in both control and treatment populations.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by kelseyfrog on Sunday April 16, 2023 @11:55PM (#35596694)
Are you pontificating about systemic bias or is this a specific critique of the techniques used to simultaneously detect the upper and lower doublets in a single shot of the experiment?
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:30AM (#35599239)
I am trying to explain to you what moron4hire is talking about. Hypothesis testing doesn't magically fix the issue he is discussing, as hypothesis testing works by collecting many imprecise measurements to average it out to a more precise level.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by klausnrooster on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:08PM (#35585557)
That's all true. I am biased because I am responsible for keeping hundreds of devices calibrated, and keeping a lab within 2C of 23C. The CLT implies that the sample mean is more likely to be close to the true population mean as the sample size increases. Not the same as more accurate. Shame on me!
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:36AM (#35599280)
The number of people in this thread not understanding the difference between bias and variance errors is too much.

http://scott.fortmann-roe.com/docs/BiasVariance.html

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by wkat4242 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:24PM (#35583197)
What's the point in measuring it with high precision if it's not accurate?
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by ilyt on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:38PM (#35583877)
Sometimes you're interested in delta of change, not absolute value itself. So absolute accuracy might be "wrong" but as long as it is consistently wrong (within duration of measurements you need to make) it doesn't matter all that much.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:45PM (#35583929)
My understanding is that a highly spherical electron implies the electron has no sub component parts. Knowing the exact radius of the electron doesn't change that, it's knowing there is no variance in the radius that is important.

And again, I was only commenting on what was being commented on here. I don't know if the experiment was also highly accurate. But people here were commenting on the precision and calling it accuracy.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:56PM (#35584960)
Precision is about how tightly clustered your measurements are.

Accuracy is about how well those measurements reflect reality.

If you are just trying to see how smooth a ball is by measuring the diameter many times at different points, then a high precision can tell you that, even if the actual diameter is different to your measurement.

You don't care about the actual diameter, you care about the variation in it.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by rightbyte on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:31AM (#35580947)
Statistics, right? It is not "one" measurement?
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by gattr on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:41AM (#35580555)
Average Earth diameter = 2·6371 km ([1]). Size of glucose molecule ≈ 9 Å ([2]). Ratio = 7.06·10¹⁷.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_radius

[2] https://sphweb.bumc.bu.edu/otlt/mph-modules/ph/ph709_basicce...

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by comboy on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:38AM (#35581598)
electron size: 10^-14

planck length: 10^-35

10^-14 * 10^17 = 10^-31

(in case somebody wondered just as I did)

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by fractalb on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:43AM (#35581648)
> 10^-14 * 10^17 = 10^-31 It’s actually 10^3
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by 1024core on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:45AM (#35581684)
Typo: you forgot the "-" before the 17 in 10^17
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:46AM (#35581688)
10^-14 / 10^17.

Or 10^-14 * 10^-17.

Minor nit to an interesting parent.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by A_D_E_P_T on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:00PM (#35585013)
Not even close. The diameter of the electron is under 10^-18 meters -- that's a sort of experimental upper bound derived from collision experiments -- but it may well be much smaller than that. Some estimates for the diameter of the electron approach the Planck length -- and some, which are no less credible, are well under the Planck length, e.g. at 10^-80m.

In physics, the electron is usually described as a point with no size at all. Thus, for practical intents and purposes, it exists but is infinitely small. (Which sort of reflects the notion that human physics is an idealization of the natural world.)

The Planck length isn't a hard physical limit for size. It's where direct measurement starts running into insurmountable barriers.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by wrycoder on Saturday April 15, 2023 @06:47PM (#35585417)
Well, 1E-18 / 1E17 is 1E-35, interestingly enough.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by mike_hock on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#35582035)
But they said they could detect a bump on the *North Pole* the size of a sugar molecule, so the diameter at the poles is relevant. Also, maybe "sugar molecule" means sucrose, not glucose.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by lagadu on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:17AM (#35581385)
I struggle with understanding that size comparison, given that the size of the electron is unknown: we only have a maximum size that's based on the accuracy of the measurements, no lower bound.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by scotty79 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#35581746)
I think it's supposed to relate the variation of the shape of electric field around electron not the size of the electron which is a pointlike particle.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by ralferoo on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#35581758)
The next sentence after the first part you quoted: "The latest results are in: The electron is rounder than that."

Which would be great if the Earth was actually perfectly round, but we've known for over three centuries that it's not. I'm sure the science the article is reporting on is fine, but it definitely sounds like the author of the article is out of their depth.

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by WJW on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:26PM (#35582067)
I know you're getting at the whole "oblate spheroid" shape thing, but I'm pretty sure people have known it wasn't perfectly round for way longer than that. You only need to look out a window to see hills and mountains after all (unless you live in the Netherlands ofc).

Fun fact: the actual shape of the Earth is neither a sphere nor an ellipsoid but a "geoid", literally something "shaped like the earth".

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:02PM (#35581865)
Definitely should have used spherical cows.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by LadyCailin on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:02PM (#35581856)
That’s not what it’s saying. It’s saying, if you blew up the electron to the size of the earth, and sprinkled a sugar grain on it, then the electron is rounder than that.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by umanwizard on Saturday April 15, 2023 @07:20PM (#35585630)
Not a sugar grain, a sugar molecule.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by butterNaN on Saturday April 15, 2023 @03:22PM (#35583753)
It's trying to put a size comparison so that our human minds can picture the scale. Earth is just a placeholder in this example. The author is inviting you to picture the the size of the planet. They could've just written the sizes in terms of 10^x , however that is not as human-friendly to envison.

There is no need to be unkind towards the author here, maybe your point is that they could have done a better job at presenting the scale for the reader? How would you write it?

Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:55PM (#35582334)
It reminds me of Aristotelian physics’ perfect ætherial heavenly bodies. Ironinic they were on the terrestrial sphere in the end.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N... by dclowd9901 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:34PM (#35586438)
I can’t even fathom how such a thing can possibly exist