It's like they say, opinions are like assholes. Everyone's got one and they all stink. At the end of the day, the only one who is really accountable for your health is you.
It depends on how exactly it was taken into one’s hands right? Can’t really know if it’s pro-science or anti-science until you see what a person is doing. Most people do pretty irrational stuff, based on stories of a doctor in my family.
Sort of definitionally you can get pretty weird or unsafe and if you’re comfortable with it not working it’s still a totally valid experiment.
(And even then, experimentation is only a part of the scientific process.)
There was a lot of this during Covid (which I know is a bad example because of it's political baggage, but anyway). Various "x cures / helps with covid" trends (sometimes including studies) but not really based on a anything. It's not really scientific to just imagine something could work, and then try it. Contrast it with vaccines, where, regardless of your view on the covid one, there's an actual plausible causal pathway from being exposed to it to getting immunity, so it's possible and a legit thing to do to run an experiment to see if it works.
I think it is possible and legit scientific to run experiments on allmost anything, no matter how weird.
What matters is how you do the experiment and what is the result - does it work? And if it does, is it reproducible?
Thats the key difference between a scientific and a esoteric experiment.
But you totally can investigate whether divine blessed guano shit cures cancer in a scientific way. Most researchers just won't waste their time with it. Experiments are expensive. This is why most experiments are indeed only conducted, if there is a solid theory about the process and not a shot in the blue.
(And another actually sad part today is, that many new if not most scientific papers out there are actually not reproducible anymore (at least not with the data provided), but no one cares or does something about it, except complaining, because there is nothing to win, from redoing an experiment of someone else. Reputation and grants demand new research.)
I wish there was an app where I could design experiments, and people could opt-in to participating in them. I'd of course participate in other people's experiments . The app could handle the statistical reasoning. Every now and then, there would be a strong enough signal in the data to attract "real" scientists to problems that would otherwise go unexplored.
People are gonna do weird stuff anyhow, we might as well see if some good can come of it.
I've had friends with relatively common illnesses like high blood pressure just not take care of themselves via diet, medicine, and exercise, then blame the medical system when their conditions got worse.
At the same time I watched my sisters health degrade over years while she fervently tried to do everything possible to make it better and saw many specialists when they said nothing was wrong and she was being a hypochondriac. It was finally after very effectively documenting everything about her condition and keeping it in a binder and keeping daily charts of her vitals, that a doctor stated "You have some very rare condition, now we have to figure out what it is".
Healthcare is deeply personal and individualized at the end of the day. The problem is we don't have the trained doctors and systems to give the level of care needed. And on the other hand, a lot of individuals don't put for one reason or another, the needed work to ensure they have good health outcomes.
The doctor gets self reported snapshots from a patients memory. It amuses me as an engineer that they detect what seems irrational, but never follow up on it in any meaningful way or ever attempt to observe the actual reality of their patients lives.
The lack of time for real follow up is understandable, but the unwillingness to accept that this fact, more than anything, colors the way they see their patients is a little maddening. So, I always find it understandable when someone decides they'd rather take their care entirely into their own hands.
Now imagine an average patient, like a mom with 7 kids that doesn’t speak English, or a 16 year old dad who smells intensely of pot. Vast majority of the patients are very different than our engineering bubbles, and doctors are humans who are trying their best.
For people who are willing to have a deeper conversation, some doctors will engage more meaningfully. But most of the process for doctors is to give you instructions to follow, then when you report back, alter them, or proceed as before.
Most people try the first thing doctor asked, and if it didn’t immediately work, change it themselves, and/or go to a new doctor. Then complain how they’ve been to 12 doctors and nobody helped, but then they stumbled on some YouTube guy who said to take 5000mg of vitamin C every 2 hours, and their back pain went away (hint: it went away on its own).
Nobody would call that “anti-science”.
Anti-science would be something like ignoring the common treatments and trying to solve the problem with natural supplements or something. Going this route often delays people from getting to proven treatments because they spend a long, long time trying underpowered or unproven things that don’t work.
It’s a mistake to ignore proven, first-line treatments and skip straight to less proven alternatives, though. Some people have built an anti-mainstream bias that puts too much emphasis on the unproven, alternative treatments while downplaying the most proven treatments.
Salt is not to blame, it turns out
That's not the flipside, that's the "exception to the rule". Of course the system's not perfect, but people don't live way longer now because our medicine is worse than before...
A sign that says "no parking on Sundays" logically implies that parking is allowed all other days.
The concept you're looking for is closer to "any statistical group has outlier cases".
The commenter I'm replying to is advocating for homeo- / naturo-pathy because of some statistically insignificant and probably actually not causally based relationship they've witnessed, which is generalizing from a ~singular case
Vs antibiotics and/or saline rinses.
For example if your air quality is bad and/or ventilation is bad and may cause sleep apnea (like high CO2 concentration often makes you feel drowsy).
But the seller of CPAP machine will not monitor your air environment.
With medical problems there are often multiple factors, and when a solution is found that fix the symptoms, care is no longer taken to find the other causes, specially if the solution is generating recurring revenues.
Theres diet, sleep, exercise. Which require no studies to know that taking better care of yourself will help you regardless of the pathology.
Then there's the somewhat strange case of orthodontist John Mew, who advocates for setting your tongue posture to the roof of your mouth in order to close the jaw properly, to prevent standard treatment of various braces, teeth alignment issues and corrective jaw surgery.
Other strange therapies that I've come across that seem unhealthy but have some backing are intentional sleep deprivation to improve depressive symptoms. prolonged fasting to reduce scar tissue. Or one I personally use alot, extremely cold showers after allergene exposure.
There are alot of silly things the human body can do that at first glance might seem irresponsible or dangerous but are about as dangerous as people in the 1900's might imagine airplanes would be.
One more thing I might add, standard care does not mean 'in your best interest' some standard practise might be too cruel to accept, like chemotherapy. Even though its proven to extend your life, it might not be proven to be in your best interest.
That said, my depression was improved more by a couple of magic mushrooms trips than by more than a year of psychology. The results have been so good that it feels wrong to share it, makes it sound like some miracle stuff and I think any depressed person would go for it in a heartbeat completely ignoring risks.
I think the stuff people are talking about are like when Steve Jobs did the fruit diet thing to cure cancer
I tried multiple doctors, treatments, tips etc and etc nothing worked. I finally visited a homeo doctor who diagnosed it right. It's deviated septum which is causing sinus infections because of regular coconut water intake. I just stopped drinking coconut water and it's been 10+ years and not another recurrence of sinus so far.
Proper diagnosis is hard and requires skill. The OP figured it by himself and in my case, someone did.
Homeopathy doctor?
Seems even a quack can get some things right XD
some people say to they put the lime in the coconut, then then they feel better.
Slightly related, I lived in the 3rd world with coconuts for a while growing up. Coconut water from a roadside stand practically put me in the hospital. I wish they had put the lime in the coconut.
Also line with mangoes is wonderful. =============
Anyways I self diagnosed with a fit bit a number of years ago. Doctors skeptical but yes I had sleep apnea. And it’s been a journey since then to self manage the machines and trouble shoot treatment. I was not blessed with great dme suppliers or providers.
Aloe vs cortisol for skin issues.
While anecdota tend to be of little value, I can at least attest to the latter not working well -- at least for my condition.
Parachutes aren't scientifically proven to work on humans.
It’s expensive to go through that rigorous process, and there’s no economic incentive to go through that for something that isn’t patentable. In the case of cranberry juice, it’s not sold as medicine. In the case of alcohol, you can buy very expensive wipes that have a certification if you need it for some industrial process.
https://www.healthline.com/health/baking-soda-for-uti#bottom...
Your logic is kinda faulty...
Cranberry juice is no more effective on UTIs than chicken soup on colds and flus. That is, it can have an impact in part because of the placebo effect (which is substantially more powerful than is currently understood), but it is not because there is any inherent benefit to cranberry juice ("chicken soup" — that is, any clear broth — is at least partially effective because it’s warm liquid fighting diseases which cause dehydration; there’s no medicinal benefit).
There's no belief system called science and you can't be pro- or anti-science. Science ironically is pretty questioning and skeptical, so questioning some piece of science, is scientific.
Certainty and the temptation toward it is your enemy if you would maintain a "scientific" worldview. Politics demands certainty, simplicity. Fascism, especially so.
There are two belief systems called science.
The less common one is the one you outline immediately after denying its existence: it's about asking questions and trying to establish evidence-based models to make predictions and testing/validating the assumptions in those models. It's probably more accurate to call this belief system empiricism.
The more common one is a deferral to expert authority, where experts are designated by certain established scientific institutions. Because many lack the time/will/ability to independently verify claims made by authoritative figures, this deferral requires substantial trust in these institutions to come up with good answers.
This second belief system is what most people mean when they label themselves or others as pro- or anti-science. Paradoxically, even though the authoritative institutions ostensibly produce information empirically, expressing skepticism and asking questions is often perceived as a lack of faith, and therefore anti-science.
The institutional science belief system really has a lot in common with religion. In fact the instutions we now trust to train scientists and dispense scientific information largely grew out of instutions with a major focus to train clergy and dispense religious information.
Empiricism is not really in that same subcategory, but it also rests on some set of ultimately unverifiable assumptions. In fact, I'd argue that one of the central assumptions of classical empiricism, that all systems are locally deterministic, is demonstrably false. The early quantum pioneers had a hard time coming to grips with this and there are still several competing interpretations of QM. This huge shift still hasn't fully percolated to many other fields of science, which often still assume local determinism and pretend QM doesn't exist.
It actually baffled me that it wasn't his doctor who picked this up. A person waking up several times with confirmation from someone sleeping besides him that he has stopped breathing, I'm no doctor and gee maybe it's because there are a few cases in my family but that screams "sleep apnea" to me.
A doctor who doesn't recognize that is maybe not the best possible doctor. To put it very mildly.
That first meeting with the specialist was a profound waste of money, but at least it got me in the door. Since then, the CPAP has helped some, but it is just as likely to wake me up too early (I toss a lot in my sleep and it doesn't always stay sealed).
Yup, it is. Because like a cargo cult, most of the external signs are similar. The difference is in the depth of knowledge used, the rigor applied to the evidence, whether the person is actively avoiding or seeking confirmation bias, etc. So, yes, much of the time, it is actually anti-science.
That said, there is no reason to hide a person's own data from them. Even if statistically, they are more likely to abuse it.
The fact that he had to go get a gray-market machine hacked to use open-source to get his own data is unconscionable. It should simply be required that all medical devices have an easy method to provide data to the user/patient, such as a Patient_SDCard_Slot, or Patient_USB_port. Obviously it wouldn't provide access to the internals, but provide a parallel output data stream that they could use or not use as they choose.
(didn't check my writing, too late to edit)
I am not one to defend doctors too much as I did have a moment, where a whole series of trained professionals missed something obvious ( in retrospect ) to the point that made me question whether they were all just trying to drain my insurance as much as they could. It is a problem, as we are still learning how our bodies really work.
<< you need to sometimes tackle your own health
That 'sometimes' is important. You want to know the line where supplements and blinds are no longer sufficient.
I’ve routinely had to do this with my own health. It was especially bad before Botox for migraine was around. Heard a lot of “men don’t get migraines, I don’t believe you” from neurologists.
For sleep apnea, it was an adverse reaction to a medication that led me to strongly request my doctor send me for a sleep study. Found out during the sleep study that I needed a good bit of air pressure and I’ve been benefiting greatly since. But it did take me doing some online research into side effects of the medication (from high quality sources), being insistent, and establishing some report with my doctor through logs, candor, and listening.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35513636
But when it's not and they have to look at a lot of details and spend a lot of time figuring out the problem many aren't interested, if only because they're pressed for time (by insurers) and trying to reduce cognitive load.
Nobody is killed (or really harmed) by trying a CPAP and the waiting list for sleep clinics can be months or years long, not to mention the expense.
It's one of the rare medical interventions that is relatively safe for an individual. Probably should be otc.
Isn't it already, if you can just buy a CPAP machine off the shelf?
And here, having done it for years, I can tell you this is nearly absolute BS. It's a hose hooked up to a fan that softly blows somewhat filtered air through a tube. That's IT. There's no remotely signficant way that this thing will hurt you even if used improperly; especially as compared to so much other dangerous OTC drugs and/or medical equipment.
Eh... I've talked to RT's and the occasional pulmonologist enough about ventilators out of idle curiosity to learn that the pressures involved do need to be carefully set within certain envelopes to minimize risks, and I'm not quite as confident as you are in this statement.
You set your controls HORRIBLY wrong on an off the shelf CPAP -- and, what? It's not like you're going to explode your lungs. Your own inability to breathe properly will make you take it off. Or you keep it on and you fart more in the morning (true story, by the way, I've never heard anyone mention this side effect of CPAPs)
They often don't even do a titration study to figure out the right pressure range anymore. They just give it to you with a reasonable default setting, let the machine figure things out automatically, and tell you to come back in a month to check the logs to see if your apnea got better.
However, if I manufactured, say, an insulin pump, there is no way I would allow it to ship with user-configurable settings in a country as litigious as the US. CPAP seems less risky, but not worth chancing anything. The US market seems to be the primary target for many medical devices, the UK might be receiving CPAPs developed primarily for the US court system.
The elements of direct and indirect dangers are more apparent and immediate with a chainsaw than say, unscrupulous use of an SSRI, a bronchodilator or a high-potency NSAID like diclofenac.
Improperly designed tubes can accumulate or retain moisture, and that small fan will blow mold into your lungs overnight.
Would you trust an Alibaba CPAP sold on Amazon for $50?
I think my case was just so severe that nobody saw me struggle with it, because it was impossible to fight. Plus, I'm autistic, so a lot of things were written off as autism.
Same with me but PTSD. Like the fact that I'm remarkably functional in crisis mode doesn't mean that it's not a problem I live there all the time. A surprising amount of medicine relies on having a stable baseline against which to compare and if that's not there, the tests don't work.
Exactly! I wanna fix something wrong with me, not something preventing me from becoming a work slave. I want to be happy with myself, not just useful to society. My own happiness should trump most metrics of functionality.
I realize in hindsight how much of my resistance to help was resistance to 'help': I've grown up surrounded by adults/authority figures offering 'help' with no consideration of my actual desires or wellbeing. I know that one. Of course I was wary: I had a good reason.
You're right that it all relies around making people functional, not whole people who have come to terms with who they are and are a psychologically stable human organism.
But I still totally agree. My main concern when I was getting prescribed my meds was "will it help me mentally instead of just making me do things?" and the answer was "yes". I didn't actually believe it, until I tried the meds and they freakin' worked. Now I'm just so thankful and grateful I found something that worked so well. I feel like my brain is finally functioning the way it's supposed to. (Neurodivergence included of course~)
What's concerning is when people ignore the experts completely.
Steve Jobs ignoring the advice for pancreatic cancer treatment comes to mind.
My sleep improved but my doctor got mad because I wasn't listening to medical advice, but going into the APAP clinician settings and changing them myself.
My spine broke, I've undergone various bone related surgeries all my life.
I decided to take matter into my own hands and built "Bone Health Tracker"[1] a FOSS bone density results tracker, I went to the front page of r/InternetIsBeautiful subreddit and through which I came across others like me who have suggested various rare diseases which I could be facing. Since then I've been working with NGOs helping those with rare diseases to help me find a doctor who can diagnose my disease and for the first time in my life I'm hopeful that I will be able to find what my disease is soon.
The frustrating thing for me is that doing so is often labeled as being anti-science, when the truth is, this guy was actually doing the science himself. It's not anti-science to take your health into your own hands. It's anti-outdated-underfunded-medical-systems.