Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N...
by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:16AM
(#35581368)
But the thing being concluded is that it's not very bumpy, and for that conclusion to hold water the data needs to be both accurate and precise within some very small bound. Spitting out precise measures of electron bumpiness isn't very hard without that accuracy. Right this second I used the "gut feeling" measurement device to conclude that the electron is round within 1024 bits of precision, and yet the authors have a publication and I don't. Is their conclusion over-blown?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N...
by AnimalMuppet on Saturday April 15, 2023 @11:52AM
(#35581756)
I don't think so. They're not measuring the radius to precision 10^-31 cm. They're measuring the differences in radius against zero, and they know the value of zero to infinite precision.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N...
by hansvm on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:05PM
(#35581885)
Sure, but it's precisely that difference which they claim to be measuring. Why does it matter that they don't also know some other value (the radius) to high accuracy? It's kind of like how a balance can measure the difference in force to high accuracy (and precision), but that doesn't mean we know anywhere near that much about the masses on the balance, and...it doesn't have to; you can just state that you know some delta accurately and not have to explain why that means some auxiliary measurement is probably precise.
Re:The Electron Is So Round That It’s Ruling Out Potential N...
by moron4hire on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:39PM
(#35582194)
* * *